REAGAN'S 'BRAIN TRUST'-- A CANDIDATE IS KNOWN BY THE COMPANY HE KEEPS

Document Type: 
Collection: 
Document Number (FOIA) /ESDN (CREST): 
CIA-RDP91-00901R000100250004-9
Release Decision: 
RIFPUB
Original Classification: 
K
Document Page Count: 
5
Document Creation Date: 
December 9, 2016
Document Release Date: 
July 12, 2001
Sequence Number: 
4
Case Number: 
Publication Date: 
April 26, 1980
Content Type: 
MAGAZINE
File: 
AttachmentSize
PDF icon CIA-RDP91-00901R000100250004-9.pdf583.55 KB
Body: 
Reagan's `Brain Trust' A Candidate Is Known by the Company He Keeps With the GOP nomination seemingly within his grasp, Ronald Reagan has put together a star-studded cast of advisers to guide him as he seeks the presidency. R oriald Reagan, the former movie actor who symbolizes the affinity between show business and electronic-era politics, is surrounding himself with a star-studded supporting cast. Already performing like the 1980 Republican presidential nominee- perhaps with good reason in view of his comfortable lead over struggling rivals- Reagan has cultivated an advisory "brain trust" composed of many of the most prominent figures in economics, domes- tic policy matters and national security affairs. Included are representatives of the defense and intelligence community, such as Frank It. Barnett, president of the National Strategy Information Center; Lt. Gen. Daniel O. Graham, co-chairman of the Coalition for Peace Through Strength and former director of the Defense Intelligence Agency; and Adm. Thomas H. Moorer, former chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff. From academe come Nathan Glazer of Harvard University, Jeane J. Kirkpatrick of Georgetown University and Eugene V. Rostow, a Yale University law professor. Economists include Milton Friedman, former Federal Reserve Board chairman Arthur F. Burns and Arthur Laffer. (For a list of keYadvisers, see box, pp. 674-75.) Reagan's congressional counselors are headed by Sen. Paul Laxalt of Nevada, his campaign chairman, and Reps. Jack F. Kemp of New York and Thomas B. Evans Jr. of Delaware. Coordinating the advisory operations for the Reagan campaign are Richard V. Allen. president of Potomac Inter- national Corp. and former senior staff member of the National Security Coun- cil, who directs the foreign affairs and defense policy input; and Martin Ander- son, former White House aide and Columbia University economics professor now at Stanford University's Hoover Institution on War, Revolution and Peace, who oversees the domestic issues area. They work with Edwin Meese, Reagan's chief of staff and principal issues adviser, under campaign manager William J. Casey. Predictably, as the national conven- tions draw near, the number of candi- dates dwindles and the early hoopla of the campaign subsides, candidates are obliged to be increasingly specific about their policy positions. Comparative analyses are made by the news media and by recognized spe- cialists in particular areas. A candidate's advisers constitute a wellspring for ideas and proposals. They conduct research and instruct and brief the can- didate. They keep him abreast of the latest developments in certain fields. They may suggest courses of action. And they may even recommend a particular book or research paper. The quality and prominence of the advisers a candidate attracts reflect his political philosophy, directly bear on his leadership capability and provide a measure of credibility to his campaign. in politics, as in other elements of society, a person is known by the company he or she keeps. So the candidate's choice of advisers tells the voters something about the office-seeker. As Anderson observed, "People around a candidate give an idea of what kind of person he is." Many campaign advisers, almost all of whom are acknowledged authorities in their fields, possess their own special constituencies and followers and hence may also serve as drawing cards. Con- versely, a controversial figure could well be a liability instead of an asset. A candidate must therefore be careful in the advisers he chooses. A Carter White House aide, for instance, reported that an offer by former Sen. Eugene J. McCarthy, D-Minn., to help in the President's reelection cam- paign was rejected because of McCarthy's well-known liberal orthodoxy. And although former Secretary of State Henry A. Kissinger has been in telephone contact with Reagan, he is noticeably missing from the candidate's public list of advisers. Aides have cau- tioned Reagan that Kis- singer would be a dis- ruptive presence because of controversy over his conduct of U.S. foreign policy while in the White House and State Depart- ment, his long and close rela- ionship with Richard Me Nixon and his reported involvement with Da- vid Rockefeller in efforts to find a suit- able home-in-exile for the deposed Shah of Iran. There