CARD NAME #1

• Document Type: FOIA
• Collection: FOIA Collection
• Document Number (FOIA) /ESDN (CREST): 06711363
• Release Decision: RIPPUB
• Original Classification: U
• Document Page Count: 5
• Document Creation Date: December 28, 2022
• Document Release Date: November 7, 2017
• Case Number: F-2017-01128
• Publication Date: July 1, 2016

Card Name
Approved for Release: 2017/11/01 006711363
Difficulty PolitiW I Wea ons
Points
Tvoe
al-Qa'ida Leadership
9
P
M
3
China Missile Testing
7
M
W
3
Missile
Iran Missile Testing
7
- M
W
3
Missile
6
P
E
3
North Korea Nuclear Talks
7
P
M
W
3
Nuclear
Pakistan Nuclear Security
9
P
M
W
3
Nuclear
Taliban Resurgence
7 _
P
M
E
3
Total
5
6
2
4
Afghanistan Opium Network
7
P
M
E
2
8
P
W
2
Nuclear
Caspian Energy Crisis
6
P
M
E
2
India Missile Program
7
M
W
2
Iraq Instability
8
P
M
2
Israel Palestinian Conflict
7
P
M
E
2
Russia Georgia Conflict
6
P
M
2
Russia Military Sales
7
P
M
E
W
2
8
M
W
2
Venezuela Foreign Policy
6
P
E
. 2
ota
8
8
5
4
Atrocities in Darfur
5
P
M
1
Bolivia Economic Reform
4
P
E
1
China Yuan Revaluation
5
P
E
1
Europe Crime and Corruption
6
P
E
1
G-8 Summit
4
P
E
1
Global Warming Summit
3
P
E
1
Indonesia Typhoon
4
P
E
1
Iraq Oil Infrastructure
5
M
E
1
4
P
1
Syria Chemical Weapon Training
8
M
W
1
Chemical
China Taiwan Posturing
5
P
M
1
Weaponized UAV Proliferation
7
M
E
W
1
Zimbabwe Unrest
4
P
M
1
o a
Totals
Total cards
23
30
6
20
8
15
2
10
Approved for Release: 2017/11/01 006711363
Points
Diff
1
3
1
4
1
4
4
1
4
1
4
5
1
5
1
5
1
5
1
6
1
7
1
8
2
6
2
6
2
6
2
7
2
7
2
7
2
7
2
8
2
8
2
8
3
6
3
7
3
7
3
7
3
7
3
9
3
9
Count of Diff
Points
Diff
1
2
3
Grand Total
3
1
1
4
5
5
5
4
4
6
1
3
1
5
7
1
4
4
9
8
1
3
4
9
2
2
Grand Total
13
10
7
30
Approved for Release: 2017/11/01 006711363
ur
r
.iPolnrs liaDiff'
1:- eri�rI-.
Emimmimm:m.
$4
L_ 1 3 I
EMEM=113=.
IMEMI=.111MMEI
11.1MIEME
MIMEMM=.51MI
�
�
�
MEMMEMME
MIMIMMEMEMM
11111M.111WMO
4
New Problem Ideal (need 16)
AI-Shabaab Attacks in Kenya
UAE Reform Crackdown
ASEAN Summit
Egyptian Islamist Political Parties
Brazil Economic Innovation
South Sudan Political Infrastructure
Syria Political Unrest
Bulgaria Law Reforms
Cuba Privatization
Russian Intelligence Activities
Iran Cyber Warfare
Iran Chemical Weapon Program
Russia Chemical Weapon Capability
India Nuclear Program
Russia Nuclear Warhead Redesign
Macedonia Ethnic Violence
Arctic Territorial Claims
NATO Infighting
Hlzballah Weapon Acquisition
Russia Defense Reform
Kuridish Activism in Turkey
2
2
2
3
3
3
3
3
3
7
IMMIMMINM
Count of De
Points
Dff
1
2
3
Grand Total
3
2
2
4
6
2
8
5
5
3
1
9
6
1
4
2
7
7
1
5
4
10
8
1
3
3
7
9
1
2
3
Grand Total
16
18
12
46
7
6
6
5
5
0
33
2
2
1
1
1
3
4
5
6
7
9
� 1
�2
�3
Difficulty
Problem
s
GEOINT
Technlq
ues
HUMINT
Technlq
ues
MASINT
Technique
s
OSINT
Technlq
ues
SIGINT
Technlq
ues
Total
Technlq
ues
54501
Technlq
ues In
Range
1
0
3
2
0
6
0
11
17%
2
0
3
5
0
6
0
14
22%
3
2
8
8
0
9
1
26
40%
4
8
10
10
1
10
8
39
60%
5
9
15
14
6
11
11
57
88%
6
7
15
15
7
11
11
59
91%
7
10
15
12
8
11
14
60
92%
8
7
11
10
8
2
13
44
68%
9
3
10
6
7
0
11
34
52%
10
0
10
2
7
0
9
28
43%
Aspect
Matchin
e
Technlq
ues
Matchln
9
Problem
s
Ratio
P
37
34
1.09
M
53
31
1.71
E
32
20
1.60
W
49
15
3.27
Approved for Release: 2017/11/01 006711363
Card Name
Difficul
-Tft111-Inr ft r 7
Approved for Release: 2017/11/01 006711363
Political Military Economic Weaponi�Pares"� Type
al-Qa'ida Leadership
9
P
M
3
China Missile Testing
7
M
W
3
Missile
Iran Missile Testing
7
M
W
3
Missile
6
P
E
3
North Korea Nuclear Talks
