REACTION TO WASHINGTON POST STORY ON LEBANESE COUNTERTERRORISM ACTION

Document Type: 
Collection: 
Document Number (FOIA) /ESDN (CREST): 
CIA-RDP90-00965R000807590013-2
Release Decision: 
RIPPUB
Original Classification: 
K
Document Page Count: 
15
Document Creation Date: 
December 22, 2016
Document Release Date: 
February 27, 2012
Sequence Number: 
13
Case Number: 
Publication Date: 
May 13, 1985
Content Type: 
MEMO
File: 
AttachmentSize
PDF icon CIA-RDP90-00965R000807590013-2.pdf1.02 MB
Body: 
Declassified in Part - Sanitized Copy Approved for Release 2012/02/28: CIA-RDP90-00965R000807590013-2 13 May 1985 Revised Version REACTION TO WASHINGTON POST STORY ON LEBANESE COUNTERTERRORIST ACTION The Central Intelligence Agency never conducted any training of Lebanese security forces related to the events described in THE WASHINGTON POST's article on 12 May 1985. it also had no foreknowledge of the bombing incident which took place on 8 March 1985 which was mentioned in the article. The Central Intelligence Agency scrupulously observes the requirements to keep all the Congressional oversight committees appropriately informed. Declassified in Part - Sanitized Copy Approved for Release 2012/02/28: CIA-RDP90-00965R000807590013-2 Declassified in Part - Sanitized Copy Approved for Release 2012/02/28: CIA-RDP90-00965R000807590013-2 JF" a O PAIL 16 May :9E5 Shultz Labels Kurt By Post `Blind AItey' J Secretary of State George P. Shuttz said yesterday t at"a report it he asmngton Post about a U S. counterterrorist pro ram that was terminated a ter an unaut o- rized oar-bomb blast in Lebanon is "a blind alley. "It's absolutely a blind alley ... a story that's created a big-hubbub about something that's not cor- rect," Shultz said. AS PUBLISHED Questioned further, he said, "I don't want to get into it because I just haven't been able to inform my- self well enough." Until now he had declined all comment on the story. nen some- on mentroned the entra, lnte h- aence Aeencys denial as b--in? pro forma Snultz responoed,, i the CIA denies something, it's denied. Declassified in Part - Sanitized Copy Approved for Release 2012/02/28: CIA-RDP90-00965R000807590013-2 Declassified in Part - Sanitized Copy Approved for Release 2012/02/28: CIA-RDP90-00965R000807590013-2 ARTICLE APPEARED M PAGE i T) CO RI) MEET Tne CIA appears to be more a victim of sensatronai -ournalism ratner than an indirect accessory to a mass muruer. Declassified in Part - Sanitized Copy Approved for Release 2012/02/28: CIA-RDP90-00965R000807590013-2 Declassified in Part - Sanitized Copy Approved for Release 2012/02/28: CIA-RDP90-00965R000807590013-2 L A ficr a headiinc stur\ anC i lead editorial in Tiir boar rngtnn Past last Wcck cnargmg the CIA with indi- rect involvement in the murderous %larch F car bombing in Beirut. chants of "death to America punc- tuated the funeral oration, for the victims. and the State I)epartment alerted U.S. Embassies in the Middle Last to the danger of violent retali- ation against Americans. From the welter of accusations, denials, am; explanations left behind by this journalistic coup, the real sequence of events is gradually beginning to emerge. As the rules and motives of the principal players become more clearly understood, the CIA appears to be more a victim of sensational journalism rather than an indirect accessory to a mass murder. In contrast to the Post's implica- tion of CIA involvement, all U.S. Offi- cials with knowledge of these events from Secretary of State George Shult: on down are unanimous in denying that the agency had any con- nection, direct or indirect. with the Lebanese intelligence team that arranged the car bombing. All informed American officials agree that the CIA did not in any way train the Lebanese who planned and carried out the bombing nor did it 'nave advance knowledge of the event. Typical of the official reaction is the comment by Robert B. Oakley, the director of the State Department's office for counter- terrorism, who found the Posts han- diing of the story "outrageous" but in retrospect it is easy to see how the Post's investigative report- ers were led astray by starling dis- coveries they made after the oombing. For example. they unearthed for the first time the fact tna: President Reagan had secretly directed the CIA last December to train and support Lebanese intelli- gence teams for the purpose of using violent action to pre-emp: and abort terrorist activity aimed at American targets. As permitted by law in cases of extreme sensitivity. this pres- idential finding was reported not to the whole membership of the Senate and House Intelligence Com- mittees, but only to their chairmen and vice chairmen. In spite of such extra precautions. this highly-secret information was somehow leaked to the Post either from the Congress or from the executive nrancn. and the Teak has fueled a growing demand for it radical review of the whiffle con- gressional oversight process Meanwhile. with cvtden,c It tn" top-secret presidential directive in nand, it was natural fur the Pu,t reporu?r- to assume at Ica'it omc indirect agency connection with the homhint; attack on one of the sus- pected terrorist strongholds but in fact nip such connection existed for two separate reasons First, the top professional intel- ligence officers in the CIA had long been skeptical of any attempt to recruit and train anti-terrorist Leba- nese hit squads for fear they might get out of control in the anarchy of a disintegrating society. Only very reluctantly did these intelligenc pros accept the new responsibility, and they would have preferred con- centrating on the counterintelli- gence penetration of the terrorist organizations as a better way of ensuring an effective defense. Moreover, once the presidential order had been issued, the agency operators in the field found the Leba- nese security services so fractured by political and religious rivalries that no recruitment or training had been undertaken by March 8 when the car bomb exploded. In a sense, this event was looked upon by CIA officers as a reprieve because it viv- idly demonstrated all the dangers of indiscriminate violence they had been predicting. In the aftermath of the Beirut massacre, the presidential finding in favor of pre-emptive counterter- rorism was rescinded and the agency let off the hook for having to cam, it out. One other facet of the American intelligence relationship with Leba- non may have misled the Post reporters. For more than 20 years, the CIA maintained a routine liaison relationship with Lebanese intelli- gence as with the intelligence ser- vices of other non-communist countries. An exchange of visits and some training was.involved but this had nothing to do with recruiting and -training counter-terror nit squads. I n the light of this background, it does