FOREIGN RADIO AND PRESS REACTION TO PRESIDENT NIXON'S MIDDLE EAST VISIT

Document Type: 
Collection: 
Document Number (FOIA) /ESDN (CREST): 
LOC-HAK-182-3-5-1
Release Decision: 
RIFLIM
Original Classification: 
K
Document Page Count: 
43
Document Creation Date: 
January 11, 2017
Document Release Date: 
December 5, 2011
Sequence Number: 
5
Case Number: 
Publication Date: 
June 21, 1974
Content Type: 
MEMO
File: 
AttachmentSize
PDF icon LOC-HAK-182-3-5-1.pdf2.44 MB
Body: 
No Objection to Declassification in Full 2011/12/05: LOC-HAK-182-3-5-1 for official use only FOREIGN BROADCAST INFORMATION SERVICE SPECIAL MEMORANDUM FOREIGN RADIO AND PRESS REACTION TO PRESIDENT aNIXON'S MIDDLE EAST VISIT for official use only 21 JUNE 1974 No Objection to Declassification in Full 2011/12/05: LOC-HAK-182-3-5-1 No Objection to Declassification in Full 2011/12/05: LOC-HAK-182-3-5-1 FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY This ropaganda analysis report is b sed exclusively on material carried in foreign broadcast and p ess media. It is published by F IS without coordination wi other U.S. Government components. FOR OFFICIAL No Objection to Declassification in Full 2011/12/05: LOC-HAK-182-3-5-1 No Objection to Declassification in Full 2011/12/05: LOC-HAK-182-3-5-1 FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY FBIS REACTION REPORT 21 JUNE 1974 CONTENTS SUMMARY . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . I. THE MIDDLE EAST . Host Countries . . . . . ? ? . . . Egypt . ? Saudi Arabia . . . . . . 3 Syria . . . . . . . . . . . . . Jordan . . . . . . . . . . . Israel . . . . . . . . . ? . Other Arab Comment .. . . . The Palestinians . . . . ? . Iraq, Libya., South Yemen . Lebanon Maghreb, Other States . . II. OTHER NONCOMMUNIST COUNTRIES West Europe Asia and Africa Latin America . 4 . 6 10 . . 13 .. . . . . . . . . . . . 22 111. COMMUNIST COUNTRIES The Soviet Union . . . ? . ? . East Europe . . . . . . . China .. . . . . . . . . Other Asian Communist . POP, OFFICIAL USE, ONLY 32 34 No Objection to Declassification in Full 2011/12/05: LOC-HAK-182-3-5-1 No Objection to Declassification in Full 2011/12/05: LOC-HAK-182-3-5-1 FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY FBIS REACTION REPORT 21 JUNE 1974 FOREIGN RADIO AND PRESS REACTION TO PRESIDENT NIXON'S MIDDLE EAST VISIT SUMMARY Egyptian comment, stressing the change in the U.S. attitude toward the Arabs as a result of the October war, placed great emphasis on the "legitimate rights" of the Palestinian people and took satis- faction in the reference to Palestinian "interests" in the joint statement on the visit. Egyptian comment on Israeli reaction to the U.S.-Egyptian agreement on nuclear energy decried "Zionist" attempts to thwart the improvement of U.S.-Arab relations, and Egyptian Foreign Minister Fahmi called for Israel to sign the nonproliferation treaty, as Cairo has done, with the warning that if Israel were to conduct an atomic test Egypt would do the same. After the President's visit to Israel, Cairo press comment cautioned that unlimited U.S. supply of arms to Israel was no longer justified and held Washington responsible for curbing Israel's "expansionist" ambitions. Saudi Arabia's King Faysal and Jordan's King Husayn expressed appreciation of the President's visit, both making clear their preoccupation with the problems of the Palestinians and of Jerusalem. Syria, maintaining a low-key approach to the Presidential tour, was the only Arab host not to broadcast the text of the President's remarks. President al-Asad, like the other Arab leaders, placed emphasis on the Palestinian "struggle." Israeli media, giving the President's tour wide publicity, displayed ambivalence, both welcoming the visit and expressing concern that improved U.S.-Arab relations not develop at the expense of American Israeli ties. The announcement on U.S.-Egyptian cooperation in nuclear energy prompted wide reaction in Israel, with Foreign Minister Alon first offering assurances to the Israeli public but later stating that concern had been expressed to the United States and expressing displeasure that Israel was not informed in advance. Other noncommunist world reaction to the visit was cautious about the practical results, and in many quarters apprehensive about the long-term hazards introduced through the U.S. agreement to provide both Egypt and Israel with nuclear power aid. West European media stressed the trip's positive implications for Watergate, and emphasized the unresolved Palestinian issue and the impact of the Middle East visits upon the President's imminent Moscow summit visit. FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY No Objection to Declassification in Full 2011/12/05: LOC-HAK-182-3-5-1 No Objection to Declassification in Full 2011/12/05: LOC-HAK-182-3-5-1 FOR OFFICIAL USE 0 Y IBIS REACTION REPO T 21 JUNE 1974 Among Asian noncommun st countries, Jap most extensive reportage and comment on "breakthrough" in U.S. relations with th concern over the Palestine question and the spread of nuclear technology to the and press comment gave special attention criticizing President Nixon for increasi agreements. Limited available African c the nuclear issue. Available Latin Amer favorable, but limit d in volume. Moscow media gave brief, factual report with TASS and the ce tral press providi coverage of some speeches in Cairo and concluding the visit to Egypt and Isra confined primarily t PRAVDA's weekly i Arabic-language talk on the '"xiiioff'icia The sparse coverage of the visit, to get of concern, suggest oviet'indecision a The emerging approach seems to be one o of a new U.S. relationship with the Ara the Soviet Union for new directions in Moscow's pursuit of etente. I Moscow at the same t me has pointed out lessening of U.S. su port for Israel, a the new Arab-America relationship to r ties with the Soviet Union. Soviet. corn benefits of detente in connection with portraying a joint U S.-Soviet role in fighting, convening he Geneva peace co disengagement agreem nts. Moscow's East Europe n allies generally "imperialist" aims i the Middle East, reflecting greater U.S. awareness of Ar Limited comment saw in Secretary Kisstn conference threat to resign a reaction of detente. 's media provided the he trip, seeing a Arabs but pointing up xpressing dismay over rea. Australian officia to the nuclear issue, g the hazard by the new mmment also laid stress o can reaction was general y ge on the President's tri g fuller, if selective, amascus and of statements 1. Scanty comment has be ternational reviews and " Radio Peace and Progres er with oblique indicatio to how to handle the tou accommodation to the ide s, while seeking to credi merican policy through that there has been no d that the Arabs do not w nt place their "traditional" ent has also stressed the :fiddle East developments, ontaining the October ference, and achieving the saw no basic change in U.S. ut viewed the trip as .b power in the area. ;er's Salzburg press o attacks by U.S. oppone is Asian communist repo tage and reaction to the. President's trip w limited and generall low key. Peking ,onfined its coverage to factual NCNA reports focusing on the Eg pt and Syria visits, and FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY No Objection to Declassification in Full 2011/12/05: LOC-HAK-182-3-5-1 No Objection to Declassification in Full 2011/12/05: LOC-HAK-182-3-5-1 FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY FEIS REACTION REPORT 21 JUNE 1974 not yet acknowledged the U.S. pledges of nuclear power aid to Egypt and Israel. Peking comment prior to the visit saw in it evidence of U.S. strength vis-a-vis Moscow prior to the scheduled Moscow summit visit. Vietnamese communist media provided very sparse coverage stressing alleged U.S. duplicity and giving play to Palestinian statements of defiance. North Korean and Mongolian People's Republic media ignored the visits. Cuban communist reaction, predictably harsh, stressed the themes that Watergate and U.S. imperialist ambitions in the Middle East were behind the trip and expressed doubt that the Egyptian welcome for the President was genuine. No Objection to Declassification in Full 2011/12/05: LOC-HAK-182-3-5-1 No Objection to Declassification in Full 2011/12/05: LOC-HAK-182-3-5-1 FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY FBIS REACTION REPORT 21 JUNE 1974 THE MIDDLE EAST HOST COUNTRIES EGYPT Before President Nixon's arrival in Egypt and throughout his stay in the Middle East, Egyptian media and officials expressed optimism about the visit and welcomed it. The President's activities in Egypt were given blanket media coverage, from Cairo radio's live relay of his arrival on 12 June to the live relay of his departure for Saudi Arabia on the 14th. The speeches exchanged between Nixon and as-Sadat were broadcast live, with President Nixon's remarks in English followed by a translation into Arabic. The speeches were repeated in Arabic in subsequent newscasts. The visits by President Nixon to various historic points also received wide coverage. A theme common to both official and media reaction was that the U.S. stand toward the Arabs "has changed considerably since the October war." A Cairo radio news analysis on 12 June said: "This visit reflects the extent of the change that has taken place in U.S. diplomacy toward the Middle East crisis after the October war." An AL-AKHBAR editorial on the 12th, as cited by Cairo radio, said that the masses will welcome not only Nixon, but also as-Sadat, since he was "able to change the U.S. Government's policy." Citing Egyptian officials' comments on the visit, the MIDDLE EAST NEWS AGENCY (MENA) on 12 June said that Fitst Deputy Prime Minister Dr. 'Abd al-'Aziz Hijazi described Nixon's visit to Egypt "as a sign of appreciation for the Arabs," and quoted Foreign Minister Isma'il Fahmi as saying that the visit is "the direct outcome of the October war." On the 13th MENA reported that Egyptian papers featured the "great official and popular welcome accorded to the first U.S. President to visit Egypt" and highlighted the speeches exchanged between Presidents as-Sadat and Nixon. Reviewing the Cairo press, MENA said that AL-AHRAM concluded that Nixon's visit was "an opportunity for translating the U.S. President's appreciation of President as-Sadat into definite commitments to remove the causes of tension in the area and to achieve the goal of a just peace." AL-AKHBAR was quoted as saying that "peace is the fulcrum of President Nixon's visit to Egypt" and the Middle East. Egyptian statements and comment were careful to assert the emphasis Cairo places on the "legitimate rights" of the Palestinian people, with President as-Sadat declaring in one speech that the "political solution and respect for the national aspirations of the Palestinians are the essence of the whole problem." Cairo radio commentator No Objection to Declassification in Full 2011/12/05: LOC-HAK-182-3-5-1 No Objection to Declassification in Full 2011/12/05: LOC-HAK-182-3-5-1 hts" of the Palestinian nterest" because in "in an official documen Muhammad Sharaf on 1 June noted that t Egyptian statement referring to the "ri people "aroused sig ificant world-wide that clause the Uni ed States recognize that the Palestinia Sharaf called this the Palestinian cau noted that in impor been and would be h that his talks with securing a declarat issue as "a politic There has been exte on Israeli and "U.S Egyptian statement a 16 June press co campaign" launched cooperation on the campaign" to comba States and Egypt a circles were basin Dayan, but said th foreign minister a already had, or wa the same as those if Dayan and the I introduced in the In an AL-AKHBAR in that Egypt could p this horrible weap FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY FBIS REACTION REPO T 21 JUNE 1974 e clause in the U.S.- 17th, according to MENA, and "sound treatment" of s are entitled to "their full legitimate rig problem of refugees." d toward the Palestinian ons President as-Sadat ha sident's visit, he explai e primarily aimed at n important step t e. AL-AHRAM on th ant Arab consultat iding after the Pr President Nixon we on of the U.S. sta problem and not sive comment from n "nuclear energy. ference reported by y "U.S. Zionist ci peaceful use of ato the improvement i d the Arab.worl#. their reaction on t Dayan had "conce ded that the nucle negotiating for w n the U.S.