INFORMATION BRIEFING FOR DIRECTOR, NSA (U)

Document Type: 
Collection: 
Document Number (FOIA) /ESDN (CREST): 
CIA-RDP96-00788R001700230005-5
Release Decision: 
RIPPUB
Original Classification: 
S
Document Page Count: 
17
Document Creation Date: 
November 4, 2016
Document Release Date: 
March 28, 2000
Sequence Number: 
5
Case Number: 
Publication Date: 
August 19, 1982
Content Type: 
MFR
File: 
AttachmentSize
PDF icon CIA-RDP96-00788R001700230005-5.pdf918.35 KB
Body: 
Approved For Release 200 EE, - DP96-00788R001700230005-5 SG1I IAGPC-G 19 August 1982 MEMORANDUM FOR THE RECORD SUBJECT: Information Briefing for Director, NSA (U) 1. (FOUO) On 5 August 1982 from 1500-1600 hours, an information briefing for LT Gen Lincoln Faurer and selected m his staff was con- ducted at the Di _ ' Conference Room HQ NSA. The briefing was requested byl Research and Engineering. The briefing was approved by DC , Attendees were: NSA LT GEN LINCOLN D. FAURER SG1 A SG1I SG1I MR. ROBERT E. RICH DIA DR. JACK VORONA OACSI BG ROY M. STROM MAJ GERALD FOX INSCOM COL BILLY F. MILLER 2. (U) Briefing is attached as Inclosure 1. Deputy Director Assistant D`.rector for Scientific & Technical Intelligence Deputy ACSI GRILL FLAME Project Officer CLASSIFIED BYOt,a4- i If -W / '303 c~7'p REVIEW ON ", a 0.0 a CREW QLL FLAME Approved For Release 2003/09/16 : IA-RDP96-00788R0010005-5 NOT RELEASABLE TO 'OREIGN NATIONALS Approved For Release 2003/ P96-00788RO01700230005-5 iE I Wil MFR SUBJECT: Information Briefing for Director, NSA (U) 3. (U) Information presented in the briefing seemed to be accepted by the attendees. Examples in the project book stimulated some general questions all of which were answered. 4. (S/NOFORN) At the conclusion of the briefing LT Gen Faurer stated that his scientific panel had reviewed parapsychology in the past. Another review would be undertaken with three options: cease all interest, pursue, the subject within the agency or join the DoD community. LT Gen Faurer indicated he would inform BG Strom when a final decision had been made. 1 Incl ROBERT J. JACHIM as LTC, MI GRILL FLAME Project Manager ~ECREi Approved For Release 2003/09/16 : CIA-RDP96-00788R001700230005-5 (SLIDE 0 ON-) 3/09/16 : 788R001700230005-5 I AM LTC JACHIM, PROJECT MANAGER FOR THE INSCOM PORTION OF DOD PROJECT GRILL FLAME, THE PURPOSE OF THIS BRIEFING IS TO PROVIDE YOU WITH BACKGROUND INFORMATION CONCERNING INSCOM'S INVOLVEMENT (SLIDE 0 OFF) _ IN PROJECT GRILL FLAME, THIS BRIEFING IS DIVIDED INTO (SLIDE 1 ON) THREE MAJOR PORTIONS, FIRST, THE HISTORY OF INSCOM'S INVOLVEMENT AND THE ROLES OF DIA AND INSCOM IN THE PROJECT, NEXT, A DISCUSSION OF REMOTE VIEWING AND EXAMPLES OF COMPLETED PROJECTS F01'% I CH