SOME GUESSES ABOUT THE NEXT KREMLIN CONSPIRACY

Document Type: 
Collection: 
Document Number (FOIA) /ESDN (CREST): 
CIA-RDP80B01495R001100030010-9
Release Decision: 
RIPPUB
Original Classification: 
K
Document Page Count: 
13
Document Creation Date: 
December 19, 2016
Document Release Date: 
December 21, 2005
Sequence Number: 
10
Case Number: 
Publication Date: 
March 1, 1969
Content Type: 
MAGAZINE
File: 
AttachmentSize
PDF icon CIA-RDP80B01495R001100030010-9.pdf2.7 MB
Body: 
12 Approved For Release 2006/01/17 : CIA-RDP80B0149S 495W01 1000300 The Easy Chair by John Fischer SOME GUESSES ABOUT THE NEXT KREMLIN CONSPIRACY If you are a gambling man, you. might want to bet a few dollars that Russia will have a major change in government before the year is out. At reasonable odds -say four-to-one, which is the least you ought to get on any guess about the So- viet Union-that could be an interesting speculation. Such is the advice I've been getting lately from people who make their living by watching the Soviet leaders and try- ing to figure out what they might do next. Some of my best friends are Krem- linologists, professing their arcane sci- ence for the government or universities or, in a few cases, in private practice. Since I have been an amateur Kremlin- watcher myself from time to time, and have on occasion been able to pick up scraps of information for them, in re- turn they sometimes tell me what they are thinking. They seldom agree; but recently most of them have been hinting --with the well-hedged caution. which is also characteristic of race-track touts and stock-market analysts-that some time in the fairly near future they ex- pect a shift in the top levels of the Rus- sian oligarchy. They also are uncommonly close to agreement about the reasons why such an upheaval seems likely. The current ruling clique has made too many blun- ders; and throughout Russian history whenever a regime piles up an intoler- able number of mistakes, it eventually topples. The recent blunders are not the result of stupidity or incompetence. On the contrary, Leonid Brezhnev and Alexei Kosygin, the co-bosses of the Kremlin, are by all accounts intelligent and experienced politicians. Their mis- takes probably were unavoidable, again for historic reasons. Russian govern- ments, whether Czarist or Communist, the outside world. And they always have had even more difficulty in adjusting to the currents of change, both inside their own country and beyond their borders. As Milovan Djilas, the former Yugoslav Communist leader, recently pointed out, "a revolution cannot change a nation, its tendencies and qualities and traits." Consequently, Djilas suggested, the pres- ent regime can best be understood as a "continuation of the Czarist bureau- cracy," with all its built-in rigidity and inertia. Moreover, the Communist society has no provision for an orderly, periodical change in command; and under its one- party system there is no such thing as a legitimate alternative government. So any change has to be accomplished by conspiracy and intrigue, often accom- panied by violence. Only a few hours before his overthrow in 1964, Nikita Khrushchev remarked to a French diplo- mat that "a political leader should never leave power of his own free will." At that very moment his friends and colleagues in the Presidium (earlier known. as the Politburo) were conspiring to remove him against his will. He went, literally screaming and cursing, but with a whole skin. Khrushchev's own climb to power a decade earlier was not so bloodless. He told the story, while he still was at the top of the heap, to a Western diplomat with whom he had become particularly well acquainted. One evening after both of them had put away a good deal of vodka, the diplomat said, "You know, one thing I never understood was how you managed to get rid of Lavrenti clay without his bodyguard. I shot him." Because he is a discreet and honorable man, the diplomat never repeated this story until long after Khrushchev's forced retirement, and so far as I know it has not been previously published. But the fact that he told it at all is an indica- tion of Khrushchev's impulsiveness and overweening self-confidence. These characteristics were evident enough when I first met Khrushchev just after the end of World War II. He was then boss of the Ukraine and a fairly junior member of the Politburo, the apex committee of the Communist hierarchy. I was a member of a mission overseeing