-Egyptia raeli officials di rea, they must sig erview reported by oduce an atomic ex n into the area," gyptian media and officials to point three of the U. q. Foreign Minister Fahmi in MENA described a "rabid Iles" over Egyptian-U.S. is energy as "an organized relations between the United certain statements by Mos-ie led certain facts." The r power facilities Israel th the United States, wer pact. Fahmi declared that not want atomic weapons the nonproliferation treaty. MENA on the 18th,Fahmi said losion "if Israel introd ces nd added that Egypt had igtied the nonproliferat4 n treaty "but it wLll not ratify the treaty unless Israel joins it." Cairo press comme as AL-AHRAM said AL-JUMHURIYAH on said Egypt had ac Arab cause, such a just and perman the President "no ment toward the M to the fact the p and agree on gene t assessing the res n the 14th, as a ne he 16th, according ieved several impo nt peace. AL-JUMH iceably avoided" m ddle East issue in esent task was to al principles. its of the visit has viewed it, peace opportunity. to Cairo radio's press review, tant political gains for he commitment" to the need or RIYAH explained that whil king any detailed U.S. commit- his speeches, this was du stablish common understanding No Objection to Declassification in Full 2011/12/05: LOC-HAK-182-3-5-1 No Objection to Declassification in Full 2011/12/05: LOC-HAK-182-3-5-1 FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY FBIS REACTION REPORT 21 JUNE 1974 In the wake of the President's visit to Israel, AL-AHRAM observed on the 17th that while the President realized that peace in the area "and the stability of oil exports" were dependent on an overall solution, such a solution must realize the Palestinians' "legitimate rights" and Israel "must recognize the reality of the Palestinian homeland." The United States, AL-AHRAM said, must now "prove that it can be independent of Israel" and give preference to what serves not only U.S. interests but the interests of peace in the area. In an article on the 18th, AL-AHRAM recalled the President's statement in Israel that peace, as well as fighting, required courage, but a courage of a different kind. If the United States was serious about the establishment of peace, then it was capable of giving Israel a lesson in the other kind of courage, AL-AHRAM said, adding that the unlimited supply of U.S. arms to Israel "is no longer justified," and the United States "becomes responsible" for ending Israel's "expansionist ambitions" in the area. Some comment affirmed that Egypt's new friendship with the United States would not develop at the expense of Cairo's relations with Moscow. AKffBAR AL-YAWN chief editor Mustafa Amin was:cited_by MENA on the 15th as declaring that "we will not buy U.S. friendship by selling out Soviet friendship, but rather will simultaneously maintain the friendship of the two superpowers." A Cairo Voice of the Arabs commentary on the 12th welcomed the President's visit as evidence of the "vital and constructive role" to be played by the United States, but another Voice of the Arabs commentary the same day emphasized that American-Egyptian realtions did not "shut the door" to "any other international power." While praising the "practical outlook" of the President and Secretary Kissinger and stressing Cairo's "confidence" in their stands, the commentary pointed out that there would be no friendship with one party "at the expense of another party." SAUDI ARABIA The Saudi radio provided extensive reportage on the President's trip throughout the area and particularly his stay in Jiddab,but there was no monitored comment on the visit. Riyadh radio on 14 June reported the banquet given by King Faysal and later broadcast recordings of the speeches exchanged by the king and President Nixon, whose speech was carried in English with passage-by- passage Arabic translation. Faysal in his speech declared that "the injustice and aggression inflicted on the Palestinian people is unprecedented in history." He expressed Saudi Arabia's faith that the United States would work for peace, adding that "we believe there will be no real and lasting peace in the area until Jerusalem is liberated and returned to Arab sovereignty, all the occupied Arab territories are liberated, and the Palestinian Arab people recover their right to their homeland and to determine their own fate." No Objection to Declassification in Full 2011/12/05: LOC-HAK-182-3-5-1 No Objection to Declassification in Full 2011/12/05: LOC-HAK-182-3-5-1 Prior to the Presid reported a statemen as-Saqqaf stressing and on 15 June it c praising the "histo Nixon's arrival? Riy nt's visit, the Sa by Minister of St ONLY FBIS REACTION REP RT 21 JUNE 1974 di radio on 8 June had to for Foreign Affairs usefulness of the visit ith the U.S.'ambassador e, just before President e comments of Foreign mmad Ibrahim Mas'ud. its policy toward the that its interest lies era." He continued: ted States will stand by visit to Saudi Arabia in t it "confirms and crowns the significance an rried an interview ic" trip. On 14 Ju dh radio carried t Ministry Under Secre Noting American prep Arabs," Mas'ud said: here, and it therefo "All that the Arabs justice and right." particular, the unde the new American pol SYRIA Syrian med Nixon's Mi the President's arri countries, but no me from any Syrian sour that four "prominent to participate in th was not carried by S ary ash-Shaykh Muh redness "to change "America realized e has opened a new ope is that the Un On the President's secretary said th cy." a maintained a low east tour. The ra als, departures an tion of Nixon's st e. On 14 June the members" of the Sy reception for the Tian media. key approach to President io carried reportage on contacts in the Arab p in Israel was monitored IRAQI NEWS AGENCY reporte ,an Communist Party refus President. The INA repor of the President's .s radio. A radio the "great guest" ween the two presi following day. Da President Hafiz a Asad talked of the displaced for 26 y impossible "withou 1d President Nixon ublic will constit en our two countri .d to al-Asad's spe ?ed announcer-read During the Syrian lei monitored from Damasc arrival ceremonies fo reported the talks be "prominent guest" the announcer-read text o the 15th, in which al- people who "have been peace in the area was to this cause." He t to the Syrian Arab Re era in relations betw President Nixon repli Later newscasts featu President's speech. tour, no live relays were eport gave details of th on the 15th and briefly ents and departure of th ascus broadcast an -Asad's banquet speech o struggle of the Palestinian ars." Al-Asad said that a real and just solution "We hope that your visit to the beginning of a new s." The radio noted that ch, but gave no details. uotations from the Damascus radio on the 16th carried an announcer-read text of a statement to the pres by President al-Aslad which said: "As we understand it, the ag eement on the dise a first step and an i divisible part of t of the question--a so ution which cannot agement . . . constitute e just overall solution xist without" Israel's No Objection to Declassification in Full 2011/12/05: LOC-HAK-182-3-5-1 No Objection to Declassification in Full 2011/12/05: LOC-HAK-182-3-5-1 FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY FBIS REACTION REPORT 21 JUNE 1974 withdrawing from all occupied Arab land and the rights of the Palestinians being secured. Al-Asad also announced the decision to restore U.S.-Syrian diplomatic relations. Following the text of al-Asad's statement, the radio carried a report on President Nixon's remarks to the press. The Syrian news agency on 16 June carried an apparent text, in Arabic, of Nixon's statement. In reporting the departure ceremonies for the Nixon party on the 16th, Damascus radio did not mention the President's next stop, Israel. On the 17th the radio reported the President's arrival in Jordan and covered his activities there and his departure for home on 18 June. Damascus radio on the 17th briefly reported that the raising of the U.S. flag over the U.S. embassy was "celebrated today" following restoration of diplomatic relations. No press comment on the visit was reviewed by Damascus radio, but MENA,-in a Damascus dispatch on the 15th, said the Damascus ATH-THAWRAH frontpaged photographs of presidents Nixon and al--Arad and "devoted banner headlines" to the visit. JORDAN Amman radio carried in-depth reportage on all of President Nixon's stops in the Middle East. Both radio and press comment on the visit, although minimal, praised the Nixon visit and U.S. efforts for peace in the area. Amman radio quoted the Jordanian newspaper AR-RA'Y as saying on 10 June that the visit shows the "highest degrees" of American policy interest. The radio again quoted AR-RA'Y on the 12th as warning that the accusations against Dr. Kissinger concerning Watergate were a threat by "forces" trying to direct American foreign policy. On the 15th Amman reported AR-RA'Y's praise of the President's visit to Cairo and the joint statement issued there. In an unattributed commentary on 16 June, Amman radio commended U.S. efforts to bring peace to the Middle East, but stressed that peace was impossible without Israeli withdrawal from occupied territories, "especially Jerusalem," and without Israeli acknowledgment of Arab rights. Another unattributed commentary carried by Amman radio on the 17th repeated praise of U.S. peace efforts and the necessity for Israeli withdrawal. On 17 June Amman radio carried a live relay of President Nixon's arrival. The radio later carried a live relay of speeches exchanged between King Husayn and Nixon at a banquet; both men spoke in English, and there was no Arabic translation. Following the relay the radio returned to a studio-originated broadcast for an announcer- read Arabic text of Husayn's speech. Presumably no Arabic version of FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY No Objection to Declassification in Full 2011/12/05: LOC-HAK-182-3-5-1 No Objection to Declassification in Full 2011/12/05: LOC-HAK-182-3-5-1 FOR OFFICIAL USE{ONLY FBIS REACTION REP 21 JUNE 1974 the President's speech was then available; the following day Amman broadcast an and also carried th visit. The departu including the speec state. Arabic-lang later newscasts. Af reported various soc Presidential party o rabic-language repo text of the joint e ceremony was rela s exchanged in Eng ge reports on both er the President's al activities and 18 June, includin ISRAEL Israeli m on the Pr similar treatment of speeches in Israel w followed by a brief texts of Nixon's spe casts as well as in Comment on the trip concern that improve of Tel Aviv's ties w press review, HAZOFE visit with "hope and of the process in th empire in the Middle NASHA STRANA, HADASH dia featured volum sidential visit to his stay in Israel re carried live in nnouncer-supplied ches'were carried he Israeli press. as ambivalent, exp U.S.-Arab relatio th Washington. In trust," while SHE t of the Nixon speech, tatement issued on the ed live over Amman radio ish by the two heads of speeches were carried on departure, Amman radio ours attended by the a military ceremony. noun reportage and comma t the Arab countries and All of Nixon's public English by Israeli radios, ummary in Hebrew. Hebrew n subsequent radio news- essing both welcome and s not develop at the expe se Jerusalem radio's 10 June forward to the forthcom ng IM called the visit part ablishing an American the British empire." "realization of es East on the ruins o ISRAEL and NOWINY rapprochement with careful that the U.S. "at our expense." Co DAVAR on the 13th, ac friendship" being fo it would not be "at t Jerusalem media indic for the President's t problems of Soviet an correspondent noted o issues, would dominat the Knesset discuss S forthcoming President broadcast of Jerusale carried a recorded in request, in which Alo Jewry during the Pres by the Golan disengag later that day quoted Nixon and Kissinger i enting on the Pre ording to Jerusale ed between Washing e expense of the o ted that among the lks in Israel woul Syrian Jewry. Th the 12th that eco the talks. Likud rian and Soviet Je al visit was repor s international s erview with Foreig asserted that Ame the Arab states is not ident's welcome in Egypt, radio, saw a "political on and Cairo and hoped t at d friendship with Israel." top issues'on the agenda be further aid and the s, a Jerusalem radio omic, rather than politic 1 leader Begin's request th t ry in connection with the ed in an English-language rvice on the 11th. The r dio Minister Alon on Begin's scan efforts "to aid Syri n ascus would be facilitat d" dential visit to Da ment agreement. A Alon as saying that demands for the release of Syrian Jews. erusalem radio broadcast the "special position" won by le them to make "humanit rian No Objection to Declassification in Full 2011/12/05: LOC-HAK-182-3-5-1 No Objection to Declassification in Full 2011/12/05: LOC-HAK-182-3-5-1 FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY FBIS REACTION REPORT 21 JUNE 1974 Jerusalem radio on 13 June featured an interview with Ambassador Dinitz on his arrival from Washington to prepare for Nixon's visit. Asked about the dangers for Israel from a U.S.-Arab friendship, Dinitz replied that, on the contrary, U.S.-Israeli relations should be strengthened by "furthering U.S. interests in the Middle East." On 14 June Jerusalem radio carried a government statement "thanking" the United States for its traditional aid to the state of Israel. The statement concluded that the government "hopes that the Presidential tour will help the Middle East countries to overcome their hostility and aggressive tendencies." Following the Cairo announcement of U.S.-Egyptian cooperation in the nuclear energy field, wide-scale and varied reaction was reported from Israel. Information Minister Aharon Yariv was quoted by Jerusalem radio on the 14th as confirming that Israel was also negotiating for U.S. help in that field. Yariv said that the U.S.