<SANITIZED> THE STRENGTHS AND WEAKNESSES OF THE PHUNG HOANG PROGRAM AND VC METHODS FOR COUNTERING THE PROGRAM

Document Type: 
Collection: 
Document Number (FOIA) /ESDN (CREST): 
05015464
Release Decision: 
RIPPUB
Original Classification: 
U
Document Page Count: 
5
Document Creation Date: 
March 9, 2023
Document Release Date: 
August 11, 2021
Sequence Number: 
Case Number: 
F-2019-01120
Publication Date: 
April 21, 1971
File: 
AttachmentSize
PDF icon SANITIZED THE STRENGTHS A[15952967].pdf242.29 KB
Body: 
-Approved for Release: 2021/08/05 C05015464 (b)(1) (b)(3) (b)(1) (b)(3) MPATE OP 7?1,4,N8 intelligence Information Report This material contains information affecting the National Defense of the United States within the meaning of the Espionage taws, Title 18, U.S.C. Secs. 793 and 794, the tranoktission or revelation of which In any manner to an unauthorized person is...prohibited by law. GROUP I Non o�Parnak deProvechng RIM dedeugleaflun NO FOREIGN DISSEM PAGE 1 OF 5 PAGES COUNTRY SUBJECT ACQ SOURCE THIS IS AN INFORMATION REPORT, NOT FINALLY EVALUATED INTELLIGENCE REPORT NO. (b)(3) (b)(1) DATE DISTR. 2 APRIL 1971 � SOUTH VIETNAM (b)(3) (b)(3) � FEBRUARY .1971 � - 1. (b)(3) THE STRENGTHS AND (b)(3) OF THE PHUNG HOANG PROGRAM 2. VIET CONG METHODS FOR COUNTERING THE PROGRAM - VIETNAM, /27 MARCH 1971,-- � FIELD NO. (b)(3) R E T/NO FOREIGN DISSEM iilcatMn) (dissem controls) STATE I DIA ARMY NAVY AIR j NSA [CRS (For Field Distribution see final paragraph) (b)(1) (b)(3) 5 3 2 1 Approved for Release: 2021/08/05 C05015464 --Approved for Release: 2021/08/05 C05015464--- S EC RE T/NO FOREIGN DISSEM SUMMARY. PAGE 2 OF 5 PAGES (b)(3) (b)(1) (b)(3) (b)(1) (b)(3) THE PHUNG HOANG PROGRAM AS A BASICALLY EFFECTIVE WEAPON AGAINST THE VC BUT WITH SOME DEFICIENCES WHICH DETRACT FROM ITS VALUE TO THE GOVERNMENT OF VIETNAM /GVNi. THE DEFICIENCIES INCLUDE THE FACT THAT A DISPROPORTIONATELY LARGE NUMBER OF VC CAP- TURED THROUGH THE PROGRAM ARE LOW LEVEL AND, THIromi) IS THE RESULT OF A CONTRIBUTING FACTOR) I.E.ITHAT NEARLY (b)(3) ALL PHUNG HOANG OPERATIONS ARE CONDUCTED DURING DAYLIGHT HOURS AND THE REAL VC CADRES AVOID CAPTURE MERELY BY STAYING IN SECURE AREAS DURING THE DAY AND OPERATING IN THE VILLAGES AT NIGHT. THE MOST SERIOUS PROBLEM IS THE ANTI-GVN BACKLASH AMONG THE PEOPLE RESULTING FROM THE ARREST AND CONVICTION OF PEOPLE IN CONTESTED AREAS WHO HAVE BEEN COERCED INTO VC MEMBERSHIP BECAUSE THE GVN FAILED TO PROVIDE THEM WITH ADEQUATE PROTECTION SO THEY COULD SAFELY REJECT VC RECRUITMENT. END SUMMARY. (b)(1) (b)(3) PHUNG HOANG PROGRAM IS A BASICALLY EFFECTIVE WEAPON AGAINST THE ,VC BUT HAS SOME SERIOUS DEFICIENCIES UPON WHICH THE VC CAPITALIZE. ON THE GVN CREDIT SIDE, THE PHUNG HOANG PROGRAM HAS SUCCEEDED IN CAPTURING A LARGE NUMBER OF VC CADRES AND RESTRICTING, THROUGH FEAR OF CAPTURE, THE ACTIVITIES OF MANY OTHERS. FURTHERMORE, THE PHUNG HOANG