is also the possibility that Kissinger might outshine the candidate. One of the tacit campaign rules is that no single adviser may loom larger in the public eye than the candidate. Further- more, policy positions must always be identified with the candidate, regardless of their origin. Until recently, Reagan's "outside" advisers dealt with him, or through his campaign staff, in an ad hoc manner. The sudden dismissal in February of cam- paign manager John Sears, national political director Charles Black and press secretary James Lake led to a campaign staff reorganization and a revision in the internal operations. Whereas Sears 672 NATIONAL JOURNAL 4126/80 Approved For Release 2001/07/27 : CIA-RDP91-00901 R0001 00250004-9 ~.t,, ,,,Approygd, ~or?Release 2001/07/27: CIA-RDP91-00901 R000100250004-9 to Reagan, Casey, his successor, broadened the lines of communication to the candidate. Then, on the eve of the Pennsylvania primary, the advisory system was, in effect, institutionalized. Reagan an- nounced he was establishing a 12- member policy council, augmented by two groups of specialized advisers, one on foreign affairs and another on defense policy- in all, 67 "distinguished experts." "Their experience," said Reagan, "will be of great assistance to me as the presidential campaign addresses issues of crucial importance to the future of our country." Allen said some of the advisers were Democrats or independents and that agreement to serve did not constitute political endorsement. Nonetheless, the great majority can be presumed to be Reagan supporters. In one case, Paul H. Nitze, a former deputy Defense secretary and a leader of the Committee on the Present Danger, who is not among the 67, reported that he was available for advice to any candidate who requested it. "It doesn't mean I'm for or against Reagan," he said. "I have intentionally tried to address myself to issues and not personalities." He acknowledged, however, that Reagan's defense policies were compati- ble with his own and said he expected to "see him again." Citing a political maxim, Anderson said, "It becomes easier to attract people once they are convinced the candidate has the nomination." That is apparent with Reagan, considering the large number of experts anxious and willing to offer him professional advice. It is not lost on at least some of them that if Reagan wins in November, they stand an excellent chance of being rewarded with a presidential appoint- ment. Though many undoubtedly are motivated by a sense of public service, it is not unlikely that the personal horizons of others reach as high as a Cabinet post, a job in the White House or the direc- torship of a federal agency. THE ADVISORY SYSTEM Special advisers, normally grouped in task forces according to issues, have long been a functional ingredient of presiden- tial campaigns. But only in recent na- tional elections have they been expanded and refined as a campaign force. The complexity of contemporary social and economic issues, the demands on the candidate to offer possible solutions to difficult problems and the incessant focus of the news media on the candidate's proposed policies have made it incumbent upon presidential aspirants to rely on the expertise of outsiders. Today, it would be almost un- thinkable to wage a presidential campaign without a "brain trust." Anderson, who served as Nixon's research director in the 1968 campaign, recalled that he super- vised 20 issue-oriented task forces involving about 250 advisers. Last year, he took nine months off to help set up Reagan's advisory arm. "I first developed an account of Reagan's record while he was governor of Califor- nia," Anderson reported. "Next, I put together a basic issues file. This meant col- lecting background material for hundreds of issues. Third, I began to build up contacts among peo- ple who would agree to advise Reagan Franklyn (Lyn) Nofziger, longtime Reagan adviser now serving on a part-time basis: "[Reagan's] approach to the cabinet [while governor] was, 'You guys are my men in the departments: you're not the department's advocate. You will run the department as if it is mine, not yours."' irrespective as to whether they would politically support him." Allen, meanwhile, started rounding up national security specialists. Commenting on his coordinating role, Allen said: "The advisers' views go unrestricted to the Governor. I have strong feelings about that. If they know their ideas aren't going direct to the candidate and being considered, they aren't likely to stay on." Allen, however, may send material to Reagan with a cover letter summarizing the information or directing the can- didate's attention to certain sections or even giving his opinion of the work and making recommendations. Still another aspect of Reagan's cam- paign operations involves an executive advisory