STAFF NOTES: EAST ASIA

Document Type: 
Collection: 
Document Number (FOIA) /ESDN (CREST): 
CIA-RDP86T00608R000300110007-1
Release Decision: 
RIPPUB
Original Classification: 
T
Document Page Count: 
23
Document Creation Date: 
December 19, 2016
Document Release Date: 
August 5, 2004
Sequence Number: 
7
Case Number: 
Publication Date: 
April 7, 1975
Content Type: 
REPORT
File: 
AttachmentSize
PDF icon CIA-RDP86T00608R000300110007-1.pdf1.15 MB
Body: 
25X1 Approved For Release 2005/07/01 :CIA-RDP86T00608R000300110007-1 Approved For Release 2005/07/01 : CIA-RDP86T00608R0003001IOQQ - eCr?t rLFO ?irt: East Asia 25X1 Approve Fair` t ele x 005/07/04 :CIA-RDP86T00608R000300 Top Secret A P r 4 7, X975 25X1 25X1 25X1 Approved For Release 2005/07/01 : CIA-RDP86T00608R000300110007-1 Approved For Release 2005/07/01 : CIA-RDP86T00608R000300110007-1 Approved For Relese 2005/07/01 : CIA-RDP86T00608F000300110007-1 25X1 EAST ASIA 25X1 CONTENTS April 7, 1975 A Domino's Eye View of the Situation in Indochina 1 Sino-Malaysian Territorial Disagreement Burma: He Win Reshuffles His Team . . . . . . . . . . . 8 Son of the Impossible Dream: Ambonese Extremists in the Netherlands NORTH ASIA North Korea: Who Manages Foreign Relations?~ ., 13 Japanese Eye US Trusteeship as-Oil Storage Site. . . . . . . . . . . 18 25X1 Appro ed Eor-ReIeose 2005/07/01 : CIA-RDP86T00608R00p300110007-1 Approved For Rele A Domino's Eye View of the Situation in Indochina 8outheant Aoian Branch/RAP Most Southeast Asian leaders expected that Hanoi would eventually dominate all of Indochina, but the rapidity with which the military situation in o?,uth Vietnam deteriorated over the past three weeks has come as something of a shock. Last week, Thailand and Indonesia publicly called for a meeting of the foreign ministers of the Association of Southeast Asian Nations (ASEAN)--Singapore, Malaysia, the Philippines, Thailand, and Indonesia-- to discuss the impact on regional affairs partic- ularly security, and to devise a common strategy for..'sealing with the changing Indochina situation. On April,,7, the Thai foreign minister reportedly said such a meeting will be held in Kuala Lumpur, May 13-15 Thailand wants to explore the possibility of developing the five-nation association into a mutual defense organization. Thai Foreign Minister Chatchaiwill probably also use the forum publicly to promote his idea of getting great power endorse- ment,of Thailand's neutrality, and by extrlnsion the neutrality of all of Southeast Asia. =' necent: developments in Vietnam are having a greater impact on Thailand than any other country and, while Bangkok does not regard a communist take-over in Indochina, as an immediate security threat, it is concerned over;the.long-term implicatio-as of potentially hostile neighbors on its eastern border. Bangkok will undoubtedly speed up efforts already under way to break from-US policies in Indochina. Indonesia has tried to play an active role in resolving the conflicts in Indochina and is the,,only Asian,state,participating in the ICCS in Vietnam. Few,. leaders in Jakarta were optimistic. about South Vietnam's ability to withstand North 25X1 25X1 25X1 Approved For Re1e4 Vietnamese pressure over the long term, but In- donesian military officers were concernod that total communist control of Indochina would in- crease the potential for subversion elsewhere in Southeast Asia. Jakarta therefore will probably enthusiastically support Thai efforts to use ASEAN to promote regional security cooperation. For some time, Indonesian military leaders have been advocating a greater security and intelligence role for ASEAN. Indonesia has been lukewarm to'the con- cept of Southeast Asian neutrality, however, since Malaysia first proposed it in 197.0. Jakarta may try to use the ASE11N forum for a coordinated ap- proach to the qunation of establishing relations with new Indochina governments. Kuala Lumpur opposes the idea of developing ASEAN into a military alliance. The Malaysians believe that such a development would unnecessarily antagonize Asian communist states Ley suggesting that the ASEAN nations expect a military confronta- tion. Instead Malaysia intends to capitalize on ASEAN concern over Indochina by renewing its efforts to promote a Southeast Asian zone of neutrality. The five ASEAN partners endorsed this concept in principle when Kuala Lumpur.first proposed it five years ago, but few'believed it was practical in the near term. Malaysia probably calculates that recent events in Indochina will ma::e the other partners more