TRENDS IN COMMUNIST PROPAGANDA

Document Type: 
Collection: 
Document Number (FOIA) /ESDN (CREST): 
CIA-RDP85T00875R000300060023-4
Release Decision: 
RIPPUB
Original Classification: 
C
Document Page Count: 
26
Document Creation Date: 
November 9, 2016
Document Release Date: 
April 7, 1999
Sequence Number: 
23
Case Number: 
Publication Date: 
June 6, 1973
Content Type: 
REPORT
File: 
AttachmentSize
PDF icon CIA-RDP85T00875R000300060023-4.pdf1.14 MB
Body: 
Approved For Release 1999/09/25: CIA-RDP85TOO875ROO 000 Q0 3-4 eontuciential rB'S TRENDS in Communist Propaganda STATSPEC Confidential 6 JUNE 1973 Approved For Release 1999/09/25: CIA-RDP85T00875R0dY00 d23- 23) Approved For Release 1999/q M, iRI I'J R?85T00875R000300060023-4 This propawlwala analysis report is based exclusively on material carried in foreign broadcast and press navdig. It is published by IBIS without coordination with other U.S. Government components. STATSPEC NATIONAL SECURITY INFORMATION Unauthorized disclosure subject to criminal sanctions Approved For Release 199dI6ffdO i-'AbP85T00875R000300060023-4 Approved For Release 1999/09/25: CIA-RDP85T00875R000300060023-4 CONFIDENTIAL FBIS TRENDS 6 JUNE 1973 CONTENTS Le Duan Stay in Peking: Divergencies Show Behind Solidarity . . . 1 PRG Marks Anniversary, Welcvaes Ambassadors to South Vietnam. . . 4 PRG, DRV Score Two-Party ICCS Probe of DRV Troops in South. . . . 7 Pathet Lao Stand Elaborated in Central Committee Memorandum . . . 7 USSR-CHINA-U.S. Soviets Denounce Western Reports That They Threaten China . . . . 10 FRG-CZECHOSLOVAKIA Prague and Its Allies Hail FRG Czechos.loavk Accord. . . . . . . . 14 G:)R-FRG-USSR Honecker Reviews FRG Relations Following Brezhnev Visit . . . . . 16 USSR Decree Clamps Down on Controversial Farm Subsidiaries . . . . . . 18 Armenian Leadership Hits Nationalism, Mismanagement . . . . . . . 19 NOTE: Tr of imenko on SALT TWO . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 21 APPENDIX Moscow, Peking Broadcast Statistics . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . i Approved For Release 1999/09/25: CIA-RDP85T00875R000300060023-4 Approved For Release 1999/09/25: CIA-RDP85T00875R000300060023-4 CONFIDENTIAL FBIS 'T'RENDS 6 JUNE 1973 IND0CHI1JA In the opening clays of the Peking sojourn of the DRV delegation headed by Le Duan and Pham Van Dong beginning on the 4th, the two sides have effusively praised one another's role and proclaimed their fraternal solidarity, but their divergent interests have also been evident. Th'. Chinese have made a point of warning against outside involvement. The North Vietnamese for their part have stressed that their goals, including reunification, are "closely interrelated objectives of paramount importance" that are to be achieved "aL all costs." Propaganda on the 6 June anniversary of the founding of the Provisional Revolutionary Government (PRG) of South Vietnam reflects a major communist effort to project the PRG into new prominence in the international arena and to buttress its claim to be the genuine representative of the southern people and an equal rival to the Saigon regime. A dramatic fillip to the PRG's international stature came with the announcement that several countries, including the Soviet Union and China, had sent ambassadors to South Vietnam to present their ' -edentials. And comment on the anniversary called attention to the PRG's increasing emergence as an official government in the international arena. The unexplained absence of PRG President Huynh Tan Phat from the anniversary celebrations raises the possibility that he is out of the country on a mission to further press the claim to legitimacy. Vietnamese communist media have ignored the U.S.-DhV talks which resumed this week in Paris, while continuing routinely to complain about alleged U.S. and Saigon violations of the peace accord. Canada's announcement that it was withdrawing from the ICCS was given little attention, but the Canadian ICCS delegation was sharply criticized in PRG and DRV foreign ministry statements charging it with going beyond the limits of the peace agreement in its investigation of the presence of North Vietnamese troops in South Vietnam. LE DUAN STAY IN PEKING: DIVERGENCIES SHOW BEHIND SOLIDARITY The Peking visit of the DRV party-government delegation led by Le Duan and Pham Van Dong, now in its third day, has been shaping up along expected lines as a high-level display of solidarity and fraternity. The Chinese have warmly hailed the Vietnamese for their ",great victory" in war against the United States, and Approved For Release 1999/09/25: CIA-RDP85T00875R000300060023-4 Approved For Release 1999/09/25: CIA-RDP85TOO875ROO0300060023-4 CONFIDENTIAL FBIS TRENDS 6 JUNE 1973 the guests have reciprocated with effusive expressions of gratitude for Chinese aid. Judging from the composition of the DRV delegation, the terms of this aid in the new circumstances are a major subject on the agenda. On the second day of the visit the Vietnamese were received by Mao for what NCNA called "an extremely cordial and friendly conversation." Behind the show of solidarity, however, there have been signs of persisting divergencies in the two sides' assessment of the situation. As Chou En-lrii made clear in his speech at the welcoming banquet on the 4th, "a completely new situation" has appeared in Vietnam as a result of the peace settlement, and the principal tack now is to shore up this settlement. While routinely demanding that Saigon and the United States observe the Paris agreement and end militrnry intervention in Cambodia, Chou reserved hi.; strongest language to warn against unspecified outside involvement, declaring that "no interference in Indochina, under whatever pretext end in whatever form, will be tolerated." Chou's warning was also underscored by a remark by Mao quoted in NCNA's account of his conversation with the visitors: "Vietnam belongs to the Vietnamese people, not to the reactionaries in Vietnam, grill less to imperialism." As in Mao's remark to Romania's Ceausescu in June 1971, when he called for unity against "imperialism; and all reactionaries," the Chinese mean the Soviet Union at least as much as the United States in referring to imperialism in such an open-ended context. Apart from an extended expression o' gratitude for Chinese aid, Le Duan's reply speech on the 4th took a significantly different direction. Taking a markedly less benign view of the U.S. role, Le I)-,.;an observed that his peoples had defeated "the most atrocious colonial war that has ever been conducted" but that the "U.S. imperialists," using "perfidious maneuvers and insolent threats," are continuing to impose "U.S. neocolonialism" on South Vietnam and to aE:rpetuate the partition of Victnam. Chou had avoided impugning U.S. motives. Most notably, Le Duan came down hard on the importance the. Vietnamese attach to their goals, including "peaceful reunification" of Vietnam. In language strikingly reminiscent of that used by Pham Van Dong when the DRV premier headed a delegation to Peking in November 1971, Le Duan stressed that these goals are "closely interrelated objectives of paramount importance to be achieved at all costs, even through a hard and complex struggle." On 20 November 1971, a few days after the suspension of the round of Approved For Release 1999/09/25: CIA-RDP85TOO875ROO0300060023-4 Approved For Release 1999/09/25: CIA-RDP85T00875R000300060023-4 CONFIDENTIAL FB1S TRENDS 6 JUNE 1973 secret Kissinger-Tho talks that had been taking place, Dong had emphasized, in reference to the two basic military and political demands in the communists' seven-point plan,, that these two points "of very essential significance" were "closely interrelated." Considering the subsequent pressure from Hanoi's big allies to loosen the link between the military and political issues, Le Duan's current formulation may have been intended as much for the instruction of Hanoi's allies* as for its adversaries. At one point Le Duan made the customary acknowledgment of the support provided by the Soviets and others as well as by the Chinese. Also, in one of his toasts he called for "the tightening of the solidarity" among the communist countries on the basis of Marxism-Leninism and proletarian internationalism. Ile did not, however, echo Chou's assertion that Sino-Vietnamese friendship is based on M-irxism-Leninism and proletarian internationalism. Since the July 1971 announcement of Peking's invitation to President Nixon, the North Vietnamese have on several occasions seemed to have expressed their pique by failing to acknowledge these as the existing basis--as opposed to a desired goal--of relations between Peking and Hanoi. * Hanoi's objectives had figured in an unusual development involving Sino-Vietnamese relations several weeks ago. NCNA belatedly reported on 4 April that on 30 March Chou had received the DRV and PRG envoys for an account of the implementation of the Paris agreement over the first 60 days. Chou was quoted as expressing his belief that the Vietnamese would sucreed in achieving "peace, independence, demccracy, and national concord"-- a formulation omitting the usual reference to reunification. Hanoi's accounts of Chou's remarks omitted this formulation altogether. Approved For Release 1999/09/25: CIA-RDP85T00875R000300060023-4 Approved For Release 1999/09/25: CIA-RDP85T00875R000300060023-4 CONFI:DEt';TIAL FBIS TRENDS 6 JUNE 1973 PRG MARKS ANNIVERSARY, WELCOMES AMBASSADORS TO SOUTH VIETNAM The highlight of the PRG's celebrations on its fourth anniversary was a "grand meeting" of more than 7,000 peop1r. held at dawn in an aria under PRG control ?.n Quang Tri Province.