committee, headed by former Treasury Secretary William E. Simon, with Michael K. Deaver, a longtime Reagan associate, as vice chairman. "Essentially, the committee is made up of a small group of close Reagan friends who have been advising him for years," said Deaver, a public relations consultant whose firm, Deaver & Hannaford, has offices in Los Angeles and Washington. "Its function has expanded with the campaign and it now serves as a sounding board for Reagan, recruits personnel and assists in fund raising." Among those on the committee, he said, are Holmes Tuttle, a wealthy California automobile dealer; Justin Dart, president of Dart Industries; William French Smith, a partner in one of California's largest law firms and Reagan's personal attorney; and Joseph Coors of the Coors beer family. Once again serving as Reagan's ad- viser, now on a part-time basis, is Franklyn (Lyn) Nofziger, a former Washington political reporter for the Copley newspapers and Reagan's press secretary when he was governor. Nof- ziger, who had a falling out with Sears early in the campaign, left and went back to his political consulting firm. Once Sears was dropped, Nofziger was invited to rejoin. "I've got commitments to my clients, but I help out whenever I can, perhaps a day or two each week," he said. Among the responsibilities of Meese, - Allen, Anderson and others on the Reagan campaign staff is to assure that the candidate is fully briefed on issues and to deter him from making the verbal bloopers and factual misstatements for which he has become known. Reagan also has a tendency to profess ignorance about matters that a public figure normally would be acquainted with, as with his publicized admission that he was not informed about farm parity prices. Approved For Release 2001/07/27 : CIA-RDP91-00901 R0001002gf64'L JOURNAL 4/26/80 673 Approved For Release 2001/07/27 : CIA-RDP91-00901 R000100250004-9 Ronald Reagan's Foreign and ... Ronald Reagan won't be suffering from any lack of advisers in the domestic and national security areas. The front-running Republican presidential candidate has formed a 12-member policy council to give him "advice and counsel on a broad range of key national policy issues," and has also named 41 foreign policy and 26 national defense advisers who, he said, would provide him with policy and research guidance during his campaign. Heading the policy council is former Treasury Secretary William E. Simon. The other members are: William J. Casey, former undersecretary of State for economic affairs, chairman and president of the Export- Import Bank of the United States and chairman of the Securities and Exchange Commission, and currently Reagan's campaign director Alan Greenspan, chairman and president of Townsend- Greenspan & Co. Inc. and chairman of the Council of Economic Advisers under President Ford Rep. Jack F. Kemp, R-N.Y., chairman for policy develop- ment of.the Reagan campaign Irving Kristol, professor of social thought, New York University Graduate School of Business. and senior fellow of the American Enterprise Institute for Public Policy Research (AEI) John McKetta, professor of chemical engineering, Universi- ty of Texas William P. Rogers, lawyer and former Secretary of State and Attorney General Donald Rumsfeld, chairman of G. D. Searle & Co. and former Defense Secretary and ambassador to NATO George P. Shultz, president of the Bechtel Group and former Treasury and Labor Secretary and director of the Office of Management and Budget (OMB) Charls E. Walker. chairman, Charts E. Walker Associates Inc. and former Treasury undersecretary Murray L. Weidenbaum, director, Center for the Study of American Business, Washington University, and former assistant Treasury secretary Caspar W. Weinberger, vice president and general counsel of Bechtel Power Corp. and former Health, Education and Welfare Secretary,--OMB director and Federal Trade Commission chairman FOREIGN POLICY Kenneth L. Adelman, senior policy analyst, SRI interna- tional, and former assistant to the Defense Secretary This has always been characteristic of Reagan. During a controversy over the size of a proposed national redwoods park in California, while he was gover- nor. Reagan is reported to have stated: "A tree's a tree. How ma ny do you have to see?" In an admittedly non-objective book, Reagan. the Political Chameleon (Praeger 1976), former California Gov. Edmund G. (Pat) Brown suggests that Reagan's semantic lapses are attributable to his dependence on "quick and simple answers to the complex questions of government and society." Brown, a Democrat, further notes that "Reagan is used to working from a script. He is a Robert C. Neumann," senior research fellow, Center for- Strategic and International Studies, Georgetown Univer- sity and former ambassador to Afghanistan and Jordan Robert Osgood, professor, School of