WE HAVE RECEIVED THE REQUESTOR'S EVALUATION AND, FINALLY, A REVIEW OF TWO PROJECTS WHICH HAVE BEEN COMPLETED BUT NOT EVALUATED, (SLIDE 1 OFF) (SLIDE 2 ON) FIRST THE HISTORY OF INSCOM'S INVOLVEMENT, IN THE FALL OF 1978, ACSI TASKED INSCOM TO DETERMINE IF (SLIDE 2 OFF) PARAPSYCHOLOGY COULD BE USED TO COLLECT INTELLIGENCE FOR OUR PURPOSES PARAPSYCHOLOGY IS DEFINED IN TWO MAJOR CATEGORIES: (SLIDE 2A ON) FIRST, PHYSICAL ACTIONS PERFORMED BY MENTAL POWERS THAT CANNOT BE EXPLAINED BY KNOWN PHYSICAL MEANS, THIS IS KNOWN AS TELEKINESIS OR PSYCHOKINESIS, AND SECOND, PERCEPTIONS WHICH CANNOT BE EXPLAINED THROUGH KNOWN SENSORY MEANS, THIS IS KNOWN AS ESP, TELEPATHY AND REMOTE VIEWING, (SLIDE 2A OFF) SPECIFICALLY, INSCOM'S TASKING WAS TO DETERMINE IF (SLIDE 2B ON) REMOTE VIEWING COULD BE USED AS A COLLECTION METHODS REMOTE VIEWING IS DEFINED, AS THE ABILITY OF AN INDIVIDUAL, TO ACCESS INFORMATION PREVIOUSLY UNKNOWN, WITHOUT REGARD TO TIME, LOCATION, OR ANY ATTEMPT TO Approved For ?}WseT 3T IK.TCIRAPi t TPR J 700230005-5 U C{zr SAC) GRILL FLAME Approved For Release 2003/09/16 : TO MEET ACSI'S TASKING INSCOM ESTABLISHED A PROJECT TEAM UNDER THE ASSISTANT DEPUTY CHIEF OF STAFF FOR HUMAN INTELLIGENCE, THE CRITERIA DEVELOPED (SLIDE 2B OFF) - TO DETERMINE IF REMOTE VIEWING WOULD BE A VIABLE METHOD WAS AS FOLLOWS: (SLIDE 3 ON) FIRST, COULD REMOTE VIEWING BE LEARNED? NEXT, COULD REMOTE VIEWING BE APPLIED AS A COLLECTION METHOD? AND, FINALLY, COULD REMOTE VIEWING RESPOND TO COLLECTION REQUIREMENTS IN A TIMELY MANNER? (SLIDE 3 OFF) (SLIDE 3A ON) FIRST, COULD REMOTE VIEWING BE LEARNED: SRI INTERNATIONAL, AN ACKNOWLEDGED LEADER INTHE FIELD OF PARANORMAL RESEARCH, RELIED UPON ESTABLISHED PSYCHICS, WHO USED THEIR INDIVIDUAL ABILITIES TO REMOTE VIEW. INSCOM, USING THE PERSONALITY TRAITS AND CHARACTERISTICS COMPILED BY SRI DURING THEIR WORK WITH THESE PSYCHICS, SCREENED APPROXIMATELY 250 INTELLIGENCE PERSONNEL WITHIN THE BALTIMORE/WASHINGTON AREA, LOOKING FOR PEOPLE WITH SIMILAR CHARACTERISTICS. BASED ON SRI OBSERVATIONS, SUCCESSFUL REMOTE VIEWERS TEND TO BE CONFIDENT, OUTGOING, ADVENTUROUS, BROADLY SUCCESSFUL INDIVIDUALS WITH SOME ARTISTIC BENT, AFTER A SERIES OF SCREENINGS AND INTERVIEWS, NINE PEOPLE WERE SELECTED, THEY WERE A MIXTURE OF MILITARY AND CIVILIAN, OFFICERS AND ENLISTED, MEN AND WOMEN. AFTER ADDITIONAL INTERVIEWS WITH THE SRI 411'"rApproved For Release 2003/09/16 60 088R001700230005-5 NOT RET.,` 1M, A73T1 TO 1ORFTGN NA'PIfl TALS Approved For Release 2003/09/16 : CIA-RDP96-00788R001700230005-5 1% fill" n P, 5 (SLIDE 3A OFF) (SLIDE 5 ON) (SLIDE 5 OFF) SCIENTISTS SIX WERE SELECTED TO GO TO CALIFORNIA FOR TWO WEEKS OF ACTUAL TRAINING, UPON THEIR RETURN TO FORT MEADE THEY