THE NEW ESPIONAGE AMERICAN STYLE

Document Type: 
Collection: 
Document Number (FOIA) /ESDN (CREST): 
CIA-RDP84-00161R000400210071-9
Release Decision: 
RIFPUB
Original Classification: 
K
Document Page Count: 
9
Document Creation Date: 
December 23, 2016
Document Release Date: 
February 20, 2014
Sequence Number: 
71
Case Number: 
Publication Date: 
November 22, 1971
Content Type: 
OPEN SOURCE
File: 
AttachmentSize
PDF icon CIA-RDP84-00161R000400210071-9.pdf1.07 MB
Body: 
Declassified and Approved For Release @50-Yr 2014/02/21 : CIA-RDP84-00161R000400210071-9 t7. %;\ T,7,1 Li? ',Pa 110iNAGE AMERICAN 'STYLE ? p tis k.ttr NoV, iv? ? One day in (he fall of .1962, President ;. John F. Kennedy summoned his top intelligence advisers to the White House y for .an urgent conference. Russian silos had been discovered in Cuba, andy in planning the .U.S. response that was shortly to unfold as the Cuban missile:: crisis, it was essential to have the most !. -accurate possible estimate of the Soviet capacity for nuclear war. The chiefs of military intelligence arrived from the !? - Pentagon with elaborate tables showing the latest projections of Russian rocket t. - power: .if the U.S.S.R. had produced all the missiles it was capable of producing,; they indicated, the American advantage I in a showdown would be perilously slight. The man from the Central Intel- ligence Agency, on the other hand,.. brought a single. piece of paper. This spare document revealed that the Soviet arsenal was in fact much weaker than t had been feared?and thus John Ken-1 ncdy discovered that he had the muscle. to twist Nikita Khrushchev's 'arm in the confrontation that lay ahead. t? The source of this crucial information was Oleg Penkovskiy, a colonel in Soviet military intelligence Who had been pass- ing vital Russian secrets to the West for sixteen months, only to be caught in No- vember 1962 and executed six months later. He was a brave but .not particu- lady admirable character, a vain neurotic who liked to dress up in British or Ameri- ? can colonel's uniforms that Western telligence .gladly lent him during his oc- casional trips outside the Soviet Union; . once, when he was in London, he even demanded?unsuccessfully?to .. be pre- sented to the Queen. But he is a figure of the .very front rank in the history of . American intelligence?not only because .. he was the secret hero of the Cuban mis- sile crisis, but also bccaUse he was very possibly one of the last of a vanishing , species, the big-power super-spy. For the American intelligence game ., has changed, radically since Oleg Pen- kovskiy's time?the secret agents have dwindled in numbers and their secrets . have declined in importance, the cloaks have turned into computers- and the dag- gers into satellites. Technology is the new order of the day: where men once riskorl ihnir lismc ES% -Declassified and Approved For Release @ 50-Yr 2014/02/21 CIA-RDP84-00161R000400210071-9 Declassified and Approved For Release @50-Yr 2014/02/21 : CIA-RDP84-00161R000400210071-9 "V:101.1eSrpl ' 17111?00.! ,r/1 t? c,11.tio.ki ?.?: V, ,?,.. ! 1,.. ;$ ????? ? 4-.. ? ....e. .. ? -:-.. ,.... ? ? I'. ? ?? --'7.::?: -- ...... P ../ . \ .....:.s.--7- ... '''''''' .1111,1111111 I. ';;. '......? ? 1,1111.1011,10 I. ? ? ..t. IIIIIIIitifiiiIII: ? ......,....,...,?i _v....I ._..........._ .... WilliIIIIIIIV , ? ? - ..- ? . ? . ? .. `, IlliiiiIMQ.,? , ' ...-?-? - ." ' S..,%, ... ? ''........'. s." ,11..'..r. ,......... . . ,..... .-......i1.1'. 1 ???? s ? ,..?...?.. '????? ? . 9. s'IiiiIiiiiiiii:IIIIiii..1 i ? III: I. i; fl il il : 11 ; ; : i : lif IRO I Illii1111101 ) iillillilllielltili: . . ' ? ? ? IIIIIIiIIIIIIIiel . , IIIII;i111.11Ii..%4. . nerypted communications: The sign o headquarters in the Langley woods low weapon or chart his order of battle, )rbiting cameras and oyer-the-horizon ra- lio scanners -now deliver most of the lesired information untouched by hu.; nan hands. In the once glamorous ranks the CIA, the patriotic adventurer has :ism way to the earnest academic. And llireaueracy has transformed what began is an amateurish happy few into a prawling intelligence conglomerate en- :canvassing more than a dozen govern- nent agencies, 200,000 employees and a budget of some $6 billion a year. Feats of Prediction On the surface, it has been a remark- ably successful transformation. The man .'ho has presided over it, CIA .director lichard Helms (page 30), enjoys one of he most exalted reputations in Wash- .ngton. U.S. intelligence wins high marks, :oo, from the secret services of its allies: -ince they shook their heads over its ? Jumbling at the Bay of Pigs, now they -..'nvy its technological wonders (page 38) and admire its feats of prediction?the 3oviet invasion of Czechoslovakia, for ex- ample, and Israel's quick victory in the ;ix-day war. The Pentagon papers cred- ited the CIA with the most hardheaded and accurate official assessments of the war in Vietnam, and even some of its left-wing detractors were obliged to ad- mit that the spooks seemed to be doing something right. The old accusation of an "invisible government"?fueled by the revelations of CIA funding of the Na- tional Student Association?has begun to fade, and the agency reports that its college receuitments are back to normal... But all is not well within the intelli- gence brotherhood. Criticism has sprung up from the unlikeliest of quarters?, within the government itself. In Congress, the once-tame intelligence "watchdogs" have begun to growl with a certain menace. ?'hen such old Senate friends as Allen Ellender and John Stennis start talking about cutting intelligence budg- ets, when the House Armed Services Committee authorizes public hearings (scheduled for next year) on the CIA N ? '? ?? \, .1? ? .--?????,r i Jr III.s..1?.