the distribution of United Nations relief supplies in the Ukraine. In his dealings with the mission, Khrushchev showed some engaging traits : an apparent open- ness and candor, at least as such things are measured in Russia; a sense of humor; a willingness to experiment; an impatient eagerness to get things done. At the same time he was prone to bully- ing his subordinates, and anyone else when he thought he could get away with it. (The Napoleonic syndrome, common among short men, especially when they come from humble beginnings.) He loved to embark on bold new projects, and then lost interest in them before they got well under way. And he seemed to me appallingly reckless. For example, he arranged a formal banquet-grotesquely formal, with candlelight, three wines, in- numerable carafes of vodka and brandy, Beria. With his absolute control of the Mr. Fischer is the author of "Why secret police, I should have thought he They Behave Like Russians" and other " books, and was editor in chief of this would be invulnerable." should have been," Khrushchev serving ngne this for quarter as ter as Regents Ryearsegents years. Pro fess- always have had trouble in estimating replied, "but he made one silly mistake. sor at the Santa Cruz campus of the what effect theirA ~SV ~r` ~I dS~ ~~ / 10. e r BBO9'4 RObi"fo ad10 for?aia. Harper's Magazine, March 1969 004.1 dllw, Approved For Release 2006/01/17 : CIA-RDP80B01495RO01100030010-9 theater and opera, incidentally giving salaries to many performers. It can put out standard cheap editions of classical American writing. It can revive the use- ful "applied" art of the WPA, with mod- est stipends and no questions asked. It can radically decentralize the unas- signed TV channels and give millions a chance to speak and perform; and it can operate one public channel of high stand- ard information and entertainment, like the BBC First Program. . . . And not least, in the sciences, instead of dispens- ing the present gigantic budget entirely through great institutes, universities, and corporations, government could give hundreds of thousands of small grants to inventors and scientists without in- stitutional connection, to increase the scientific pool; we might occasionally turn up a Faraday.... PAUL GOODMAN Oceanic Institute Waimanalo, Hawaii Fourth-party Rumblings In "The Man Who Ran Against Lyn- don Johnson" [December], David Hal- berstam has recorded more background on what has inelegantly been dubbed the "Dump Johnson" movement that any other author to date. At one point, how- ever, Mr. Halberstam's account is fac- tually incorrect. His decription of the meeting of the Coalition for an Open Convention on August 25, 1968, attributes "fourth-par- ty rumblings" to Marcus Raskin and me. The statement is half-right. Mr. Raskin was already involved in organizing a fourth party. At the meeting in ques- tion, I stated that the difficulties already encountered by Mr. Raskin's signature- gatherers proved once more the futility of minority-party politics in the United States. It would have been quite inconsistent of me to make "fourth-party rumblings." I worked informally with Al Lowenstein and Curtis Gans since the summer of 1967 in the "Dump Johnson" movement, and worked within SANE for its organ- izational support of such a movement, which was forthcoming in October 1967. In January, 1968, SANE became the first national organization to support Eugene McCarthy. By August 25, the movement had gone further than I had dreamed possible a year earlier and we were about to organize the New Demo- cratic Coalition. If Mr. Halberstam's in- formants detected "a defeated quality" to the August 25 meetings, that feeling did not encompass all of the partici- pants. SANFORD GOTTLYEB Executive Director, SANE Wash '0m%%1l. FEdr Want to get the feel of Europe? Take the wheel of a Citroen. Order your Citroen now for delivery upon ar- rival. Place your order through your author- ized Citroen Dealer or through Citroen Cars Corporation. Or see your travel agent. Your car will be delivered to you directly from the Factory. It's your assurance of getting the most reliable European Delivery plan, and the ------------------------------------- Citroen Cars Corporation Dept. 9HA-3 East: 641 Lexington Avenue New York, N.Y. 10022 West: 8423 Wilshire Boulevard Beverly Hills, Calif. 