seem that the Post story was inflated to suggest conclusions well beyond what the facts could support and that the CIA got a bum rap. In the process, American lives may have been needlessly endan- gered. In fairness to the top editors of the Post. it should be pointed out that the press spokesman for the CIA strongly objected to the story when it was read to him 24 hours before publication. In the absence of CIA Director William Casey. the agenc%. huHevet, passed up Inc opportunitt. it was given it, appeal up the line where the iG is ment nn h' have been different i e all the fact. were on the table (f)rd ,f .vc* r nanrrn,tllc yn dreutrd crrirnnntst Declassified in Part - Sanitized Copy Approved for Release 2012/02/28: CIA-RDP90-00965R000807590013-2 Declassified in Part - Sanitized Copy Approved for Release 2012/02/28: CIA-RDP90-00965R000807590013-2 - ~A".EA2lAl:..ii0 ARAB HIJACKERS FORCE T.W.A. JET TO FLY TO BEIRUT ONE KILLING IS REPORTED 104 Americans Are on Airliner! -Gunmen Said to Belong to the Islamic Holy Isar By JOSEPH BERGER Arab gunmen commandeered a Trans World Airlines jetliner with 104, Americans and 49 other people aboard yesterday and forced it to fly on a twist. ing course from Athens to Beirut to Al- giers and then back to Beirut, where the pilot said one passenger was shot to death. Minutes after the plane landed for a u. Associated Press, the pilot radioed the had seized the plane after smuggling control tower there: "He just killed a two grenades and two 9-millimeter pis- passenger! He just killed,a passen. tols through X-ray machines at the ger! " Athens airport by wrapping the weap. One of the hijackers then got on the ons in fiberglass insulation. radio and told the control tower: "You He identified the two men as Ahmed see. You now believe. There will be an- Karbeia and All Yunes, both 20-year- other within five minutes." old Shiite Moslems, who he said had Islamic Terrorist Group come with him from Cairo and spent Ow night at the Athens airport. The hijackers, whose number was The volatility of the situation became put by passengers released during the apparent as the Boeing 727 approached odyssey at either two or three, were re- theJBeirut airport for the first time. ported to be members of the terrorist When the control tower at first denied group Islamic Holy War, which took re- permission for the plane to land, the sponsibility for the suicide bombings of pilot made a frantic appeal that was re- 1983. More than 300 people died in those blasts. There were earlier reports that one man had been shot and that several passengers had been beaten when the plane stopped in Beirut the first time, but these were contradicted by other reports that said the t -no-passengers were hurt. During the fist stop in Bei- rut the hijackers freed at least 19 pas- sengers; arost of them wedieftand chil- dren, and they released at least 18 NEW YORK TTT"FS 15 June 1985 gerq,qW. ct+ew, uunless Israel. released St+1em prisoners captured in I.Adigfta the Algerian preys agency But, they did not carryout their threat before the plane, T.W.A. flight 847, took off once again for Beirut. At 2:20 A.M. today in Beirut (7:20 P.M. Yesterday New York time), the jet landed in Beirut. Air controllers in Larnaca, Cyprus, said that before land- ing, the pilot radioed to say he had only 50 minutes of fuel left. Hijackers Press Pilot "We want- to determine whether there are any people on the ground at Beirut airport," the pilot was quoted as saying. "We are exhausted, we have been flying all day, and low on fuel." He said the hijackers "are pressing us to know what are the circumstances at Beirut airport." The hijacking yesterday was the third this week in the Middle East. The Beirut airport was involved in all three. A man captured at the Athens airport reportedly confessed to being an ac- complice to the hijacking today and said he was a member of Islamic Holy War'. The man, identified as All Atwa, a 21- year-old Lebanese, reportedly told a linois who were returning from a visit to Israel, according to Jackie Soucek, ppaarish secretary of St Ill . Margaret Mary Roman Catholic Church in Algonquin, . Flight 847, carrying eight crew mem-* bens and 145 passengers, left Cairo yes- terday morning for Athens, where it was scheduled to pick up passengers and continue on to Rome. In Athens, 10 Passengers boarded, including two well-dressed Arab men in their early 20's carrying leather suitcases and al nylon traveling bag, according to a Po- lice spokesman. Within minutes after takeoff, the PO_ lice said, two armed Arab men rose from their seats in the rear of the plane.-One of the men approached the pilot and threatened to blow up the jet. He ordered the pilot to divert the flight from Rome to Beirut, a 700-mile jour. ney acnvgRihe Mediterranean Sea in the opposite direction. According to passengers who were later freed, the armed men - some passengers said there were three - di- rected them to put their hands behind their heads and seized passports as they went down the aisles. Frances Reynolds, 67 years old, a passenger from the Chicago area, said thelhijackers, "all looked Arabic and they had beards." She said, "They kept yelling 'Down t Down!' in Arabic. One of the steward- esses translated for us. The stewardess said they had a bag of grenades and were going to blow the plane up." The hijackers, she said "were b , eat- didn't osee. IItt, the but head She said. thumps." As the plane approached the airport, the control tower told the pilot: "you have not permission to land Beirut Air- port. It's up to you and to the hijackers to go on." "Beirut," the pilot radioed back, "the hijacker has pulled the pin on his hand grenade. He will land at Beirut. He is desperate. "We must, I repeat, we must land at Beirut. We must land at Beirut. No al- ternative.