CONTINUED IN AN IN-HOUSE TRAINING PROGRAM MODELED AFTER THE SRI TRAINING PHASE, A TIMELY MANNER? AFTER THE PERSONNEL WERE LOCATED AND TRAINING HAD BEGUN, THE NEXT QUESTIONS TO BE ANSWERED APPLIED TO THE SECOND AND THIRD CRITERIA CONCERNING OPERATIONS. THAT IS, COULD REMOTE VIEWING BE APPLIED AS A COLLECTION METHOD? IF SO, WOULD THE INFORMATION BE OF REASONABLE ACCURACY AND ACCEPTED AND USED BY THE INTELLIGENCE ANALYST WHO RECEIVE THE PRODUCT, FINALLY, COULD REMOTE VIEWING RESP TO COLLECTION REQUIREMENTS IN WORK TO ANSWER THESE QUESTIONS WAS OVERCOME BY EVENTS. (SLIDE 5A ON) IN SEPTEMBER 1979, ACSI TASKED INSCOM TO LOCATE A MISSING NAVY AIRCRAFT F. THE ONLY INFORMATION PROVIDED WAS A PICTURE OF THE TYPE AIRCRAFT MISSING AND THE NAMES OF THE CREW, WHERE THE AIRCRAFT WAS OPERATING WAS NOT DISCLOSED, ON 4 SEPTEMBER 1979, THE FIRST OPERATIONAL REMOTE VIEWING SESSION TOOK PLACE, IN THIS INITIAL SESSION, THE REMOTE VIEWER PLACED THE AIRCRAFT TO WITHIN 15 MILES OF WHERE IT WAS ACTUALLY LOCATED, BASED ON THESE RESULTS, INSCOM WAS TASKED TO WORK AGAINST ADDITIONAL OPERATIONAL TARGETS. THESE TASKINGS FORCED A PREMATURE HALT TO THE INITIAL TRAINING PHASE," IN DECEMBER 1979, THE PROJECT WAS (SLIDE 5A OFF) COMMITTED TO OPERATIONS Approved For Release 2003/09/16 : CIA Approved For Release 2003/09/16 : CIA-RDP96-00788R001700230005-5 THE BACKGROUND OF INSCOM AND THE GRILL FLAME PROJECT WOULD BE INCOMPLETE WITHOUT EXAMINING THE DIFFERENT ROLE OF DIA AND INSCOMS SINCE THERE APPEARS TO HAVE BEEN SOME BLURRING OF THESE DISTINCTIONS IN THE PAST, (SLIDE 6 ON) DIA IS CONCERNED WITH: ASSESSING THE THREAT, PRINCIPALLY FROM THE SOVIET UNION AND CHINA. DETERMINING COUNTERMEASURES TO ANY U,S, VULNERABILITI AND, DETERMINING THE POTENTIAL OF REMOTE VIEWING USING ESTABLISHED PSYCHICS. DIA PERFORMS THIS FUNCTION PRIMARILY THROUGH CONTRACTS AT SRI, INSCOM I S APPLYING REMOTE VIEWING TQ_..SS I ST I N ITS EVALUATION AS A COLLECTION METHOD,'ND TO DETERMINE IF REMOTE VIEWING CAN BE LEARNED BY PROFESSIONAL INTELLIGENCE PERSONNEL WHO ARE NOT ESTABLISHED PSYCHICS, OUR REMOTE VIEWING COLLECTION IS DONE WITH ASSIGNED PERSONNEL, WE CONTRACT ONLY FOR SPECIFIC ITEMS WHICH ENHANCE OUR COLLECTION, FOR EXAMPLE: WHICH TARGETING METHODS HAVE THE HIGHEST PROBABILITY OF SUCCESS, CAN THE ACCURACY OF A REMOTE VIEWER BE DETERMINED FROM AN ANALYSIS OF HIS STATEMENTS? CAN THE SRI NEW TRAINING TECHNIQUE INCREASE THE QUALITY AND RELIABILITY OF COLLECTION, (SLIDE 6 OFF) THIS COMPLETES THE BACKGROUND PORTION OF THE BRIEFING. Approved For Release 2003/09/16: CJ -' 9~ 0~88RO01700230005-5 Approved For Release 2003/09/16 : CIA-RDP96-00788R001700230005-5 THE NEXT PORTION COVERS THE ANATOMY OF A COLLECTION PROJECT AND PRESENTS