90211 Please send me your free brochure, on Fac. tory direct European Delivery of Citroen Cars. Name biggest Factory-direct, tax-free savings. Address Financed Purchase-Repurchase plans also available. For full information, write for our free European Delivery brochure. State Zip ------------------------------------- THE METHOD, A BIT DIFFERENT... THE TASTE, TRULY DELIGHTFUL An adventure in perfection, Melitta is made by an all-new. three-minute filter method that's especially designed to deliver nothing but pure coffee taste and goodness, Gone are the fats and oils, the bitter after-taste. Melitta-made for the appreciative people with above average coffee tastes. Melitta-for those who will put that little extra (like our filter pa- per) into making coffee. Melitta-for the higher-ups who want a little more than the extra-ordinary.At gourmet shops, 14 Approved For lease 2006/01/17 : CIA-RDP80B01495, p01100030010-9 This Steinway 'was started June 15, 1968. This Steinway will be finished June 20,1969. A year may sound like a long time to work on one grand piano, but Steinway has proven that's how long it takes to make a fine musical instrument. Of course, we could save a lot of time if we didn't make the Steinway Accelerated'Action. (But then Steinway wouldn't have its unique responsive touch.) Or if we didn't kiln dry the wood before and after gluing. Or didn't hand condition the felt in every hammer for truest tone. Or go through the months of precision voicing and tuning. The reason just about every great pianist you can think of chooses Steinway isn't because it takes a year to make it. It's because of the way it sounds when it's finished. Which is really the only reason anyone should ever buy a Steinway. Steinway & Sons and a footman in eighteenth-century cos- tume behind each chair-for the U. N. mission and the senior members of his own staff. Before the end of the dinner he was so drunk that he launched im- promptu into an offensively belligerent speech, became incoherent, and finally had to be helped out of the room, glassy- eyed, by two of his military aides. At the time it seemed improbable to me that such an unstable character would ever become the supreme ruler of the Soviet empire. Obviously I was wrong-as I have been in a good many other calculations about the Russians. But his instability and impulsiveness did lead eventually to his overthrow. How his downfall was accomplished is a breath-catching story, as full of sus- pense and Byzantine intrigue as any es- pionage novel. All of its details probably will never be known, barring some cata- clysm which opens up the secret archives of the Kremlin. But the fullest account yet available has recently been published under the title The Fall of Khrushchev (Funk & Wagnalls, $4.95) by William Hyland and Richard W. Shryock. It de- serves more attention than it has re- ceived so far, because of what it tells about the inner workings of Soviet poli- tics-and because it suggests, obliquely, how the next change of regime may come about, and why. The book probably is a thinly-dis- guised intelligence document. Its authors are identified only as "longtime students of Soviet affairs" who are "currently employed by the federal government." That smacks of the CIA or one of its companion agencies; if the authors were, say, State Department men, one would expect more explicit information about their rank and credentials. Internal evi- dence indicates that they are veteran Kremlinologists, thoroughly familiar with material such as obscure Russian publications and the tapes of Soviet broadcasts, which would not be easily available to anyone outside the intelli- gence establishment. And they write in the standard jargon of the intelligence appreciation, a style unmistakable to anyone who has read or worked on such reports. If this suspicion is correct, it does not reflect on the value of their work. A number of books-the Penkov- skiy memoirs in this country, for exam- ple, and the Philby story in Russia- have been published with the known encouragement of the respective national intelligence agencies. They are none the less illuminating for all that. Stalin's death in 1953 was followed by two years of infighting and secret ma- neuver within the Soviet power struc- SMOM19003PA'IAT96 Khrushchev had Approved For R Aft Approved For Release 2006/01/17 : CIA-RDP80B01495RO01100030010-9 ::.listen: there's a hell of a good universe next door; let's go. e. e. Cummings said it. And he himself can take you there, by way of his own reading. Since a poet hears a poem in his mind's ear as he writes it, he