Advanced Inter- national Studies, and director of the security studies Adda B. Bozeman. professor emeritus of international relations, Sarah Lawrence College W. Glenn Campbell, director of the Hoover Institution on War, Revolution and Peace, Stanford University Lev Dobriansky, economics professor, Georgetown Univer- sity Peter Duignan, senior fellow and director of African and Middle East studies, the Hoover Institution Charles H. Fairbanks, assistant professor of political science, Yale University. and fellow, AEI Roger W. Fontaine. director of Latin American studies, Center for Strategic and International Studies, Georgetown University Jeffrey B. Gayner, director of foreign policy studies, the Heritage Foundation Nathan Glazer, professor, Graduate School of Education, Harvard University Mose L. Harvey, director of the Advanced International Studies Institute, University of Miami Rita E. Hauser, attorney and former U.S. representative to the United Nations Commission on Human Rights Fred C. Ikle, consultant and former director of the Arms Control and Disarmament Agency David C. Jordan, professor of government and foreign affairs, University of Virginia Jenne J. Kirkpatrick, professor of government, Georgetown University, and resident scholar, AEI Ernest W. Lefever, professor of government, Georgetown University Carnes Lord, assistant professor of government and foreign affairs, University of Virginia Edward N. Luttwak, research professor, Georgetown University, and senior fellow. Center for Strategic and International Studies. Georgetown University Charles Burton Marshall, consultant on foreign policy and former member of the State Department policy planning staff Constantine Christopher Menges, consultant to the Hudson Institute Henry R. Nau. associate professor of political science,--, .quick study,' as they say in the acting business, and he made a very handsome living for years playing roles that required only that he memorize his lines, not plumb beneath them for hidden meanings, subtleties or nuances." Brown, defeated for reelection by Reagan in 1966, may have been guilty of a personal bias, but other Reagan watchers have observed the same qualities. The current practice, as laid down by Casey, who has become a more forceful campaign manager than anticipated, is to have one or more issues specialists travel with Reagan at all times. This is in addition to Meese, who accompanies Reagan almost constantly. The assign- ment may go to Anderson or Allen, or others such as Roger W. Fontaine of Georgetown University's Center for Strategic and International Studies and a member of a newly appointed panel of foreign policy advisers. "We will be doing more cycling of people on the campaign plane," said Allen. "It will depend on the issues." Recently hired to assist Meese on the campaign circuit was James Brady, a veteran press-public relations adviser, who had previously worked for former budget director James T. Lynn, Sen. William V. Roth Jr., R-Del., and John B. Connally during his unsuccessful bid for the GOP nomination. Brady will 674 Al *+&, bd 2001 /07/27 : CIA-RDP91-00901 R000100250004-9 . ; . Defense Policy Brain Trust program, The Johns Hopkins University Robert L. PfaltzgraffJr.. professor of international politics, Fletcher School of Law and Diplomacy, Tufts Univer- sity Walter L. Pforzheimer, former legislative counsel to the Central Intelligence Agency Richard E. Pipes, professor of history, Harvard University Uri Ra'anan, chairman of the international securities studies program. Fletcher School of Law and Diplom- acy Edward Rozek, professor University of Colorado of comparative government, Pedro A. Sanjuan, director, Hemispheric Center, AEI Frank Shakespeare, president of RKO General Inc. and former director of the U.S. Information Agency Laurence H. Silberman, executive vice president, Crocker National Bank and former ambassador to Yugoslavia and deputy Attorney General Richard F. Starr, director of the international studies program, Hoover Institution William .L. Stearman, professor and director of the Russian studies program, Georgetown University Robert Strausz-Hupe, former ambassador to NATO, Sweden and Belgium Raymond Tanter, professor of political science, University of Michigan, and fellow, the Wilson Center, Smithsonian Institution James D. Theberge, international business consultant and former ambassador to Nicaragua Robert W. Tucker, professor of political science, The Johns Hopkins University Charts E. Walker Richard L. Walker, director of the Institute of International Studies, University of South Carolina Richard J. Whalen, author, and business consultant and chairman of Wires Ltd. Aaron Wildavsky, professor of political science, University of California (Berkeley) - - Curtin win! Enterprise DEFENSE Frank R. Barnett, president, National Strategy Information Center David