LETTER FROM CHARLES T. TART, PH.D. TO: PA RESEARCHERS.

• Document Type: CREST
• Collection: STARGATE
• Document Number (FOIA) /ESDN (CREST): CIA-RDP96-00787R000500250012-9
• Release Decision: RIPPUB
• Original Classification: U
• Document Page Count: 6
• Document Creation Date: November 4, 2016
• Document Release Date: March 29, 2000
• Sequence Number: 12
• Publication Date: May 6, 1978
• Content Type: LETTER

Approved For Release 2000/08/07: CIA-RDP916-0078
UNIVERSITY OF CALIFORNIA, DAVIS
DEI'A1 TMENT OF PSYCHOLOGY
May 6, 1978
To PA Researchers
I want to thank you all for promptly returning the questionnaire
I sent out about possible military applications of psi and fund-
ing of parapsychological research. I have done a tally of the
reports, and they are presented in the enclosed brief paper, which
I've also submitted for presentation at the PA in August, as I
think all our members should be aware of this data.
I hope you find this data useful: it certainly confirms the ter-
ribly underfunded state of the field, and also confirms the un-
pleasant fact that we seem to agree that there are negative uses
for psi. Although I will not formally present the paper until
August, assuming it is accepted for the program, feel free to use
the information in it meanwhile in any way you feel is beneficial
for advancing the field. If you need a source reference you may
cite this as an unpublished paper or a personal communication for
the time being.
With best wishes,
Charles T. Tart, Ph. D.
Professor of Psychology
Approved For Release 2000/08/07 : CIA-RDP96-00787R000500250012-9
 Approved For Release 2000/08/07 : CIA-RDP96-00787R000500250012-9
A Survey of Expert Opinion on Potentially Negative
Uses of Psi, U.S. Government Interest in Psi, and
the Level of Research Funding of the Field
Charles T. Tart
University of California at Davis
CPYRGHT
Considerable concern has been expressed by some parapsychologists
lately about the possible military uses of psi ability. This concern is
partially based on assessments that the U.S.S.R. is not only conducting
secret research on the development of military applications of psi, but
that this military research is funded at high support levels such that
significant progress on understanding and using psi is more likely in the
U.S.S.R. than in the U.S.A. These kinds of concerns have been expressed
in the recently declassified Defense Intelligence Agency document DST-
18105-387-75, "Soviet and Czechoslovakian Parapsychology Research."
Adequate assessment of this situation is difficult for several reasons.
First, any estimate of what is happening with secret military research in
the U.S.S.R. must involve considerable inference and conjecture. Second,
there has been no collection of expert opinion in the U.S.A. as to whether
psi can potentially be used for military purposes. Third, there has been
little,;if any factual data on the actual level of support of parapsychologi-
cal research.in the U.S.A.
This paper will report a survey of (1) expert opinion on the potential
military uses of psi; (2) the degree to which the U.S. government has offi-
cially made inquiries about the field among experts in parapsychology; and
(3) the level of funding of parapsychological research over the past five
years. Hopefully this will provide some data relevant to these important
questions.
Sampling Procedure:
 l.l-' T K Rnoroved For Release 2000/08/07 - CIA 1CSP96-00787R000500250012-9
Except for possible classified research on psi, it is relatively
straightforward to identify the handful of individuals and research labora-
tories that have produced the bulk of experimental data on parapsychology
in the last five years. Based on the membership list of the Parapsychological
Association (PA), my knowledge of the literature, and my personal acquain-
tance with most of the workers in this field, in March of 1978 I sent ques-
tionnaires to individuals (the director or an outstanding individual scien-
tist) at 14 identifiable parapsychological research laboratories in this
country. My criteria for selection was that each individual had to be a
full member of the PA who had been actively working and publishing in the
field for the last five years. Each had to have at least one occasional
colleague to qualify to represent a laboratory or center. In order to pro-
tect the confidentiality of my respondents, I shall not specify my selection
criteria in any more detail, but I believe that an almost identical selection
would be made by every knowledgeable parapsychologist. Thirteen of the four-
teen questionnaires were completed and returned to me.
The questionnaire asked each respondent for his or her opinion on three
potential military applications of psi, about official government visits to
their laboratory, and about the average funding level of their laboratory
over the past five years.
Results:
Question 1: "How strongly do you believe that psi abilities might poten-
-tially be used in the future in a practically useful way for espionage and
military intelligence activities? Assume that very large amounts of money
and scientific manpower would be used to study and develop these. activities
in making your estimate."
The response categories allowed for this and the following two questions
were "Impossible," "Unlikely," "Possible," "Likely," and "Certain." No
Approved For Release 2000/08/07 : CIA-RDP96-00787R000500250012-9
 CPYR
roved For Release 2000/08/07 : CIA-RP96-00787R000500250012-9
respondent considered espionage use of psi impossible or unlikely. Four
considered it possible, five likely, and the remaining four considered it
certain.