$ ..... .1;te..i.;?1CII. for the first time, it is time for even as peerless a Washington pro as Helms to look to his defenses. More serious still, the White house has -expressed its displeasure with certain features of intelligence work. A fortnight ago, Mr. Nixon moved to bring its quality and costs more lightly under control. He invested Helms with new authority to oversee all the intelligence agencies, par- ing away budgetary fat and professional. overlap wherever possible. With Helms elevated to super-spyrnaster, day-to-day operation of the CIA fell to his deputy, Lt. Gen. Robert E. Cushman Jr., 56, of the Marine Corps. And in the White House, Mr. Nixon solidified Henry Kis- singer's power to evaluate intelligence reports and, in particular, to make them more responsive to the needs of the policymakers. Outwardly, these maneuvers might ap- pear to be a mild bureaucratic rebuke to the intelligence community; their real punch was delivered in a supersecret Presidential "decision . memorandum" spelling out Mr. Nixon's dissatisfactions and desires in meticulous detail. His ma- jor complaints are faulty intelligence, run- away budgets and a disparity between a glut of facts and a poverty of analysis. Though the President holds Helms and his agency in generally high regard, he has been irritated by a series of intel- ligence community failures. The SALT talks had to be delayed for months while the White House tried to sort out dis- crepancies between the various agencies on how well the U.S. could detect pos- sible Soviet violations of any arms con- trol agreement. Estimates of the Viet Cong supplies that used to flow through the Cambodian port of Sihanoukville were off by several orders of magnitude, and there was a complete failure to pre- dict the ferocity of North Vietnamese re- sistance to the ill-starred campaign in Laos early this year. The elaborate com- mando raid on an empty North Vietnam- ese prison camp at Son Tay 'still rankles, and the White House blames the intelli- gence community for not catching sooner Plototoa by Wally MeNamee?Newawy..k the Russian-built surface-to-air missiles that suddenly sprouted in the Middle East cease-fire Zone in 1970. Some of these gripes may conceal mis- takes more properly laid at the Adminis- ? tration's own ? door. Intelligence officers insist, for example, that they gave clear - warning that Egypt would use the cease- fire to strengthen its forward defenses, but that the policymakers chose to ignore them. In any case, Mr. Nixon seems in- tent upon removing all possible bugs from the intelligence system as it faces - what is likely its most critical test of re- cent years: Solving the mystery- of the ' apparent Soviet missile build-up.? Secret of the Silos For about a year, the Russians have . been digging new silos at their missile. sites, some of them bigger than any holes they have ever dug before. -What is go- ? ing to fill them?an improved version of . the giant SS-9, accurate enough to knock out the U.S.'s underground Minutemen,. . or perhaps some entirely new missile with capacities as yet unknown? And what intent lies behind these develop- ments?are the Soviets possibly striving. . for a "first-strike capability" that would . break the current nuclear standoff be- tween the two superpowers? Upon the ? - answers to these questions hinge several key U.S. decisions?in the SALT talks, in the Middle East, in .defense budgeting. "We are at a moment of transition, a very critical moment," says a top Pentagon -planner. "Either the Soviets slow down, or we must speed up." The technological boom in intelligence gathering has produced a cascade of raw data without any accompanying im- provement in methods of analysis. In the intelligence trade, where according to ancient tradition, an apparently insignifi- cant fact may offer the key to some vital revelation, there seems to be an irresist- able- urge to collect all the. information possible?and the age of the satellite, the computer and the hypersensitive radio has transformed the pool of available . factlets into a mighty ocean of data. The Novemi Declassified and Approved For Release @ 50-Yr: 2014/02/21 : CIA-RDP84-00161R000400210071-9A Declassified and Approved For Release @50-Yr 2014/02/21 : CIA-RDP84-00161R000400210071-9 glut has surpassed the human capacity to absorb-4'01e), had roumus filled with data that WVIVIII analyzed because there was no analyst on the payroll to do it reports ono Administration aide who recently in- vestigated the intelligence agencies. veh.a.s awns, (lw nwre availability of an in fact creates um overwl 1elm- . ing temptation to report it, even %Olen it can be of no possible use. The secrets that intelligence uncovers often seem to serve the interests of human curiosity rather than national security. Some Prcsi-. dents are delighted by these idle revela- tions?John Kennedy and Lyndon John- son used to love poring over raw intelligence reports?but not, apparently,. Richard Nixon. - ? Every morning not long after dawn, a black- P1\111?1'01 from the CIA rolls through the southwest gate of the White House bearing a stiff, ? gray, legal-size folder marked President's Daily Briefing. 1 /7- wmuy helms: Farewell to the glory days It is a compendium of the most secret ? reports on world developments of the past 24 hours, and only three other copies are delivered: one to the Secretary of State, one to the Secretary of Defense and one to the Attorney General. Henry Kissinger carries the President's copy in- to the Oval Office about 9:30?but or- dinarily the *President doesn't even bother to read it, he simply asks Kis- singer to summarize the highlights. Mr. Nixon does tuck it away with a batch of memos for his evening reading, and he may?or may not?read it later. Only rarely does Kissinger succumb to the temptation of giving the President a tidbit of raw intelligence: one item that he did deliver was the news from Hanoi that the North Vietnamese had loosed a band of roving barbers on search-and-shear missions' among the city's long-haired youngsters. Mr. Nixon is simply not interested in secrets for their own .sake. All too often, the White House complains, intelligence reports fail to supply the analytical THE COOL PRO WHO RUNS THE CIA Iii his 1)111S1 ripe blItilliVSti MIR With porket. koidkerchicf flourishing just so, Bich- ard McGarr:ill Helms at 58 epitomizes the American meritocracy. Ire could bo an urbane corporation counsel on Wall .Street, butt in fact he oversees the world's most IllaSSiVe intelligence complex, and the new directive from President Nixon, ? charging the 'director of the Central Intelligence Agency with face-lifting the entire -American spy effort, only en- hances I lelms's awesome authority. No other intelligence chief in the ?vorld is so patently visible. Even NATO allies do not admit owning a man like Helms, although his counterparts exist. "Europeans accept ? that government . should operate in a covert way," suggests a British diplomat, "but answerability is the whale point of your system. So I sup- pose a Richard Helms must have an official and open existence." In more than five years as CIA 'director,: Richard Helms has emerged as a bureau- crat of cool 'competence. It is not surpris- ing that Helms should appear so serene while much of official Washington throbs with self-conscious activity.? lie joined the CIA at its birth and grew along with it, the first director