-Egyptian agreement meant nothing more than "American aid to Egypt for the production of electricity from nuclear reactors." Foreign Minister Alon commented on this subject in an interview carried by Jerusalem radio on 15 June. Asked if he was "worried" by the U.S.-Egyptian agreement, he said: "When the reference is to nuclear power stations and nuclear fuel . . . under agreed supervision, there is no danger in that." Alon's views were described as "irresponsible" and "liable to seriously harm Israel's security" by Knesset member Shemu'el Tamir, as reported by Jerusalem radio. "In the wake of the many repercussions" from the U,S.- Egyptian cooperation, Alon spoke again on Jerusalem radio on the 15th. He said that he was "neither pleased nor frightened" by the agreement, and added that even if it were only for peaceful reasons, "it is much too soon . . . there is as yet no economic justification." Alon also expressed displeasure that "we were not informed . . . in advance." On the 16th Jerusalem radio reported a special meeting of the Knesset Foreign Affairs and Defense Committee with the foreign minister, precipitated by the committee's "concern over the U.S. agreement with Egypt." Jerusalem papers on 16 June, ,as reported by Jerusalem radio, welcomed Nixon to the area and hailed U.S. efforts for peace, but continued to convey concern over the U.S.- Egyptian pact. No Objection to Declassification in Full 2011/12/05: LOC-HAK-182-3-5-1 No Objection to Declassification in Full 2011/12/05: LOC-HAK-182-3-5-1 Jerusalem radio on t e irp 16th gave live c arrival at Ben-Gurio aort, includin welcoming speech in nglish and Nixon's reported briefly on he initial U.S.-Is to live coverage, Je usalem radio carri speeches, given in E glish, at a banque Jerusalem radio on t e 17th carried a r Kissinger's press co ference in Jerusal provided on subseque't newscasts. Info was quoted by Jerusa em radio on 17 Jun remarks by Kissinger He repeated Isra negotiate" with the alestine Liberatio said that a Palestin an state between J endanger Israel." NLY FBIS REACTION REP 21 JUNE 1974 verage of Nixon's President Katzir's reply. The radio also aeli talks. Returning d the two presidents' in the Knesset. port on Secretary m, with further details ation Minister Yariv on his reaction to l's stand "not to Organization and also rdan and Israel "would A radio corresponden is report on the U.S.-Israeli statement on the visit was broadc st by Jerusalem radio on the 17th; the text of the statement was published the follo ing day in the Hebrew- language papers DAV and HA'AREZ. The 1eparture ceremonies on the 17th were covere live by Jerusalem adio. In its review of the Israeli press for 1 that "satisfaction" s voiced over the "continue to stand by Israel," but that the U.S.-Egyptian agr ement, about which Following the Preside is departure, Jer reported that the Lik d and Mafdal facti nuclear power agreeme t. The opposition "experts believe ther is a real danger. have caused serious d mage by their stat prospects for foiling the agreement." Prime Minister Rabin held a press confer live by Jerusalem rad o, in which he s June, the radio noted resident's promises to oncern was growing over Nixon said "not one word salem radio on'the 17th ns submitted a no-confid nts" on the U.S.-Egyptia parties said that while . the government spoke nce on the 17th, carried ed up Nixon's visit as cance. Rabin praised d U.S.-Israeli relations having "symbolic" and "practical" signif the visit on the grow ds that it further and the prospects for peace in the area. quoted the Israeli pr ss as summing up N "with mixed feelings.' The radio noted attention to the U.S. promises of long-t aid, while voicing mo nting concern over race in our region." Jerusalem radio on 18 Ju on's Middle East visit hat the papers drew rm "security and economic a possible "nuclear arms No Objection to Declassification in Full 2011/12/05: LOC-HAK-182-3-5-1 No Objection to Declassification in Full 2011/12/05: LOC-HAK-182-3-5-1 FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY FBIS REACTION REPORT 21 JUNE 1974 OTHER AwaB COMMENT THE PALESTINIANS Reaction from some Palestinian factions, particularly as reported by Iraqi media, has been predictably hostile to the United States' Mideast policy and has made digs at the Arab regimes which received the President. Voice of Palestine programs using Baghdad and Algiers radio facilities expressed strong opposition to the visit, while the clandestine Voice of Palestine ignored the trip except for sparse reportage on major events, particularly references to the Palestinian issue. The Cairo Voice of Palestine on the 18th reported an "official Palestinian source" as warning that the "Zionist enemy's security pledge by Nixon will not be achieved," a statement also reported by the IRAQI NEWS AGENCY (INA). In its only other monitored commentary on the visit, the Cairo Voice of Palestine on the 19th criticized King Husayn, calling his reliance on President Nixon "futile." A Baghdad Voice of Palestine commentary on 12 June proclaimed that "the ugly face of imperialism will not be beautified by as--.Sadat's praise," and a day later another commentary declared that the President's motives for his visit were to show "certain parties and states of the world that the Middle East is within the U.S. sphere of influence" and "to cover up for the Watergate scandal." An Algiers Voice of Palestine commentary-on the 17th defined the American idea of peace in the Middle East as ultimately based on "Arab recognition of the Zionist entity in Palestine." The commentary called for establishment of a Palestinian state on "all occupied Palestinian soil" and warned that U.S. efforts to impose its concept of peace as well as the Zionist concept of peace would "lay the foundations for war" instead of peace. The radio had noted on 14 June that the Egyptian-U.S. statement had said that "a just and lasting peace in the Middle East must take into account the interests of the Palestinian Arab people." An Algiers Voice of Palestine commentary on the 19th called the Israeli raids on Lebanon that day the result of a "strategy which was endorsed by President Nixon during his visit to occupied Palestine." Noting that all Arab fronts had "ceased fighting" the enemy, the commentary said the Palestine front now has to "shoulder with its people and revolutions the consequences of the disengagement agreements." INA on 14 June cited an official of the Popular Front for the Liberation of Palestine--the General Command--as criticizing at a press conference in Baghdad the "21-gun salutes fired in Arab capitals for those who supplied the U.S. planes that three weeks ago exterminated an-Nabatiyah camp and other camps of our people." FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY No Objection to Declassification in Full 2011/12/05: LOC-HAK-182-3-5-1 No Objection to Declassification in Full 2011/12/05: LOC-HAK-182-3-5-1 FOR OFFICIAL USE 0 Another official of t is fedayeen organization was reported by INA the same day as asser ing that the Nixon visit was "evidence of the level to which po itical affairs have deteriorated," and warning against a dan Brous "imperialist, reactionary and Zionist plot" aimed at expanding U.S. influence i the Arab area. Tripoli radio on 15 J e broadcast a join to Libya by Palestine iberation Organiza it declared that the tab nation would n at misleading and plot ing by U.S. imperi FBIS REACTION REPOR 21 JUNE 1974 statement on the visit ion chairman Yasir 'Araf t; t be deceived by "attempts list circles trying to liquidate the Palestin question and exte mate and obliterate th Palestinian personalit It The Libyan and Palestinian revolutions, the statement said, wo 1d resist all "cap tulationist solutions," and al-Qadhdhafi and " rafat in the state ent pledged to "escalate the Palestinian armed truggle." IRAQ, LIBYA SOUTH YEMEN Reacti n to the President and So th Yemeni media wa predic ably negative, cri s visit by Iraqi, Libyan regard to the Presiden and the United St regimes who welcomed t e "archimperialist provided daily reporta e and comment. Th ATH-THAWRAH, organ of he ruling Socialis the welcome of the "co.onialist execution Arab regimes" as disgr ceful. It maintai always deal with "Nixo and his Zionist g characteristically and ical, and severe, both in tes as well as those Arab to Iraqi and Libyan media Baghdad newspaper Arab Ba'th Party, descri r" by the "compromising ed that true Arabs would g" with steadfastness an struggle, rather than iplomacy and submission. An article by the newspaper's "Observer" contended that "the was coming to our home and like a conquero affairs editor said th President was not Iraqi people were ange ed by his presence leader of U.S. imperiali to Baghdad radio's Arab man of peace, and that n the Middle East. The en by the host governmen Arab people. The Iraqi rgued that the visit was gimes from their anti- en them and the Soviet radio often cited the security measures to as a true indication of the feelings of th Communist Party newspap r TARIQ ASH-SHA'B part of a plan to divert the progressive r imperialist efforts and drive a wedge betw Union and the other soc alist states. Libyan media also adopt d a defiant positi and questioning his int ntions. Tripoli r President was posing as a peacemaker to gu Israel and increase U.S influence in the strongest language appe red in the newspap views were disseminated by the Libyan news that there was no place in the Arab world a grave or an inferno. Arab "kowtowing be FQR OFFICIAL USE ONL n, castigating the President dio commented that the rantee the existence of iddle East. Some of the r AL-FAJR AS-JADID, whose agency. The paper implie or the President except i ore the American god of war," No Objection to Declassification in Full 2011/12/05: LOC-HAK-182-3-5-1 No Objection to Declassification in Full 2011/12/05: LOC-HAK-182-3-5-1 FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY FBIS REACTION REPORT 21 JUNE 1974 - 11 - the paper said, was "a defeat in the worst form." The Libyan news agency's political commentator described the U.S. offer of nuclear aid to Egypt as a trick designed to justify giving Israel nuclear weapons. South Yemen's Aden radio echoed many of the same critical themes. The radio denounced the visit as a reflection of U.S. interest in maintaining influence in the Arabian Peninsula and the Persian Gulf area. Saudi leaders were accused of briefing the President on arrangements to topple the regime in the PDRY. The Aden news- paper 14 OCTOBER suggested that the United States was reformulating its policy in the area to enable Israel, Saudi Arabia, and Iran "to create a new balance against the liberation and democratic movements of the people in the area." LEBANON Major and favorable interest in the Nixon visit was expressed by Lebanese public spokesmen. Several high officials, including the acting prime minister and the defense minister, indicated they were hopeful that the visit would contribute to the peaceful resolution of the Middle East problem. Lebanese Minister of State Shadir stated that the visit reflected a historic change in U.S. policy to insure the establishment of a balance between the influence of the United States and the Soviet Union on the one hand, and the Arab states and Israel on the other. Lebanon's diverse newspapers reflected a broad spectrum of criticism and praise. Those newspapers with close ties to the more radical Middle East groups tended to assess the visit in highly critical terms, while other papers ranged from great enthusiasm to mild criticism. The latter papers were generally in agreement that the ultimate results of the trip would be beneficial. Unusually sharp criticism was contained in pro-Iraqi and pro-Libyan papers, and in AN-NIDA, the Lebanese Communist Party paper. MAGHREB, OTHER STATES Monitored Moroccan media, while closely cover- ing the President's trip, did not comment extensively. The newspaper LE MATIN published several increasingly enthusiastic articles praising Nixon's political courage. The anti- Nixon and anti-Kissinger campaign directed by the powerful "Zionist lobby,! LE MATIN wrote, has not prevented Nixon from pursuing his new Middle East policy. In a similar fashion, a Moroccan press, agency commentary paid tribute to Nixon's "courageous stand" in charting a new foreign policy line in the face of "increasing Zionist control" in the affairs of state. At the same time, however, it emphasized the necessity for the Arabs to preserve relations with the Soviet Union on a "firm basis." The agency's press review on 18 June said the President's trip remained the main international affairs topic in the papers, and noted that papers had pointed out that the President had "issued a disguised warning to the Arab countries about the Palestinian guerrillas" during his visit to Israel. No Objection to Declassification in Full 2011/12/05: LOC-HAK-182-3-5-1 No Objection to Declassification in Full 2011/12/05: LOC-HAK-182-3-5-1 21 JUNE 1974 OR OFFICIAL USE 04Y FBIS REACTION REPOR Tunisian reaction to while stressing the n Destourian Party's Fr "exceptional importan toward the problem of The paper saw this as that there had been h emphasized the "enorm e President's trip ch-language paper e" of the tour, ass the first time in o pe of a "Just and 1 us difficulties" a was generally favorable, estinian problem. The 'ACTION. emphasized the rting that the U.S. attitude s definitely changed." er a quarter of a centur sting peace," but it ad. The party's Arabic- ition of the legitimate language paper AL-' rights of the Palesti was "not lacking in a President Nixon's con "appreciable" number unresolved. Algeria's response to Arab radicals but the reservations about U. Algiers radio comment Palestinian question reason for discord. Liberation Front, EL-: provided little comma published an editoria ing peace constituted exploit" the region. contended that U.S. w Monitored Sudanese, U media confined their Iranian, Greek, Turki on the visit, but the Teheran radio and cla Teheran hailed the U. the wisdom of Egypt's The clandestine Radio Nixon's main objectiv world." The radio al lauding the Nixon vis work for peace in th Our Radio, described noted that while Nixo give financial suppor his "bloody plans aga called U.S. recog cans "decisive," b biguities." Regar acts on his visit, f "fundamental" pr the trip was not a limited available . policy and criti d that President N eant that no progr he French-language OUDJAHID, publishe t. The NFL's Arab asserting that th a "veil" concealin The paper scorned rds were in glarin h, and Cypriot-med only available co .