THE NORTH KOREAN SUCCESSION

Document Type: 
Collection: 
Document Number (FOIA) /ESDN (CREST): 
CIA-RDP83B00227R000100080006-5
Release Decision: 
RIPPUB
Original Classification: 
C
Document Page Count: 
13
Document Creation Date: 
December 19, 2016
Document Release Date: 
February 12, 2007
Sequence Number: 
6
Case Number: 
Publication Date: 
March 1, 1982
Content Type: 
REPORT
File: 
AttachmentSize
PDF icon CIA-RDP83B00227R000100080006-5.pdf724.53 KB
Body: 
pro Ddec or Release 2007/02/12 : CIA-RDP83BOO227R00010008Q0~65.ential The North Korean Succession Confidential EA 82-10032 March 1982 COPY 3 0 4 Approved For Release 2007/02/12 : CIA-RDP83B00227R000100080006-5 Approved For Release 2007/02/12 : CIA-RDP83B00227R000100080006-5 Approved For Release 2007/02/12 : CIA-RDP83B00227R000100080006-5 Directorate of Confidential Intelligence The North Korean Succession Information available as of 16 February 1982 has been used in the preparation of this report. The author of this report isINortheast Asia Division, Office of East sian nalysis. Comments and queries are welcome and may be directed to the Chief Northeast Asia Division, on I Confidential EA 82-10032 March 1982 Approved For Release 2007/02/12 : CIA-RDP83B00227R000I 00080006-5 Approved For Release 2007/02/12 : CIA-RDP83B00227R000100080006-5 Confidential Key Judgments President Kim I1-song has ruled North Korea since 1945, and his inevitable passing will introduce major uncertainty into the Korean scene. To minimize that uncertainty, he intends for his eldest son, Kim Chong-il, to succeed him. Kim Chong-il, at age 40, is exercising increasing control over day-to-day affairs, especially in domestic political and economic matters. The father- to-son succession has no precedent in the Communist world, but special circumstances in North Korea make the succession likely. Indeed, the image of father and son is being craftily projected in an effort to make the eventual transfer of power appear both natural and ordained. The deliberate manner in which the son is being groomed indicates that an early succession is not anticipated. Kim I1-song, who will be 70 in April, continues to be very active and retains ultimate authority over the decisionmaking process. While the Soviets and Chinese have avoided endorsing the succession scheme, there is no evidence that the succession issue has adversely affected North Korean foreign policy. Kim Chong-il's accession to power is by no means assured, however. While we have not been able to observe any active opposition, other senior North Korean leaders presumably have ambitions and may view the son as an up- start. Kim Chong-il's position would be uncertain if Kim 11-song died or was incapacitated before the son solidified his alliances within the critical military and security services. Over the years Kim 11-song, by dint of one-man rule and a pervasive personality cult, has kept North Korean resources almost totally mobilized toward the goal of a reunified Korea under P'yongyang's control. A North Korean regime headed by anyone other than Kim Chong-il probably would be less reluctant to begin dismantling the elder Kim's cult and his policies. A prolonged and debilitating succession struggle, in particular, would seriously dilute P'yongyang's ability to sustain the reunification drive and the strict, authoritarian controls that have reinforced Kim 11-song's long reign. This worrisome prospect may explain in large part the great effort Kim 11-song has undertaken to ensure an orderly transfer of power to his son. Confidential EA 82-10032 March 1982 Approved For Release 2007/02/12 : CIA-RDP83B00227R000100080006-5 Because the son's claim to legitimacy is closely tied to loyalty to his father's vision, a regime led by Kim Chong-il would be likely to present a large measure of continuity characterized by: ? Hostility toward South Korea and the United States. ? Strong commitment to reunification on P'yongyang's terms. ? Military strength at the expense of social and economic development. ? Stress on self-reliance (chuche). We know little about Kim Chong-il's personal traits. In view of his youth and lack of experience he may be prone to act impulsively when, for example, he is faced with a shooting incident along the Demilitarized Zone. Kim Chong-il, in any event, could not automatically wield the absolute power his father has, and this would reduce his own freedom of action in forging North Korea's foreign and domestic policy. Approved For Release 2007/02/12 : CIA-RDP83B00227R000100080006-5 Approved For Release 2007/02/12 : CIA-RDP83B00227R000100080006-5 Confidential The Son Goes Public The problems that North Korea's tightly closed soci- ety present to the intelligence analyst are nowhere better illustrated than in Kim 11-song's nearly 10- year, behind-the-scenes campaign to groom his eldest son as his successor. During that campaign the son, Kim Chong-il, was never identified at public gather- ings, the media did not mention his name, and he did not meet with foreigners. The regime nonetheless kept the North Korean popu- lace apprised of the younger Kim's activities by the use of special honorific expressions. The most promi- nent codeword for the son was-and still is-the "party center." Through