to rise through the ranks. He has been privy to almost every CIA triumph and fiasco since 1947, and those 24 years have taught him survival, not just overseas but back in Washington, too. "To succeed in this town," he once told a friend, "you have to walk with a very quiet tread.' Candor, within the obvious. limits of ? his job, has become a Helms trademark. He maintains a cozy liaison with tradi- tionally suspicious Congressional commit- tees. Says a Senate staffer: "Committee members find him the most forthright of. all the administrators who come before - us. He is certainly more frank in his- - field than Mel Laird is when he comes to talk about the Defense Department." Helms's professional detachment was taxed during the Johnson days when Walt RoStow massaged intelligence reports submitted to the President by under- lining in yellow crayon whatever but- tressed his own persuasion. But Helms .sidestepped any confrontation. He was so self-effacing that an LBJ lieutenant recalls: "I thought he had the personali- ty of a dead mackerel. But he certainly had the respect of the President." At .White House lunches under LBJ, Helms assiduously avoided venturing in- to policy decisions. "If he had the facts," says a participant, The presented them quietly and quickly without any great fanfare or interjection of his personal opinions. If he didn't have the facts, he would admit, 'I don't know about that, Mr. President, but I'll try to find out the answers as soon as possible'." . ? Under Helms, the CIA delivered. Part- ly as a consequence, :he is among the few ? holdovers from the Johuson era in a It Wadlingion poq today. His ciithadc escalating OA ter:1,1,01(4w expvum:s thoh, with a rwailting budget reduetit; ingratiated him with President Nixon.; If the spymaster's more dramatic e pleits reinain shrouded, I 1111114 dropped clues aplenty to his personalit The son of an expatriate aluminium (ace'. utive, young Dick was educated at pol schools in Switzerland and Germany, la it waS at Williams College that he bega to show the kind of sober purposefulia: that has marked his career. By the tirr. be graduated in 1935, 1 [elms -had editd the yearbook and the newspaper, servo as junior and then senior class preside; and earned his Phi Beta Kappa kc Awed classmates voted him "most rt spected" and "most likely to succeed Through a friend's father, Helms himi tied a job in the Berlin bureau of Unite Press (now UPI) and as a 23-year-oh cub correspondent scooped up an ei elusive interview with Adolf Hitler. Aftc two years, Ifelms returned home to th business. side of the now-defunct Indian apolis Times, working up to nation: advertising manager. While there, h married Julia Bretzman Shields, a highi strung sculptress divorced from the Ba; basol shaving czar, Frank B. Shields. Into the Spy ? Establishment With the war, Helms completed Nav: Reset* training at Harvard and, 1943, volunteered for the Office of Stra tegic Services. IIc wound up at war' end working for Allen Dulles in Berlin After the OSS was dismantled, Helm followed Dulles into the embryonic Cen tral Intelligence Agency.. Helms quickl tuned in to the politics of the cold wai (When. a Russia-bound ? Williams clas mate wrote him inquiring about Commu nism in 1959, Helms whipped off 43-page typed analysis of Communi5 aggression, which he entitled "Convers:i tion with a Doubting Thomas.") For fifteen years, Helms disappeare into the CIA's "plans" section, the et phemism for the group-. handling covet activities. In 1962, he took over th section. He was bypassed for director i favor of outsiders, but in mid-1966, aftc a stint as deputy director, was final] appointed by Johnson to run the CIA. But as Helms's public fortunes rosi his home life deteriorated. In June 1961 after 2S years of an increasingly unhapp marriage, Helms left his wife. They wer divbrced in September 1968. Thre months later, he married a former neigl bor, Cynthia Ratcliff NIcKelvie, the mod- er of four children and herself new] divorced from a prominent surgeon. Though he earns $42,500 a Year, ti Helmses live frugally in a $22.6-a-mout high-rise apartment in Chevy Chasi Md. English-born -Cynthia, a hands= 30 neclassified and Approved For Release @ 50-Yr 2014/02/21 : CIA-RDP84-00161R000400210071-9 Newswee: Declassified and Approved For Release @50-Yr 2014/02/21 : CIA-RDP84-00161R000400210071-9 Is redhead, works part-time for the Smith- sonian Institution's radio stati(m.?She is also a dedicated ecologist who helped found Concern. ?a washington con- servation group that focuses on recycling. Cynthia Helms has even converted her husband. Now everything they buy must come in biodegradable containers:- Helms knows how to leave his prob- lems at the office and he. can ll sleep sou.a? ly at night. "I know when Dick has had a had day just because he looks that was. when, he ism," home;" Cynthia Helms told NEwswEEK's Elizabeth Peer, "but I also know he's not going to tell me about -it." Before dinner, he drinks a Single Scotch. On Fridays, be abandons himself to a dry Martini with a lemon twist; Cynthia trots out -beforehand .to buy the weekly lemon. Once a week they take in a movie. Helms also enjoys reading spy novels sent by his son, a New York attorney. 'Weekends, the Ilelmses Commute to Wit's End, Cynthia's shore cottage in Lewes,.Del. Security precautions .are elaborate but imperceptible. A CIA specialist periodi- cally combs ? the Chevy Chase apartment for ''bugs." The phone number is unlisted, though it appears in the Washington social register. Helms also has a direct line to CIA headquarters. A third phone, to the White Ifouse, was taken out (luring an LBJ economy drive. helms is second only to Henry Kis- singer as a prize catch on the Washing- ton social circuit?partly because it's chic to have a master spy to dinner' and partly because he is such an attentive companion for the ladies. Washington din- ner parties invariably degenerate into shop talk, and Helms is in no position to chime in. So he finesses the situation. "He. has that nice quality of letting a woman talk, too," says ?Mrs. jack Valenti, wife of the - former LBJ aide. helms used .to carry a pocket-size beeper So ? 4,ta I. ;... . , r..L..4:,1 ? 1. bridges that a polieymaker needs to cross the gap from information In dcckinii. Tht; word has liven pie...