PROGRAM HAS MADE IT MORE DIFFICULT FOR THE VC TO SECURE 4 3 THE SUPPORT OF THE RURAL POPULATION. MANY VILLAGERS REFUSE TO 2 S ECRE T/NO FOREIGN DISSEM , A � � .1! � lit 4 Approved for Release: 2021/08/05 C05015464 _Approved for Release: 2021/08/05 C05015464----- S EC RE T/NO FOREIGN DISSEM PAGE 3 OF 5 PAGES SUPPORT THE VC THROUGH EITHER FINANCIAL OR MATERIEL CONTRIBUTIONS OR SERVICE IN FRONT OR MASS ORGANIZATONS BECAUSE OF FEAR OF ARREST BY THE GVN. THIS DOUBLE EFFECT, ON THE ONE HAND INHIBITING VC CADRES AND ON THE OTHER, DISCOURAGING THE PEOPLE FROM SUPPORTING THE VC, HAS SUBSTANTIALLY INCREASED THE VC 'S PROBLEMS IN GVN-CONTROLLED AND CONTESTED AREAS. 2. ON THE DEBIT SIDE FOR THE GVN, THE PHUNG'HOANG PROGRAM HAS AT LEAST TWO SERIOUS FAULTS-- A. IT CAPTURES A DISPROPORTIONATELY LARGE NUMBER OF LOW- LEVEL VC, MANY OF THEM MERE SYMPATHIZERS OR TAXPAYERS, AND RELATIVELY FEW HIGH�LEVEL MEMBERS OF THE VC INFRASTRUCTURE. ONE REASON FOR THIS IS THAT NEARLY ALL PHUNG HOANG OPERATIONS ARE CONDUCTED DURING DAYLIGHT HOURS AND THE SENIOR-LEVEL VC AVOID CAPTURE BY HIDING IN SECURE AREAS DURING THE DAY AND ENTERING.THVVILLAGES (b)(1) ONLY AT NIGHT.- INMOST. DISPUTED AREAS GVN VILLAGE (b)(3) AND HAMLET OFFICIALS AS WELL AS MEMBERS OF THE PEOPLE'S SELF- (b)(3) DEFENSE FORCE /PSDF/ ALMOST ALWAYS MOVE INTO OUTPOSTS AND STRONGPOINTS (b)(1) DURING THE NIGHT)LEAVING THE VILLAGE VIRTUALLY UNPROTECTED AND OPE(b)(3) TO PENETRATION BY SMALL NUMBERS OF VC. PSDF AMBUSH OPERATIONS AND USUALLY EASILY AVOIDED. SOON, WARNING, OFF THE INFILTRATORS. INFILTRATION INTO ONLY ONE MAN WOUNDED./ THE OCCASIONAL (b)(1) WERE HALF-HEARTED, POORLY ORGANI(b)(3) THE PSDF ALWAYS FIRED TOO (b)(1) (b)(3) IN EIGHT MONTHS OF NIGHTLY R. THE MOST SERIOUS DEFECT IN THE PHUNG HOANG THE VC SUFFERED (b)(1) (b)(3) (b)(1) (b)(3) PR OGR AM IS THAT IT ALIENATES THE PEOPLE BY ARRESTING_ AND CONVICTING 'LARGE Mt!MRER S OF REALLY INNOCENT PEOPLE. THIS IS BECAUSE AT LEAST WLF oF...LIE STRUCTURE OF A TYPICAL VILLAGE OR HAMLET IN MOST ce,..1.11100111111XCAP.M.Y.,. courFsTED AREAS CONSISTS OF PAPER CADRES WHO NEVER DO ANY AWN. ^*. ACTTIAL WORK FOR THE VC AND WHO HAVE SEEN RECRUITED BY PURE pop3cIo,N. THE VILLAGE PARTY SECRETARY AND THE VILLAGE PARTY COMMITTEE MUST ,i4ow RESULT 5 TO _TIT_ R j CT COMMITTEE. ACCORD I NG TO THE SIZE f)T,' IMP. VILLAr., THESE COMMITTEES MUST RECRUIT A CERTAIN NUMBER 5 4 3 2 1 SECRET/NO FOREIGN DISSEM Approved for Release: 2021/08/05 C05015464 - -Approved for Release: 2021/08/05 C05015464-- - SECR TATO FOR:EIGN _DISSEM PAGE 4 OF 5 PAGES OF FARMERS' AND WOMEN'S ASSOCIATION CELLS, A CERTAIN NUMBER OF MILITARY AND CIVIL IAN PRO SEL YT I NG' CADRE S dETERA ;1: SELDOM-,T IF EVER, IN CONTESTED AREAS CAN ALL OF THESE POSITIONS BE FILLED RY VOLUNTEERS, SO THE VILLAGE PARTY SECRETARY SELECTS VILLAGERS TO FILL THE SLOTS. THE VILLAGERS HAVE NO CHOICE BUT TO AGREE RECAUSE THEY KNOW