7
P
M
W
3
Nuclear
Pakistan Nuclear Securi
9
P
M
w
3
Nuclear
Taliban Resurgence
7
P
M
E
3
Syria Political Unrest
Russia Intelligence Activities
8 P
M
3
China Cyber Warfare
8
China CountersPace Capabilities
6
Iran Chemical Weapon Program
8
M
W 3 Chemical
Total 8 10 3 6
Afghanistan Opium Network
7
2
8
2
Nuclear
Caspian Energy Crisis
6
2
India Missile Program
7
2
Iraq Instability
8
2
Israel Palestinian Conflict
7
2
Russia Georgia Conflict
6
2
Russia Milita Sales
7
2
8
2
Venezuela Foreign Policy
6
2
AI-Shabaab Attacks in Kenya
UAE Reform Crackdown
Egypt Islamist Political Parties
Hizballah Weapon Acquisition
Russia Nuclear Warhead Design
Kurd Activism in Turkey
Russia Defense Reform
Total
13
14
7
7
Atrocities in Darfur
5
P
M
1
Bolivia Economic Reform
4
P
E
1
China Yuan Revaluation
5
P
E
1
Europe Crime and Corruption
6
P
E
1
G-8 Summit
4
P
E
1
Global Warming Summit
3
P
E
1
Indonesia Typhoon
4
P
E
1
Iraq Oil Infrastructure
5
M
E
1
4
P
1
Syria Chemical Weapon Training
8
M
W
1
Chemical
China Taiwan Posturing
5
P
M
1
Weaponized UAV Proliferation
7
M
E
W
1
Zimbabwe Unrest
4
P
M
1
Macedonia Ethnic Violence
5 P
3 P
Total
13
7
10
2
Totals
34
31
20
15
Total cards
46
10P-SEGRET,
3
3
3
3
3
3
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
Syria Political Unrest
Russia Intelligence Activities
China Cyber Warfare
China Counterspace Capabilities
Iran Chemical Weapon Program
Al-Shabaab Attacks in Kenya
UAE Reform Crackdown
Egyptian Islamist Political Parties
Brazil Economic Innovation
South Sudan Political Infrastructure
South Korean Missile Program
India Nuclear Program
Russia Nuclear Warhead Redesign
Hizballah Weapon Acquisition
Russia Defense Reform
Kuridish Activism in Turkey
ASEAN Summit
Bulgaria Law Reforms
Cuba Privatization
Macedonia Ethnic Violence
Arctic Territorial Claims
NATO Infighting
Approved for Release: 2017/11/01 006711363
Approved for Release: 2017/11/01 C06711363
Card Name
Effect
Aggressive Counterintelligence
Counter a HUMINT collection technique
Persona Non-Grata
Counter a HUMINT collection technique
Misinformed Source
Counter a HUMINT collection technique
Encryption
Counter a SIGINT collection technique
Linguists Reassigned
Counter a SIGINT or OSINT collection technique
Bad Weather
Counter a GEOINT Technique
Satellite Warning
Counter a satellite-based GEOINT collection technique
Satellite Failure
Counter a satellite-based GEOINT or SIGINT collection technique
Ground Station Failure
Counter a satellite-based GEOINT or SIGINT collection technique
Corrupt Signature Database
Counter a MASINT collection technique
Disinformation Campaign
Counter an OSINT collection technique
Customer Bias
Counter an OSINT collection technique
Media Blackout
Counter an OSINT collection technique
Compartmented
Counter a non-OSINT collection technique
Denial and Deception
Counter a non-MASINT collection technique
No Exploitation Resources
Counter any collection technique
Competition
Counter any collection technique
Red Tape
Counter any collection technique
Internal Politics
Counter any collection technique
Hard Target
Increase difficulty of problem by 1
Hard Target
Increase difficulty of problem by 1
Soft Target
Decrease difficulty of problem by 1
SoftTarget
Decrease difficulty of problem by 1
Really Hard Target
Increase difficulty of problem by 2
Really Soft Target
Decrease difficulty of problem by 2
Provide Feedback
Expand a collection technnique's spectrum by 1
Rotation to a Collector
Expand a collection technnique's spectrum by 1