receptive. Kuala'L'impur will argue that regional neutrality will buy time, particularly for Thailand, to cope with the changed political situation in Southeast Asia. Singapore Prime Minister Lee Kuan Yew is one of the Southeast Asian leaders most concerned about the probable extension of communist pressure onto the Malaysian Peninsula,via Thailand. In ,the past,.however, he has generally denigrated ideas of a regional defensive body as unrealistic. Lee believes guaranteed neutrality for Southeast Asia Approved .For Rel jase 2005/07/01 : CIA-RDP86T00608RO p0300110007-1 25X1 25X1 Approved For Relea is a noble but impractical goal and argues that regional security depends on 'a balance of forces between the great powers. The Philippines has not taken'a l:ublic position on the ASEAN meeting. President Marcos may well use the opportunity to renew his calls for a Southeast Asian summit conference, a pet idea of his that other ASEAN leaders have consistently rejected. Developments in Indochina will probably cause Marcos to intensify his current effort to create an independent Philippine foreign policy and reduce Manila's long-standing identification with the US. Marcos, however, shows no interest in terminating US military base rights and is therefore likely to remain cool to proposals for neutralizing Southeast Asia. Marcos may. try to turn US foreign policy reverses in Indochina to his own advanLa a, hoping to get a more favorable hearing on Philippine requests for economic and military aid as well as better terms in the ongoing negotiations over a new-base agreement. An ASEAN foreign ministers' conference, when it finally convenes; will probably produce no diplomatic surprises and :ay well be lit; le more than a group hand-holding session. Indonesia, Malaysia, and Singapore already recognize Hanoi, and Thailand will probably renew efforts to'_open a dialogue with the North Vietnamese on eventual relations. There will probably be more discussions about expanding'ASEAN: to include Indochina once the situation there has stabilized. Other 5outhea6t,Asian states have displayed little immediate concern about events in Indochina, Australia's Prime M.tni :;.er Whitlam has :publicly looked forward to the demise of 'the Thieu government and his Labor government is not uneasy over the political consejuer' s of its collapse., Whitlam probably, hopes, _ however,. that his offer of planes 25X1 25X1 Approved For;Re64se 2005/07/01 : CIA-RDP86T00608R0c(.030011.10007-1 Approved For Relea 00300110007-1 :to. help evacuate'-refugees wsll dispel any .tn outaooJc to, feel much impact from the current ''l.Australian counterpart, ie.banieally toe inauiur .not as critical, of US Indochina policies as Sts suggestions that:he is smua over the aurrnnt Ne,W n may reiterate a previous proposal that a general Southeast Asian conference--including t4 e Indochina stated--he convened once the Indochina . 25X1 Approved For ReleaO Malaysian officials have privately expressed concern over Peking's continued publication of maps depicting China's long-standing claim to the 'rseng-idu Reef--an area of shoals lying on the East Malaysian continental shelf some 60 nautical miles off the Sarawak coast where Malaysia has sponsored petroleum extraction. There is no evidence that the issue is likely at this time to disturb relations between the two countries, but it could create fric- tions sometime in the future. Since 1949 most of the South China Sea has been depicted on maps published both in Peking and in Taipei as within the territorial limits of China-- although Peking have indicated 25X1 that the map symbol is used se-claimed island groups and does not represent an official territorial sea claim. Tseng-mu Reef is described in Peking publications as "the' southernmost part of China" and within the Nan-she (Spratly) group of islands. Although Tseng-mu is not pinpointed by geographical coordinates, the term clearly. applies to an extensive group of shoals whose wester.' extremity, termed Lydie Shoals on West- ern hydrographic charts,:is located about 57 nautical miles northwest of Bintllu oa the Sarawak coast. From Lydie Shoal, numerous shoals and banks--some not named and none above mean low tide--extend east for about 70 miles. Chinese maps include most of these shoals as Chinese territory. All lie in shallow waters on the East Malaysian continental shelf. The basis for any Chinese claim to East Malaysian shelf waters rests on shaky legal grounds. Neither Teeng-mu nor other shoals and banks claimed consist of any known land area that