(d c011ect fewer facts and asse!.s diem more lilly. And the flew Kissinger review panels ? are de-? signed not, as some .crities suggw.ted ? last week, to sereen mit views contrary to - Administration policy but to draw in more information in a form that is useful. Overruns and Overlaps . Technology has also infected the in- telhigetireieiueits, as it has the Penta- gon, with cost overruns. "The overruns . on these satellites," says a horrified White . I louse staffer, "make the (-GA transport ? plane It like .a piker." Modern spying does not come cheap, the Administration is quite pmpared to admit, but neither does it require the extravagant overlaps , between different intelligence agencies or the excesses of trivia amassed in the name of thoroughness. I fence Helms's reinforced powers as intelligence super- ? chief, with authority to oversee other -.? agencies' budgets and to reorder their l? priorities. Neither Richard Helms nor Richard .? Nixon wants to weld the intelligence gatherers into a single streamlined mech- anism. The President, according to one i? of his aides, "has given careful thought to what degree diversity in the intelligence -? community is an essential luxury of a . democratic society." If there were only a single agency and if on some crucial point its information were wrong, this staffer warns, "by God, it would be all ? over. Having some diverse views coming to the White House as they do now means one intelligence service is effec- ? tively acting as a check on another." So the revamped order of battle of the in- tchhigctice community (chart, page 32) -7'? will probably endure for some time.. Its main intelligence-gathering ciimponents: NATIONAL SECURITY AGENCY: ,These are the code breakers. They. sponge. up the secret arimmunications. of foreign governments (both friendly and other- - wise), feed them into what is probably the most elaborate computer system any-. where in the world iind reportedly boast remarkable success ill cracking the most complicated modern ciphers.. They also. devise the encrypting systems used by the U.S. Government. The American world lead in computer technology gives the U.S. a sizable edge over the Soviets - in this critical area, but it is shrinking. NSA's staff of linguists, analysts and ?? mathematical wizards, is based behind a? ? dense security .curtain at Fort Meade, Md., but it also directs a network of elec- tronic surveillance throughout the world. DEFENSE INTELLIGENCE AGENCY:..De- fense Secretary Robert McNamara de- '; vised this outfit in 1961 to try to consol- - idate the various service intelligence _ units. Unfortunately, says one. former - top intelligence official, it was "a brain- child that died at birth." The three serv- ice units still exist separately, and DIA limps along with officers on loan and without much power of its own. Accord, November 22, 1971 31 . Declassified and Approved For Release @50-Yr 2014/02/21 : CIA-RDP84-00161R000400210071-9 ? - Ws, it). At eNn m er?Nr whwer k Wife Cynthia: A lemon every Friday the agency could always summon him, but "the damned thing kept going off during the middle of dinkier parties." - So CIA technicians have devised one that now Vibrates discreetly instead. 'Let the Wordsmiths Handle That' ? Helms logs a ten-hour workday, with a half-day Saturday. Sometimes he rises ?? early to play tennis, wearing long white flannels even in muggy summer. Then a black Chrysler takes him to the.CIA cam- pus across the Potomac in Langley, Va., where he rides a private elevator to his cream-colored office. 'After perusing the 'overnight reports, Helms meets his top aides for 9 a.m. coffee in the conference room. lie dislikes long meetings and can dismiss a subject with an impatient: "Let's let the wordsmiths handle that." The agency structure is still informal ? enough that a vital field report can reach Ilelins's desk minutes after it arrives, but Helms insists that all regular memos be tight, literate and neat. Before he leaves- at 6:30 p.m., he reads over the ititchli- gcncc summary to be given the Presi- dent the next day.. In reorganizing the intelligence net- - work, Helms will have less time for agency routine, (bough he has been able to assume important new responsibilities without having to surrender many old prerogatives. Henry Kissinger still stands . between him and President Nixon, but a White House aide notes: "Henry re- spects Helms as much as be respects anyone around here." Indeed, Richard Helms may yet be able to parlay his position into the sort of lifetime tenure enjoyed by j. Edgar Hoover at the FBI. "Richard Helms has to be the real pro in government today," says one top intel- ligence ?specialist. "He's not the big operator like Allen Dulles and whether he's the manager that John McCone was we're going to find out. His brief has . always been cool, careful professional- ism.' At a time when the United States seeks a lower profile abroad, Helms's cal- ibrated touch may be 'exactly what the. American intelligence effort needs. ? ? liernard Clolfryd?Newsweek _Helms at play: Flannels year-round Declassified and AP-proved For Release @ 50-Yr 2014/02/21 : CIA-RDP84-00161R000400210071-9 .1 ! ,!?"` "n. t! ? r f????;,, r?????? ? . ; E 1 i ?oz I; 1.; or AIIII :Oral Y of I:a C40,11,110N - DEFENSE DEPARTMENT NATIONAL SECURITY AGENCY National Cryptologic Command The code makers and the code breakers; 20,000 staffers, mostly at Fort Meade, Md. ..??????? 01.11Mkalidar???11,...?... NATIONAL SECURITY COUNCIL The basic cloci:,ion?makIng body. All In. tellInimco for tho Pritnitlent Vows through tho NGC and ita chief, I lonry Kissinger. NSC Intelligence Committeo A now unit headed by Kissinger. Its job: to give assignments to the intellinence community and to 'review' tho results. Net Assessment Group Another now panel, to make specific com- parisons of power balances In the world. U.S. INTELLIGENCE BOARD Tho board of directors of the intelligence community. All agencies have a seat st the table; Helms ol tho CIA Is tho boss. DEFENSE INTELLIGENCE AGENCY Designed to coordi- nate military Intelli- gence. Direct budget ? of $100 million; spends an added $700 million 1 through armed forces; 5,500 staffers. ? ARMY 38,500 Intelligence staffers; budget of $775 million; does most of its spy work for the NSA. il???? CENTRAL ? INTELLIGENCE . AGENCY Tho premier intelligence agency. Budget estimated at S750 million: Staff of 15,000. Evaluates much of the Input of DIA and NSA. 4.4111?11.1?1????101.11.0 NAVY 10,000 Intelligence staffers; same budget as the Army; has phased out spy ships. AIR FORCE 60,000 staffers; 52.8 ? billion budget, mostly spent on spy-satellite program. A , FORE:lc:a I 1 1. ItITELLIGEItc,i: . Ariviz.;oisY ii0A,F{D fltitn-ritihon nrivi:.ory 1 pan4:1; mrint'. bimonthly., i 'FORTY COMMITTEE' OR '303 GROUP' A secret panel, chaired by Kissin- ger. advise:. the President on 'W- yatt operation:. INTELLIGENCE RESOURCES ADVISORY COMMITTEE A spin-elf of the Intelligence Board, headed by Helms, de- signed to pare down budgets. STATE DEPARTMENT Intelligence and Research Bureau Tiny but authoritative; headed byes-CIA man. FEDERAL BUREAU OF INVESTIGATION Main responsibility for do- mestic counterespionage. 