- they are beating the passenger!" he Beirut officials had at first blocked said. "They are threatening to kill the runway with buses, but removed them now. We must have that fuel now, them. The plane touched down not far immediately!" Cries and groans that from' he burned wreckage of a Jorda. sounded as if someone was being nian airliner that had- been seized beaten could be heard in the back- Wednesday by men believed to be Shi ground Ire blown u Moslems. The Jordanian plane was While in Algiers, the gunmen asked p on the ground after its 66 pas- that Michael H. Newlin, the United sengers and crew members were re- States Ambassador there, be brought leased unharmed. to the airport. It was not clear what Hijacker Reads Statement r sengers. In. Washington, ole he played in the release of the pas- The jet's first stop in Beirut, which Reagan said American offic arls were lasted two and a half hours, appeared more in Algiers. Most of those released "doing everything that can be done" to to be primarily for refueling. During the were said to be Americans. gain the release of the Americans, but meat stop in one Arabic the gver the read a states he declined to provide details. over the aircraft's A '1'berat of Executions radio outlining their demands. While in Algiers, the gunmen threat- Passengers From Illinois These included the release of Shiite ened to execute the remaining passer- at lmong east 24 Roman Catholics from 11 Moslems of l were in Lebanon; internationa Declassified in Part - Sanitized Copy Approved for Release 2012/02/28: CIA-RDP90-00965R000807590013-2 STAT Declassified in Part - Sanitized Copy Approved for Release 2012/02/28: CIA-RDP90-00965R000807590013-2 condemnation of Israeli military ac- The gunmen this time threatened to tions in southern Lebanon: condemna- "execute" the remaining passengers tion of United States support for Israel unless Israel released Shiite M otim and of United States actions in the Arab prisoners. A series of tebetw*en the age" world; and condemnation of a car tions were concj bombing in Beirut march 8 that killed rian authorities consulted hijackers, with 80 people. Published reports have said Ambassador Newlin ultei~ said the bombing was carried out by a that ous stages. Reports in Al riie Presi- States may have had training from the United Chadli Benjedid, the Alge States Central Intelligence Agency. dent, received a letter from President The Israelis are holding about 800 Reagan about the hostage situation, Lebanese Shiite Moslems at a prison but its contents could not be ~ held. near the port of Haifa. The of -carrying At bout 8 P M., United Press Interna- out arrested terrorist charges the buses drove back to out terrorist activity against Israeli tional reported, carrying 18 passen- hijakers in southern Lebanon. The an airport lounge hijakers asked that the prisoners be g Other dispatches put the number at transported to Sidon, Lebanon. The released passengers, mostly eld- 20, and said they included 17mreen, 2 were erly women and children, were permit- women and a child. Many ted to slide down the plane's yellow tears, the agency said, though none emergency chute, according to report- was injured. In New York, T.W.A. said ers at the scene. They were flown on a 21 passengers were released in Algiers. r after a five-hour Middle East Airlines plane to Larnaca, half-hour Algiers, lathe Boeing 727 taxied Cyprus. stop There, discussing the first reported onto a runway and took off. ? rted from Beirut that Is- shooting, one of the freed women, Irma Reuters repo was takingponsibil- Garsa of Laredo, Tea., said the hijack- lamic Holy War and said it proved ers had shot in the neck a passenger ity for the hijacking she described only as.black man. She the organization could strike against said the man did not appear to be seri- "U.S. imperialism" at will. ously injured, according to The Associ- A United States official told The As- sociated Press in Algeria that uncon- ated Press. Mrs. Garza was freed in Beirut along firmed information indi i td~ athe t leas with her daughter, Irma Trautman, sengers on the and two of the daughter's children, 104 Americans, Greeks on e Sudane stand Katherine and Susan. her husband,' ians,2Lebanese , Vincente, and her son-in-law, Robert one Mexican. The nationalities of the Trautmann, reportedly remained on others were not known. the plane. The hijacking was the third in the The T.W.A. plane, with about 130 pas- Middle East in three days. Hours after sengers and crew aboard, took off the Jordanian plane was hijacked west across a Lebanese 707 jet carry- again , this ra efor g Algiers, a voy- lu 80 passengers and 6 crew members the of 1,900 ni es i was taken on had the landed ground from Cyprus Authorities ties at . Houari Boumedierine over that by a Palestinian international Airport there gave the hi- who said lie was retaliating for the Shi- jackers permission to land because ites' hijacking. After he held three they were told the T,W.A? jet was again crew members hostage, authorities low on fuel, the official Algerian press gated his demand to be flown to the agency said. Jordanian capital, Amman. The plane touched o and n at came to a at the Algiers airport Fire- fighting a mile from the air terminal. fighting equipment s into and taken out to the of Al- giers and flights were blocked. Declassified in Part - Sanitized Copy Approved for Release 2012/02/28: CIA-RDP90-00965R000807590013-2 Declassified in Part - Sanitized Copy Approved for Release 2012/02/28: CIA-RDP90-00965R000807590013-2 ARTICLI ON pAGE cs os TIME 24 June 1985 Nation Terror Aboard Flight 847 Muslim hijackers hold Americans hostage on a murderous journey Millions around the world watched their television sets or listened to their radios as the horrific drama unfolded. "He has pulled a hand-grenade pin and is ready to blow up the aircraft if he has to. We must, I repeat. we must land at Beirut. We must land at Beirut. No alternative." After much delay. the curious, grudging reply of the Beirut control tower: "Very well Land. Land quietly Land quietly." Then another desperate plea: "They are beating the passengers. They are threat- ening to kill the passengers. We want fuel nos Immediately Five minutes at most, or he is going to kill the passengers.- After that. another. more excited. more hostile voice in broken English "The plane is release of 700 Shi'ites from Israeli custo- dy, and this appeared to be the first step in realizing that goal. If Israel and presum- ably the U.S. balked. declared the hijack- ers, "our blood will be a witness." Tension and deep fatigue had marked the TWA jetliner's third arrival at Beirut. Not only was the crew frazzled, but the plane was thought to be in need of main- tenance. Beirut authorities had again tried to refuse permission to land, but had n a political level. the hijackers of Flight 847 called for the release not only of the Lebanese Shi'ites still held by Israel, but of a few others imprisoned in Cyprus and Kuwait. They also demanded the immediate with- drawal of Israeli forces from southern Leb- anon (a pullout has been under way since January and, except for patrols and forays hack into the border area. is now virtually been overruled by the hijackers and by a complete) and international condemnation desperate-sounding pilot who said he had of the U.S. and Israel. In a broader sense, only five minutes' worth of fuel. Even as the Shi'ites of Lebanon, newly radicalized he prepared to land, Shi'ite militiamen by the violence that has plagued their around the airport fired their weapons out country, particularly since the Israeli inva - tosea. at what they claimed was an Israeli sion of June 1982, are seeking a fairer booby-trapped. If anyone approaches. we gunboat. The lives of remaining passen- shake after generations of neglect