conceivably could fit the Approved for Rel April 7, 1975 ase 2005/07/01 : CIA-RDP86T00608F00030011 0007-1 Approved For Relea - 0300110007-1 25X1 Approved For Relea 0300110007-1 definition of an "island" and thus be used to pro- vide base points for delimiting shelf boundaries. The nearest Chinese-claimed "land", appears to be Louisa Reef (Nan-tung Chiao)--actually no more than a iewrocks--located some 165 miles northeast of Lydie Shoal.,. Even if Peking's claim to Louisa Reef were recognized and the roof were used as a base point from which to allocate shelf boundaries between the PRC and Malaysia, a Chinese claim to Tbeng-mu Reef would not necessarily be valid, since a trench over 200 meters deep separates Louisa from the East Malaysian shelf. Malaysia's right to exploit seabed resources on the extensive East Malaysian continental shelf appears unquestioned, except for a curious orris ion of the East'Malaysian shelf in the 1966 Continental Shelf and-Petroleum Mining Acts. These acts claim for Malaysia shelf rights to "...the seabed and subsoil of. those submarine areas adjacent to the coast of the States of Malaya"; use of the term "States of Malaya" seems to limit legal claims only to shelf waters off peninsular Malaysia. Regardless of the ambiguities in these acts, petroleum conces- sions on the East Malaysian shelf have been granted and exploration undertaken since the mid-1960s. Sarawak Shell maintains concession rights on the shelf. A large gas field about 100 miles offshore from Bintulu, is unde+ development. Peking has. voiced no objection to past and present seabed exploration and exploitation under Malaysian auspices near PRC-claimed reefs and shoals. Nevertheless, the persistence of Chinese claims suggests Peking's interest in its South China Seas 25X1 25X1 Approved. For Rele April 7, 1975 X00300110007-1 , 25X1 E 25X1 M Approved For Releaso 00110007-1 25X1 Burma: No Win Reshuffles His Team Extensive changes in the Burmese cabinet and military command during the past several weeks indicate that although President No Win still dominates the regime, factional rivalry is contin- uing within the government. The changes include the appointment of two new cabinet ministers, a number of new deputy ministers, and the transfer of sev- eral key regional military commanders to less influential posts. Some of the shifts appear to have strengthened the role of the civilian leadership of the ruling Burma Socialist Program Party (BSPP) at the ex- pense of the army. Friction between these two elements is not new, but until now the army clearly has had the upper hand. BSPP officials reportedly believe, however, that the transfer of the regional commanders to jobs with less authority as deputy ministers was a move to increase party control over the army. The commanders allegedly had resisted BSPP guidance and party officials claim that shift- ing the men will make army officers generally more responsive to the party. The army has actually increased its-role in the regime, however, since one of the two civilian cabinet ministers has lost his post. Minister of Mines Dr. Nyi Nyi was forced out on a constitutional technicality--he did not meet one of the qualifica- tions for office. Despite his replacement by a mil- itary man, some BSPP leaders were not displeased at the change. They disliked Nyi Nyi and were jealous of his influence with Ne Win. The changes also apparently enhance the position oc General San Yu as the number two man in the gov- ernment. Several of the new appointees have close April 7, 1975 25X1 Approved For Relea P0300110007-1 IN 25X1 Approved For Relea ties to San Yu and one of the ,replaced regional commanders had been hostile to him. San Yu has long been regarded as the heir-apparent to No Win, but he is disliked by several members of the inner circle. ,No Win may have engineered the shake-up in part to play off various elements in the government against one another. After the riots in Rangoon last December, his prestige appeared to have been damaged and there were some signs that his position might be in danger.'It is,now-clear, however, that No Win re- mains in full control and that the continuing ri- valry amon subordinates is,not a threat to him. I I 2005/07/01 CIQ 1DE86TOQ608R000300~ .{DO07-1 25X1 Approved For Relese 2005/07/01 : CIA-RDP86T006084000300110007-1 25X1 INDONESIA Son of the Impossible Dream: Ambonese Extremists in Whn Nothi lands On April. 