1 "ATOMIC ENERGY COMMISSION , Interprets data on global nuclear developments. I . TREASURY DEPARTMENT Focuses on drugs and economic intelligence. ing to one former Air Force man, the worst features of the American intelli- gence system are here' on most glaring display: it is, he says, "like some giant vacuum cleaner picking up millions of pieces of lint that we store in our compu- ters." Recently, DIA has trimmed itself down and toned itself up a bit, but there is more to be done. Just this month, a new post?Assistant Secretary of Defense for Intelligence?was created for precise- ly that purpose. ARMY, NAVY AND AIR FORCE INTELLI- GENCE: These are the big spenders. Some $5 billion of the $6 billion-annual intelligence budget pours out of military .coffers, but this is because the services manage most of the vast hardware in- volved; the Air Force, with the recon- naissance satellite program, carries the main load. If major budget cuts aro to be made, they will fall most heavily here: Senator Eilender, for example, has de- manded that $500 million bo trimmed forthwith. . STATE DEPARTMENT INTELLIGENCE 32 AND RESEARCH DIVISION: No spies need apply here; INR's main sources are For- eign Service officers in U.S. embassies abroad. It scores high on analysis, but CIA's technological tricks give the agen- cy a huge advantage that has recently left INR farther .and farther behind in the competition for the President's ear. A former top CIA man, Ray Cline, was made head of INR, and its star may rise again. FEDERAL BUREAU OF INVESTIGATION: All counterspying against foreign agents within the U.S. is conducted by the FBI. Besides the obvious defensive benefits, counterespionage can yield important clues to the limits' of an enemy's knowl- edge by spotting the targets of his spy- ing within your own . borders. "In one ease a few years ago," recalls a counter- intelligence agent, "we traced a pattern of Russian efforts to obtain data hero that gave us all Illmoluto picture of their level of development in long-range sub- marines." Unfortunately, during the de- clining years of J. Edgar Hoover's reign, l'i?rtga & the quality of FBI- counterspying has deteriorated sharply, and working rcla- tions between the bureau and the CIA have grown distant and strained. CENTRAL INTELLIGENCE AGENCY: This, ; of course, is the hub of the American in- telligence universe. Its director is chief not only of his own agency but also?even before Mr. Nixon's latest directive rein- forced his powers?of the entire U.S. information-gathering 'enterprise. Its cm- ; 'ployees compose what is very likely, with the possible exception of the Mafia, the most closed corporation in American society. The road to their sprawling ? headquarters in the woods of Langley, Va., is marked with a modest sign an- nouncing Fairbank highway Research ? Station (a Transportation Department agency that does indeed maintain an, :outpost nearby). They work together,' play together and sometimes live to.: gether; they go A0 Ow same (bet ors and.: ? if need be, to the same psychiatrists:, their talents and triumphs are rarely; -sung outside the agency's walls and ? ? Newsweek, November 22, 1971 ' Declassified and Approved For Release @50-Yr 2014/02/21 : CIA-RDP84-00161R000400210071-9 Declassified and Approved For Release @ 50-Yr 2014/02/21 : CIA-RDP84-001167R0004dor2r1101677c1-9 "?? not even vitliiii them: even when .? quit. their friemls can never quite sure that they are not simply estab- ing a deeper cover. The CIA is not a fession; it is a way of t is a changing one, however. In the .1-war days?from the CIA's founding 19.17 until, say, the mid-I960s---its Pllasis was on covert operations. on -Mg and, as they came to be nick- tied; "dirty tricks." The mainstay of ? agency then was the officer overseas. ? bribed the local journalists to plant ries favorable to the United States guess I've bought as much newspa- space as the A&P," chortles a former A man), or quietly helped bankroll a movement that might be of. use Ile day (the headquarters that Charles Gaulle maintained in Paris until his urn ? to power in 1958 was partially .ided by the CIA). The -CIA man eckcd on private lives or credit ratings see who might be blackmailed or ibed into working as agents. (The cuts who volunteered, such as Pen- vskiy; were almost always the best-- :hen you buy a spy," points out a vet- an, "you're really renting him until. mcone comes along who offers him ore money.") Pursuit of a Red Face The old-time agent kept an eye on the ussian opposition, with occasionally. :nosing results. "I .remember only too , ell," recalls a British secret agent, 'one ccasion when I was on post in Berlin lid we were given the word that a. ace' [Soviet double agent] was coming i. My brief was to follow him, to pick im? up at a certain house near the bor- er. This I. did, and I stayed- with this hap for days.. Thought I was really on o something. He appeared to have ac- ?ess to U.S. military HQ in Berlin and recdom of the embassy in Bonn. My )cople were getting terribly excited ,bout the whole thing. We eventually liscovered that the chap I was following vas CIA, and be was following me, send- ng in reports about my access to the Iritish Embassy, and so on. Never located die face, either. ' Occasionally there was derring-do of a more momentous nature?some of it welt-known by now. There was the 1953 coup in Iran that returned the Shah to power- and thus .kcpt rich oil fields from the Russians, the Guatemala uprising in 1954 that-overthrew a leftist government, the 1955-56 Berlin tunnel through which. U.S. operatives tapped the telephones from East Berlin to Poland and Moscow ?Helms had a hand in planning and executing this affair. And many exploits have remained ob- scure. There was, for example, the here- tofore untold story of successful intrigue in the Congo. Early in 1961, Antoine Gizenga sprung from the motley ranks of Congolese politics to make his bid for dominance of the infant republic. He had attended the Prague Institute for African Affairs, had 'spent six weeks in Russia Newsweek, November 22,1971 .!?rte. Preadirtii Daily lirkf The meilium and the message: Henry Kissinger and the top-secret PIM and was clearly; as Washington. saw it, Moscow's new man in the Congo. Qum- - ga