EXAMPLES OF RESULTS FROM COMPLETED PROJECTS, (SLID 6A ON) TYPICALLY, A PROJECT BEGINS W I TH A REQUEST FOR INFORMATION ON A TARGET, WHICH IS NOT SUSCEPTIBLE TO NORMAL COLLECTION SYSTEMS, OR FOR CUING DATA TO TARGET OTHER INTELLIGENCE SYSTEMS, BASED UPON PERSONNEL AVAILABLE, PRIORITY OF THE TARGET, AND TIE POTENTIAL FOR PROVIDING REQUESTED INFORMATION, THE INSCOM PROJECT MANAGER MAKES A DECISION WHETHER TO ACCEPT OR DECLINE THE PROJECT. (SLIDE 6A OFF) SOURCE HAD BEEN ABLE TO PROVIDE THE NEEDD I NFORMATI ON r ONCE THE PROJECT IS ACCEPTED, THE FIRST TAS1( IS THE CONSTRUCTION OF A REMOTE VIEWING COLLECTION PLANS MANY TIMES, EVEN THOUGH THE LIKELIHOOD OF OBTAINING THE INFORMATION IS NOT HIGH, THE PROJECT IS ACCEPTED SINCE NO OTHER INTELLIGENCE THIS COLLECTION PLAN LISTS THE ESSENTIAL ELEMENTS OF INFORMATION (EEI) AND THE INTELLIGENCE INDICATORS WHICH WILL ADDRESS THESE EEI , ALSO LISTED ARE THE TARGET TIME WINDOWS FOR WHICH THESE INDICATORS WILL BE RELEVANT, THE COLLECTION PLAN ALSO SPECIFIES WHICH REMOTE VIEWERS WILL BE USED, THERE MAY BE MORE THAN ONE SESSION FOR A PARTICULAR PROJECT, SEVERAL SESSIONS MAY HAVE TO BE DONE TO ADDRESS ALL THE INDICATORS NEEDED TO ANSWER THE EEI, 14d A REMOTE VIEWING SESSION IS A TEAM EFFORT (SLIDE 8 ON) THERE ARE TWO MEMBERS OF THIS TEAK, Approved For Release 2003/09/16 : 1 k 0788R001700230005-5 -etlyr p-M,F';Aq RT;F jro T'i7R IG I TaATI01\T,2' Approved For Release 2003/09/16 : CIA-RDP96-00788R001700230005-5 SECRET ONE IS THE INTERVIEWER, THE OTHER IS THE REMOTE VIEWER, THE INTERVIEWER CONTROLS THE SESSION, HIS JOB I S TO KEEP THE REMOTE VIEWER ON TRACK, TO DIRECT THE FOCUS OF THE REMOTE VIEWER AND TO QU~UST ON HIM ABOUT THE TARGET, THE REMOTE VIEWER. IS RESPONSIBLE ONLY FOR REPORTING, THE GOAL OF THE SESSION IS TO COLLECT INTELLIGENCE. TO DO THIS, GREAT CARE IS TAKEN TO TRY AND FORCE THE REMOTE VIEWER TO PRO ONLY INFORMATION OF INTELLIGENCE VALUE, THIS IS DONE BY DENYING HIM OTHER SOURCES OF INFORMATION ABOUT THE TARGET. WE ALWAYS KEEP THE RATE VIEWER 1 1 MOST TIMES THE INTERVIEWER IS ALSO KEPT "BLIND", SO HE WILL NOT INADVE-ENTLY LEAD THE REMOTE VIEWER. (SLIDE 8 OFF) AT THE START OF THE SESSION, THE I NTERV I EWER PROVIDES THE REMOTE VIEWER WITH THE TARGETT CUING_D TATHE REMOTE VIEWER HAS NOT SEEN THIS INFORMATION BEFORE. HE RECEIVES IT ONLY AT THE START OF THE (SLIDE 9 ON) REMOTE VIEWING SESS I ON J TTARGET CUING DATA MAY FALL INTO SEVERAL CATEGORIES, IT MAY BE GEOGRAPHIC OR UTM COORDINATES, AN OVERHEAD PHOTOGRAPH OF THE AREA, OR A PHOTOGRAPH OF AN INDIVIDUAL OR OBJECT, PERHAPS, THERE IS SCE REASON NOT TO GIVE TAROT INFORMATION TO A REMOTE VIEWER! Approved For Release 2003/09/16 C1A-RDP96-d0788R001700230005-5 1iS~ ~5 :' e) 