2, Dutch authorities in Arnhem an- nounced the arrest of ten Ambonesi exiles charged with plotting to kidnap Queen Juliana. The ten reportedly planned to hold the Queen hostage until their demands for independence of the south Moluccan islands in eastern Indonesia were satis- fied. The ten are members of an extremist off- shoot of the exiled Republic of the South Moluccas, a dissident Indonesian organization centered in the Netherlands since the early 1950s. Christian Indonesians from the island of Ambon in the south Moluccas provided a large segment of the East Indies colonial troops dating from the early days of Dutch administration. The Ambonese developed a special relationship with the Dutch and so firmly adopted Dutch culture and values that they were frequently called "Black Dutchmen." Ambonese troops participated in the conquest of other parts of colonial Indonesia and later served as security forces throughout the archipelago--a tradition which did not endear them to latter-day Indonesian nationalists. The transfer of sovereignty from the Nether- lands to the Federal Republic of Indonesia in 1949 created problems for the Ambonese, who had little in common with the nationalist Javanese controlling the government. More important, many Ambonese troops had fought on the Dutch side against Indonesian independence. Fearful of retaliation from victorious nationalists, dissident Ambonese rebelled against Jakarta's rule in April 1950 and proclaimed a Republic of the South Moluccas encompassing Ambon and several surrounding is- lands. After negotiations failed, Jakarta sent April' 7, 1975 -10 Approved For - .RO,Q0300110007-1 Approved For Rele troops against the. rebels--soizing the major towns within a matter of weeks, although sporadic resintrnce continued in the interior of Ambon Island until mid-1952. The cause of the doomed republic was quickly taken up by the sizable Ambonese community in the Netherlands, most of whom were former members of .the East Indies colonial army. By mid-1951 an estimated 11,000 former troops and their families had been removed to the Netherlands and placed in refugee camps. Few had any skills other than soldiering, and they proved an almost indigest- ible lump in Dutch society. Their disillusionment was and is a fertile breeding ground for propa- gandists of the Moluccan Republic. As early-as December 1952, Dutch government officials began promoting the idea of repatriating the Ambonese refugees to Indonesia. 25X1 25X1 April 7. 197S -11- 25X Approved For 9elease 2005/07/01 : CIA-RDP86T006089 000300110007-1 25X1 Approved For Rel The stickiest problem is that of second- generation Ambonese, who have become the driving force of the political dissidents.. Although the old leadership of'the Republic of the South Moluccas still appemrs on the letterhead of the Ambonese political organization, radical youth have been responsible for recent publicity- creating violence. In addition to the purported kidnap plot, Ambonese extremists carried out a gas-bomb attack on the World Court in 1974. In 1970 they had attacked the Indonesian Embassy, and such activities are a continuing irritant in Indonesian-Dutch relations. 25X1 25X1 25X1 Approved For Rel X300110007-1 Approved For R North Ko;oai Who Manages Foreign Relations? 25X1 As late as 1966, only time-tested party func- tionaries filled the ranks of the Korean Workers Party's (KWP) Political Committee. They were al- most all colleagues of Kim I1-song in the anti-Japa- nese guerrilla movement of the 1930s and were named to high office essentially on the basis of loyalty to Kim, not administrative genius. The currency of loyalty has by no means been devalued in Pyongyang. Beginning in the late 1960s, however, the Political Committee was expanded to accommodate specialists in diplomatic and economic affairs. Their promotion re- flected a requirement for new skills in handling specialized problems as well as a conscious effort by Kim II-song to integrate key government administrators into the ruling party hierarchy. tional battles.. Better educated an more W. Enter the Experts in 1966 and 1970, Pyongyang added the foreign affairs specialists who-are now full members o2 the Political Committee; the candidate members were brought aboard between 1972 and 1974. For the foreign affairs specialists, ai for the Political Committee generally, the 'distinction between full and candidate membership is more than just one of a voting or non-voting voice in formulating policy. It is also a matter of differ- ence in age and background. Kim Tong-kyu, Pak Song- chol, and So Chol, the diplomatic experts who are full members, are in their early sixties, all