THE GVN PROTECTS THEM AND THEIR FAMILIES FROM THE VC ONLY DURING THE DAYTIME. ALL OF THESE NAMES ARE RE- CORDED AS FILLING VC POSIT IONS AND THE NAMES ARE FORWARDED TO VC DISTRICT HEADQUARTERS. HOWEVER, IT IS ONE THING TO FORM AN ASSOCIATION ON PAPER AND ANOTHER TO PUT IT TO � at WatK. THE VARIOUS CELLS AND ASSOCIATIONS FORMED IN THIS MANNER (b)(3) (b)(1) (b)(3) USUALLY NEVER HOLD A MEETING', THE PR OSEL YT ING CADRES MAY NEVER ATTEMPT TO PERSUADE ANYONE TO WORK FOR THE VC AND THE FINANCE ECONOMY CELLS WILL CONTRIBUTE ONLY WHAT THEY ARE FORCED TO PAY. IF PRESSED TO OPERATE, THEY WILL OFFER EXCUSES, AND, IF PRESSED TOO HART4 THEY MAY RALLY, MAKING THE VILLAGE .COMMITTEE APPEAR INCOMPETENT TO THE DISTRICT COMMITTEE AND ENDANGERING THE WHOLE PAPER STRUCTURE. THE ANT I-GVN BACKLASH OCCURS WHEN PHUNG HOA NG DAYTIME OPERATIONS, BASED ON CAPTURED DOCUMENTS OR PRISONER OR RALL IER INFORMATION, RESULT IN THE ARRESTS OF THESE "PAPER CADRES" WHO LIVE IN THE VILLAGES WITH THEIR FAMILIES. THE VILLAGE PARTY COMMITTEE MEMBERS ARE SELDOM APPREHENDED BECAUSE THEY ARE PHYSICALLY PRESENT IN THE VILLAGE ONLY AT NIGHT. THE ARRESTED PERSONS ARE OFTEN INTIMIDATED AND SOMETIMES BEATEN UNTIL THEY SIGN A CONFESSION. THEIR DISCLAIMERS OF INNOCENCE OF VC INVOLVEMENT ARE DISREGARDED BY THEIR- CAPTORS AND THEY ARE USUALLY CONVICTED AND SENTENCED TO JAIL MANY OF THESE PEOPLE HAVE RELATIVES WORKING FOR THE GVN WHO DEEPLY RESENT THIS INJUSTICE. 3. BECAUSE THE GVN DOES NOT PROVIDE ADEQUATE PROTECTION FOR THE PEOPLE IN THE CONTESTED AREAS, BUT ST ILL PUNISHES THEM FOR ._INVOLUNTARY COOPERATION WITH THE VC, THE POPULATION IN DISPUTED AREAS FEARS AM) RESENTS THE PHUNG ROAM PROGRAM. THE VC TRY TO CAPITALIZE ON THIS ATTITUDE BY STIRRING UP THE PEOPLE AGAINST THE PRIM HOANG PROGRAM WHENEVER SOMEONE IS ARRESTED. IF A LARGE 2 1 SECRET/NO FOREIGN DISSEM is 4 3 2 1 got -: St1171 Approved for Release: 2021/08/05 C05015464 -Approved for Release: 2021/08/05 C05015464__ SECRET/NO FOREIGN DISSEM PAGE 5 OF 5 PAGES NtimriER OF ARRESTS OCCUR IN A PARTICULAR AREA, THE VC TRY TO OR- WilF, AN ANT I-PHUNG HOA NG CAMPAIGN AMONG THE PEOPLE TO PRESSURE r;CAL GVN LEADERS TO WITHDRAW SUPPORT FROM THE PHUNG HOA NG. MOOR AM. ORGANIZING SUCH A CAMPAIGN IS FACILITATED BY THE FACT THAT NEARLY EVERY FAMILY IN A CONTESTED AREA HAS HAD A RELATIVE ARRESTED AND POSSIBLY MISTREATED OR FALSELY CONVICTED BY THE GYM AT ONE T IME OR ANOTHER. /F IELD COMMENT: THE VC CADRES I ARE NOT GIVEN ANY GUIDANCE ,ON HOW TO CONDUCT THEMSELVES IF ARRESTED AND THEY ARE NOT INSTRUCTED TO ACCUSE INNOCENT _PERSONS OF BEING VC. (b)(3) (b)(1) (b)(3) (b)(1) (b)(3) FIELD D ISSEM:. STATE, USMACV USAir), CORDS, DIR1JUSPAO /MR. NICKEL ONLY/, 7TH AIR FORCE, USARV NAVFORV 1021 FAS, OFT, 525TH MI GP, CINCPAC PACFLT , PA CAF ARPACIALSO SENT S EC RE T/NO FOREIGN D ISSEM (b)(1) (b)(3) 5 4 3 2 1 Approved for Release: 2021/08/05 C05015464