-Egyptian rapproc recent policy than Iran Courier carri was "to,establish o noted that "reac t in an effort to region. The Turk ixon's visit as a talks about peace to the Israeli Go nst the peoples of t noted that this recognition less of the importance of the paper said, an lams have been left vitriolic as the reactio of omment was infused with s Tong al evaluations of U.S. in entions. xon's avoidance of the ss had been made on the basic newspaper of the ruling N tional news agency reports but c-language newspaper, ASH SHA'B, President's claims about bring- U.S. aims to "dominate and .S. claims of neutrality and contradiction to deeds. a carried extensive reportage ent here was monitored fr m oadcasting to the area. ement and dwelt at lengt on d a brief talk saying thalt a stronghold in the Arab ionary sources" have bee hide" the Soviet union's sh-language clandestine tation, so-called display of peace " and with the Arabs he continues to ernment.and has not give up the Middle East." No Objection to Declassification in Full 2011/12/05: LOC-HAK-182-3-5-1 No Objection to Declassification in Full 2011/12/05: LOC-HAK-182-3-5-1 FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY FBIS REACTION REPORT 21 JUNE 1974 - 13 - II, OTHER NONCOMMUNIST COUNTRIES WEST EUROPE The news media of France, Great Britain and West Germany provided extensive reportage and comment on the President's trip, some comment viewing the trip as a breakthrough toward peace and other comment seeing it as an escape from the troubles of Watergate, but most agreeing that only time will tell if anything tangible has been achieved. FRANCE French media reaction was cautious but generally optimistic in assessing the positive achievements of the President's trip, while presenting overall favorable impressions of the popular and official welcomes accorded the President through- out his visits. A 19 June editorial in LE MONDE stated that in all the countries the President visited he received a welcome that was "either cordial or triumphant, depending on the situation." It attributed the Arab and Israeli leaders' decision to put aside their misgivings about aspects of U.S. policy toward their respective opponents to their awareness of "the material means" at U.S. disposal. The communist L.'HUMANITE introduced a sour note. by quoting a. Libyan paper which asked why the President was being feted when he had been "primarily responsible" for denying the Arabs victory .over Israel. Israel's muted "detachment and certain cynicism".in the face of the enthusiastic Arab welcome was dictated,,. according to LE FIGARO on 17 June, by a desire to "play along" with the President as "better preparation" for his USSR trip. The Palestinian question dominated much.of the French comment. LE FIGARO asked if President Nixon was "not coerced by as-Sadat" into including in the U.S.-Egyptian statement a reference to "the Palestine people's legitimate interests." The,same paper also noted that the communique with Jordan mentioned Resolution 338, whereas King Husayn had "constantly" referred to Resolution 242 in his banquet speech. L'HUMAN.ITE wrote that King Faysal "appeared all the more vehement" in his demand for consideration of the Palestinians' national rights in light of his traditional position as "one of the most faithful U,S. allies." A Paris radio dispatch from Damascus on the 16th noted that al-Asad's statements to President Nixon did not stand on protocol in stressing that peace is not possible without a "just and real solution" to the Palestinian problem. No Objection to Declassification in Full 2011/12/05: LOC-HAK-182-3-5-1 No Objection to Declassification in Full 2011/12/05: LOC-HAK-182-3-5-1 - 14 - Other Paris comment . ended to view the to its effect on Sov et attitudes. Par Claude Mangeot comma ted on 12 June, fo "were very intereste " in the trip sine to America, the Midd a East "is confirm United States." And a radio commentary 13 June noted that b deciding on rappr States, the Arabs we e taking "a calcul their Soviet ally." A striking feature o the French press. the first day, littl if any reference difficulties of Pres dent Nixon and Dr. Paris radio did not tress the Waterga.t. Notable exceptions eluded a Michel An on 10 June which co tinted that the Pre Middle East "to for et his worries over and a report by rad o commentator Edoua PSIS REACTION REPORT 21 JUNE 1974 resident's. trip in relation a radio correspondent Jea instance, that the Sovies in .".reopening its doors" the leadership of the by Edouard Sablier on chement with the United ted risk" of "irritating overage was that, after Kissinger. Similarly, aspect to any great extent. rol dispatch from Washington ident had left for the the Watergate affair," d Sablier, who noted on the 13th that the A ab leaders "are perfectly aware of the good turn" they are doin the President and who emphasized as-Sadat's statement that Nixo 's dismissal would b e viewed in the Arab world as a "tragedy " L'HUMANITE on 18 Ju e expressed res.erv effects of the trip stating that "the the Middle East wil be far from over Mr Nixon's spectacu ar have been switc comment L'AURORE of 19 June, as report end, after all the "fanfare and specta of a "genuine solut on" had become cle tionsabout the lasting battle for a just peace i nee the projectors of ed off." In a similar d by AFP, said that in th ular ovations," no prospect r. UNITED KINGDOM ter an initial fl ssinger's Salzhur press relied heavil on prominently di own correspondents nd REU.TER dispatch trip. The TIMES re orted extensively in Egypt, declaring that the agreement the strides made by Washington in the OBSERVER labeled t trip a "gaudy tri concern over the "problems and dangers of the Palestinian . A highly favorable TIMES editorial of that the new U.S.-Arab relationship co Israeli intransige ce over the withdr FOR OFFICIAL U rry of. editorial comment on press conference, the B itish played reports from its s in.covering the Presid nt's n the "rapturous welcome' signed there "emphasizes :fiddle East.." Although t e mph," most papers expres ed ahead," particularly tha the 15th, though warning 1d be threatened by al issue, noted that the No Objection to Declassification in Full 2011/12/05: LOC-HAK-182-3-5-1 No Objection to Declassification in Full 2011/12/05: LOC-HAK-182-3-5-1 FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY FBIS REACTION REPORT 21 JUNE 1974 Soviets "can hardly be expected to view Mr. Nixon's triumphal progress through the Middle East with unalloyed pleasure." The DAILY TELEGRAPH, traditionally the most pro-Nixon of all British papers, in an editorial on the 17th, claimed that through Kissinger's and Nixon's Middle East travels, the United States "has scored for herself and the West as a whole the first global success for many weary years." The same issue nevertheless prominently reported negative U.S. and world reaction to the trip, an example of which was supplied by its Damascus correspondent, who stated that objections to the trip "did not come entirely from pro-Russians. I was told some of Sadat's more sophisticated friends felt he was pinning too many hopes on an American President hopelessly weakened by Watergate." WEST GERMANY West German media comment as usual covered a broad spectrum, but highlighted the three themes of Watergate, the Palestinian issue, and the placing of nuclear reactors in the Middle East. SUEDDEUTSCHE ZEITUNG,reviewed by the Cologne Deutschlandfunk, editorialized on 14 June that the foreign policy successes of the President stand in almost "fantastic contrast" to his "domestic calamities," and noted that Nixon wants to present his critics at home with a President "cheered abroad." Likewise, NEUES OSNABRUECKER ZEITUNG of 17 June, also reviewed by Deutschlandfunk, saw the man "plagued by Watergate worries" "revived" by millions of cheering Arabs. The Muenster WESTFAELISCHE NACHRICHTEN of 19 June, reviewed by the same radio, called the cheers greeting the President "balm" for him personally and an indication that a "Watergate-weakened" America can still play its part in world politics. In contrast, the prestigious FRANKFURTER ALLGEMEINE ZEITUNG' termed it "unfair" that the trip should be viewed by many, in light of Watergate, as a "possible relief" for the President on the "foreign affairs frontline." In a comment on 18 June, reported by Deutschl,andfunk, the paper congratulated the "much-chided" Nixon for considerably mitigating the dangers of the Middle East "powderkeg" and concluded that he can be counted on in the future as well. Similarly, a Mainz radio commentary of the 18th said the President's trip had improved the "climate and sentiment" even if no "direct and concrete" steps toward peace had been taken. Earlier on the 5th, setting the stage for the visit, an editorial in the same Frankfurt paper had concluded that the United States now has "greater influence" than the USSR "on the Nile" and that the "American word :.today in nearly all of the Arab Orient wields more No Objection to Declassification in Full 2011/12/05: LOC-HAK-182-3-5-1 No Objection to Declassification in Full 2011/12/05: LOC-HAK-182-3-5-1 weight than during the urbulent sixties." eluded that "it is in t e common interest that the leading Wester power puts in a s in the Middle East." Some comment cautioned The Ludwigshafen RHEINP noted that the "most d and pointed to the Pal Middle East situation. date points to the Pal City of Jerusalem as b HANNOVERSCHE ALLGEMEIN same radio, noted that and commented that if his visit a "great his deeds,lthe Arabs' "dis WELT, in an editorial acknowledgement of the "concession" which the The 17 June Duesseldor U.S. nuclear aid to Eg ing whether the modera by a "hatemonger" like had possibly left a "t of 19 June accused the circle into motion" in customers," where MUEN States would in the en their assistance---"a k gainst expecting .t 21 JUNE 1974 The editorial con- f the Western world If-assertive appearance o much from the trip. ALZ of 17 June, re fficult" problems h tinian question as The Dortmund RUHR- stinian question an ing "nearly insurmo ZEITUNG on the 13t ixon was a'man who is "fine words," li orical turning poin chantment" will be the 18th, pointed legitimate interest cabs will insist o RHEINISCHE,POST, t, is reported by e as-Sadat might not al-Qadhdhafi and sp United States of s dewed by Deutschlandfunk ve not yet been solved capable of spoiling the the problem of the Old. , as reported by-the loved "grand words" e those in Cairo calling " are not followed by all the greater. DIE to the President's of the? Palestinians, as being fulfilled. discussing the-promise eutschlandfunk as questi one day be replaced culating that Nixon . SUEDDEUTSCHE ZEITUNG tting an "ill-boding an effort "to please all its Mideast HNER MERKUR wonder whether the United receive what the Soviets received for ITALY Although Ita dominate the newspapers during the and Milan's CORRIERE D' from correspondents on Ugo Stille that, regar the President's trip p symbolize and strength Arab relations. A gen shown the United State y's acute domestic front pages and ed rip, two major pap LLA SERA, publishe the trip. Both pa less of the allege rsued largely posi n the turnabout" r rally expressed vi to be "the real p roblems tended to torial columns of Italian rs, Turin's LA STAMPA daily factual. dispatche ers agreed with CORRIERE' domestic implications, ive aims "intended to cently achieved in U.S.