veterans of the Kim I1-song guerrilla band. In contrast, the candidate members--Yu Chang-sik, Kim Yong-nam, and Ho Tam--are in their late forties or early fifties. They were recruited for Central Com- mittee and Political Committee membership from the.For- eign Ministry and have no background in either the anti- Japanese movement or in,the party's early postwar fac- d cosmo olitan April 7,, .1975 Approved For Re` 300110007-1 25X1 25X1 Approved For Rele than their committee seniors, they have helped soften the rougher edger of North Korea's diplo- matic style. While their seniors have had little experience outside the communist world, these candidates have pioneered ties with the developing nations and strengthened North Korea's position in international forums. The Full Members Kim Tong-kyu, named a vice president of the North Korean government in November 1974, is the highest ranked of the six foreign affairs experts. He became a candidate member of the Political Com- mittee in 1966 and a full member at the Fifth KWP Congress in 1970. In connection with his recent assumption of the vice, presidency, Kim has appar- ently moved from ninth to fifth place in the party hierarchy. His past foreign affairs assignments include service as consul general at the nearby Soviet port of Nakhodka and director of the Central Committee's international Department. Pak Song-chol has been the most prominent for- eign affairs figure in postwar North Korea. He be- came a full member of the Political Committee in 1966 and once held fourth place in the party lineup; he is currently ranked only eighth. Pak served as foreign minister from 1959 to 1970. In 1972, he was named Pyongyang's chief negotiator on th3 North- South Coordinating Committee, set up to explore avenues of political interchange between the two Koreas. Currently first vice premier of the cabinet, Pak has broad government responsibilities that prob- ably fill his schedule and limit his iealings abroad. In the past, Pak Song-chol played an influential role in North Korean relations with Moscow and Peking. So, Chol was named a full member of the Political Committee in 1970; he follows Pak Song-chol in party .April 7j 1975 Approved For' R ease ; 00300110007-1 25X1 Approved For - 8R000300110007-1 rankings. Like Pak and Kim Tong-kyu, So Chol has recently taken on administrative chores outside the realm of foreign affairs. He is currently chairman of the KWP Central Committee's inspec- tion Committee, n, body responsible for party dis- cipline. So's pizi; assignments include tours as charge d'affaires in Peking, ambassador to North Vietnam and to Czechoslovakia, and chairman of the subcabinet level Committee for Cultural Rela- tions with Foreign Countries that handles people- to-people exchanges. And the Candidates Yu Chang-sik, now ranked first among the Polit- ical Committee's candidate members, is apparently one of the golden boys of the KWP. Soon after join- ing the. Committee in 1973, Yu became deputy to Pak Song-chol on the North-South Coordinating Committee; he held the position until January 1975. At the relatively young age of 53, Yu has achieved unusual prominence in both foreign affairs and party adminis- tration. He was vice minister of foreign affairs in the early sixties and then served as chairman of the Central Committee's Liaison Department, responsible for subversive activities directed against South Korea. Yu Chang-sik has more recently been identi- fied as deputy chairman of the Central Committee's Organization and Guidance Department, which handles all party personnel matters, and as chairman of its External Affairs Department. (The responsibilities of this newly created organ are not precisely known.) Yu's rise in January to the top ranking of the Politi- cal Committee's candidate members--from fifteenth only a few months earlier--occurred at the same time as his appointment as a secretary of the Secretariat of the Central Committee. Kim Yong-nam,,named to the Political Committee in 1974, is also enjoying rapid upward mobility. He April 7, 1975 Approved For IR0003001.10007-1 25X1 Approved For RIease 2005/07/01 : CIA-RDP86T00608R00p300110007-1 25X1 became a secretary of the Central Committee Sec- retariat early this year, rising at that time from fifth to second, place among candidate members. Kim Yong-nam's long service as a vice minister of for- eign affairs--he had prime responsibility . for rela- tions with the USSR and Eastern Europe--was punc- tuated by'tours as a deputy department chairman on the Central Committee. He