Question 2: "How strongly do you believe that psi abilities might poten-
tially be used in the future in a practically useful way by the military to
physically harm, sicken, or kill individuals? Again assume enormous re-
sources devoted to such development."
considered
No respondent,,) this impossible, two thought it unlikely, seven
possible, three likely, and one certain.
Question 3: "How strongly do you believe that psi abilities might oten-
tially be used in the future in a practically useful way by the military to
physically interfere with the operation of physical equipment, such as com-
puters, observation instruments, etc." Again assume enormous resources
devoted to such development."
The distribution of answers to this question was almost identical to
those of the second question. No respondent thought this impossible, one
thought it unlikely, seven possible, four likely, and one certain.
There is a fairly general consensus of these experts, then, that several
military applications of psi are possible or even likely if enough development
research were carried out.
Question 4: "Have you or one of your laboratory staff been approached
by agents or officials of the U.S. government, acting in an official capacity,
in the last five years, in order to gather information on parapsychology for
any government agency?"
The alternatives here were "Never," "Once," "Several Times," and "Fre-
quently." The bulk (8) of the respondents had never been approached, one
had been once, and four had been approached several times. None answered
that they had been approached frequently. Thus the U.S. government has
Approved For Release 2000/08/07 : CIA-RDP96-00787R000500250012-9
 Tart -[+_
CPYR"r ed For Release 2000/08/07 : CIA-RDP96-00787R000500250012-9
gathered at least some information about the field from knowledgeable sources.
Funding Level: Because the question of funding in a chronically under-
funded field can be emotionally sensitive, the questionnaires were returned
to me in a manner that did not allow me to identify individual respondents.
I asked the respondents to estimate their laboratory's average yearly budget
(over the past five years) that had been available for research on psi.
Teaching or service activities were not to be included in this estimate, nor
was any dollar value to be put on volunteer help. Researchers who had a
full-time salary but who could use only part of their time on psi research
were to prorate their salary accordingly. I would guess that the funds
available to these 13 respondents probably represent at least 80-90% of all
the funds available for scientific parapsychological research. Thus the figures
below should be close estimates of actual dollars that have been available
for research.
The total funds available per year for the entire group of respondents
was $552,000. The distribution of these funds was quite uneven: individual
yearly laboratory budgets ranged from no funds at all to $150,000. While
the mean level of yearly funding was $42,500, the median level was $17,000.
That is, half the active research laboratories in the U.S.A. had yearly
research budgets of less than $17,000.
As a comparison, a generally accepted figure for yearly support of a
single research scientist in industrial settings is $75,000. By this standard,
the total yearly budget for scientific parapsychological research in the U.
S.A. is sufficient to adequately support seven and three-tenths scientists.
It is of some interest to look at the relationships between funding level,
frequency of government visits, and assessment of military potentials of psi.
I computed a total military potential score for each respondent by assigning
0, 1, 2, 3, or 4 points for "Impossible" to "Certain" responses to the three
Approved For Release 2000/08/07 : CIA-RDP96-00787R000500250012-9
 Approved For Release 2000/08/07 : CIA-F~DP96-00787R000500250012-9
CPYRGHT
questions about potential military applications of psi. A respondent who
thought all three applications were certain, e.g., would receive a military
score of 12, while one who thought they were all impossible would receive a
score of zero. I assigned numerical values of 0, 1, 3, and 6 to the "Never,"
"Once," and "Several Times," response categories about government visits.
As the "Frequently" category was not used, it was not assigned a.value
Using this procedure, estimated military potential and yearly budget
were not significantly correlated- (r = -.20), nor were military potential
and frequency of government visits (r = -.33). Frequency of government visits
and yearly budget level were suggestively (p 4 .10, 2-tailed) correlated
(r = +.51). This probably reflects the fact that larger laboratories are
more visible.
Discussion:
As mentioned at the beginning of this paper, it is difficult to accurately
assess the extent of U.S.S.R.'s research effort in developing military appli-
cations of parapsychology. The expert scientists sampled here, however,
generally agree that at least some military applications may be possible or
likely, especially the use of psi for espionage purposes.
I had originally planned to compare the parapsychology research budget
with other fields of science, but the total amount is so low for any field
of science that this would be fruitless. Many large corporations undoubtedly
have higher budgets for researching more attractive packages for facial tissues.
As to possible discrepancy in the size of research efforts in the U.S.
S.R. and the U.S.A., the budget data revealed in this survey indicate it
would take but a tiny fraction of national resources for the U.S.S.R. to
overshadow U.S. research activity by one or two orders of magnitude.
Approved For Release 2000/08/07 : CIA-RDP96-00787R000500250012-9