* Assuming the trappings of a conventional national day celebration, the meeting wan atte;tded for the first. time by delegations from the DRV as well its foreign delegations from Cambodia, Laos, and Cuba and the newly appointed ambassadors from the USSR, PRC, DPRK, GDR, Poland, Hungary, Algeria, and Mauritania. Wi,:h the usual speaker, PRG President Huynh Tan Pha., notably absent, "an it.iportant speech" was delivered to the meeting by Nguyen Iluu Tho, Chairman of the NFLSV and of the PRG's Advisory Council. The speech is not yet available in translation, but according to Liberation Radio's account of the meeting it dealt with the situation and tasks of the southern people and with the PRG's stand on the settlement of internal affairs in South Vietnam. In addition to Tho, the South Vietnamese officials at the meeting included Vietnam Alliaice chief Trinh Dinh Thao and PRG Foreign Minister Nguyen Thi Binh, who was reported by Hanoi media on .' May to be on her way back to South Vietnam after a stopover in the DRV. The North Vietnamese representatives included a govern- m,nt delegation led by Vice Premier Nguyen Con, a member of the VWP S.cretariat, and a National Assembly delegation led by Nguyen Xien, a ;'ice chairman of the Assembly Standing Committee. FORiTIGN ENVOYS The first announcement that a number of countries had sent ambassadors to South Vietnam came in a Liieration Radio :,eport on 5 June which said that over a period of days ambassadors from the Soviet Union, China, North Korea, and Algeria had presented their credentials to the PRG "in the liberated area of South Vietnam." Although the PRG has sent ambasstdors to many of the 33 countries which have recognized it,** Thi;, is the first time that the locus of the celebration has been spe.cifiad. In previous years the ceremonies were described as being held in "a liberated area." Liberation Radio on 3 June broadcast a list of countries, including the DRV, which it said had officially recognized and establish.d relations with the PRG. The list included 29 nations as having made this move prior to the peace agreement and added that since then Uganda, Dahomey, Burundi, and the Republic of Guinea had joined their ranks. CONFIDENTIAL Approved For Release 1999/09/25: CIA-RDP85T00875R000300060023-4 Approved For Release 1999/09/25: CIA-RDP85T00875R000300060023-4 CONFIDENTIAL FB.S TRENDS 6 JUNE 1973 only Cuba had previously appointed an amb'ssador to the PRG. The announcement of the dispatch of ambassadors comes some two weeks after Hanoi and the PRG had belatedly criticized France for establishing ambassadorial relations with the GVN without making a similar move toward the PRG.* It seems possible that the Vietnamese waited to criticize the French until after they had assurance that other countries would send ambassadors to the PRG. The first indication of the new move was a -+ June TASS repr'rt that the Soviet ambassador to Burma, Aleksey Yelizavetiri, had also been appointed ambassador to the PRC. I4CNA the next day noted that Ambassador Wang Jo-chieh, w'no had left his post in North Yemen last December, left Peking on 28 May and presented his credentials to the PRG on 3 dune. PRG reports on the activities of various ambassadors in some cases additionally noted the appearance of embassy secretaries and attaches, thus further suggesting the intention to establish a permanent presence in South Vietnam. The Cuban ambassador is now referred to as "dean of the diplomatic corps." He presented his credentials to FRG Foreign Minister Nguyen Thi Binh in Paris in June 1969 and later reportedly traveled to South Vietnam but did not remain there. His return to South Vi.attiam was first noted in a 5 June Liberation Rddio report that he had been received by Mime. Binh "recently, in a PRG-controlled area." HANOI COMMENT Hanoi greeted the PIZG anniversary with more than usual fanfare, marking the event with a "grand meeting" on 4 June attended by Politburo members Truong Chinh and Nguyen Duy Trinh. No meeting was held last year, although Truong Chinh did pa:, an anniversary call on the PRG