knows how he wants it to sound. And you too will hear how the poem ought to sound - with a new understanding not only of the poem, but of the poet himself - when you listen to the great poets of our age reading from their own works on Caedmon Records. T. S. Eliot reading Poems and Choruses edna st. vincent millay reading her poetry Long the acknowledged leader in spoken word recordings, Caedmon boasts an incomparable li- brary of literary voices: Robert Frost, Carl Sand- burg, Dylan Thomas, William Faulkner, J. R. R. Tolkien, Ernest Hemingway, Edna St. Vincent Millay, T. S. Eliot, W. H. Auden and many others. Just look in your favorite record store for the complete Caedmon collection, or fill in and mail the coupon below. Remember, nobody who knows, reads or studies poetry should be without ... no record library is complete without CAEDMON RECORDS. CAEDMON RECORDS, Dept. HM-99 505 Eighth Avenue New York, New York 10018 Please send me the records whose numbers I have circled below. I enclose $5.95 for each record, and understand that you will pay all postage and handling costs. 1-1 Name ............................. (Please Print) TC 1045 TCPj5Iirov R6 Relea =06/0'pg723CIA-RD98OB01495R00UO30A10r9'ip......... Approved For$elease 2006/01/17 ,CIA-RDP80B 1495001100030010-9 Gorki? 1 Ori i t is k l elo for gfts. or yo c rdi sets rafted in rich s id=silver ou r ster l i n cups and 6 f~ -t ray rim m+ d ire st rlln , $36.00# complete uli l ? rape or cl ssic # apoleo es(gr 1 ., ;i esi jew l;r r stores an sil er vare I p rtments= You can learn tv w6 ft it t t1e Osmiroid prn, an,turr nib and mrfw b oarardu~tvnJ m Only $2.50 at art material, stationery and pen shops as well as college book stores. Your check or money order can also be mailed to Pentalic Corp., 132 West 22nd Street, New York, N.Y. 10011. Add 50 cents to cover hnndling. State whether right or left handed.... Nothing is more satisfying than learning to produce the beautiful thicks and thins that characterize the italic hand and it's easy to learn as the pen, held at the proper angle, does most of the work for you. So be a penman, own an Osnilroid. USE YOUR ZIP CODE REPRINTS AVAILABLE Send for a list of other articles from Harper's Magazine which are avail- able in reprint form. Write to: Lucy Mattimore, Reprint Editor Harper's Magazine 2 Park Avenue New York, N.Y. 10016 Quantities of 100 or more: prices on request. Small quantities, when available: 15 cents each. THE EASY CHAIR finally eliminated his chief rivals- Beria, Malenkov, Molotov, Bulganin- did he feel secure enough to embark on a program of his own. It was an ambitious one. He knew that many changes were overdue after the long, frozen night of Stalinist terror, and some of the things he sought were genuinely in the inter- ests of the Russian people. More food, more housing, more consumer goods. Less fear of police terrorism. More flexi- bility and efficiency in the clumsy, creak- ing administrative machinery. More freedom-just a little more-for Soviet artists and writers. But every one of these changes was profoundly disturbing to some en- trenched interest in the country's hier- archy. To produce more food and con- sumer goods, he had to take money away from the armed forces and heavy industry-the Soviet version of the mili- tary-industrial complex ; the resulting struggle ended in apparent victory only after he fired Marshal Georgi Zhukov, the most famous hero of World War If. Khrushchev's repeated shake-ups of the Party organization and the secret police jarred whole armies of bureaucrats out of their soft jobs and comfortable ways of doing things. His denunciation of Stalinism offended his colleagues in the Presidium, because all of them (includ- ing of course Comrade K. himself) had been implicated in Stalin's crimes. They felt even more threatened by his tenta- tive experiments in freeing some parts of the economy and the intellectual com- munity from rigid centralized control. Such heresy was not only ideologically scandalous. It also imperiled the whole structure which gave the Communist elite their power and privileges. They felt much as the conservatives of the Vatican Curia did after Pope John opened the gates of change in the Catho- lic Church. For if Authority permits a little freedom of thought, of criticism, and of action, where and how can it be checked before it sweeps away Authority itself? To offset the opposition to his domes- tic innovations, Khrushchev needed some spectacular