and dis- will blow it up. Either refueling the plane gers and crew were obviously still in dan- ctimination by Lebanon's wealthier and or blowing it up. No alternative." ger. But particularly disturbing was the more powerful Maronite Christians and After airport authorities complied, news that on the plane's second stop in Sunni Muslims. Beyond all that, the Shiite the stricken plane took off from Beirut. Beirut the previous night. some six or fanatical fringe, inspired by the example of where it had landed after having been hi' eight passengers with Jewish-sounding the Iranian revolution, wants to destroy the again and re- surnames had been hastily removed from last vestiges of Western "decadence" in the jacked out osAthens. Ho ag. la - the aircraft in the darkness In effect. this off Islamic world, particularly the presence of ed in Allgiers, thentook oHours turned late that night to Beirut, the meant that the well-organized hijackers the U.S., that "Great Satan." To accom- had created a hostage crisis within a hos- fish this goal, these extremists have dem- the hone-weary senseless . And mnsiinut tes after rising, the landing. crew slay- tage crisis, and there was no end in sight. p m U.S.. it was no ordinary sky- onstrated that they are willing and even ea- ing of a hostage, and a harsh voice over For the ger to employ savagery and mass murder. the plane's radio: "You see" You now be- lacking. no incident involving some trou- This was the first hijacking of an lieve it. There will be another in five min- bled soul who needed to be jollied or sweet- American airliner in the Middle East utes." and the nightmare rolled on. talked or strong-armed out of a free ride to since Ronald Reagan took office in Janu- In the beginning. the hijackers were 1 Havana or Timbuktu It was an American . ary 1981, and the Administration was outnumbered by their captives 153 to 2. I plane. Trans World Airlines' Flight 847 on deeply disturbed. It was convinced that and U S. authorities tended to believe that its leg from Athens to Rome. with 153 pas- the hijackers of Flight 847 were in the the terrorists would soon be overwhelmed by exhaustion if nothing else. By Sunday morning, however, with the plane on the ground in Algiers. the ranks of the hijack- ers had swelled to between twelve and 15. and all but 32 male American passengers and crewmen had been released. The gunmen set a 10 a.m. deadline l5 a m E ,D T i for their demands to be met, but then inexplicably left Algiers more than an hour ahead of time. Once again. their destination was Beirut On landing there. they demanded the release of 50 fellow Shiite Muslims currently detained in Is- rael. such a gesture was justified. the hi- jackers said. by their freeing of three American men the night before in Al- giers The terrorists had been seeking the sengers and crew members aboard, at least same league as the ones who seized a Ku- 100 of whom were Americans. Most im- waiti airliner last December. took it to portant. the hijackers were identified by an Tehran and eventually killed two Ameri- accomplice as members of Islamic Jihad can passengers. That incident ended for Holy Warl, the shadowy Shi'ite Muslim when the Iranians sent a platoon of secu- organization that is regarded as a sort of rity men aboard the plane dressed as umbrella for various fundamentalist terror a maintenance crew The hijackers 1 groups operating in Lebanon and other were arrested. but there is no evidence Middle East countries. Loyal to Iran's rev- olutionary ruler. the Ayatullah Ruhollah Khomeini, and quite possibly subsidized and directed by the Iranian leadership. Is- lamic Jihad and its confederates are blamed for many of the suicide bombing missions that have afflicted American and other Western military bases and diplo- matic missions in the Middle East in the past two years that they were ever brought to justice. As Flight 847 zigzagged around the Mediterranean, the Administration faced the vexing question of what it should, or could, do to respond to the crisis. By 9 a.m. Friday, a working group chaired by Robert Oakley, chief of the State Department's of- fice for combatting terrorism had gathered next to Secretary of State George Shultz's office in the State Department's antiterror- ism suite. The group set to work on a 24- hour watch. monitoring events, establish- ing communication lines, serving as liaison Declassified in Part - Sanitized Copy Approved for Release 2012/02/28: CIA-RDP90-00965R000807590013-2 Declassified in Part - Sanitized Copy Approved for Release 2012/02/28: CIA-RDP90-00965R000807590013-2 4 th the various foreign governments in- volved, soothing the families of hostages and working out options for US. action. That evening, the Administration dis- patched antiterrorist to orce units OM-West Germany and t-ort Bran. 40- to 50-man units are trained in such skills as counterintelligence and comman- o~tions but they have never even used to storm a eirated airliner. When asked later in the day what the U.S. was doing to help, the President re- plied, "Everything that can be done." But when asked if it were true that Washing- ton had threatened to retaliate against Iran if any U.S. hostages were harmed by Islamic fundamentalists, Reagan said flatly, "I can't answer that." n fact, Shultz had warned Iran months ago that if any of the Americans kid- 1 naped in Beirut were executed by its Lebanese surrogates, Iran would suf- fer the consequences. Precisely what that means would have to be carefully deter- mined, but the U.S. has long since learned that it is difficult to retaliate against so amorphous an enemy as the Lebanese fa- natics. Their headquarters and even their whereabouts are hard to pin down, and their precise links with Iran are not easy to define. As Friday turned to Saturday and the ordeal continued, the President remained in touch with the situation from his weekend retreat at Camp David, tell- ing National Security Adviser Robert McFarlane. "Let's do all we can to sup- port the Algerians. Our main objective is to get those people out safely." Shultz can- celed a trip to Evanston, Ill., where he had planned to accept an honorary degree from Northwestern University. On Sunday, Shultz and McFarlane were back at their desks tracking the ominous new trends in the crisis. The President remained at Camp David, but was due to return to the White House Sunday afternoon. The hijacking of Flight 847 had begun Friday morning when the plane, a Boeing 727 that had taken off from Cairo two hours earlier. landed at Athens and took on additional passengers. Among them were 24 members of three Roman Catho- lic churches from towns in northeastern Illinois, who had spent a fortnight visiting the Holy Land. Also among them were two well-dressed young Arabs carrying shoulder bags who had arrived