local indoctrination sessions, the people were made to understand that these codewords were, in fact, describing the son's activities. Kim 11-song, we judge, saw a number of advantages in keeping the succession scheme under wraps: ? It provided an opportunity for the son to be tested, while keeping the elder Kim's options open if the son failed to measure up. ? It enabled Kim 11-song to avoid lameduck status. ? It shielded North Korea from possibly embarrassing foreign commentary. The regime used the Sixth Congress of the Korean Workers Party-North Korea's ruling Communist party-to introduce Kim Chong-il officially to the rest of the world. At the congress, held in October 1980, Kim Chong-il was named fourth-ranking mem- ber of the party's 19-member Political Bureau. His name had never before appeared in a public leader- ship listing. As one of the top five in the party hierarchy, Kim Chong-il became a member of the newly instituted "Presidium" or standing committee of the Political Bureau. He was also designated a secretary on the party's Secretariat, ranking behind only his father, who is the "General Secretary." As the ranking secretary, Kim Chong-il is now charged with the day-to-day political Kim Chong-il: Personality Cult Unfolds The World Revolutionary People highly praise the dear leader comrade Kim Chong-il, the only succes- sor to the great leader comrade Kim Il-song, and express boundless reverence for him.... Dear comrade Kim Chong-il is an outstanding think- er and theoretician.... We should actively introduce and propagandize the greatness of the dear leader comrade Kim Chong-il, his ideas and theories and his precious exploits.... The Korean people hold dear comrade Kim Chong-il in high esteem as the leader of the revolution and construction who translates and embodies the lofty intentions and the chuche idea of President Kim Il- song. Excerpts from a broadcast by the North Korean official news agency on 19 No- vember 1981 claiming to report foreign praise of Kim Chong-il. work of the party. He also was appointed a member of the party's prestigious Military Committee, ranking after his father and Defense Minister 0 Chin-u. The younger Kim is the only official other than his father to serve on both the Secretariat and the Military Committee. The party congress stopped short of formally desig- nating Kim Chong-il as successor to his father. Even so, Kim 11-song's decision to "go public" with his son and, by extension, the succession scheme was not taken lightly. As long as the son remained behind the Approved For Release 2007/02/12 : CIA-RDP83B00227R000100080006-5 Approved For Release 2007/02/12 : CIA-RDP83B00227R000100080006-5 scenes it was possible for the elder Kim to abandon the scheme, as in the early 1970s he had abandoned a similar effort to groom his own younger brother, Kim Yong-chu. Heightened Profile Since the party congress, the buildup of Kim Chong-if has intensified. Early in 1981, P'yongyang began to encourage foreigners to offer toasts to Kim Chong-il's health at diplomatic functions. By late spring, North Korea began publicizing these greetings as well as longer stories and commentaries hailing the son's exploits. In some cases P'yongyang has attributed to foreigners favorable comments on Kim Chong-il, when in fact no such comments were made. In May 1981, North Korea started selectively publi- cizing Kim Chong-il's activities in the official media, focusing on his duties in domestic political and eco- nomic affairs. Kim Chong-il's appearances at about 10 functions in 1981 served to keep him in the limelight, but the attention paid to him does not begin to rival that given to his father, whose appearances were publicized on at least 130 occasions during 1981. North Korean newspapers now treat Kim Chong-il more extensively than they do any other leader with the exception of Kim 11-song. In the party daily: ? Articles on Kim Chong-il appear on page 1 in the lead position on the upper right-hand side. ? Kim Chong-il's name is printed in boldface type. ? The sizes of the headline and the type font have increased, although they are still somewhat smaller than those used for Kim 11-song. The major duties that Kim Chong-il is now openly performing closely parallel those attributed to the "party center" before the party congress. He is charged with ensuring that party members remain loyal to Kim II-song, a task that is enshrined in the slogan "dyeing the whole of society" with Kim II- song's thoughts. His role as chief interpreter, protec- tor, and propagandizer of Kim 11-song's thoughts not only provides the younger Kim with a potent political weapon against would-be challengers, but also but- tresses his supporters' claim that he is the logical choice to carry on his father's achievements. Approved For Release 2007/02/12 : CIA-RDP83B00227R000100080006-5 Approved For Release 2007/02/12 : CIA-RDP83B00227R000100080006-5 Confidential to*A01T?~ awl ' JLA Ia4,a 4 o a- ?~~q . 1 -91 TTI`4 l *1t, 01 Pi q16'101-401 -kj A i ~sl ~ ?~ o wl i 5 1 8?a -e1 2 201-1 xl _ .A1 X171 ~1 ~~ i 1 s= 3 "1i '3c ?9 ~~ 1 'N 8 z ,lam ?~ ~Ls q4 -4 - Ol.3L ^I A Zd 4SS- rd 1 ale 4'i7 7 ?A 4 3i8}-7l -1f ?l _g ]oj. n}3 4kll s4 Ul *-* o *4 0101-1 N1 d -11or -a.47_14 M ~3oQ ~o~~1 Ti4~ oof?