broke away from the United Nations- backed Congolese Government and set ? up a regime of his own in Oriental Prov- ince, arming 6,000 troops with smuggled Russian guns and paying them, thanks to ? Soviet financing, at the princely rate (for Africa) of $180 a month. The word was sent out from the White House authoriz- ing covert operations to stop him. ? It was clear to the. CIA that Gizenga's -Russian support?both the money and the weapons?was arriving via the Sudan, and a message ? arrived from friendly Euro- pean agents that a Czech ship was bound for Port of Sudan with a cargo of guns disguised as Red Cross packages for. refugee relief in the Congo. A direct. appeal to the port authorities to inspect the crates would never work, the CIA's man in Khartoum realized; the Sudanese would have to be faced with public ex- posure of the contraband. Appropriate arrangements were made on the wharfs before the Czech ship docked. "If my memory serves me right," a former CIA man says, "it was the Second crane load. The clumsy winch operator let the crates drop and the .dockside was soddenly covered with new Soviet Kalashnikov rifles." , ? That left the money. By late in 1961, Gizenga's troops had grown restive: they had not been paid since the first Soviet subsidy arrived months before. Gizenga appealed to Moscow, and KGB opera- tives obligingly delivered $1 million in .U.S. currency to Gizenga's delegation in Cairo. From an agent who had pene- trated Gizenga's Cairo office, the CIA learned that a third of the money was to be delivered by a courier who would take a commercial flight to Khartoum, wait in the .transit lounge to avoid the baggage -search at customs, and then proceed by another plane to Juba, a town on the Congolese border. Plans were laid accordingly. When the. Congolese courier arrived in Khartoum and settled into the transit lounge, his suitcase between his knees, he was startled to hear himself -being paged and ordered to proceed immedi- ately to the -customs area. After a mo- Declassified and Approved For Release @ 50-Yr 2014/02/21 ? Tony Rollo?Newkwc.k . ment of flustered indecision, he took the bag over to a corner and left it unob- trusively near some lockers before leav- ing for customs At that point, a CIA man sauntered out of the men's room, picked up the suitcase, and ? headed out the back 'door where two cars were waiting with motors ?running. - Not long afterward, Gizenga's government fell; it was said that his troops suffered from shortages. of arms and were upset because ? they hadn't been paid. Rule of the Knights Templar ? . These were the glory days, ? albeit overcast now and 'then by disasters such... as the Bay of Pigs. ?A rousing sense of mission invigorated the agency then, the camaraderie of unheralded warriors on a lonely battlement of the free world. Few would have expressed it quite that way? spies are an urbane lot on the whole?but that was the spirit of the fraternity, and it called forth a special breed. Mostly East- ern and Ivy League, often well-born and. moderately rich, they were moved by a -high sense of patriotism and a powerful undercurrent of noblesse oblige. Many of them were veterans of the elite Office of , Strategic Services under the colorful "Wild Bill" Donovan during World War II, and they carried forward its . high esprit. Men such as Allen Dulles, Kermit Roosevelt, Frank Wisner, Richard Bis- sell, Tracy Barnes, Robert Amory and Desmond Fitzgerald?the "Knights Tem- plar," one former colleague calls them? ruled the agency in the cold-war days' and set its adventurous tone. But this created problems. The bright young men attracted into the agency tended to assume that the road to ad- vancement lay strewn with "dirty tricks." Trained to bribe, recruit and suborn., that. is precisely what they did when they were sent into the. field, even when the 37 : C IA- R DP84-00161 R000400210071-9 ; Declassified and Approved For Release @50-Yr 2014/02/21 : CIA-RDP84-00161R000400210071-9 THE BEEP, BUNK AND THRUM OF SPY GADGETRY on a mountain top outside Taipei, a U.S. Air Force Chinese-language specialist tunes his radio receiver in on mainland China's air-defense network and starts a tape. Across the continent, a supersonic aircraft called the SR- ( for strategic reconnaissance) 71' streaks along the Soviet border, its "side-looking" radar recording elec- tronic "pictures" of a missile installa- tion 50 miles inland. Somewhere over the Arctic, a giant "Big Bird" recon- naissance satellite ejects a film pack containing close-up photos of still an- other installation; the film is snatched in midair by a rendezvousing plano-. and whisked back to a U.S. air base for analysis. Around the world?and above it?whole battalions of super- sophisticated devices, beeping and blinking and thrumming round the . clock, provide the electronic eyes and cars of U.S. intelligence. The nation's arcane arsenal of gadg- etry includes the massive $1 billion code-breaking and data-storage com- plex that the National Security Agen- cy operates from its Fort Meade, Md., headquarters?one of the largest conglomerations of computers in the world. But the bulk of the costly hardware is arrayed on the frontiers of the Communist world where the American intelligence-gathering proc- Css actually takes place. Targets: The Air Force's SR-71 is the chief spy ?plane in the arsenal?a 2,000-mph, extremely high-altitude successor to the U-2. The U.S. long ago stopped intelligence flights over China and the Soviet Union. But the SR-71 still cruises the borders of both nations, loaded with cameras and side-looking radar that can pinpoint intelligence targets (often selected by ? the Cl A) many miles inland. Nowadays, however, most of the peeping is done by Air Force satellites stuffed with an astonishing assortment of gadgets. They are equipped with black-and-white, color and TV cam- ? cras, of course. But in addition, these eyes-in-the-sky carry sight "sensing". devices, including infra-red cameras for night photography, radar to peer through cloud cover, radiation count- ers to detect nuclear explosions, heat sensors to record rocket launches, and even an experimental infra-red sensor and microwave radar to detect a sub- merged nuclear submarine by tho slightly warmer water it leaves in the wake of its reactors. The new mainstays of tho U.S.'s skyborne early-warning system aro multipurpose Project 0.17 surveillance satellites. Working in pairs, these "constellations,", as they are called, sweep across all of European . Russia and the Asian land mass in "dwelling" Declassified and Approved For Release orbits 22,000 miles high. On board is still more equipment for sniffini; out nuclear blasts and rocket firings?as %yell as long-range TV cameras to flash instant pictures back to intelligence centers on earth if a blast or a launch- ing goes off. ? 