has, for the last sev- eral years, been chairman of the Central Committee's International Department, which has the main respon- sibility for the formation of diplomatic policy. The political fortunes of Ho Tam, Minister of Foreign Affairs since 1970, are less clear. Ho achieved candidate membership on the Political Com- inittee three years ago; he seems to move up and, down in the upper third of the candidate roster. As for- eign minister, and earlier as vice minister, Ho has specialized in dealing with Middle Eastern and African states. He is the most widely traveled of North Korea's diplomatic specialists and is Pyongyang's chief spokesman for foreign affairs initiatives. A Rising Generation The promotion of Kim Tong-kyu and such younger menus Yu Chang-sik and Kim Yong-nam to positions of greater administrative responsibility does more than recognize outstanding talent and bring a foreign affairs weight to a broad range of decision-making. It is one of the signals of Kim 11-song's intent to begin turning the affairs of state and party over to a new generation Kim Tong-kyu, the newly appointed vice president, though the same age and background as Kim 11-song, is a decade younger than the current, seasoned team of vice presidents: Choe Yong-kon and'Kang Yang-uk. ,Choe and Kang have held their posts, in one guise or another, since the early 19509, and elevation of a April 7, 1975 -16"? 25X1 Approved Eor R ass- 200 507X}1 " " RDPC6T0000CR~ -Pa~v003pU'F ,0007-1 Approved For Relp se 2005707701 : 00110007-1 younger man to this height is a striking change. Kim Yong-nam and.Yu Chang-sik have,becomo the young- est of the secretaries of the Central Committee's Secretariats their positions are the party equiva- lent of vice premier in the cabinet. While Kim I1-song began to give the Korean Workers Party a younger cast several years ago, over the past yyear, the transformation has appeared to take on higher priority. Last month, for example, the,general secretary spoke with unusual candor on the matter, telling a conference of industrial ac- tivists that'"the old cadres...are all valuable treasures of our. party (but) three decades have passed since,liberation...and they have now reached an old age and are unable to keep pace with the rap- idly developing realities." In foreign affairs man- agem nt, at least Kim is acting to remedy the prob- lem. 25X1 25X1 25X1 Approved For Releas 25X1 Japanese Eye US Trusteeship as Oil Storage Site I F Japanese firms are considering constructing a 94-million-barrel crude oil storage facility or central terminal station in the Palau Islands, part of the US-administered Carolina group east of the Philippines. Officials claim that participation by oil-producing countries and international oil firms will be essential. The project could eventually include a refinery and serve as a transshipping point for other East Asian nations. First-stage plans call for tanks holding 30 million barrels--six days of current Japanese imports--to be built at a cost of $670 million. Japan currently has crude and product stocks of about 340 million barrels--68 days of imports--and Tokyo will try t& increase this to at least 500 million barrels by 1980. The Japanese oil companies are looking for sites abroad beca'ise of strong local opposition to building new storage,facili.ios in Japan. Besides adding to storage capacity, the Palau facility would encourage large tankers to use Indonesia's Lombok and Makassar Straits--the route east of Bali and Borneo--in preference to the shallower, congested Malacca Strait. T'kyo has become increasingly sensitive to the problems of using the Malacca Strait since a 238,000-ton Japanese tanker ran aground there in January, causing a massive oil spill. Middle East crude would be delivered to Palau in 500,000-ton tankers and then to Japan in smaller ships. About 80 percent of Japan's crude oil.imports now pass through the Malacca Strait, with only three tankers regularly using the Lombok-Makassar route. Oil industry spokesmen estimate that diverting tankers of 280,000 tons or more to the Lombok-Makassar Straits-would add only 0.2 percent to the price of oil in Japan. 25X1 25X1 The Palau protect would be loss costly than is proposal to build a pipeline and storage ilitiss in the Isthmus of Kra in Thailand. The a c l Japanese also have been considering Wilding a central terminal station in Indonesia, but Tokyo and Jakarta n ti e l o oca have yet to agree on a mutually acceptabl despite several years of negotiation. April 7, 1975 - 300110007-1 25X1 25X1 25X1