A. Burchinal, retired Air Force general and former deputy commander in chief, U.S. Forces in Europe focus on the issues and help deal with the press. A WHITE HOUSE AGENDA Not unnaturally. Reagan, who has had his eye on the 'White House for more than four years, has made plans should he arrive there. Notwithstanding Reagan's assaults on federal social 'welfare programs and big government in general, Allen predicted, He will not go to Washington with animosity toward the federal bu- rca ucracy." Ife would, however, seek conceptual changes in the governmental structure, e'PKjally in the national defense, foreign Joseph Churba, Security president, Institute for International Jacquelyn K. Davis. consultant and strategic analyst John Davis, retired Army lieutenant general and former assistant director of the National Security Agency Russell E. Dougherty, retired Air Force general and former commander in chief, Strategic Air Command Leon Goure, associate director, Advanced International Studies Institute, University of Miami Daniel 0. Graham, co-chairman of the Coalition for Peace Through Strength and former director of the Defense Intelligence Agency Walter F. Hahn. defense analyst Martin R. Hoffman, attorney and former Army Secretary Peter C. Hughes, defense analyst William R. Kintner, professor of political science, University of Pennsylvania, and former ambassador to Thailand Charles M. Kupperman, defense analyst John F. Lehman Jr., president of the Abington Corp. and former deputy director of the Arms Control and Disarmament Agency 1. William Middendorf II. president of Financial General Bankshares Corp. and former Navy Secretary Thomas H. Moorer, retired admiral and former chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff Patrick J. Parker, chairman, National Security Affairs Department, U.S. Naval Postgraduate School Jeffrey Record, consultant and strategic analyst Edward L. Rowny, retired Army lieutenant general and former Joint Chiefs of Staff representative to SALT negotiations William R. Schneider, consultant to The Hudson Insti- . tute Harriet Fast Scott, consultant and writer on Soviet militar y affairs William F. Scott, consultant and writer on Soviet military affairs William R. Van Cleave, director of the Institute for International Studies, University of Southern Califor- nia -_: c . _ John W. Vogt Jr., retired Air Force general and former commander in chief, U. S. Air Forces in Europe Lewis Walt, retired general and former commandant of the Marine Corps Seymour Weiss, vice president of the Abington Corp. and former ambassador to the Bahamas policy and intelligence sectors. "My own view is that he would replace the foreign policy machinery down to the assistant secretary level," Allen said. Singled out for a complete overhaul, according to Allen's scenario, would be the National Security Council's staff operations and its characteristically competitive relations with the State Department. "Do we need a huge NSC staff in the White House?" Allen asked. "Is it a policy maker or a policy facilitator? Maybe its 150 or so people ought to be put back into the federal bureaucracy, giving the State Department a new lease on life." He questioned whether a President "should be inundated with the latest cable traffic and overburdened in sheer volume of minute-to-minute details. Should he not be allowed to concentrate on longer range, critical problems worthy of presidential attention? "There is latent bureaucratic strength in the department. Why should there be a competing organization within the White House. one that constitutes a massive backchannel?" Reagan. in line with similar projec- tions, would also reestablish "a strong economic component" within the foreign policy-national security complex somewhat like the defunct Council on International Economic Policy. Es- Approved For Release 2001/07/27 : CIA-RDP91-0090180001001 SOe@4-20URNAL a 26 80 675 t s Apr~gv For Release 2001/07/27 : CIA-RDP91-00901R000100250004-9 an executive agency by State Department that would review li President Nixon in 1971 to coordinate the matters of mutual concern to the three work of U.S. agencies dealing with North American countries and help foreign economic affairs, the council was establish and implement North-South disbanded early in the Carter Ad- accords. ministration. A second executive agency discon- tinued by Carter, the Foreign Intelligence Advisory Board, would also likely be revived by Reagan. The panel, created by President Eisenhower in 1956, was intended to review the various activities .of the Central Intelligence Agency and other units within the American in- telligence community. In abolishing the board in May 1977, Carter maintained that its work was rendered redundant by monitoring services performed by the NSC and the Senate Intelligence Com- mittee. A forceful advocate of a