'Bird': The most recent addition to U.S. reconnaissance snooping is a. 10-ton satellite called "Big Bird,' first launched at Vandenberg Air. Force Base in California last June. Streaking . through its orbit, Big Bird scans broad land areas with one wide-angle cam- era, radios what it sees back to ground stations; and, on order, turns a ? giant "narrow angle" second camera on targets of special interest for close- up pictures?a: multiple function that used to require at least two less so- phisticated satellites. One of Big Bird's first orders: to find and fix the dozen or so medium-range ballistic missile sites believed to be deployed through- out. China. And it probably did: cam- . narnese officers radioed to their troop,.. The major portion of America's ra- dio intercept intelligence probably derives horn a super sensitive, global -network of ground stations like the one the Air Force maintains at Onna Point, Okinawa, 10 miles north of Kadena Air Base. Here, inside a win- dowless concrete compound on a crag- gy coastal promontory, Chinese-lan? guage specialists, Morse code "ditty catchers" and tactical analyst's man banks of radio consoles round the clock. Their job, and that of more than 50,000 Army, Navy arid -Air Force specialists like them at listening posts scattered Irma Wiesbaden, Ger- many, to the tip of the Aleutians, is the. tedious, detailed and never-end- ing surveillance .of the armed forces of potential enemies?their strength, .whereabouts and 'disposition. ? One -measure of how well they do their. job is .the fact . that language specialists have been known to identify an enc- Tin' high-spying S11.-71: In an arcane arsenal, super-eyes and -cars .eras in satellites 100 miles high can clearly photograph objects on the ground the size of small cars (though tales of pictures of anything smaller are most likely. science fiction). For communications interception? which some experts say accounts for 90 per cent of the nation's raw intelli- gence?radio and radar gear take the place of cameras in satellites.. These orbiting cars (called "ferrets") are capable of piclang up every form of electronic communication except those sent on land telephone lines and line-of-sight microwave transmis- sions. They can .read radar pulses from ground stations and in-flight mis- siles as. well. They are joined in the skies by so-called "Black Air. Force" aircraft?usually lumbering old C-121 Super Constellations that can tarry in one area for as long as six or eight hours and carry far heavier, and fan- cier, equipment than the swift SR-71. Th, Navy has mothballed all its Pueb- lo-typo intelligimco ships. But ? ono experimental Navy Super Connie dubbed "The Blue Buzzard" was em- ? ployed in Vietnam- as an airborne re- lay station that could cut in on, and countermand, orders that North Viet- . my unit commander by nothing more than a regional accent in his voice. But as good as the techniques of collection are, there are, problems of n in Says oe senior in officer: "You can't tell strategic or political intent from a photograph. And you can't tell what the enemy may have on his drawing boards." The astonishing escalation of in- genious gadgetry over the last decade has caused still another problem?in- formation overkill, A Special Presi- dential team reviewing the intelli- gence community discovered that 95 per cent of the estimated $6 billion spent annually was going into intel- ligence collection, only 5 per cent . into analysis?and Washington's intelli- gence headquarters were being inun- dated with mountains of perishable,. unsifted information. The report was one of the key elements leading to the President's decision to reorganize the intelligence community. ?wero trying to monitor everything all over the ss-odd," explains Senate .Armed Services Committee Chairman John Stennis. "We simply don't need to keep sight of every blade of grass. and every grain of sand." . @ 50-Yr 2014/02/21: CIA-RDP84-00161R000400210071-9 tin?rtr.ttni r Declassified and Approved For Release @ 50-Yr 2014/02/21 : CIA-RDP84-00161R000400210071-9 "Ow farm," a secret baining base oh the East Coast where they :114: V 1.001((1 iii various techniques ol Ilit !.py game: voiles, flows, agent handimg., wcatoinrY, demolition and handio?liand combat, Ind the vast majorii y of reertins lire. boinal for 1)1)1, and a life centering in the huge CIA compound iii 'Langley, The agency. encourages claimishoess.- "There's ma: street in MeLean la suburb next ?t1)-1.angley1 where the cotire block is filled with CIA types," one spy says. More important, set:laity precautions dic- tate a certain motherliness. "From die day you start your career," a veteran . .says, 'you're encouraged to go to the 'agency for help, to tell them everything." If a CIA employee gets into trouble? drunk driving, for example?he is told to call the agency's Security. office immedi- ately. If his house is robbed, he's to notify. security 'before the police. If he. gets into financial problems, the agency has a benevolent fund to help him out. ? ? It buys .hint theater tickets, advises his.: children On where to go to college, se- lects security-cleared physicians and psy- chiatrists ...(and 'requires :.a fellow CIA man to be on hand during any, treatment rcipiiring an anesthetic.. that might in- ? duce loose talk), offers him guidance on stock-market investments, provides an indoor *gym, athletic teams and even na- ture walks: ? ? ? No Room at the Top There is a certain insulation about it -all?and, some critics say, about its work. as well. With the rapid expansion of .re- eent years, layers of bureaucracy have begun to clog .the channels along which.- ? raw ? intelligence flows ?upward. And ? . there is very little new blood corning in at the middle levels or the top; the agen- cy has a logjam of twenty-year men, Agency people are also sometimes ac- cused of one of the oldest of spies' fail- ings?refusing to believe anything unless it has been iliscovered Some voices within the government are'?