- was. that :the trip had wer in the Middle East." No Objection to Declassification in Full 2011/12/05: LOC-HAK-182-3-5-1 No Objection to Declassification in Full 2011/12/05: LOC-HAK-182-3-5-1 FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY, FBIS REACTION REPORT 21 JUNE 1974 Both papers agreed that the trip was a blow to Soviet influence in the Middle East, but they differed in assessing its impact. Igor Man asserted in LA STAMPA that the USSR was "not humiliated," where-- as CORRIERE commentator Sormani insisted that the trip was "a serious slap in the face for Moscow." Freacobaldi, in CORRIERE, took a reserved position, stating that the President's "journey of peace" had been "not a point of arrival but one of departure." The communist newspaper L'UMITA expressed suspicion of the:Presiden.t's motives, declaring that the trip pursued the "obvious. aim" of "strengthening the Presidential image" at home. Its unattributed dispatches also expressed doubt that the trip would contribute to a settlement in the Middle East, emphasizing particularly--as did noncommunist., newspapers--the uncertainties remaining on the Palestinian issue. AUSTRIA Most Austrian papers gave prominent coverage to all phases of the trip, particularly to his stay in Salzburg, but editorial comment was relatively scant. Noncommunist press assess- ments were cautiously optimistic that the trip would help stabilize the Middle East situation, whereas the communist press viewed the trip in stock terms as indicative of a change in U.S. policy toward the Arabs which was "enforced" by the powerful support given them by the USSR and the other socialist countries. Additionally, the Austrian media gave heavy play to Secretary of State Kissinger's. Salzburg press conference in which he threatened to resign. An editorial of the Socialist ARBEITER-ZEITUNG on 13 June, entitled "Uncle Sam in the Middle East," stressed the "heart-warming" re- ception in Egypt and added that it is a "small miracle" that "the United States has succeeded in being,'or becoming, good friends with both sides in a grave conflict." It warned, however, that "Nixon's visit to the Middle East has aroused great, perhaps too great, hopes on both sides," and that "it will take great diplomatic skill to reduce these hopes to a reasonable level." This and several other papers stressed that the main question, the Palestinian problem, still remains to be solved. An editorial in the independent DIE PRESSE on 15 June stressed the interrelationship between foreign and domestic policy and the negative influence of the President's "weakened domestic position" on U.S. foreign policy, observing that he "is attempting to defend himself, against the hydra of the mass media and the consequences of the recklessness of his own staff with the aid of foreign policy." Another DIE PRESSE editorial on 20 June summed up the outcome of No Objection to Declassification in Full 2011/12/05: LOC-HAK-182-3-5-1 No Objection to Declassification in Full 2011/12/05: LOC-HAK-182-3-5-1 F R OFFICIAL USE ONL FBIS REACTION REPORT 21 JUNE 1974 the Middle East trip as that only Brezhnev's for a more concrete indicati "coordinated" their Midd out their "spheres of in A communist VOLKSSTIMME by Nixon to outstrip his Arab countries, assertin "mere down paymen hcoming visit to A n as to what exten e East endeavors a luence." ditorial on 12 Jun East?," Viewed the EC economic rivals race between the political weapon a kind o EC has started. In anoth Arabs Have Been Successfu depicted Nixon's trip as Middle East issue," "enfo the Arabs by the USSR and OTHER COUNTRIES Portu in Pr A Lusitania news agency r as "historic," and Deputy over Lisbon radio on 19 J "exceeded all expectation Nixon's statements of "co Portuguese positions." Stockholm's conservative reflected the view of muc Kissinger's Salzburg pres the entire trip. Its cov of the Scandinavian newsp themselves to factual cov with only sparse comment. r editorial entitl it the communist V "symptom of Ameri ced" by the powerf the socialist coun uese media express sident Nixon's tal port on 19 June d Prime Minister Sa ne, commenting tha ," emphasized what plete support for VENSKA DAGBLADET, of the Scandinavi conference threat. rage went further, pees, which on the rage based on press Reviewing the res for peace,-" declaring ab capitals will give the superpowers have d have perhaps mapped entitled "What Does trip as an attempt n relations with the s ,used oil as a nited States and the d "Not Nixon but the LKSSTIMME on 20 June a's yielding on the 1 support given to ries. d particular interest s with General Spinola.. scribed the meeting rniero in a statement the meeting had he termed President ortuguese policy and a 12 June editorial,. press that Dr. ed to ".overshadow" owever,. than most agency reports is of the trip in that the President ip to consolidate from Dr. Kissinger's, not be regarded as a 19 June editorial, SVENS would "not neglect to make his "domestic policy advan diplomacy, but that this " "secure forever." President's activities thr UUTISET, reviewed by Heisi turn" and a change toward "persistently aimed at" by Union. The paper criticiz to "belittle" the role pla though "important" steps t aid of the Soviet Union. DAGBLADET stated the most of" the t age" already gaine redit side" should was light, but .ra ughout the trip. i radio, called t etente, which it c the socialist coun d the "Western rea ed by the Soviet U ward peace had bee is reports covered the e 19 June KANSAN e trip a "positive racterized as a policy ries headed by the Soviet tionary press" for trying ion and said these "parts 1" possible only with the No Objection to Declassification in Full 2011/12/05: LOC-HAK-182-3-5-1 No Objection to Declassification in Full 2011/12/05: LOC-HAK-182-3-5-1 FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY FBIS REACTION REPORT 21 JUNE 1974 ASIA AND AFRICA JAPAN Japanese media, which carried extensive reportage on the trip, viewed it as a diplomatic success for the United States and the Arab nations. The United States was credited with achieving a breakthrough in strengthening relations with the Arabs, but presumed U.S. nationalistic interests in securing oil supplies, plus uncertainty over the Palestinians, were seen as causes for anxiety. The spread of nuclear technology in the Middle East also evoked comment and dismay. Suggestions that the trip was at least partially motivated by domestic considerations linked to Watergate were widely published. Editorially, ASAHI said that an attempt to achieve a diplomatic success in the wake of Watergate served as a backdrop to current U.S. efforts in the Middle East but that "more fundamentally," Washington's basic aim was "to pursue its long-term national interest--that is,.preventing the risks of a confrontation with the Soviet Union . . and the danger of losing a stable source of oil supply." On 21 June the same paper concluded its editorial by saying, "With the date of the Geneva Mideast Peace Conference still undecided and the road to peace in the Middle East regarded as stretching endlessly, the fact that the word 'nuclear' has appeared in the-first step taken toward that goal leaves us with a deep feeling of anxiety." A 20 June YOMIURI editorial noting that enduring peace in the region was impossible without a settlement of the Palestinian problem said: "We have been impressed by the progress made so far . . . . However, a true and lasting peace has yet to be achieved." The JAPAN TIMES editorial of 19 June, encouraged by the frank exchange..of.ideas between the President and the Arab leaders, noted.that."President Nixon will now be.in a more advan- tageous position.in.his forthcoming meetings with Soviet Communist Party Chief Leonid Brezhnev. . . ." A 20 June editorial in the Japan Communist Party paper AKAHATA criticized the trip as an. effort by the United States to establish "a new alliance with the ruling groups representing national interests in Arab countries, thus dragging the latter into the world strategy of..U.S..imperialism. Therefore the United States has made a 'step forward' toward the establishment of a new type of indocolonial rule in this area." No Objection to Declassification in Full 2011/12/05: LOC-HAK-182-3-5-1 No Objection to Declassification in Full 2011/12/05: LOC-HAK-182-3-5-1 on the President's little comment. Avai able editorial cc visit as strengthenin U.S. position Soviet expense. ACE DAILY NEWS edi the trip as giving President Nixon more " his forthcoming trip t Moscow, but predi pressure on its positi n, the Soviet.Unio in the Middle East. T e editorial also p may "shore up" the Pre ident's "deteriora d o m e s t i c f __ _ T_ 3-_ r t -_ _ i _ n t me i U.S. announcement of ptoposed nuclear aid mention of nuclear aid in reporting U.S.- SOUTH VIETNAM The ouch Vietnamese pr trip generally light co of comment ranging fro cynicism in the " cautious optimism in t e 11pro-government" monitored radio or tel vision comment. such as DAN CHU and QU T CHONG viewed the a diplomatic victory, oosting Nixon's pr relief from the pressu es of Watergate. exemplified by the pap rs DAI DAN TOC and 21 JUNE 1974 rried extensive reportag ourney but have offered nt has portrayed the .n the Middle East at orial of 10 June viewed rump cards" to use in ted that despite current inted.out that the visit ing" position on the romptly reported the to Israel but avoided gyptian agreements. ss gave President Nixon's erage, with the tenor pposition" press to papers; there was no e pro-government papers President's trip as stige-and providing some e opposition press, IEN TIN, dealt with the ing that.it brought trip in cynical and dep ecatory terms, cla no new results and was imed at reducing d Watergate. Comment in he independent pap PHUONG was generally sk ptical. The latte on the 17th that "Presi ent.-Nixon's trip cannot end either.in Ca ro, Damascus, Tel leg' should be in Indoc ina, if he is actu a generation of peace f r the world." rs HOA BINH and DONG observed in an article oward world peace' . viv or Moscow. Its 'las lly determined to create OTHER ASIAN COUNTRIES Strong comment b and the press ha offer to provide nuclea technology to Egy the backdrop of recent uclear tests by In comment has underlined ustralia's preoccu proliferation and criti ized President Nix further irritated the s report, Deputy Premier decision as "most unfor a helpful effect on Mid Australia on 17 June ex nuclear aid to construe inns on 20 June c unate" and predict le East peace. Th a bomb. Australian officials centered on the U.S. t and Israel. Noting ia, France and the PRC, ation with nuclear n's actions as having to a Melbourne radio iticized the President's d that it cannot have governor of South Egypt might use the No Objection to Declassification in Full 2011/12/05: LOC-HAK-182-3-5-1 No Objection to Declassification in Full 2011/12/05: LOC-HAK-182-3-5-1 FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY FBIS REACTION REPORT 21 JUNE 1974 Sparse Indian and Pakistani comment has sidestepped the issue of U.S. nuclear aid to Israel and Egypt, while focusing on the visit as the climax of a remarkable turn of U.S. fortunes in the Middle East since the October 1973 war. A Delhi radio commentary on the 19th portrayed the United States as the chief beneficiary of the visit, claiming that little outward progress had been made on resolving fundamental issues dividing the Israelis and Arabs. It said that President Nixon was intent on avoiding contentious issues, hoping to strengthen. Washington's position by means of economic and technical assistance, but added approvingly that Arab leaders had persisted in calling attention to the issue of Palestinian-national rights. The commentary alluded to the implications of superpower rivalry in the visit, noting that Moscow had felt impelled recently to remind the Arabs of past Soviet support and of historical U.S. backing for Israel. The pro-Soviet PATRIOT on the 16th deplored the fact that Cairo seemed to be turning-its back on the past era of Soviet aid and rejecting the heritage of the Nasir period, prefering to "hand over" Egypt's economy to "U.S. monopoly capital.!' Karachi radio commentaries have taken pains to balance praise for U.S. Middle East achievements symbolized in the Nixon visit with a warning of Arab determination to-achieve total liberation of their lands. A 16 June article expressed hope that President Nixon would use his influence to move Tel Aviv to a "more rational view of existing reality." Limited Malaysian and Indonesian comment has similarly praised the U.S. achievements, while noting the need for further progress toward a resolution of contentious Arab-Israeli issues. Philippine and South Korean media have not been heard to comment on the visit. AFRICA The President's trip to the Middle East has been fully reported by most monitored African radios, but few have originated comment. The major point of controversy in the-sparse comment thus far revolves around the nuclear issue. Salisbury (Rhodesia) radio was notably outspoken on this issue, recalling the recent Indian test in observing: "How do you stop someone from making gunpowder when you have supplied the ingredients?" An 18 June Nigerian radio commentary also cited the nuclear agreement as creating a "more inflamable" world situation, but it hedged its position by stating that this "should not rule out the use of nuclear devices for peaceful purposes." No Objection to Declassification in Full 2011/12/05: LOC-HAK-182-3-5-1 No Objection to Declassification in Full 2011/12/05: LOC-HAK-182-3-5-1 As the trip began, Brazza from its Cairo correspond Washington's position in to Egyptian President Sad on the same day was less DAILY GRAPHIC speculated reason for the trip, and that the case of the Pale trick is used to effect a Israel." Available Niger the President's enthu.aias A column in the Benin SU of Egyptians" seemed. to-a and pointedly called on t to shed "old intransigent stated that "in terms of surpassed the achievements LATIN AMERICA ille radio. on. 11 J nt hailing the vis he Middle East and t. The Ghanaian a hat "indispensable he Nigerian radio tinians must still an press comment o FBIS REACTION REPORT 21 JUNE 1974 ne carried an account t for consolidating giving much credit d Nigerian comment aian state-owned oil" was the prime ommentor stressed be resolved, "whatever Syria, Egypt, and 16 June, following , was more forthcoming. hat the ''broad mass peaceful purposes in in the movement NAISSANCE WEEKLY 1dent Nixon may have ent. is welcome:. in Cairo cept the President' e Palestinians to-j . " And the. ENUGU rld politics" Pres of any other presi Monitored Latin American m Presidential trip, though the day. Radio newscasts Paraguay, Peru, Bolivia, a of the trip on a regular b reports. Newspapers treat foreign press agency repor sample of editorial opinio favorable, and sometimes g ARGENTINA Among Argent CLARIN and t type items. CLARIN'S edit act with considerable free under pressure of worries he could bask in the fresh of the spectacular success the editorial complained o in the commercial aspects journey "can be considered consolidates peace, a cond to all nations." The LA 0 problem" in relation to th dia gave.continuou eldom featuring it from Argentina, Br d Central America sis, relying on fo d the trip as fron age and radiophoto presented the tri owing terms. ne newspapers revi e 19 June LA OPINI rial noted that Pr om" on his trip be ver U.S. oil requi U.S. prestige in t of his Secretary of the neglect. of th f the trip, it-cone a positive step to tion which. will obj INION article conce trip and noted tha oblem" by "insist a sharp definition of the p 'stage-by-stage. coverage to the as top news item of sil, Chile, Uruguay, eported most aspects eign press agency page news and featured . The available in generally wed, only the 19 June N carried commentary- sident Nixon "could ements and,..in addition, e region as 'a result State there-" While underdeveloped world uded that-the-president he:-extent that it ctively spread developmep.t trated on the"Palestini.n the-President.-"avoided g that it must be solved No Objection to Declassification in Full 2011/12/05: LOC-HAK-182-3-5-1 No Objection to Declassification in Full 2011/12/05: LOC-HAK-182-3-5-1 FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY FBIS REACTION REPORT 21 JUNE 1974 BRAZIL JORNAL DO BRASIL, carried frontpage leads on the trip every day from 12 to 18 June. On 13, 14, 15 and 17 June the paper frontpaged radiophotos highlighting Nixon's stay in Egypt, Saudi Arabia and Israel. On 15 June the paper ran the text of the agreement between President Nixon and Sadat. JORNAL DO BRASIL'$ reportage was taken from various news. agencies. In general, the three aspects of the trip which received the greatest attention were Secretary of State Kissinger's press conference in Salzburg, the agreement to supply nuclear technology to Egypt and the-President's talks with Portuguese President Spinola. MEXICO An editorial in NOVEDADES of Mexico City on 4 June linked the forthcoming visit to the Watergate scandal, noting that Nixon's foreign policy was "one of his most effective weapons" in terms of his prestige at home. However, NOVEDADES warned, the President's "struggle" should not be overemphasized. To do so would be to belittle the importance of these "highly meritorious" actions. The paper also saw a relationship to the forthcoming Moscow summit meeting and expressed the hope that both sides would make strides toward achieving a "a sound understanding" and true peaceful coexistence without the cold war and the tensions of the past. PANAMA An editorial in LA ESTRELLA DE PANAMA on 11 June also professed to see a relationship between the President's domestic troubles and the Middle East trip. CallingNixon"capable and shrewd," the paper guessed that the President "might even survive" Watergate, saying he has taken advantage of the "favorable circumstances" in order to make the trip, a journey made possible in large measure by the successes of Dr. Kissinger. The paper expressed the hope that, as a result of "Nixon's wise decision" to go ahead with the visit, the results would benefit not only the Arab states and Israel, but also the international reputation of the United States and of the President. The Panama City CRITICA carried a column at the end of the visit warning of the dangers inherent-in_t'ie U.S. nuclear aid to both Cairo and Tel Aviv. It will be "extremely easy" for Israel, the paper wrote, to change that aid into an offensive nuclear capability, and since the Arabs are not as technically advanced as the Israelis, the Soviet Union "will not hesitate" to provide similar expertise to the Arab states. The paper blamed the United States for seemingly adopting a dual standard: one week criticizing India for-testing a nuclear device; the next, providing Cairo and Tel Aviv with a powerful instrument which "undoubtedly" will end up in the military laboratories of both nations. No Objection to Declassification in Full 2011/12/05: LOC-HAK-182-3-5-1 No Objection to Declassification in Full 2011/12/05: LOC-HAK-182-3-5-1 OR OFFICIAL USE ONLY PSIS REACTION REPORT 21 JUNE 1974 - 24 - III. COME UNIST COUNTRIES THE SOVIET UNION Moscow media provided b President's trip, with if selective, coverage ief, straightforwa reportage on the ASS and the central press offering correct, f some speeches in afro and Damascus eluding the visits to Egypt and Israel. primarily to two uccessive weekly PRAVDA and to Arab c-language commentaries and of the statements co Comment has been confined international reviews in on the "unofficial" Radi coverage of U.S. policy to the trip, together wi oblique indications of c how to handle the tour. While Moscow earlier sco in Washington's Middle E seems to suggest some ac relationship with the Ar in American policy by vi Moscow nevertheless is a support for Israel has n themselves do not wish t their "traditional" frie As the President began h concern came in Gromyko Minsk on 10 June. Refer foreign policy, Gromyko problems could be solved that "it certainly cannot Union's interests." eace and Progres A dearth of Soviet tatements on the ddle East just prior h the sparse comme t on the visit and ncern, suggest Sov et hesitancy as to fed at Egyptian de larations of a change st policy, the evo wing Soviet approach ommodation to the dea of 4& changing U.S. bs, while taking c edit for new directions tue of Soviet inf.l ence through detente. pains to point ou that Washington's t lessened, and t stress that the Arabs e new Arab-America relations to replace dship with the Sov at Union. s trip, the first timation of Soviet Supreme Soviet pr --election speech in ing to the "high" prestige of the USSR's eclared that no imp rtant international ithout Soviet part cipation and added be 'solved to the d triment of the Soviet At the same time, with th commentators have gone ou detente. Relating the "n the Middle East, Moscow h made it possible for the during the October war, t vening of the Geneva conf the Sinai and Golan disen trip, meager Soviet comme ing the Presidential visi regarding Arab-Soviet rel prime Middle East peacema forthcoming Mos.co summit in mind, Soviet of their way to pay up the benefits of w atmosphere" in U.S.-Soviet relations to s asserted that th relaxation of tension wo powers to avoid.a dangerous confrontatio "take the initial ve" leading to the con- rence, and to play an "important role" in agement agreements During the President's t on the Arab-Isra li issue--without mention --complained of We tern press "fabrications" tions and portraye the Soviet Union as a er. No Objection to Declassification in Full 2011/12/05: LOC-HAK-182-3-5-1 No Objection to Declassification in Full 2011/12/05: LOC-HAK-182-3-5-1 FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY FBIS REACTION REPORT 21 JUNE 1974 COMMENT The PRAVDA international review on 9 June, in Moscow's first observation.on the visit, merely noted that a large part of the world press regarded the President's-tour, and the possible resumption of U.S.-Syrian relations, as evidence of an American desire to normalize U.S.-Arab relations which had been ""undermined" by U.S. support for the Israeli "aggressors." There was no further comment until PRAVDA's review the following week, when the paper noted on the 16th that the Arabs had rightly regarded the United States as "the accomplice of the-Israeli aggressors," but that the new international climate provided an .opportunity for a change in the nature of U.S.-Arab relations. Indirectly indicating Soviet misgivings over the implications of.this.change, PRAVDA ascribed to "cold war advocates" a desire to interpret the President's trip "in their own way and use it for a campaign aimed at undermining Arab-Soviet friendships" PRAVDA displayed sensitivity over what itdescribed as "rightwing press" assertions that U.S. policy would lead to elimination of the USSR's influence in the Middle East. Replying to "Western observers" who were displaying enthusiasm for "'Americanization' of the Middle East," PRAVDA recalled Secretary Kissinger's assurance in his 6 June news conference that the United States had neither the intention nor the capability to eliminate Soviet influence from the region. A foreign-language commentary by Rassadin on the 19th followed PRAVDA's lead in charging that "cold war" supporters tried to exploit the Presidential visit to widen the campaign against Arab-Soviet friendship. Moscow's Radio Peace and Progress provided an example of initial Soviet uncertainty as to how to handle the trip. An RPP Arabic-language commentary on 10 June carefully avoided any mention of the President's visit in discussing what it called an upsurge of U.S. press interest in the Arab world, evidenced by visits to the area by a "big team of U.S. reporters." On the 17th the radio replayed PRAVDA's remarks, of the previous day, and a commentary on the 18th pegged to the U.S.- Israeli statement saw the U.S. affirmation of readiness to provide Israel with weapons and "substantial" economic assistance as en- couragement to Israeli occupation of Arab territory. The commentary acknowledged that "certain changes" had occurred in the United States' Mideast policy which gave the Arabs."an opportunity to alter their relations with America' but gave much .credit for these changes to the Soviet Union. And in an Arabic-language commentary on the 19th, Radio Peace and Progress claimed that the "positive developments" in U.S.-Soviet relations had given the USSR the opportunity to "actively influence" the U.S. stand on the Middle East, although "despite this" it was evident that American assistance to Israel would continue. No Objection to Declassification in Full 2011/12/05: LOC-HAK-182-3-5-1 No Objection to Declassification in Full 2011/12/05: LOC-HAK-182-3-5-1 FBIS REACTION REPORT 21 JUNE 1974 COVERAGE OF VISIT play up statements that on the Middle East prob on the 14th cited Egypt disengagement was only basis of Security Counc was similarly quoted by limited reports o the various speeches Moscow has .tended to wn public positions c-language Broadcast at as declaring that j the issue on the an President al Asad I.calling disengagement account noted President taken were only a tep by step toward he President as saying over the Palestinian de during the trip, coincide with its. em. Thus, an Arab an President as.-Sa step toward solvin q1 resolutions. Sy ASS on the .16th as a first step toward a fi Nixon's remark that the beginning, and the task a just and lasting peace the United States unders question. In reporting the U.S.-Eg a peace settlement that interests of all the peo Palestinian people." Th declared peace could onl the framework of the Gen that the United States a ment on nuclear energy, concluded this month on A 17 June TASS report on the two countries would energy and U.S. delivery temporary agreement on t month. The TASS account m peace. The TASS irst steps already. as now to advance ood Syria's concer ptian statement of of the fact that t lea of the Middle account did note. va peace conferenc d Egypt would begi d that ..a provisi, principles, TASS on .e document called for unt the "legitimate ast, including the hat the statement h negotiations within TASS also reported negotiating an agree- l .ag.reement would be lear fuel to Egypt. elivery of U.S. nu the U.S.-Israeli at ign an agreement on of nuclear fuel to oeused on the matt ed that military continued on a long-term give "substantial economi maintaining its military TASS on the 16th reported resumption of U.S.-Syrian and U.S.