1'G ~ U d iu TIOr"' 1,:; Approved For Release 2003/09/16 : Cl - DP96-00788R001700230005-5 THE WAY TO OVERCOME THIS IS SIMPLY TO PLACE THE TARGET INFORMATION IN A SEALED ENVELOPE, THE REMOTE VIEWER IS GIVEN THIS SEALED ENVELOPE AND HE IS TOLD THAT THE TARGET FOR TODAY IS IN THE ENVELOPE. HE IS THEN SIMPLY ASKED TO DESCRIBE THE TARGET. ONCE THE REMOTE VIEWER HAS THIS CUING DATA, THE TAPE RECORDER IS TURNED ON AND THE SESSION BEGINS $ (SLIDE 9 OFF) (SLIDE 9B ON) AFTER THE SESSION, WHICH LASTS ABOUT 30 MINUTES, THE REMOTE VIEWER IS ASKED TO DRAW THE PERCEPTIONS HE HAD DURING SESSION. THIS IS IMPORTANT BECAUSE THE DRAWINGS MAY BE MORE ACCURATE OR SHOW A DIFFERENT PERSPECTIVE THAN THE VERBAL DESCRIPTIONS OF THE TARGET, AFTER THE DRAWINGS ARE DONE AND THE REMOTE VIEWER TALKS ABOUT THEM, THE REMOTE VIEWING SESSION IS COMPLETED, THE TAPE IS THEN TRANSCRIBED AND A TRANSCRIPT FURNISHED TO THE PROJECT REQUESTOR, AFTER THE PROJECT IS COMPLETED THE REQUESTOR PROVIDES AN EVALUATION, AS IN ANY OTHER (SLIDE 9B OFF) TASK, FEEDBACK IS ESSENTIAL, THE FOLLOWING GRAPHICS ARE SUM1'RIES OF OUR OPERATION FROM SEPTEMBER 1979 THROUGH JULY 1982. (SLIDE 10 ON) NOTE THE CONPAR I SON OF SESSIONS TO PROJECTS, THE SPECIFIC NUMBER OF COLLECTION SESSIONS, NECESSARY TO MEET A PROJECT'S REQUIREMENTS, IS BASED UPON THE REQUESTOR'S TASK I NG , AS AN EXI1'LE, THE SUPPORT PROVIDED DURING THE IRANIAN HOSTAGE CRISIS COVERED AN EXTENDED PERIOD OF TIME AND RESULTED IN AN EXCESS OF 200 SESSIONS, OF THE 65 PROJECTS COMPLETED AND FULLY EVALUATED1OVER 50 PERCENT HAVE PROVIDED INFORMATION OF VALUE TO THE REQUESTOR (SLIDE 10 OFF) Approved For Release 2003/09/16 : CIA- F8 F19 =d&788 001700230005-5 AM'PrTrASA-pTT:O 'PORRIGN NA' TONALA Approved For Release 2003/09/16 : CIA-RDP96-00788R001700230005-5 (SLIDE 11 ON) THE RESULTS OF EVALUATED PROJECTS ARE DEPICTED ON THIS SLIDE, IT SHOULD BE NOTED THAT WHILE 1 Ml IS LISTED AS THE OFFICIAL REQUESTOR ON EIGHT PROJECTS, TWO PROJECTS WERE CONDUCTED IN SUPPORT OF ARMY ACS I /I NSCOI1 AND ANOTHER WAS THE MISSING MACOMS, TWO WERE LOMB NAVY AGE, (SLIDE 11 OFF) I WOULD NOW LIKE TO COVER OUR PROJECT BOOK. THE PROJECT BOOK ACCOMPANYING THIS BRIEFING PRESENTS EXAMPLES OF INTELLIGENCE COLLECTED THROUGH REMOTE VIEWING, PRIOR TO ITS REVIEW I WISH TO EMPHASIZE THE FOLLOWING POINTS : REMOTE VIEWING IS NOT A MAGIC LAMP AND IS NOT A SUBSTITUTE FOR CURRENT INTELLIGENCE WORK, R91OTE VIEWING IS A HIGHLY CONTROLLED AND FORMALLY ESTABLISHED, UNIQUE INTELLIGENCE COLLECTION CAPABILITY GPI I CH HAS THE FOLLOWING CHARACTERISTICS: (SLIDE 12 ON) IT IS PASSIVE TO THE EXTENT OUR KNOWLEDGE, COLLECTION BY REMOTE VIEWING IS TOTALLY PASSIVE ONLY ONE CLAIM OF DETECTION OF REMOTE VIEWING IS KNOWN. CHINESE