representation in Hanoi, and the anniversaries in 1970 and 1971 were marked with recept~.ons given by the PRG and attended by DRV Politburo members. As usual, North Vietnam's government leaders sent a message to Nguyen Iuu Tho and Huynh Tan Phat and, as has been the case in most years, the anniversary was hailed editorially in the Hanoi press. The Hanoi meeting was sponsored by the Vietnam Fatherland Front and the Hanoi Administrative Committee and was addressed by Foreign Minister Trinh and Nguyen Van Tien, head of the PRG's special * Vietnamese communist comment on the French action is discussed in the TRENDS of 31 May 1973, pages 9-10. Approved For Release 1999/09/25: CIA-RDP85T00875R000300060023-4 Approved For Release 1999/09/25: CIA-RDP85T00875R000300060023-4 CONFIDENTIAL FBIS TRENDS 6 JUNE 1973 representation in the DRV; in addition, Truong Chinh offered brief opening and closing remarks. Both of the main speakers sought to demonstrate the PRG's increased stature: Trinh, for example, cited the recognition of the PRG by foreign governments and its participation as a member in the July 1972 nonalined conference, and claimed that the peace agreement and the act of the international Vietnam conference "confirmed the decisive role" of the PRG in the settlement of internal affairs in South Vietnam and its "prestige and important position in the inter- national arena." Trinh's routine allegations of U.S. and Saigon violations of the accord included the claim that Washington and Saigon were "gning so far as to refuse to recognize and then to eliminate the PRG." Charging that "neocolonialism" continues in the South despite the peace accord, Trinh promised that the North must therefore continue to "perform its duty" to the South "until neocolonialism is completely wiped out of the southern part of our country and until our fatherland is reunified and the South and North are reunited." Both Trinh and PRG representative Tien referred to the PRG as the only representative of the South Vietnamese people--a characterization that ""as been pressed since the peace ?ccord. And Tien added that the PRG is the "supreme authoritativ- organ reflecting the will and deep aspirations of all strata" In the South. At another point, Tien also asserted that the "victories" in the past four years had "consoli-lnted the role and great power and simultaneously reflect the stability and strength" of the PRG as "a government that is really of the people, by the people, and for the people and that the entire people strive to defend and build." The 6 June NHAN DAN editorial reviewed the progress of the struggle in the South in past years and claimed that the Paris agreement had fulfilled the most important objectives mentioned in the NFLSV platform and the PRG's 12-point program of action. This "great victory" of the "national democratic revolution," according to the paper, has caused a great change in the balance of forces and "created conditions for advancing toward the achievement of other objectives." Echoing themes brought up in Trinh's speech, the editorial also lauded the PRG's international position and promised DRV backing until reunification is achieved. CONFIDENTIAL Approved For Release 1999/09/25: CIA-RDP85T00875R000300060023-4 Approved For Release 1999/09/25: CIA-RDP85T00875R000300060023-4 CONFIDENTIAL FBIS TRENDS 6 JUNE 1973 PRG, DRV SCORE TWO-PARTY ICCS PROBE OF DRV TROOPS IN SOUTH Foreign ministry statements fiim the PRG and DRV, on 1 and 3 June, respectively, assailed both the Caradian and Indonesian ICCS delegations for their investigations -regarding the resence cf North Vietnamese soldiers in the South. The statement pointedly noted that the Paris accord makes no mention of North Vietnamese troops and accused the Canadian delegation of misusing the ICCS to carry out activities that far exceed the limitations of the agreement. The statements did not go Into detail about the activities of the Canadian and Indonesian delegates, instead cryptically referring to investigations and reports in the Da Nang area on the "so-called case of 'North Vietnamese prisoners of war."' They held that the investigation violated Article 18 F of the agreement and Article 9 A of the protocol on the ICCS which stipulate that the commission sh:~ll operate in accordance with the principle of consultations and unanimity. The Canadian delegation has been criticized by the communists since mid-April when Ilanoi scored remarks by its chief, Gauvin, taking part..cular umbrage at a statement he made alluding to the presence of North Vietnamese troops in the South.