Update Intelligence Requirements
Expand a collection technnique's spectrum by 1
Coordinate Requirements Across IC
Expand a collection technnique's spectrum by 1
Working Group Meeting
Expand a collection technnique's spectrum by 1
Provide Targeting Help
Expand a collection technnique's spectrum by 1
Provide Funding to a Collector
Expand a collection technnique's spectrum by 1
Support from IC Leadership
Expand a collection technnique's spectrum by 1
Good Justification
Expand a collection technnique's spectrum by 1
Leverage Personal Relationship
Expand a collection technnique's spectrum by 1
Think Outside the Box
Counter any other Reality Check card except Collection Manager Challenge
Think Outside the Box
Counter any other Reality Check card except Collection Manager Challenge
Think Outside the Box
Counter any other Reality Check card except Collection Manager Challenge
Think Outside the Box
Counter any other Reality Check card except Collection Manager Challenge
Think Outside the Box
Counter any other Reality Check card except Collection Manager Challenge
Think Outside the Box
Counter any other Reality Check card except Collection Manager Challenge
Think Outside the Box
Counter any other Reality Check card except Collection Manager Challenge
Think Outside the Box
Counter any other Reality Check card except Collection Manager Challenge
Collection Management Challenge
Player must explain how the technique would be used against the problem
Collection Management Challenge
Player must explain how the technique would be used against the problem
Collection Management Challenge
Player must explain how the technique would be used against the problem
Collection Management Challenge
Player must explain how the technique would be used against the problem
Collection Management Challenge
Player must explain how the technique would be used against the problem
Collection Management Challenge
Player must explain how the technique would be used against the problem
Collection Management Challenge
Player must explain how the technique would be used against the problem
Collection Management Challenge
Player must explain how the technique would be used against the problem
Collection Management Challenge
Player must explain how the technique would be used against the problem
Collection Management Challenge
Player must explain how the technique would be used against the problem
Collection Management Challenge
Player must explain how the technique would be used against the problem
Collection Management Challenge
Player must explain how the technique would be used against the problem
55
10P-SECREL
Approved for Release: 2017/11/01 C06711363
Approved for Release: 2017/11/01 006711363
Difficulty
Problems
GEOINT
Techniques
HUMINT
Techniques
MASINT
Techniques
OSINT
Techniques
SIGINT
Techniques
Total
Techniques
% of
Techniques
1
0
3
2
0
6
0
11
17%
2
0
3
5
0
. 6
0
14
22%
3
1
8
8
0
9
1
26
40%
4
5
10
10
1
10
8
39
60%
5
5
15
14
6
11
11
57
88%
6
5
15
15
7
11
11
59
91%
7
8
15
12
8
11
14
60
92%
8
4
11
10
8
2
13
44
68%
9
2
10
6
7
0
11
34
52%
10
0
10
2
7
0
9
28
43%
Total
30
Aspect
Matching
Techniques
Matching
Problems
Ratio
P
37
23
1.61
M
53
20
2.65
E
32
15
2.13
W
49
10
4.90
Discipline
# Techniques
GEOINT
15
HUMINT
17
MASINT
8
OSINT
11
SIGINT
14
Total
Number of techniques
18
16
14
12
10
8
6
4
2
0
65
Difficulty
�GEOINT Techniques
�HUMINT Techniques
�MASINT Techniques
�OSINT Techniques
�SIGINT Techniques
Approved for Release: 2017/11/01 006711363