from Cai- ro the day before. Along with a third man, they spent the night in the airport lounge, waiting to board the TWA plane. As it turned out, only two of the men managed to get seats on the crowded flight; the third, after arguing with TWA officials, was forced to stay behind. He was later arrested at the airport by Greek police and identified as Ali Atwa, 21, an air- conditioning technician from southern Lebanon. He identified his confederates as Ahmed Gharbiyeh and All Youness, both 20 and also Lebanese. According to police, Atwa said he and the others were members of Islamic Ji- had, a claim later affirmed by an anony- mous callei in Beirut and then disputed in a statement delivered to news agencies there. The confusion may stem from Iran's recent efforts to play down its con- nections with terrorists in hopes of win- ning international support for its 4%-year The jet's stops, Eastern times: 1) lands in Beirut 4 a.m. Friday; 2) arrives Algiw s 10:.SO a- back in Beirut, 7:20 p.m.; 4) Algiers again, 2:45 a.m. Saturday. On a inday, it returnee to Beirut. struggle against Iraq. Atwa told police that his friends had managed to smuggle two grenades and a 9-mm pistol through the airport's X-ray machines by wrapping the weapons in fiber glass insulation. Scarcely 20 minutes after the plane had taken off for Rome's Leonardo da Vinci Airport, on a flight that was supposed to continue via a Boeing 747 to Boston, Los Angeles and San Diego, it was taken over by the two terrorists, who wildly bran- dished their grenades and pistol They gave the pilot, Captain John Testrake of Rich- mond, Mo., the first order fly to Beirut. At Beirut International Airport, the last thing officials wanted was a skyjacking crisis on their hands, and so they blocked the air- port runway with buses and other obsta- cles. But the terrorists and their captive pi- lot were having none of it. Demanded the pilot: "They are beating up passengers. We must land in Beirut. He has pulled the pin of the grenade. We must land. He is ready to blow up the plane." On the ground in Beirut, the plane was refueled as the hijackers had ordered. The terrorists also asked to speak to an official of Amal, the mainstream Shi'ite Muslim political and military force, but Amal lead- ers refused the request. After announcing their demands; the hijackers released 19 women and children via a yellow escape chute lowered fivm the forward door. One freed hostage, Irma Garza of Laredo, Tex- as, said that the terrorists had shot a pas- senger in the neck. Another of the released passengers, Frances Reynolds of Chicago, ficials responded to the plane's landing request by closing their airport. But they changed their minds after the arrival of an urgent plea from President Reagan to Algerian President Chadli Bendjedid. U.S. officials, who well remember the im- portant role played by Algerian diplomats in settling the Iranian hostage crisis al- most five years ago, had hoped that the hi- jacking could be resolved one way or an- other in Algiers. But after remaining on the runway there for five hours, during which time they released another 21 pas- sengers, the hijackers ordered the pilot to take off again and head back to Beirut. I t was well past midnight in the Middle East when Flight 847 again landed in Beirut. The airport-tower operator did his best to refuse permission, but Cap- tain Testrake was adamant: he was run- ning out of fuel, and the 'terrorists were threatening to ? kill him. A hijacker may have clinched the argument by shouting, "We are suicide terrorists! If you don't let said, "Mom was some shooting, but 1 didn't due raise my head to see what was happening. The hijackers were beating people on the header." Passengers were un.. nerved by the behavior, of the hjj kem They was hysterical, they were scream- ing," said Patrida Weber of Albuquerque. Next stop was Algiers, where local of- Declassified in Part - Sanitized Copy Approved for Release 2012/02/28: CIA-RDP90-00965R000807590013-2 Declassified in Part - Sanitized Copy Approved for Release 2012/02/28: CIA-RDP90-00965R000807590013-2 us land, we will crash the plane into your control tower, or fly it to Baabda and crash into the Presidential Palace!" The tower relented. The plane touched down at 2:20 a.m. Saturday. Once again, the hijackers asked to speak to an Amal official, and when none appeared, they responded by murdering an American passenger and throwing his body onto the tarmac. They claimed the victim, a young man with a crew cut, was a U.S. Marine who had taken part in "securi- ty blowups in Lebanon-" It was then, after the pilot shouted over the radio, "He just killed a passenger' He just killed a passen- ger!" that a hijacker declared, "You see? You now believe it. Them will be another in five minutes." When the control-tower operator remonstrated with him, saying, "Isn't it a shame, killing an innocent pas- senger?" the hijacker replied angrily, "Did you forget the Bir al Abed massacre?" He was referring to the March 8 car bombing in the Bir al Abed suburb of Beirut that killed more than 75 Shiite Muslims but he body of the murdered Ameri- can had been lying on the tarmac for about two hours when a hijack- er told the tower. "The Red Cross can come and get the body." The hijacker then called for fuel, food and water, say- ing. "[ want 200 sandwiches. 150 apples and 88 lbs. of bananas. But the fuel first, and make it fast." As the food and fuel were taken on. the pilot said he wanted the runway cleared for takeoff at dawn. He was asked for his destination. His re- ply: "I don't know." The next destination turned out once more to be Algiers, where the plane land- ed, for the second time, at 7:45 a.m. local time (2:45 a.m. E.D.T.) Saturday. Algeri- an officials authorized the landing on con- dition that the hijackers not use violence. Before leaving Beirut. it turned out, the hijackers had demanded that Ali Atwa be released by Greek authorities and brought to Algiers. Otherwise, they said, they would kill all eight Greeks on the plane, including Singer Demis Roussos. Greek authorities complied and sent Atwa to Al- giers in an Olympic Airways plane. ^ Terrorist All Atwa in Algiers on his way to join his comrades on Flight 847 failed to hurt Sheik Mohammed Hussein Fadallah. one of Lebanon's pro-Iranian Shiite religious leaders. Shiites later claimed that the U S Central Intelligence Agency had engrneere t ee em ing, in an attempt to tight Shiite terrorism with counterterrorism: the CIA denied the charge Moments after the killing of the pas- senger. an Amal official and his body- guard went aboard the plane. where they remained for some time. As negotiations continued. a hijackerasked that all airport lights he turned off. and the demand was met. At the time. it seemed that the hijack- ers were fearful of an