triumphs abroad-and no doubt he also craved them for the sake of his own inflamed ego, after his dec- ades of servility under Stalin. The pros- pects looked good. He assumed-and stated publicly-that Russia's launching of the first Sputnik and intercontinental missiles was shifting the balance of mili- tary power in his favor. The Western alliance was in considerable disarray. Colonial empires in Africa and Asia were breaking up, leaving weak suc- cessor governments that seemed to offer tempting opportunities for Communist intervention. So in 1958 he launched a Approved For Release 2006/01/17 : CIA-RDP80BOl 495RO01 100030010-9 Approved For Release 2006/01/17 : CIA-RDP80B01495RO01100030010-9 YOU CAN LIVE IN NEW YORK ALLYOUR LIFE AND NOT BE A NEW YORKER. Through a streak of insanity which you share with eight million other people, you've chosen to live in the most unlivable city in the world. Sure it's worth it. But only if you know how. And that's what New York Magazine is in exist- ence for. Not just to tell you what's going on all around you, including behind your back. - But more important, to help you cope. We'll show you how to get a rent-controlled, semi-professional apartment; even though you're not a semi-professional person. We'll tell you how to go about getting your kid into private school with confidence, even though you graduated P S. 165. Worried about how the city's being run? We are too. So we send writers like Gloria Steinem and Peter Maas to pry into private places and tell you what Lindsay and Hogan and Rocky, and, even ex- New Yorker, Richard Nixon are up to. If there's a battle raging in town, we've got the war correspondents to cover it. Whether it's white vs. black in the ghettos, students vs. faculty at Columbia, or Craig Claiborne vs. Michael Field over a hot kitchen stove. Just one more thing, be- cause we know your time is short. In fact, that's the point: because your time is short, you can't afford to waste it on bad movies or dreary plays or dull, second-rate food. So, we've got Judith Crist to help you pick the flicks. John Simon to tell you what unforgettable- evening-in-the-theatre to forget. Alan Rich to guide you safely through Philhar- monic, Carnegie, Hunter and the Met. And the Underground Gourmet to direct you to dozens of undiscovered restaurants stashed around town. If you'd rather stay home, you can amuse yourself with that downtown theatre of the absurd, Wall Street, as chronicled by `Adam Smith'. Or with one of Stephen Sondheim's sadistic crossword puzzles. Sure New York is a lunatic city. But we've got the people who can make sense of it. Because they're New Yorkers. People like Tom Wolfe and Judith Viorst and Dick Schaap and Ralph Schoenstein. And a few dozen others we're about to discover. You can pick up New York Magazine at your newsstand for forty cents an issue. But why not If you mail this coupon we'll enlist you in New York-the real New York-for only $8 a year. (The newsstand price would add up to over $20 a year.) Or subscribe for two or three years and saveeven more. Mail to: New York Magazine, Subscription Dept., Box 322, Des Moines, Ia. 50302. Name - Address City State Zip-_ ^1yr.at$8 ^2yrs.at$12 ^3yrs.at$15 ^ check enclosed ^ money order ^ bill me send for a year's subscription at eight dollars. And save twelve bucks a year. With creamed spinach at the Automat up to 25? a por? tion, it may be the last remain ing bargain in town. Rico, Virgin Islands $12 per year; elsewhere $15 per year. Approved For Release-2OO6I0-141-7= 1495 001100030010-9 Approved For Rase 2006/01/17 : CIA-RDP80B01495 1100030010-9 I THE EASY CHAIR Coming in Harper's John Corry's CUBA NOW Harper's Contributing Editor has just returned from a month's visit to Castro's Cuba, ten years after the Revolution captured Havana. Here, in a brilliant, firsthand, reportorial account, is the story of what is happening in that country and an appraisal of what this small Caribbean nation's experiment in Marxist-authoritarian adventures means to itself and its people, to the U.S., and to the world .. . 