-? now calling for a radical shift toward , 'candor in almost all intelligence work.. They argue that the great bulk of the in- formation that CIA and the .rest of the..: spy network gleans ought to be made: public to anyone- who is interested. At the 'same time, virtually all covert para- military operations?the dirty tricks? should be abandoned entirely. In effect, this is a new and expanded version of President Eisenhower's old "open skies" plan. It rests upon the propo- sition that dirty tricks generally do more harm than good to the nation's interests, and that intelligence does most for the cause of ?peace when its fruits are dis- played for all to see. Most American strategists have long since accepted the . notion that the world is made safer and more stable when each of the superpow- ers knows a fair amount about what the other is up to?the U.S. makes no real effort to conceal the full range of its mili- tary power from the Russians. Why not, ask - the new advocates of open skies, ii 1;11 frua,,7,4 the damage to American prestige great if they were l'slIOS(11. 1):11'11C- v as the c111,1 war wam,(1 aml as liology look OVVr 1110 most critical the host thing that most agvilts id (mold do was nothing at all, bitt was not what bright young advenlnr- iiad in mind, and so they began to or not to apply ill 1111` III'S' 1/lace. 1111S a critical shift of both personnel kinction -took place within the agen- inring the latter 1960s. In part it was ittiral evolution, in part encouraged the new director, Dick Helms. The :s of attentiOn and prestige \vithin . switched from 1)1)1' (for Deputy ?elor?Plans, the covert operations) to 1 (Deputy Director?Intelligence, .the nnation-sifting unit). The prime re- . ts were no longer bright young Social ister types blit state university Ph.D.'s. Amon CIA recruitment manual is lied to, among others, biologists, lor- is, aerodynamicists, artists, cartogra- rs, geologists, geodesists, mathemati-. is.. and, astronomers. Our -people," . ins --(who himself. was once head of : IP). boasted in a rare public address . : year, "have academic degrees in 298 ?-? fields of specialization:" A former lligence man marvels that "when you the agency even the most obscure 'slim, they always trot out some little . lady who has made that subject her study." Exit the Tennis Players still exists, ? of course, but the . tehword. for operatives in the field. is ? as one wag puts it, "Don't do some- ng?just stand there." As for the type person attracted into this side Of the.. IN a former agency man speaks wryly . the "change from tennis ? players to viers." Many of the dirtier tricks in - .Anam?notably the "Phoenix" program it used torture and assassination to try root out the Viet Cong infrastructure vera assigned to temporary "contract"? (silts: retired Army officers, Special aces spinoffs or former Stateside po- einem Since 1969, however, the agen- has cut back on these activities. CIA insiders say it has given up the up business entirely, though there are my who arc convinced that it had a Ind in the Creek colonel's take-over in )67 and the overthrow of Prince Si, inouk in Cambodia last year (at least the extent of not blowing the. whistle plots of which it was aware). A few !ars ago, Can. Joseph Mobutu of the Ingo tried to interest Langley in a itsch against the Marxist regime in razzaville across his western border, but .c agency was not interested. This is not because it has lost the Ca- Icily for such enterprises. It has, after 1, been not so secretly training, equip- :ng and virtually leading a 95,000-man -my in a reasonably successful war in .aos for nearly a decade. It is currently inploying a Washington firm as a cover ). train frogmen to sky-dive into a lake and blow up ?11 1111rp (1.1111. Ali(1 it has concocted a delightful little rose lo spread disaffection against the csilid Si- hanonk among the Cambodian peasantry that once revered 111111. A gilled sound engineer using sophisticated electronics has fashioned an exCellent eminierfeit of Ole Prince's voice?breathless, high- pitched and full of giggles. This is beamed from a -clandestine radio station in Laos Nvith messages artfully designed to offend any good. Khmer; in one of t hem, "Sihanimk" exl a nis young WI/1111111 ill "liberated areas" to aid the cause by sleeping with the valiant Viet Colig. ? But this sort of escapade is far less Ire- quent these days, and some top agency hands gladly accept the charge .that the ? 'ovember 22, 1971 ????? ? UP' Cushman: Minding the shop CIA has turned. into -a group of gray bureaucrats. Things may have been more exciting during the Dulles years, there may have been an ?n in those days that has faded now, but it was this ?n that helped produce the. Bay of Pigs.. The agency may have become less color- ful, according to this view, but this simply marks its passage from exuberant ado- lescence to responsible maturity. However staid a bureaucracy the CIA may have become, there are still some very peculiar features of going to work there. First of all, one of the prerequi- sites for employment is a lie-detector test. "The lie detector is the big hurdle," recalls a former spy. "Guys are really scared of that, scared of what it will show. I remember a friend of mine had stolen some money when he was-running his fraternity's 'soft-drink concession. He was so worried it would show up that be told them. "They said, 'Oh, that's OK. Glad you told us.' He's still with the agen- cy." The agency is not particularly prud- ish about its staff, unlike the FBI or the KGB. "It doesn't mind the flawed gen- ius," a onetime employee says. "It will overlook an individual's aberrations?as long as it receives complete loyalty." Once In, DDP candidates are &yin to ? 39 Declassified and Approved For Release @50-Yr 2014/02/21 : CIA-RDP84-00161R000400210071-9 _ Declassified and Approved For Release @ 50-Yr 2014/02/21: CIA-RDP84-00161R000400210071-9 NAT. IONAL AFFAIRS ? carry this philosophy of disclosure one step further? It is almost surely too soon for that; ? ;. perhaps it would never be practicable. The. world still has its ugly secrets, and it ? . is probably best for .everyone's peace of mind that most of them are kept in private. But the very fact that the (pies- t ion is being put is a sign of the wrench king ? ? adjnstments that American intelligence ? - has had to make in its long metamorphosis ???? ? from the (lays of Wild Bill Donovan and 1-.? the Knights Templar. Today, the. fear- some weaponry of the two superpowers ? has grown NO sophisticated that virtually ? no,intclligence coup, no matter how extra- ?? ordinary, could alter the balance of pa- . ?? ? tential destruction on both sides. Tho.? .? gaudy era of the adventurer has passed in the American spy business; ? the .bu- reaueratie age of Richard C. Helms and , his gray specialists has settled in. . Declassified and Approved For Release @ 50-Yr 2014/02/21 CIA-RD P84-00161R000400210071-9