SCIENTISTS CLAIM TO HAVE DETECTED REMOTE VIEWING DURING THEIR EXPERIMENTS WITH CHILDREN, DATA ON THESE EXPERIMENTS SG1 B IS INSUFFICIENT TO VALIDATE THIS CLAIM, WORK TO REPLICATE THESE EXPERIMENTS IS CONTINUING AT SRI$ Approved For Release 2003/09/16 : -I47, OO788R001700230005-5 } r #A;a' 1 Approved For Release 2003/09/16 : CIA-RDP96-00788R001700230005-5 IT IS INEXPENSIVE THE PRINCIPAL COST OF REMOTE VIEWING COLLECTION IS THE PEOPLE INVOLVED. THERE IS NO EXPENSIVE HARDWARE, AND LASTLY, THERE IS NO KNOWN DEFENSE TIME, TARGETIF7,OR DEGREE OF DIFFICULTY ALL HAVE NO APPARENT EFFECT ON COLLECTION BY REMOTE VIEWING, EVEN CONCEPTUALIZED PLANS HAVE BEEN COLLECTED AGAINST PRIOR TO THEIR ACTUAL I NPLEMENTATI ON , (SLIDE 12 OFF) REMOTE VIEWING HAS BEEN SUCCESSFULLY USED AGAINST OF TASKING. FIVE ARE DESCRIBED IN THE PROJECT BOO CODED FOR EASY REFERENCE, THEY ARE : (SLIDE 13 ON) EN CATEGORIES < AND ARE COLOR 1. PENETRATION OF INACCESSIBLE TARGETS (BLAC( TAB) 2. SCIENCE AND TECHNOLOGY INFORMATION (RED TAB) 3. CUING OF OTHER INTELLIGENCE COLLECTION SYSTEMS (YELLOW TAB) 4, IMMINENT HOSTILITIES (BLUE TAB) 5, DETERMINATION OF NUCLEAR FROM NON-NUCLEAR TARGETS (GREEN TAB) Approved For Release 2003/09/16 : CIA-RDP96-00788R001700230005-5 OIT RE PLASI TIE TO T"07FIC-14 NLTTOr7ALS Approved For Release 2003/09/16 : CIA-RDP96-00788R001700230005-5 AT THIS TIME TRIO CATEGORIES: PENETRATION OF INACCESSIBLE TARGETS, AND THE CUING OF OTHER INTELLIGENCE COLLECTION SYSTEM I DOMINANT (SLIDE 13 OFF) THERE ARE TWO ADDITIONAL CATEGORIES WHICH WE BELIEVE TO BE EQUALLY IMPORTANT, BUT FOR WHICH THE DATA BASE IS INSUFFICIENT, THEY ARE HUMAN SOURCE ASSESSMENTS AND ACCURATE PERSONALITY PROFILES, (SLIDE J3A ON) EACH EXAMPLE IN THE BOOK PRESENTS THE ACTUAL TARGET, THE REASON FOR TARGETING, AND THE TARGETING DATA, EXAf'ES OF VERBATIM VIEWER DESCRIPTIONS ARE PROVIDED WITH THE ANALYSTS COMMENTS TO THE RIGHT, ADDITIONAL PROJECTS WHICH ARE NOT DETAILED IN THE BOOK ARE LISTED IN THE APPENDIX, (SLIDE 13A OFF) AT THIS POINT I WOULD LIKE TO WALK YOU THROUGH TWO OF THE EXAMPLES IN THE BOOK, k' 5 (SLIDE 13B ON) SG1A THE FIRST, UNDER TAB ONE IS SG1 A THE FIRST PAGE CONTAINS THE TARE H, THE TASKING AND TARGET SG1A SG1A CUING DATA, Approved For Release 2003/09/16 : Approved For Release 2003/09/16 : CIA-RDP96-00788R001700230005-5 SG1A SG1A SG1A THE NEXT TWO PAGES CONTAIN REMOTE VIEWER'S PERCEPTIONS OF THE TARGET AND THE ANALYSTS COMMENT, THE NEXT THREE PAGES ARE DRAWINGS DONE BY THE REMOTE VIEWER AND THE FINAL PAGE IS SG1 A (SLIDE 13B OFF) (SLIDE BC ON) SG1A (SLIDE 13C OFF) (SLIDE 13D ON) THE NEXT EXAM='LE IS UNDER TAB TWO.. SG1 A AGAIN, THE FIRST PAGE LISTS THE TARGE , THE TSS1JING AND THE TARGET CUING