-Jordanian statem to Israeli Prime Minister States, but the invitatio in TASS' report on the U. sentence report on the Pr Saudi Arabia was virtuall commentary on the 19th di AN-NIDA' as reporting the asis and that the 'aid "' to cover I otential. relations. TASS r is noted the Pres Rabin and King Hus to President as.-S .Egyptian stateme sident's arrival i ignored. The Rad cite the Lebanese tement also noted that cooperation in nuclear srael, and that a would be signed this r of aid, reporting eliveries would be nited States would rael's expenses in ..announcement on the ports on the U.S.-Israeli dent's invitations yn to visit the United dat was not mentioned t. Other than a two- Jiddah, the visit to o Peace and Progress Communist Party daily nt that the United No Objection to Declassification in Full 2011/12/05: LOC-HAK-182-3-5-1 No Objection to Declassification in Full 2011/12/05: LOC-HAK-182-3-5-1 FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY FBIS REACTION REPORT 21 JUNE 1974 States wanted Saudi Arabia "to be strong" and as pointing out that Washington was interested in strengthening "Saudi reaction" as the mainstay of U.S. policy in the region. EAST EUROPE Scattered comment from Moscow's orthodox East European allies-- Bulgaria, Czechoslovakia, East Germany, Hungary, and Poland--generally argued that President Nixon's tour signified no basic change in "imperialist" aims in the Middle East, but was undertaken because of "realistic" U.S. awareness of the Arabs' new influence stemming from their successes in the October war and the oil embargo. These countries' commentators also saw a connection between the trip and the President's Watergate-related difficulties at home, reiterating their standard charge that the President's critics 'are motivated mainly by opposition to detente. Such motives were blamed by Hungary, Poland, and Czechoslovakia for the attacks on Secretary Kissinger, in the wake of the Secretary's. Salzburg press conference. The orthodox East European comment also duly included tributes to the Mideast role of the Soviet Union, under Brezhnev's leadership. The tour drew the largest reportorial coverage among East European radios in Hungarian and Czechoslovak media,` including almost daily half-minute film clips on Prague TV. A sizeable volume of Yugoslav comment was uniformly favorable both with regard to the President's tour and to Secretary Kissinger, while the Romanians have thus far refrained from commenting on the trip, limiting their coverage to brief, factual, and implicitly positive reports. Albanian comment, predictably hostile to the President and Kissinger, viewed the tour as symbolizing both con-, flict and "collusion" between Moscow and Washington. ORTHODOX Czechoslovia's Bratislava PRAVDA on 13 June, viewing ALLIES the President's trip as "unquestionably the high point of a demonstration of the 'new' U.S. policy" in the Middle East, charged at the same time that the United States and "other imperialist forces" aimed, as before, at capitalist exploitation and undermining of progressive forces in the area. Dominant in U.S. thinking, the commentary added, was the realization that oil is found in the Arab countries, not in Israel. Another Bratislava paper, SMENA, declared on the 19th that-the results of the President's visit to Israel confirmed that there were "no essential changes" in U.S. policy toward the Arabs or its political, financial, and military support to Israel. A Bratislava PRAVDA comment cited by CTK on the 20th linked the results of Nixon's Israel visit to the resumed bombing of Lebanese FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY No Objection to Declassification in Full 2011/12/05: LOC-HAK-182-3-5-1 No Objection to Declassification in Full 2011/12/05: LOC-HAK-182-3-5-1 OR OFFICIAL USE ONLY FBIS REACTION REPORT 21 JUNE 1974 villages and Palestini s, saying: "Nos 11 share of the re- sponsibility for this situation lies on th United States, which continues its big milit ry and economic sup ort to Israel, the aggressor." On the 15t , a dispatch from E PRAVO's Washington correspondent predicted that while the Pres dent would be welcomed throughout his tour, he ould be repeatedly confronted with the "decisive," still unsol d Palestinian prob em, first raised by President as-Sadat duri the Cairo visit. The dispatch paid tribut to the results of Moscow's "patient and uno. tentatious diplomacy" in persuading the Arabs o accept a UN sett ement. The East Berlin domestic service on the 18t grudgingly praised the President for pressing I rael into a "chang of course" toward a peaceful solution. The ommentary doubted. t the same time whether the President's influent could be "decisiv " on this score. In the meager Bulgarian co ent, a Beirut-date fined dispatch in the Sofia party daily RABOTN CHESKO DELO on the 18th remarked at the windup of the tour that, because of continu d U.S. support for Israel--exemplified by a promised nuclear r actor--and the U.S. "neglect" of the Palesti ian liberation mov ent, "the problems remain." While Prague, Sofia, and East Berlin took a largely cynical view regarding allegedly unch aged U.S. pro-Isra ii policy, Poland and Hungary were relatively uted on this score. Thus, ZYCIE WARSZAWY on the 12th was favorabl in tone in attrib ting two basic aims to the President's trip: First, to convinc the Arabs through aid agreements that the resent, more evenh ded U.S. policy represented "a durable c ange"; and second, to show Moscow, on the eve of the President's trip there, his r. diners to cooperate with the USSR in restori g peace to the area. The paper noted in this connection that President Nixon "is kno as a consistent advocate of detente and c existence." And t e Budapest daily MAGYAR NEMZET, also on t 12th, praised the timing of the trip--afte the troop disengagement a reements and befor the next phase of the Geneva negotiations and t e Moscow summit--a d predicted that a just settlement could be achie. ed "if all sides d splay good will." An 18 June commentary on Bud pest domestic TV, hale characterizing current U.S. Mideast pol.i y as "a double gam ," assessed the overall results of the to r as "fruitful" an "successful" with regard to detente and to he President's sta ding at home. WATERGATE In pointing to domestic motiva ions for the President's trip, Brati lava PRAVDA on the 12th stressed that he "is under the furious pre cures of the adver aries of detente, and this is reflected in the ourse of the Water ate affair" and the No Objection to Declassification in Full 2011/12/05: LOC-HAK-182-3-5-1 No Objection to Declassification in Full 2011/12/05: LOC-HAK-182-3-5-1 FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY.. FBIS REACTION REPORT 21 JUNE 1974 Congressional impeachment deliberations. In favorable tones, the commentary noted that the Middle East trip could divert attention from these domestic matters and direct it toward the Nixon Administration's efforts to complete the transition from a policy of confrontation to one of negotiation. In a similar vein, a talk on the Budapest domestic radio on the 10th remarked that "while the wrangling over the raising of impeachment charges is in progress in Congress and in other forums, the American President is obviously concentrating his efforts on international diplomacy." And the 12 June ZYCIE WARSZAWY also gave the President the benefit of the doubt in commenting that "it would be a considerable simplification to place this trip, as some .commentators are doing, merely in the context of the political showdown between the White House and Congress," adding that "its scope and significance reach far beyond Washington." A favorable overall assessment of the tour carried by Warsaw's PAP on the 20th, which highlighted the President's promise of a nuclear reactor to Egypt, concluded that "the visit was undoubtedly a success for Nixon, though it is doubtful whether this success will put an end to the Watergate affair." KISSINGER The Hungarians, followed by Czechoslovakia and Poland, promptly denounced the charges against Secretary Kissinger which occasioned his threat to resign at his 11 June press conference in Salzburg. Early the next day the Budapest radio carried a comment from its New'York correspondent to the effect that, in the U.S. domestic controversy, "the attack is now directed, through the person of the Secretary of State, against the main foreign policy line of the Nixon Administration." A Budapest TV commentary the same day predicted that the possibility of Kissinger's resignation would cast a shadow over the President's talks with both Arab and Israeli leaders. This talk, as well as the government paper MAGYAR HIRLAP the next day, publicized favorable comments on Kissinger by Senator Fulbright and other Congressional leaders. Subsequent attacks on the Secretary's critics by Polish media culminated in a 16 June Broniarek commentary in the party daily TRYBUNA LUDU. Entitled "Rumors and Insinuations," the article construed the charges against Kissinger as a warning from pro- Israeli elements to the Secretary and President Nixon that they should not lose sight of Israel's interests during negotiations with the Arabs. The article also characterized the charges as "a new stage (since H. Kissinger has been spared up to now)" of the alleged campaign by U.S. politicians, such as Senator Jackson, against U.S.-Soviet detente. No Objection to Declassification in Full 2011/12/05: LOC-HAK-182-3-5-1 No Objection to Declassification in Full 2011/12/05: LOC-HAK-182-3-5-1 FBIS REACTION REPOR 21 JUNE 1974 A Washington correspon PRAVO on the 14th, whi Kissinger's guilt or i ant's dispatch publ e cautioning that s ocence would be pr raising of "old chargesl" against the Secre the start of the Presid summit. Charging that part in the anti-Kissi it proved impossible to placed on the.firing li nt's Mideast trip he Washington POST er campaign," the wreck Nixon's trip e." ROMANIA As the only relations w about the trip, limitin was characteristically avoided having to join in their praise of the situation. The party d the 12th that the "no taking place "in the fr in the Mideast situatio disengagement on the Si any reference to either contrasted with a 1 Jun disengagement, in which praise equal to that fo YUGOSLAVIA Belgrade initiati the visit would serve a about the U.S. attitude generally displayed lit problems in U.S.-Soviet Describing the visit as viewed it as necessary the Mideast crisis but measured by progress ac of the President's arri Milutin Milenkovic point in U.S. relations, citi the United States had "e neutral, mediating" role qualified these observat the real alliance" with East European coun th Israel, Romania its coverage to t ircumspect. By re or break with the oviet Union's role ily SCINTEIA noted lization" of U.S. mework of importan , that is, the Gen ai and Golan front the U.S. or Soviet SCINTEIA article Gromyko and the So Kissinger and the media took a posit e in visiting the useful purpose was toward the Palesti shed.in Prague's RUDE eculation regarding ture, denounced the ary at this juncture--at nd before the Moscow played "a considerable ispatch added that "once to Moscow, Kissinger was ry maintaining diplomati was virtually silent rse reports. Bucharest raining from comment it then Warsaw Pact countries in the Middle East in a Cairo dispatch on gyptian relations was developments which occurred va conference and .the ." However, it avoided mediating roles. This n.the Syrian-Israeli iet Union were given ve view of the President' ideast, but optimism that qualified by concern ian issue. Belgrade le concern that the visit might create or Arab-Soviet relations. "undoubtedly useful o "disclose the dep tedthat its "full eyed in settling t 1 in Egypt, Belgra d out Arab satisfa the opinion of u sentially changed adopting an "obje ons by noting that srael had occurred ," BORBA on the 11th h and complexity" of significance" would be e crisis. On the day e radio.commentator tion with the trend amed Arab sources that is position" on the tive, and even a nd Israelis. Milenkovic "no real breaking up of I l No Objection to Declassification in Full 2011/12/05: LOC-HAK-182-3-5-1 No Objection to Declassification in Full 2011/12/05: LOC-HAK-182-3-5-1 FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY FBIS REACTION REPORT 21 JUNE 1974 Belgrade repeatedly emphasized that the Mideast crisis could not be settled without resolving the Palestinian question, and on the 15th a TANJUG commentary singled out as the."greatest result" of the visit up to that time the U.S.