attack by the Israelis or by one or another of their enemies with- in Lebanon. In fact. however, it later be- came clear that they wanted the darkness for other reasons: to bring aboard about a dozen additional terrorists as reinforce- ments, as well as a supply of arms and am- munition: and to remove the six or eight passengers with Israeli- or Jewish-sound- ing names. A day later. a released passen- ger. Ken Lanham of San Francisco, re- ported that the hijackers went up and down the aisle calling out the names of these people. and then led them away Soon after the TWA jetliner landed in Algiers. two ranking Algerian officials came aboard and began discussions with the hijackers. The negotiations evidently paid off. Having released three hostages on arrival. the hijackers then released 58 others. That apparently left only Ameri- can men on board. "We're begging them to keep the plane in Algiers." said a State Department official. "Keep talking, keep wearing them down, but for Christ's sake. don't let that plane take off again." Among the stunned and fatigued pas- sengers released in Algiers was Dorothy Sullivan of Chicago, who described the tension during the seemingly endless or- deal. One of the original hijackers had been soft-spoken, the other brutal, she said, and the latter liked to go up and down the aisle thumping passengers on the head. Several passengers recalled that Stewardess Uli Derickson, of Newton. N.J., had stood up to the hijackers. Said she, speaking of her passengers: "They're doing what you tell them to do. Why do you keep beating them up?" The released passengers also noted that, before leaving the plane, they were relieved of their cash and valuables by the hijackers. 3, That evening, the terrorists an- nounced that if their demands were not met by the following morning, they would fly to an unspecified destination. and de- stroy the plane and perhaps its remaining passengers. By early Sunday afternoon. they had made good on only the first half of their ultimatum. arriving in Beirut for the third time. On the ground. the hijack- ers called for food. fuel, newspapers and videocassettes. They urged the Interna- tional Red Cross to work for the release of the 50Shi'ites in Israel and "move fast be- fore it is too late so that all will achieve sat- isfactory results." The hijackers added ominously that the next communique would be their last. presumably meaning that they planned to destroy the plane afterward. Back in the U.S., some worried rela- tives learned of the hijacking only hours before they had intended to go to the air- port to welcome travelers home. Against a backdrop of yellow ribbons and flickering candles, parishioners of three Catholic churches in the Chicago area spent the day praying, huddling around radios and ex- changing bits of information. They were cheered by the news that many of their 24 friends had been released in Beirut or Al- giers. "We're waiting, we're praying, we're hoping." said the Rev. Robert Garrity of St. Margaret Mary Church in Algonquin. where parishioners maintained an all- night vigil. Elsewhere, reactions were much the same. -[just hope they're not beating peo- ple. like they say they are." said Pete La- zansky of Tulsa. whose parents were on board. Other passengers included Kath- ryn Davis and her fiance James Hoskins Jr., both 22 and from Indianapolis, whose parents had given them European vaca- tions as college graduation presents. "I was going to pick her up this evening." said Stockbroker Stephen Davis of his daughter. "We just sit here and wait." Passenger Irma Garza of Laredo tele- phoned her brother-in-law from Cyprus to tell him that she and three relatives had been released but that her husband, a granddaughter and son-in-law were still on board. Said the brother-in-law: "She sounded real nervous. She was crying." Tina Migos, of Revere, Mass., had been preparing for the arrival of five relatives from Greece who were to attend the chris- tening of her year-old son. "We had a party planned and everything," a cousin reported. "Now we're just waiting to hear what's going to happen." In Florissant, Mo., Kath- arine Ellerbrock tuned in a morning TV show and real- ized that she was listening to the recorded voice of her brother. Flight Engineer Ben- jamin Zimmerman, talking to the Beirut control tower. She said her brother, who manages to be both a full-time TWA pi- lot and a Lutheran pastor with a ministry in the mountains of 01111011111111111 Declassified in Part - Sanitized Copy Approved for Release 2012/02/28: CIA-RDP90-00965R000807590013-2 Declassified in Part - Sanitized Copy Approved Idaho, was "strong, steady and stable" and "has got to be a comfort to the passengers." In Richmond. Mo., a small town northeast of Kansas City. friends and neighbors stayed up to follow the ordeal of Captain Tes- trake, who in his spare time raises horses. restores small antique planes and nurtures a recently planted vineyard on his nearby farm. "He's been an airman for a long time," said Howard Hill, editor of the Richmond Daily News. "He won't panic." One of the most troubling aspects of the plight of Flight 847 was that it was the third hijacking that occurred in the region within three days last week, and the sec- ond apparently engineered by Lebanese Shi'ites. In earlier times, Arab skyjackers tended to be Palestinians. from one or an- other faction of the Palestine Liberation Organization, attempting to advance or at least dramatize the Palestinian cause. Shi- ite Muslim terrorism. linked to Iran ideo- logically if not logistically, is both more puzzling and more frightening: drive out the American Satan and all its influence. The week's first hijacking had begun on Tuesday. when half a dozen Shi'ites stormed aboard a Jordanian-owned Boeing 727 at Beirut airport. They over- powered eight Jordanian security guards, then ordered the Swedish pi- lot to fly to Larnaca, Cyprus. Over the next 28 hours, as the plane bounced around the eastern half of the Mediterra- nean, the skyjackers had am- ple time to air their com- plaints. They were angry about an Arab League statement supporting the cause of the Palestinians in the Beirut refu- gee camps, which have been under attack by Lebanese Shi- ites for the past three weeks. The Shi'ites want to drive out the Palestinians to make sure that the P.L.O. will never again be able to set up a "state within a state" in Lebanon. After several dire threats, the hijackers freed the passengers, blew up the plane and sped off in a Range Rover, disappearing into the Shiite neighborhoods near the airport. Several of the released passengers then boarded the first plane they could catch out of Beirut. a Middle East Airlines flight to nearby Cyprus. But as the Lebanese Boeing 707 landed there, a young Palestin- ian, producing a hand