~S 4~ 9I 0-101 E O 01 01 TL 0-12 01 01 a 71' 7iaT ?~ ~~ ~l moo{- '1 A4 r 41- tCA-j EI oOIrja4I M L C=> OTI LLZ! 1OTI - O104 c c- I 7lM OI 02IV.74 c CM x ` 0 0 %kr 1 i i XkIWI2I and December newspapers. Heightened emphasis on Kim Chong-il in the party daily Nodong Sinmun is seen in the gradually in- creasing size of type used in headlines about Chong-il's guidance activities in the June, August, 25X1 Approved For Release 2007/02/12 : CIA-RDP83B00227R000100080006-5 Kim Chong-il appears deeply involved in both formu- lating and supervising the implementation of North Korea's economic policies and plans. One of his more publicized contributions is the so-called speed bat- tle-mobilizing all available manpower and resources to achieve a specific goal in a relatively short time. The concept is patterned after the Chollima, or winged-horse, campaign-a labor-intensive produc- tion campaign Kim 11-song instituted in the late 1950s. The two techniques have been coupled in a single slogan-the "spirit of Chollima spurred on by the speed campaign." This slogan elevates the son's contribution in directing the national economy to the same level as that of his father. Perhaps Kim Chong-il's most celebrated innovation is the "three-revolution team" movement, a nationwide campaign initiated in 1973. Such teams, made up of technicians, students, and representatives from the party, are sent to factories and farms to check on the performance of local party and administrative leaders. The teams are credited with eradicating all sorts of bureaucratic evils and outmoded concepts. In practi- cal terms, the movement provides the younger Kim with a separate and powerful institutional arm to purge or demote veteran functionaries and replace them with handpicked representatives. A Long Apprenticeship North Korea, through its official press, clearly is attempting to portray Kim Chong-il's activities in a manner that evokes the image of his father's activities over the past years. Kim Chong-il, for example, is now shown making periodic inspection trips in the prov- inces, accompanied by other senior North Korean leaders. He also is shown inspecting the progress on construction projects in P'yongyang. The younger Kim is credited with the decade-long campaign to modernize and beautify the capital city-the results of which have impressed even the harshest foreign critics of the North Korean regime. The activities that the son has not engaged in are just as important, however, in gauging the overall pace of the succession: ? He has yet to make a publicized speech or publish an article under his own name. A youthful Kim Chong-il looks on respectfully as his fat her visits a "three revolution" exhibit, probably in the early 1970s. Photos such as this one are appearing in current North Korean publica- tions with increasing frequency as part of the effort to link the younger Kim historically with the achievements of his fat her.I 2X1 ? He has not presided over a major national event. ? He has not met with foreign leaders. ? He has not traveled abroad in his capacity as a high- ranking official. This pattern of activity suggests that the elder Kim is still moving at a deliberate pace on the succession scheme. In any event, the succession issue dominates North Korean domestic policy concerns. At every major domestic function the party sponsors, the publi- cized proceedings are focused almost exclusively on the campaign to ensure that party functionaries ac- cept Kim Chong-il's instructions without fail. The one development that obviously could cause the succession scenario to quicken would be a sudden deterioration in Kim 11-song's health. The elder Kim, who will be 70 in April, is overweight, a heavy smoker, and probably has high blood pressure. He has a large growth on the back of his neck, which is not life threatening but is too complex to remove for purely cosmetic reasons. In the past year or so North Approved For Release 2007/02/12 : CIA-RDP83B00227R000100080006-5 Confidential Korea has permitted this growth, which is visible at the hairline from the left side, to appear in official photographs, a reminder of the elder Kim's mortality. This new candor reinforces the need for addressing the succession issue. Kim 11-song nonetheless shows no sign of slowing down any time soon. He has remained extremely active since the party congress and has no hesitancy about meeting in long sessions with foreign visitors. In April, Kim 11-song will be receiving numerous foreign leaders who have been urged to attend gala celebra- tions marking his 70th birthday. Preparations for this demanding schedule would not be proceeding if Kim 11-song's health were questionable. Foreign Reactions Thus far, China and the USSR, P'yongyang's treaty allies, have avoided public commentary on Kim Chong-il. Among "fraternal" Communist countries, the issue of succession has long been viewed as an internal matter. North Korea, in developing its ration- ale for a planned succession, has not endeared itself to Beijing or Moscow, however. In thinly veiled terms, P'yongyang has argued that its method will help avoid the chaos that followed the deaths of Stalin and Mao. China, for reasons of political expediency, would probably be more