-Egyptian statement recognizing the "interests" of the Palestinians. TANJUG pointed out, however, the distinction between "interests" and "a real act of granting recognition to the national rights of the People of Palestine," which "is still rejected in practice." TANJUG raised the Palestinian question again on the 20th noting that throughout the remainder of the trip the President was unwilling to go beyond the Cairo state- ment. Moreover, it reported that Kissinger's remark in Jerusalem about bringing the Palestinians into negotiations through Jordan had caused Arab "protests" and "may bring about new conflicts and even a more complicated situation in international relations." Yugoslav comment on Moscow's attitude toward the trip shifted some- what following the tumultuous welcome given the President in Egypt. A Teslic BORBA commentary on the 11th, the day before his arrival, maintained that the visit was "welcomed" not-only by the Arabs and the Israelis but also by the Soviet Union,. which saw the tour as a "component and indispensable part of joint American-Soviet efforts to reach a just solution of the crisis through negotiations in Geneva." The Egyptians' enthusiastic welcome for Nixon, however, seemed to raise questions about possible Soviet irritation. On the 17th Zagreb radio commentator Milika Sundic described the Cairo treatment as an "embarrassing episode" which, he said, would be "quickly forgotten, if for no other reason than because it is not in the interest of the United States to upset relations with Moscow." Claiming that Washington-Moscow relations remained not only good "but even better," Sundic predicted that Cairo would do all in its power to "iron out its difficulties with Moscow as soon as possible." Comment on Kissinger's Salzburg press conference was generally sympathetic. On the day after the news conference TANJUG cited Arab press comment that allegations against Kissinger were the result of a "Zionist conspiracy" aimed at undermining the visit, and Belgrade radio commentator Kosta Timotijevicforecast that Kissinger "has all the chances to survive politically both the present and who knows how many future presidents." ALBANIA Tirana comment emphasized that the United States had not abandoned its close ties with Israel and that President Nixon was aiming at strengthening Washington's "imperialist" influence in the Arab countries at the expense of Moscow, even though No Objection to Declassification in Full 2011/12/05: LOC-HAK-182-3-5-1 No Objection to Declassification in Full 2011/12/05: LOC-HAK-182-3-5-1 the two big powers cant the Arabs. On the open radio, in an unattribut three main objectives: loving" and to gain "po in Arab minds of the Un and profoundly hostile" position, just as Mosco Washington Moscow rival "understanding" between should remain unsettled in the future in the ro peoples under the guise in the Mideast. The party daily ZERI I by ATA on the 13th, con forced to visit the Ara between them and the Un perspective" both for t successes in the Octobe opinion in.favor of the ware of "vain promises ued to operate in ng day of the trip d commentary, outi To present U.S. "i itical capital at ted States as "pro to the Arabs; and was trying to do y, however, was vi the two that fund so that the two su e of "arbiters of of so-called speci Y FBIS REACTION REPORT 21 JUNE 1974 "collusion" against the Tirana domestic p.erialism" as "peace- ome"; to erase the image Israeli, warmongering o "undermine" Moscow's o Washington. The wed as tempered by an ental Mideast problems erpowers could emerge he fate of the Arab 1 responsibilities" OPULLIT, in an .art clecarried in full ended that Preside t Nixon was practically states in order to seek a "disengagement" ted States once he ad seen the "dark e United States and Israel following Arab war, the oil embar o, and rising public rabs. The daily w rned the Arabs to be- or peace" and "vari.us diplomatic maneuvers.' Picking up American press reports on Kis.s.i tapping role, Tirana portrayed the allegati unattributed article tit gate Scandal," ZERI I PO STAR-NEWS as reporting t in testimony before the September. Although Kis ignored, ATA on the 18th to save both Nixon's and ed "Kissinger--Par at "he had failed enate Foreign Rela inger's Salzburg p. interpreted the Mi Kissinger's "skins CHINA Peking has thus far rest straightforward NCNA rep stays in Egypt and Syria other Middle East stops. of nuclear power assista report on the President' of U.S.-Egyptian relatio principles, and stressed icted coverage of its that have .f ocu and have given onl Peking has not m ce to Egypt and Is. talks in Egypt ac s, noted the two s progress toward bi errs alleged wire- icipant in the Water- ited the Washington o speak the truth" ions Committee last ess conference was east visit as designed he trip to brief, ed on the President's passing mention to tioned the U.S. offers ael. A 15. June NCNA nowledged .the consolidati n des' declaration of ateral economic cooperati n. No Objection to Declassification in Full 2011/12/05 : LOC-HAK-182-3-5-1 No Objection to Declassification in Full 2011/12/05: LOC-HAK-182-3-5-1 FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY. FBIS REACTION REPORT 21 JUNE 1974 The report indirectly demonstrated continuing -U,.S..-Egyp.tian differences over Middle East political questions,, citing Sadat's stress on the need for respecting Palestinian national rights while noting the President's acknowledgement that he had not come "with ready-made solutions for these complex problems." A shorter 17 June NCNA report on the President's stay in Syria highlighted the agreement to reestablish diplomatic relations that had capped his talks with President Asad. A 6 June NCNA article pegged to.the White Hause .announcement of the President's Middle East trip had taken pains to portray the journey as the latest step in the successful U.S. advance in the area, at Soviet expense, since the Octo.ber.1973war.. It had noted Washington's achievements in bringing about the troop disengagement agreements, cited Secretary Kissinger's 4 June testimony before the Senate Foreign Relations Committee that the United States was de- termined to strengthen the recent tendency of Arab states to end their one-sided reliance on Moscow, and reported the, Secretary's defense of U.S. aid appropriations for Arab nations. Linking President Nixon's Middle East tour with his upcoming trip to Moscow, NCNA had also cited Western press observations that the former trip served to demonstrate a,strong U.S. position, while underlining the weakening of the Soviet stances on the eve of the Moscow summit. OTHER ASIAN COMMUNIST VIETNAM North and South Vietnamese communist media reported only the barest details of the President's itinerary and played up evidence of alleged U.S. duplicity, in effect warn- ing against Arab cooperation with the United States. 'The first Hanoi reference to the President's tour came in a 3 June article in the North Vietnamese party paper NHAN DAN, which contended that the United States is pursuing its own unchanged interests in the Middle East. The article recalled Secretary Kissinger's recent diplomatic efforts in the area--saying that the Secretary has presented President Nixon with "a passport to return to the Middle East"--and went on to sarcastically question the portrayal of Kissinger as the Arabs' "friend,, as a reliable negotiator. who lives up to his promises" and to maintain that Washington is trying to protect Israel and divide the Arab states. The article. was critical of Egypt's improvement of relations with the United States, but noted with approval evidence of continuing Syrian circumspection. No Objection to Declassification in Full 2011/12/05: LOC-HAK-182-3-5-1 No Objection to Declassification in Full 2011/12/05: LOC-HAK-182-3-5-1 FOR OFFICIAL USE 0 FBIS REACTION REPOR 21 JUNE 1974 During and after the to reception given the Pre a statement by Yasir 'A would not lay down thei Hanoi media and Liberat retaliatory air strikes and quoted a Beirut paps light for the attacks. r Vietnamese coimnu ident in Arab coup afat that the Pale arms until they a on Radio ptedictab in Lebanon after t r charging that Ni: 1st media-ignored the ries but publicized tinian "revolutionaries". hieve their objectives. y reported Israel's e President's departure on had given the green NORTH KOREA, MONGOLIA Mongolian People's Repu report or comment upon The monitored. P: transmissions f lic media have not resident Nixon's M ~ongyang radio and KCNA on North Korea, and been heard to either ddle East visits. CUBA Havana's reaction was p themes. that'Wa?tergate a prime factors motivating was included in both th progress and in several domestic radio and telev Havana on 11 June carrie President's arrival in S "to offset his political scandal," and to the U.S the long years of "erode of backing Zionism. Ano ostentatious display of press comment that the p economic-political influ Among the commentaries, a talk by Jose Maria Gon 20 June. Admitting that personally and for U.S. up the results of the tr of developing economic-p and Jordan; the resumpti strengthening of all kin "the wealth of wisdom Ni: edictably negative d U.S.:imperialiat the President's to running news accou more extensive comm ~sion programs. a Vienna-dateline lzburg which refer downfall brought a interest in rep.ai: contacts" brought her broadcast the ecurity" at Salzbu rpose of the trip nce" among the Ara nd keyed,to the mb.itions were the r. Derogatory comment is of the President's ntaries carried in report on the ed to his attempt out by the Watergate ing the effects of about by the policy ame day stressed "the g -and quoted Lebanese as "to spread imperialist he most pointed an alez Jerez over Had the tour represent oals in the Middle p in the following litical relations n of diplomatic re s of bonds with Isr on acquired." authoritative was ana television on d a gain for Nixon East, Gonzalez summed terms: The prospect ith .Egypt, Saudi Arabia.. tions with Syria; the el"; and, as a bonus, No Objection to Declassification in Full 2011/12/05: LOC-HAK-182-3-5-1 No Objection to Declassification in Full 2011/12/05: LOC-HAK-182-3-5-1 FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY FBIS REACTION REPORT 21 JUNE 1974 At the same time, Gonzales stressed the.unchanging nature of U.S. interests in the area. Nixon's commitments-to the Arab countries--financial aid, investments, and technological aid that included a nuclear reactor for peaceful purposes-were, Gonzalez stressed, much more ambiguous than what he pledged to Israel." Israel, Gonzalez added, was pleased with. Nixon's visit, "not because of his tranquillizing words but because of the agreements that were.signed." Gonzalez detailed the general terms of the U.S.-Israeli joint communique. He noted that the condemnation of terrorism "totally suits the theses of Israel," as it sounded a warning to its neighbors, and he asserted that Nixon had spoken of peace "but always in general terms." Gonzalez said Nixon had "evaded" the Palestinian problem in talks with the Arabs. Kissinger "spoke out more clearly" on the issue, Gonzalez added. He pointed out that the Secretary of State's view that the Palestinians should be present at the Geneva talks fitted in with ".Israel's thinking."In conclusion, Gonzalez said the reactionaryp.ress..tries to make Nixon out as "the arbiter of the Mideast situation and a friend of the Arab people" in an effort to obscure his "direct complicity with Israel's aggression." "Such propaganda,". Gonzales said, "clashes with reality" and aims at isolating the Arabs from their real friends, the Soviet Union and the socialist. countries. The clear- cut goal of this propaganda is to divide the Arabs and to consolidate imperialist positions in the Middle East, "to the detriment of the- Arab people's just cause." The regional Matanzas domestic service.comnentator,. David Segura Nunez, in a 14 June talk entitled "Allah Bless Nixon."ridiculed the reception accorded Nixon on his arrival in Cairo. Suggesting that the reception that greeted "the Yankee chief of state" was a staged affair, Segura Nunez said: "It is, inconceivable that the Egyptians, the same people who have frequently been forced to endure the results of Zionist aggression contrived by U.S. aggressive circles, have a sincere desire to cheer such a notorious and accomplished genocidal felon. . . ." Without mentioning President Sadat, Segura Nunez said it was difficult to speculate "on a leader's conduct in abandoning the scenario of the people's struggle." He added: "We would like to believe no other leaders under any conditions would have allowed this masquerade of the masses. . . ."" Segura Nunez concluded that "it is not for nothing that Israel is spoken of as the 51st state. . . .11 No Objection to Declassification in Full 2011/12/05: LOC-HAK-182-3-5-1 No Objection to Declassification in Full 2011/12/05: LOC-HAK-182-3-5-1 FOR OFFICIAL USE 01 Y FBIS REACTION REPOR 21 JUNE 1974 Guido Garcia Inclan, i his commentary ."L Freddy" on 18 June, speculated that Nixon's promises of.loans to the Arabs would not be reg rded favorably in heU.S. Senate. Kissinger's role was noted, and sometimes-disparaged, in several news reports and comme taries. Havana television and radio on 11 June reported Kissi ger's press conference, pointing out that his threat to resign w s made on "the eve-of, Nixon's Mideast visits" and "outside s own country.." DavidSegura Nunez in another regional Matan as domestic servic commentary entitled "Mandrake the Magician in a Spot,"' on 12 une, scoffed at Kissinger supposed "unbelievable feats" with regard to Vietnam and the Golan Heights. FOR OFFICIAL USE 0 No Objection to Declassification in Full 2011/12/05: LOC-HAK-182-3-5-1 No Objection to Declassification in Full 2011/12/05: LOC-HAK-182-3-5-1 No Objection to Declassification in Full 2011/12/05: LOC-HAK-182-3-5-1