grenade, threatened to blow up the plane as a protest against the earlier Shi'ite hijacking. He soon sur- rendered to the plane's captain, however, after being granted his request to fly to Amman aboard a Jordanian airliner. On board both the hijacked Jordanian plane and the hijacked Lebanese plane were Professor Landry Slade, an American who is serving as an acting dean of the American University of Beirut. and his teenage son William. "It wasn't bad," the younger Slade remarked, after he and the other passengers had been released in Cy- for Release 2012/02/28: CIA-RDP90-00965R000807590013-2 prus, "but it isn't something we want to talk about." Two days later, when he learned of the hijacking of TWA Flight 847, Landry Slade told reporters, "God help them all. I know what it's like." Professor Slade was, in fact, a good deal luckier than his col- league. Thomas Sutherland, 54, dean of the American University's agriculture and food sciences faculty. Sutherland had been kidnaped earlier in the week as he was rid- ing in a six-car convoy from Beirut airport to his campus home. He thus became the seventh American and the twelfth West- erner currently being held by various ex- tremist groups in Lebanon. In a sense, the hijackings were a micro- cosm of the horrors rampant in the two countries that formed the backdrop of the case. Iran and Lebanon. In Iran. 78 people were killed and 332 others injured one night last week in a series of bombing raids by Iraqi aircraft against the Khomeini re- gime. After a series of antiwar protests, the Tehran government sponsored a huge demonstration at which thousands of marchers chanted, "War, war till victory!" Iran has serious internal problems. but none so critical as to constitute an immi- nent threat to Khomeini's authority. In Lebanon, as usual, superlatives were insufficient to describe the scene. The fighting in the refugee camps be- tween Palestinians and Shi'ites spread to other parts of West Beirut. On Friday morning. a shell struck a vegetable mar- ket there. killing or wounding 50 people Two suicide bombers crashed an explo- sives-laden car into a Lebanese Army po- sition. killing 23 and wounding 36. Since the victims were mostly from the predom- inantly Shi'ite Sixth Brigade, reports had it that the bombers were Sunni Muslims, who have sided with the Palestinians in the current struggle and view with appre- hension the Shi'ites' lust for a greater share of political power. The Shi'ites and the Druze were allies until about a month ago, but last week they were shooting at each other after a group of Amal militia- men tried to stop a car loaded with Druze. Druze Leader Walid Jumblatt agreed to a cease-fire but later, when asked how long it would last, replied. "Only God and Syr- ia know." Given all these circumstances. Syrian President Hafez Assad was con- tent to let the rival factions in Lebanon fight on fora while before he risks his own troops to try to restore order. In Lebanon, the Israeli forces were largely gone, but the impasse continued between the United Nations peacekeep- ing forces and the Israeli-backed, pre- dominantly Christian militia known as the South Lebanon Army. Two weeks ago, the S.L.A. had seized 25 Finnish sol- diers of the U.N. force, released three of them and taken the others to the Chris- tian town of Marjayoun. It refused to let them go until eleven of its own members had been handed over by the Shi'ite Amal militia. The S.L.A. accused the U.N. force, which does not recognize the S.L.A. as an independent militia and customarily dis- arms its members whenever they try to pass through U.N lines. of having cap- tured the eleven S.L.A. members and turned them over to Amal. The Shiite mi- litia. in turn, claimed that the eleven S.L.A. members had defected to their side At midweek. Israel arranged for West- ern newsmen to visit Matjayoun The trip demonstrated not only that the Finns were in good condition. hut that the Israelis. if they chose to do so. could hase ended the incident quickly by putting pressure on the S.L.A. The situation took a comic turn late in the week when the eleven S.L.A. men. all of whom happened to be Shi'ites in an overwhelmingly Christian militia, told U.N. and Red Cross officials that they had no desire to return to the S.L.A. Confront- ed with this information, the S.L.A. com- mander. General Antoine Lahd, released the Finnish soldiers the next day. This was the world that had produced the nightmare of Flight 847, an ordeal that continued without resolution as the new week began. There were hints that Israel might be willing to release its Shi'ite detainees if the U.S. asked it to do so: after all, only a month ago, the Israelis had ex- changed 1,150 prisoners, including some world-class terrorists, for three of their own servicemen. At the same time, there were reports that the U.S. Sixth Fleet in the Mediterranean had invoked a "radio silence" on its movements-a possible sign of action to come. Perhaps nothing so aptly epitomized the chaos of Lebanon for Americans last week as the fate of the body of the young man, said by the hijackers to be a U.S. Ma- rine. who had been murdered on Flight 847. After lying on the tarmac for two hours, the body, with a bullet wound in the head, had been taken by an International Red Cross ambulance to a morgue at the American University Hospital in Muslim West Beirut. U.S. officials, based on the other side of the "green line" in Christian- dominated East Beirut, were unable to re- trieve it for 24 hours. Not until Sunday morning did a State Department spokes- man announce that the body was at last on its way to a U.S. air base in Spain for iden- tification. Used first as proof of the hijack- ers' resolve, the stranded corpse had thus become a symbol of the obstacles and divisions that afflict the terrorists' homeland. -ay W7NtamE S,,4& Rp,,td by John aorrell/A/stars, Doan Flsc>Mr/Giro and Jotiarr,a McGoary/Washlnafon Declassified in Part - Sanitized Copy Approved for Release 2012/02/28: CIA-RDP90-00965R000807590013-2 Declassified in Part - Sanitized Copy Approved for Release 2012/02/28: CIA-RDP90-00965R000807590013-2 ARTICLE 611 PAGE. AASr.