strengthened U.S. military posture, Reagan is reported to favor an enhanced role for the Joint Chiefs of Staff in defense strategy planning, as well as greater involvement in policy development by the Defense PAST PERFORMANCE One of the unresolved political questions is whether the campaign and a candidate's past performance as a public figure offer satisfactory clues to his probable behavior as President. "They approach it but you don't get a complete picture," said political analyst Richard M. Scammon. "They give an indication of how a candidate handles himself under fire, how organized he is and how he feels about certain issues. But the presidency is so unique, so un- duplicated that you can't get a perfect picture. A candidate's record and previous service can sometimes be deceiv- ing. Look at Harry Truman! But it all helps." Be that as it may, Reagan aides and associates stress that he hasn't changed Richard V. Allen coordinates foreign affairs and defense Department's international security af- fairs office, which is involved in for- mulating and coordinating defense policies in the international political, military and economic spheres, including arms control and disarmament. - In the foreign policy area, Reagan is examining the feasibility of creating a sort of "council of elders," retired ambassadors and veteran foreign service officers whose professional background and breadth of information could be mobilized in times of national emergency. He would also consider efforts to improve U.S. relations with its neighbors, Canada and Mexico, by establishing an office of continental affairs within the much over the past several years and that many of the characteristics he exhibited as governor of California would probably carry over into the White House, should he make it there. Sen. Richard S. Schweiker, R-Pa., selected by Reagan as his prospective running mate in the 1976 campaign, said the candidate is "comfortable in delegating responsibility.... He works easily with his staff and listens to the pros and cons of subordinates. He doesn't crowd them or unduly assume authority." Nofziger, who worked closely with Reagan for many years, similarly ob- served: "He understands the use of the Cabinet and personal staff. He's willing to sten and delegate authority. While governor, he met with the cabinet members about once a week and they would talk and kick things around. His approach to the cabinet was, 'You guys are my men in the departments; you're not the department's advocate. You will run the department as if it is mine, not yours, and this is administration policy and you will carry it out.'" Despite the fact that both Reagan and Carter aspired to the presidency without having had Washington experience and that each assumes a rather aloof attitude toward the nitty-gritty of politics, Reagan aides insist that if he reaches the White House, he will not make the same mistakes that Carter has in the past three years. "One of the things Paul Laxalt and I feel strongly about is that the errors of the Carter Administration aren't repeated," said Schweiker, who serves as Reagan's Northeast campaign coordinator. "Every time Gov. Reagan comes to Washington, we hold a meeting with his initial supporters on the Hill and with prospec- tive supporters for the specific objective of establishing liaison with Congress." Deaver recalled that one of the first moves by the Reagan forces in Sacramen- to "was to get together with a bunch of old political hands who knew how to deal with the Legislature; I assume it would be the first thing we would do in Washington. We certainly would not ignore the legislators like Carter." Anderson and Nofziger are convinced that a lack of direct Washington ex- perience would not hurt Reagan political- ly. -"So much depends on having a good staff and Cabinet," Nofziger said. "If they know what they're doing they'll sit down with the congressional leadership. The California Legislature comes closest to being similar to the U.S. Congress; it works full time, has a big staff and a lot of research assistance. And Reagan's people got along with the Legislature while he was governor." In response to questions about Reagan's lack of foreign policy ex- perience, Nofziger noted, "Jerry Ford didn't have foreign experience when he became President." Besides, argues Anderson, the debate over Washington experience is a specious one. If experience were so important, he said. "the ideal President would come into office after having been Vice Presi- dent, Secretary of State. a U.S. Senator, a Member of Congress and be 35 years old. He just doesn't exist. "Reagan has spent a lot of time in and around Washington and he knows many people there. That's indicated by the people he has around him." ^ 676 NATIONAL JOURNAL 4/26/80 Approved For Release 2001/07/27 : CIA-RDP91-00901 R000100250004-9