'VF and stories, articles, essays, and poems by FRANK O'CONNOR ROBERT LOWELL DAVID HALBERSTAM JAMES Q. WILSON JOHN W. ALDRIDGE NAT HENTOFF OSCAR LEWIS JOHN CIARDI ROGER WILKINS KTNGST.EY AMIS Approved series of power plays against the West. By threats, ultimatums, and harass- ment of the air corridors, he tried to force the NATO allies out of Berlin. He demanded a final peace settlement in Central Europe on his own terms. He grabbed for power bases in the Middle East and the Congo. But each of these offensives failed-all for the same fun- damental reason: the West called his bluff. Presidents Eisenhower and Ken- nedy both refused to yield to Khrush- chev's threats, and he was not prepared to back them up with armed force. By 1961 other things were going wrong for him too. Just as the orthodox old-timers had predicted, Khrushchev's moves toward liberalization had set loose forces that were hard to control; in Hun- gary they seemed to jeopardize the very structure of the Soviet empire, and had to be suppressed by Russian troops. His grandiose schemes for plowing up the Virgin Lands and for planting American corn in the Ukraine were embarrassing failures. For a brief period he tried an impulsive reversal of foreign policy, call- ing for "peaceful coexistence" with the West; the most notable result was the split with China, since Chairman Mao could not tolerate such craven truckling to the enemy. Realizing that his critics both in the military and the Party bureaucracy were growing increasingly restive, Khrushchev decided on the biggest gam- ble yet in hopes of restoring his droop- ing prestige and authority. This time his miscalculation was double: he was unable to set up a missile base in Cuba before the United States could find out about it; and when it was discovered, the Americans did not acquiesce. Once again he was forced to back down, this time in the most humiliating public con- frontation of all. That did it. His colleagues in the top agencies of the regime were alarmed by the risks he had been taking, and dis- gusted by their failure. They also were acutely unhappy over a new set of pro- posals that Khrushchev was advancing -for drastic economic and administra- tive reforms, for a showdown with China, for opening negotiations with West Germany. It probably was the evening of October 11, 1964 (according to Hyland and Shryock), that two of his associates in the Presidium, Brezhnev and Suslov, decided that The Boss would have to go. The way in which they recruited other Presidium members into the conspiracy, and went about the delicate business of enlisting military and secret police sup- port is reconstructed by the authors in I I Jet Olympic to Athens. And cruise to the Golden Islands with Sun Line. Olympic begins your vacation on a new Boeing 707. Chanel-dressed hostesses wine and dine you to lively bouzouki music (in stereo of course). All the way to Athens. By land, see two weeks of Athens on an Olympic tour., Plane ticket, hotel room, and car with Unlimited Mileage from $490.* By sea, Sun Line takes you to Golden Islands like Delos, Mykonos, and Rhodes in the sunny Aegean, aboard small-scale luxury liners with cozy cocktail lounges, continental cuisine, a nightclub, sun decks, heated swimming pools and picture-windowed staterooms with air-conditioning and private facilities. Sun Line leaves Piraeus any Monday or Friday for 3, 4 or 7 days from March 31 to October 24. From only $75. By land, sea, and air see Greece with Olympic and Sun Line. For more information, call your travel agent. Safety Information: The ms. Stella Solaris*, the ms. Stella Maris**, and the ms. Stella Oceanis* , ships of Greek Registry, meet international safety standards for new ships developed in 1948* and 1960** and meet 1966 fire requirements. *Based on jet economy group fare from New York GIT and on two persons traveling together. For Release 2006/01/17 : CIA-RDP80BO OUR EUROPEAN DELIVERY PLAN HAS AS MUCH RED TAPE AS ANYBODY ELSE'S WE JUST CHARGE YOU LESS FOR IT. When you buy a European car Volvo has reduced the quan- tion, 1500-mile servicing, and in Europe, a lot of red tape tity of paperwork you have to European registration. Insur- comes as standard equipment. do yourself. You sign two ing a Volvo and delivering it It takes about a pound of forms. And, of course, a check. to anywhere in Europe is paperwork to get your car pre- We've also reduced the cheaper than insuring and de- pared for delivery, insured, quantity of money you have livering most other cars. registered. delivered, serviced, to pay for the paperwork. We But the hest. thing about sav- shipped to America, and charge as littleas.$271apound. ing on a Volvo in Europe is cleared through customs. Because shipping a Volvo that your savings don't stop The going rate for this pa- from the factory in Gothen- at the water's edge. perwork is anywhere from burg, Sweden, to Newark,N.J., Volvos last long enough to $64=1 to $1230 a pAp *daed Fk)*ReQU9l2-1016#b4f47na CM-R DME Oq 9$K0014100 less you buy a Volvo. Tex., is free.