~VG: 3 LETTERS TO THE EDITOR The CIA on the March 8 Car Bombing In its lead news article May 12, The Post alleged that the CIA had "an indi- rect connection" to the March 8 car bombing in Beirut which killed more than 80 people and wounded many others. Before the story was published, the CIA categorically denied to The Post reporters any involvement. direct or indirect, in the bombing. Moreover, in a statement immediately after the story appesred- the agency pudicy denied airy caomsction with this event. The Hasse Select Committee an In- tdigenoe OJPSa aveetipted The Post story and inter ails reported to the h Haas an Jame 12 tarn: "the oonnmitte I's review has uncov- ered no evidenoq that any U.S. inteth grins agency-any U.S. government agency-h s encouraged or psrtiopsted its article gave the American public in any terrorist activity in Lebanon. Fur- and the rest of the world the false im- ther, the committee was able to di.. pression that the U.S. government cover no evidence that any U.S. intdlt was involved in terrorist activity. This gewe agency had forelmowledge of the misleading theme has been picked up March 8 bombing outside the residence by other journalists as fact and has of Shah Hussein Fadlaiah. even been cited by the Shute terror- "Without addressing the specdes of fiats as one of them rea for the hi- the allegations raised in connection will jaddng of TWA Flight 847. this deplorable terrorist evtent, the corm it is imperative that The Post metre states that its review of relevant proncptly correct the teamed and bring documents and Aes and its interview of to its readers' attention the HPSCrs appropriate government af6cWs Weds refutation of agency aolvat ut in the to the cwA*mm that no U.S. govern -. March 8 bombing, As Seaetry of State meat oompbady, direct or indirect, can George Shub said in commenting an be estabished with respect to the The Post's story, if the CIA denies March 8 bombing in Beirut" something, irs denied'. The CIA regrets that The Post fig- GEORGE V. LAUDER noted our denial of any involvement in 01 n s - "G1" the March 8 Beirut incident and that sshiu g ~tcn Wtan Declassified in Part - Sanitized Copy Approved for Release 2012/02/28: CIA-RDP90-00965R000807590013-2 Declassified in Part - Sanitized Copy Approved for Release 2012/02/28: CIA-RDP90-00965R000807590013-2 99th Congress 1st Session HXSE OF REPRE.S=ATIVES Report 99- RESOLUTION OF INQUIRY CONCFJN NG TERRORIST BOMBINGS IN BEIRUT, LAN June 12, 1985.-Referred to the House Calendar and ordered to be printed Mr. Hamilton, from the Permanent Select Camittee on Intelligence, submitted the following [To accompany H. Res. 171] The Permanent Select Canmittee on Intelligence, to when was referred the resolution (H. Res. 171) requesting the President to provide certain information to the House of Representatives concerning covert training of counterterrorist units to act against anti-American terrorists in Lebanon or other parts of the Middle East, having considered the same, report unfavorably thereon and recommend that the resolution do not pass. On May 14, 1985, House Resolution 171 was introduced by the Honorable Dan Edwards and referred to the Permanent Select Committee on Intelligence. The resolution requests the President to furnish to the House all documents and factual information in his possession which relate to covert training or other support, from January 1, 1984 to May 15, 1985, of counterterrorist units (including any Lebanese intelligence personnel) to engage in action against anti-American terrorists in Lebanon or other parts of the Middle East. Introduction of the resolution followed press allegations that the CIA had been authorized to train and support counterterrorist units of foreigners for strikes against suspected terrorists before they could attack U.S. facilities in the Middle East. Immediately after the introduction of the resolution, the committee began to interview intelligence officials and review pertinent intelligence documents. The purpose of this review was to determine whether or not any evidence existed to support the charge that the United States Government, and specifically the Central Intelligence Agency, knew about beforehand, or was in sane way responsible for, a March 8, 1985 bombing incident in Beirut, Lebanon that caused the loss of at least 80 lives and 100 other casualties. Declassified in Part - Sanitized Copy Approved for Release 2012/02/28: CIA-RDP90-00965R000807590013-2 Declassified in Part - Sanitized Copy Approved for Release 2012/02/28: CIA-RDP90-00965R000807590013-2 Ch June 12, the committee met in closed session to consider the resolution. After a discussion of the information derived from its review, the committee ordered the resolution reported adversely. The committee's understanding of the concern which underlies the introduction of house Resolution 171 is that U.S. counterterrorism policy not stoop to the tactics of terrorism in seeking to prevent it. The issue posed by the resolution of inquiry is a serious one. It relates to the U.S.,policy in countering terrorism, about which there is as yet no clear national consensus. The committee's review has uncovered no evidence that any U.S. intelligence agency - any U.S. Government agency - has encouraged or participisfed in any terrorist activity in Lebanon. Further, the committee was able to ,discover no evidence tha U.S. intelligence agency had farewIedge of the March 8 bomb outside the residence of Sheik Hussein Without addressing the specifics of the allegations raised in connection with this deplorable terrorist event, the committee states that its review of relevant documents and files and its interview of appropriate government officials leads to the conclusion that no U.S..Government complicity, direct or indirect, can be established with repect to the blanch 8 bombing in Beirut. COITTEE POSITION On June 12, 1985, the Permanent Select Committee on Intelligence, a quorum being present, ordered the resolution reported adversely by voice vote. OVERSIGHT FINDINGS With respect to clause 2(l)(3)(A) of Rule XI of the House of Representatives, the committee's findings and recommendations concerning House Resolution 171 are contained in the body of this report. FISCAL YEAR COST PROJECTIONS With respect to clause 2(1)(3)(B) of rule XI of the House of Representatives and section 308(a) of the Congressional Budget Act of 1974, this resolution does not provide new budget authority or tax expenditures. CONGRESSIONAL BUDGET OFFICE ESTIMATE With respect to clause 2(1)(3)(C) of rule XI of the House of Representatives, the committee has received no report from the Congressional Budget Office. Declassified in Part - Sanitized Copy Approved for Release 2012/02/28: CIA-RDP90-00965R000807590013-2 Declassified in Part - Sanitized Copy Approved for Release 2012/02/28: CIA-RDP90-00965R000807590013-2 REOCMMENDATION5 OF THE TrEE O,T GOV yr OPERATIOk1s With respect to clause 2(1)(3)(D) of rule XI of the House of Representatives, the cottunittee has not received a report from the Committee cn Government Operations pertaining to the subject of this resolution. Declassified in Part - Sanitized Copy Approved for Release 2012/02/28: CIA-RDP90-00965R000807590013-2 Declassified in Part - Sanitized Copy Approved for Release 2012/02/28: CIA-RDP90-00965R000807590013-2 Iq Next 5 Page(s) In Document Denied STAT STAT Declassified in Part - Sanitized Copy Approved for Release 2012/02/28: CIA-RDP90-00965R000807590013-2