* The Indonesian delegation has not previously come under attack, and the current statements carefully disassociated the action of the Indonesian ICCS team in Da Nang from the policy of the Jo.karta government, citing a report that the Indonesian Foreign Ministry said its ICCS teams were not instructed to join the efforts of the Canadian delegation on this question. Hanoi duly reported Canada's announcement on 31 May of its intention to withdraw from the ICCS. The only other allusion to the announcement came in a 1 June article in the army paper QUAN DOI NIIAN DAN which criticized the British Foreign Office for a statement that DRV and PRG refusal to cooperate with the ICCS compelled Canada to withdraw. PATHET LAO STAND ELABORATED IN CENTRAL COMMITTEE MEMORANDUM The Lao Patriotic Front (LPF) Central Committee marked the passing of 100 days since the signing of the cease-fire agreement by issuing a lengthy, 31 P`ay memorandum on the status of the LPF-RLG * See the TRENDS of 18 April 1973, pages 4-5. Approved For Release 1999/09/25: CIA-RDP85T00875R000300060023-4 Approved For Release 1999/09/25: CIA-RDP85T00875R000300060023-4 CONFIDENTIAL FI3IS TRENDS 6 JUNE 1973 negotiations. The memorandum differs from an LPF Central Committee statement of 23 April--60 days after the cease-fire agreement--in its detail regarding LPF proposals during the prulonged talks with the RLG. Substantial detail regarding the LPF positions was first supplied in a series of four Pathet Lao radio commentaries from 17 through 20 May, and the memorandum now elaborates on those broadcasts. The memorandum, which was released at press conferences in Vientiane, Sam Neua, and Hanoi on 1 June and disseminated by LPF media on the same day, was notable for its explicit criticism of Premier Souvanna Phouma. While propaganda in the past has referred critically to "rea,:tionaries," the memorandum now said that Souvanna Phouma and other RLG negotiators have tried to avoid discussion of "essential questions" and have "shown no sincere desire for a settlement." They were accused of changing their minds "too often," modifying proposals "again and again," and advancing "very absurd claims.'' The memorandum also castigated the United States and the RLG for violating the cease-fire provisions of the February agreement and attacked the United States for instigating the RLG to procrastinate in the negotiations. The document accused the United States of engaging in "perfidious maneuvers" to ostensibly transfer Air America and the Lao "Special Forces" to RLG control in an attempt to circumvent stipulations in the agreement for their disbandment. It also revealed that on 7 May a U.S. serviceman had been captured by LPF forces while engaged in a mission to direct groups of commandos introduced into the zone under the control of the "patriotic forces" to conduct acts of sabotage. Pathet Lao media have not yet identified the serviceman but Hanoi and East German media have quoted an LPF official in Hanoi as saying that he is a major attached to "the U.S. Special Forces in Laos." LPF POSITIONS In addition to repeating, the negotiating positions outlined in the May series of Pathet Lao radio broadcasts,* the memorandum offered new information which can be summarized as follows: + The International Commission for Supervision and Control should not be granted powers not assigned to it under the 1962 Geneva * The TRENDS of 23 May 1973, pages 7-9, discusses four Pathet Lao radio commentaries from 17 through 20 May which revealed LPF positions on the possible creation of a deputy premier post, the distribution of ministerial portfolios, the functions of the proposed "National Political Coalition Council," and the neutralization of Luang PraL:ng and Vientiane. Approved For Release 1999/0,911-ADP85T00875R000300060023-4 Approved For Release 1999/09/25: CIA-RDP85T00875R000300060023-4 CONFIDENTIAL FBIS TRENDS 6 JUNE 1973 agreement. The RLG wants an enlarged commission to assume additional duties, which would be "incompatible with the sovereignty of Laos." 1- Territorial areas in contention between the two sides should be delimited "to avoid further conflict on the basis of respect for the regions controlled and administered by each side." The RLG "wants to take advantage of the absence of boundaries and cease-fire lines to avoid the recognition of the existence in Laos of two zones controlled by two sides." + The RLG should allow "hundreds of thousands" of civilians held in "so-called refugee camps" to return to homes they left as a result of U.B. bombing and RLG military operations. By