* So are prepara- payments. 9 out of every 10 registered here in the last eleven years are still on the road. Which is no guarantee, but indicates how long a Volvo should hold up here. Can you think of another souvenir of your trip to Eu- rope that will do as well? Write us for a free Volvo Euro. pean Delivery brochure. Or ask any Volvo dealer. Approved Forel~ase 2006/01/17 CIA-RDP80B014001100030010-9 THE EASY CHAIR rebels, Khrushchev was vacationing at the time at his villa in Sochi; if he had been in Moscow, he might well have found out what was happening in time to squelch it. Even in his absence, the conspirators felt they had to move fast, and by Monday, October 12, they had gathered enough strength to call an emergency meeting of the Presidium to vote their absent leader out of his job. The next day Khrushchev cut short his vacation and flew back to Moscow, probably because one of his few remain- ing loyal henchmen on the Presidium (Mikoyan?) had tipped him off. Ile was met at the airport by the chief of the secret police and escorted at once to a Kremlin conference room where the Pre- sidium was again in session. At the head of the table sat Brezhnev, in Khrush- chev's accustomed place. He broke the news, brushed aside Khrushchev's bel- ligerent protests, and told him to appear the following morning before the full Central Committee of the Communist party, which would formally ratify his dismissal. At that final meeting , Suslov pre- sented a twenty-nine-point indictment of Khrushchev's blunders. The accused man was permitted a rebuttal, which has been described as rambling, aggressive, and profane-and the Committee then voted to remove him from all his Party positions. But the vote was not unani- mous; and when the decision was an- nounced to the public a couple of days later, it was framed in face-saving terms. Khrushchev had asked to be re- lieved of his duties, the communique said, because of "advanced age and poor health." Something very similar may happen one of these days to one or both of his successors. Brezhnev and Kosygin are far more cautious, and their style of command apparently is less offensive to their somewhat less-than-equal col- leagues in the Party hierarchy. But so far they have been no more successful than Khrushchev in solving the gritty, inescapable problems of the Soviet realm. They have clamped down on the lib- erals and intellectuals both at home and in their satellite states. The result has been a wave of revulsion throughout the world, even among lifelong Communists in many countries. Moreover, repression has not stopped the muttering-in Czechoslovakia, where the Russian oc- cupation promises to be a prolonged embarrassment, nor in Poland and Ro- mania, nor even among their own disil- lusioned young people. Their Arab clients lost the Six Day War with Israel, in spite of Russia's That describes Kodak's top super 8 movie twosome-the new KODAK INSTAMATIC0, M9 Movie Camera and the KODAK INSTAMATIC M95 Movie Projector. The instant-load M9 movie camera gives you greater movie-making versatility. Battery drive-no winding ever. A wide zoom range-5 to I. More shooting speeds-four, ranging from 12 to 32 frames per second. Precise through-the-lens viewing, zone focusing, and automatic exposure control. Sports finder, too. And handsome wood-grain vinyl styling. The M95 movie projector gives you greater movie-showing versatility. It has seven projection speeds -- three forward speeds... three reverse speeds... and a still "speed" when you want to freeze on a single frame. Shows both super 8 movies. and 8mm. Has 400-foot reel capacity. See this smart pair at your Kodak dealer's. The camera, less than $23o. The self cased projector, from less than $200. Prices subject to change without notice, Approved For Release 2006/01/17 : CIA-RDP80BOl 495RO01 100030010-9 ASk 95R001100030010-9 Dry Sack on-the-rocks is a great drink before lunch or dinner. Dry Sack has the body and superb nutty flavor to stand up to ice cubes. No wonder Dry Sack on-the-rocks, the man's sherry, is so popular. lavish contributions of planes and tanks; and now they seem to be sliding toward another, and more dangerous, confronta- tion in defiance of Soviet cautions. The Chinese not only are as hostile as ever; they also are making alarming (to