DATA. NOTE: IN THIS CASE, TO PRECLUDE EITHER THE INTERVIEWER OR THE REMOTE VIEWER FROPI KNOWING ABOUT' THE TARGET PRIOR TO OR DURING THE LIFE OF THE PROJECT, A PHOTOGRAPH OF WAS PLACED INSIDE A DOUBLE WRAPPED AND SEALED ENVELOPE BY TEE TASKING ANALYST, Approved For Release 2003/09/1 SG1 A Approved For Release 2003/09/16 f clA-RDP96-00788 R001700230005-5 THE SECOND PAGE CONTAINS THE REMOTE VIEWER'S PERCEPTIONS AND THE ANALYST'S COMMENTS, THE FINAL FOUR PAGES ARE DRAWINGS DONE BY THE REMOTE VIEWER WITH ANALYSTS COMMENTS ADDED IN RED, ON THIS PROJECT THE REMOTE VIEWER (SLIDE 13D OFF) (SLIDE 13E ON) AS YOU REVIEW THIS BO(](, YOU MAY ASK ABOUT PROJECTS WHICH WERE UNSUCCESSFUL. OUR ONLY DETERMINANT OF SUCCESS OR FAILURE IS WHETHER OR NOT THE INFORMATION PROVIDED IS OF INTELLIGENCE VALUE N SG1 A SG1 A IT IS POSSIBLE THAT THE INFORMATION COLLECTED IS ACCURATE AND OF HIGH QUALITY, BUT, IF IT IS OF "NO INTELL-IGEN V .l , IT WOULD BE CONSIDERED A FAILURE, HOWEVER, BECAUSE OF THE UNIQUE WAY THE INFORMATION IS PRESENTED, THE ANALYSTS ARE REQUIRED TO REVIEW THE DATA IN A NON-TRADITIONAL MANNER, Approved For Release 2003/61'K-pP96-00788 R001700230005-5 Approved For Release 2003/09 i 96-00788R001700230005-5 FOR EXAJPLE, IN SIX PROJECTS INFORMATION FORWARDED WAS INITIALLY CONSIDERED INACCURATE, HOWEVER, ON LATER REVD IT WAS DETERMINED TO BE CORRECT, IN ONE CASE, THE'TASKER EVEN AI11I TTED ERROR IN HIS CONTROL DATA, (SLIDE 13E OFF) Approved For Release 2003/09/16 : CIA-RDP96-00788R001700230005-5 ?T R,IMRL; 'i3M l Ci Lu:.Ci TJATIOI A7,S SG1A Approved For Release 2003/09/16 : CIA-RDP96-00788R001700230005-5 Next 3 Page(s) In Document Exempt Approved For Release 2003/09/16 : CIA-RDP96-00788R001700230005-5 Approved For Release 2003/09/16 : CIA-RDP96-00788R001700230005-5 THIS BRIEFING HAS COVERED THE HISTORY OF INSCOM AND THE GRILL FLAME PROGRAM, HOW WE BEGAN IN THE PROGRAM, AND SOME OF THE ACTIONS WE HAVE BEGUN TO IMPROVE OUR PRODUCT, OUR OBJECTIVES FOR THE FUTURE CONCERN: , SELECTION OF PEOPLE, AND INCREASE THE RELIABILITY OF REMOTE VIEWING, IN SUMMARY: VG 17 ON THE COLLECTION OF INTELLIGENCE THROUGH REMOTE VIEWING HAS DEMONSTRATED ITS VALUE, REMOTE VIEWING IS A SUCCESSFUL COLLECTION METHOD (NOT AN EXPERIMENT), THE PROFESSIONAL INTELLIGENCE ANALYSTS WHO ASSIGN US PROJECTS, EVALUATE US ONLY BY THE INTELLIGENCE WE PRODUCE, REMOTE VIEWING SHOULD NEVER STAND ALONE, BUT SHOULD BE USED IN CONJUNCTION WITH INFORMATION FROM OTHER INTELLIGENCE SOURCES, VG 17 OFF VG 18 ON REMOTE VIEWING IS PASSIVE, INEXPENSIVE, THERE IS NO DEFENSE AND THERE IS NO RISK OF COLLECTION COMPROMISE, VG 18 OFF THIS CONCLUDES THE BRIEFING, ARE THERE ANY QUESTIONS? Approved For Release 2003/09/ F6-00788 R001700230005-5