inclined than the Soviet Union to tolerate a family succession. Beijing, wants to keep P'yongyang firmly in its camp and over the years has been willing to overlook Kim 11-song's cult. Beijing will find it difficult to accede to North Korean pressure for explicit endorsement of the succession, however, because of domestic Chinese political sensi- tivities. China's present top leaders used criticism of the personality cult of Mao Zedong and his successor Hua Guofeng to remove the latter from the party chairmanship in 1981. China's desire to skirt the succession issue came to the fore during the visit of Premier Zhao Ziyang in December 1981. Not only did Zhao fail to acknowl- edge Kim Chong-il, but the North Korean hosts themselves refrained from making any mention of the son in connection with Zhao's five-day stay in North Korea. The omission was made all the more striking by a publicized appearance by the son at a separate event in P'yongyang during Zhao's visit. The Soviets, for their part, are extremely distrustful of Kim 11-song and have been unwilling to endorse Kim's cult. They have not forgotten Kim's ingratitude for past assistance and his penchant for taking high- risk actions that jeopardize Soviet strategic interests. Moscow probably does not cherish the prospect of trying to cope with the younger Kim, who could be as irascible and unpredictable as his father. Kim Chong-il's Assets Historically, Communist states have had great diffi- culty arranging an orderly transfer of power. More- over, Kim 11-song's father-son succession scheme has no precedent in the Communist world. Thus, by most standards, Kim Chong-il would seem to have more going against him than for him. There are, however, some special conditions at work in North Korea that improve the son's chances. First, of course, is Kim It-song's great personal power. Many of his senior lieutenants may be unenthusiastic about the younger Kim, but they are undoubtedly loyal to Kim 11-song-he has systematically eliminat- ed his opponents over the years. Thus, resistance, if any, is likely to remain passive as long as the senior Kim is around. There are no obvious challengers to Kim Chong-il. The older Kim's personal involvement in virtually every aspect of North Korea's development has cre- ated an enormous gap between Kim 11-song and his immediate subordinates. Only party veteran Kim Il has anything approaching an independent stature, and his health is poor. Finally, North Korea is probably more of a closed society than any other country in the world. A generation has matured under virtually exclusive in- doctrination in Kim 11-song's thought. To the people, Kim 11-song is both a political leader and a father figure. North Korean propaganda has sought to cap- italize on and magnify this personal appeal in order to establish the legitimacy of the son's claim. Indeed, the image of the father and the son is being craftily projected in an effort to make the eventual transfer of power appear both natural and foreordained. Approved For Release 2007/02/12 : CIA-RDP83B00227R000100080006-5 Approved For Release 2007/02/12 : CIA-RDP83B00227R000100080006-5 The Murky Background of Kim Chong-il Despite his heightened publicity, reliable information on Kim Chong-il's personal history remains meager. He was born on 16 February 1942, a date that P'yongyangfinally cormed on his 40th birthday. There is still uncertainty concerning where he was born. Most accounts suggest that Kim Il-song took refuge in the Soviet Union after Japanese forces moved against Korean Communist guerrillas in Manchuria in the late 1930s. North Korean hagiographers, how- ever, put guerrilla leader Kim in the Korea-Manchu- ria border area. The issue has implications for the younger Kim. As successor, it is important that his birthplace be established on Korean soil or in terri- tory under the operational control of Kim II-song's partisan forces. Kim Chong-il's early family life is also obscure. His mother, Kim Chong-suk, died in 1949 at the age of 32. Since the mid-1970s, a campaign has been under way to depict her as a fervent follower of Kim II-song and a staunch revolutionary in her own right. This program is also meant to lend support to Kim Chong- il's cause. Kim II-song remarried in the early 1950s. His second wife, Kim Song-ae, is a member of the party Central Committee and leader of the women's league. During her infrequent public appearances, she is identified as Kim Il-song's wife. Kim Il-song reportedly has a son and daughter by this second marriage, but neither has been mentioned by name in the press.I Kim Chong-il reportedly studied briefly in Eastern Europe and ultimately graduated from Kim II-song University in P'yongyang. He apparently did not serve in the armed forces but moved directly into an important post in the central party apparatus. Kim Chong-il reportedly has a wife and children, but they have never been mentioned in the North Korean media. 25X1 25X1 Approved For Release 2007/02/12 : CIA-RDP83B00227R000100080006-5 Approved For Release 2007/02/12 : CIA-RDP83B00227R000100080006-5 Approved For Release 2007/02/12 : CIA-RDP83B00227R000100080006-5 Confidentia1pproved For Release 2007/02/12 : CIA-RDP83B00227R000100080006-5 Confidential