refusing to grant approval for their return, the RLG is denying their "economic and political" rights and "democratic liberties." (With the future elections in mind, the LPF obviously wants to bolster its vote-getting position by enlarging the electorate in areas it controls with released refugees.) CONFIDENTIAL Approved For Release 1999/09/25: CIA-RDP85T00875R000300060023-4 Approved For Release 1999/09/25: CIA-RDP85T00875R000300060023-4 CC::FIDENTIAL FBIS TRENDS 6 JUNE 1973 USSR-CHINA-U, S. SOVIETS DENOUNCE WESTERN REPORTS THAT THEY THREATEN CHINA With Brezhnev's visit to the United states in the offing, Moscow has again expressed acute sensitivity to having its China problem put in a triangular context that could limit its leverage in big-power relations. A statement issued by the Soviet embassy in Washington and supported by press comment denounced Western press reports concerning a Soviet threat to China. Concurrently. Moscow his chose;^ this time to present a wide-ranging critique of '::inese foreign policy, including a warning that Peking's raising of territorial questions could trigger chain reaction which would undermine the international uv?tem that has emerged since World War II. Earlier, a Soviet broa..:ast to China offered a notably gloomy assessment of Sino-Soviet relations, flatly asserting that no progress has-been achieved in the border talks. The Soviet embassy statement,* released on 1 June, denied what is said were recent reports in the American press that "diplomatic intervention by the United States has averted an inevitable nuclear attack" by the Soviets on China. In an allusion to ongoing East-West negotiations, the statement closed by observing that such "provocative" reports "have nothing in common with the interests of international detente and peace." It also noted that these reports are similar to remr ks made recently by an unnamed Chinese leader to American journalists. The Soviets may have been prompted to issue this denial by reports on the book by John Newhouse on the SALT negotiations that is being serialized in the NEW YORKER. These reports have highlighted the book's assertion that the Soviet Union had approached the United States concerning joint steps to forestall any military actions by the Chinese. The embassy statement has been followed by press comment similarly directed at rebutting the portrayal of a Soviet threat to China. On 3 June PRAVDA carried a commentary by N. Sablin taking exception * Several statements and protests have been issued by the embassy in Washington in recent years, most of them dealing with Jewish activities directed against the Soviets in the United States. A statement issued on 6 June denied reports that the Pentagon papers had been handed over to the embassy. CONFIDENTIAL Approved For Release 1999/09/25: CIA-RDP85T00875R000300060023-4 Approved For Release 1999/09/25: CIA-RDP85T00875R000300060023-4 CONI- IDENT[AL FBIS TRENDS 6 JUNE 1973 to n UI'I report from London linking the Soviet troop buildup along the Chinese border with the Soviet diplomatic offensive in the West. PRAVDA quoted the report as saying Moscow's "c!+plomatir offensive in Europe and the United States" is prompted by the Kremlin's desire to gain freedom of action against China. Sablin observed darkly that "there are no f w leaders" in the West who would like to put the Soviet Union and the PRC on a collision course and "to wa':m their hands on this." APALIN ARTICLE The wide-ranging critique of Chinese foreign IN IZVESTIYA policy, by C. Apalin in the 2 June ;morning issue) of IZVESTIYA, follows the familiar script used by the Soviets in recent years in their effort to discredit Chinese policy now that it has hec)me more formidably flexible and effective. Thus Apalin argues that the Chinese h2 c sought to adapt to circumstances by "complex tactical maneuverinb" while keeping their "strategic course unchanged." A-cording to Apalin's analysis, the Chinese are trying to destroy the existing system of international relations in their pursuit of great-power hegemonistic goals. All of this is familiar enough in Soviet anti-Chinese polemics, including charges that Peking is seeking allies from among even the most imperialist forces in order to isolate the Soviet Union as the number one enemy. The Apalin article is notable, however, for its use of the border question in elaborating the line that the Chinese are enemies of detente. \ccording to Apalin, the Chinese have recently been "feeding certain circles in certain countries with inflammatory material for stirring up nationalist pass~?_,