the. Kremlin) noises about a rapprochement with the United States. To get their faltering economy in order, Brezhnev and Kosygin urgently need to slow down the arms race and divert the money saved into domestic uses. But an understanding with Amer- ica and Western Europe has proved im- possible, so long as Soviet troops are poised in Czechoslovakia and the shoot- ing continues in Vietnam and the Middle East. Their most pressing question of all is: How do you run a modern, complex, high-technology society under a system of centralized, rigid controls? Brezhnev and Kosygin have found no answer-be- cause, as even their own people are be- ginning to suspect, there is none. Their industrial managers, and scientists, and local administrators keep saying, with increasingly open insistence, that such a system just won't work. It could per- form, after a fashion, during the war and the early period of industrialization, when the Soviet Union had only a few simple goals. Today, however, the de- mands of its society are more numerous and sophisticated-ranging from space exploration to contemporary women's fashions, salable exports, a new auto- mobile industry, an efficient production of not-quite-so-shoddy consumer goods. Such goals evidently cannot be reached without some dispersal of decision- making and some degree of freedom-in consumer choice, in pricing, in mana- gerial discretion, in scientific inquiry, and in the flow of scarce resources. In sum, an approach to something like a pluralistic society. That, of course, is the one thing that Brezhnev and Kosygin and their fellow conservatives in the Communist appa- ratus cannot tolerate, since it would immediately jeopardize their own au- thority. They seemed doomed, there- fore, to increasing conflict with Russia's New Class, as Djilas has called it: the managers and technologists whose role grows steadily more important in every modern industrial state. The consequent tensions and pressures are likely to ac- cumulate quietly below the surface, until something has to give, like an earth slip- page along a fault line. Then one or two of the younger members of the hierarchy may again begin to talk guardedly about the necessity of a change in command, and the conspiratorial tactics which might bring it about ... All of the people who have talked to 495R001100030010-9 -24 Approved Fo She Needs Your Love Little Mie-Wen in Formosa already knows many things . the gnawing of hunger . . . the shivering of fear ... the misery of being unwanted. But she has never known love. Her mother died when she was born. Her father was poor-and didn't want a girl child. So Mie- Wen has spent her baby years without the affection and security every child craves. Your love can give Mie-Wen, and children just as needy, the privileges you would wish for your own child. Through Christian Children's Fund you can sponsor one of these youngsters. We use the word spon- sor to symbolize the bond of love that exists between. you and the child. The cost? Only $12 a month. Your love is demonstrated in a practical way because your money helps with nourishing meals .. . medical care . . . warm clothing . education ... understanding housemothers ... And in return you will receive your child's personal history, photograph, plus a description of the orphanage where your child lives. You can write and send packages. Your child will know who you are and will answer your letters. Cor- respondence is translated at our overseas offices. (If you want your child to have a spe- cial gift-a pair of shoes, a warm jacket, a fuzzy bear-you can send your check to our office, and the entire amount will be forwarded, along with your instruc- tions.) Will you help? Requests come from orphanages every day. And they are i h e r urgent. Children wrapping rags on t feet, school books years out of date, milk I wish to sponsor ^ boy ^ girl in Name ------ supplies exhausted, unwed mothers. b THE EASY CHAIR me about the possibility of such a palace rebellion are pretty vague about the man, or men, who might next climb to power. Of the eleven present members of the Presidium, Mikhail Suslov almost cer- tainly can be ruled out. For decades he has been the court theologian, the guard- ian of the Party's ideological. purity. As such, he has had considerable influence, but no real power base in the military, the police, the industrial structure, or the Party machine. (That is why he was not chosen, despite his early role in the anti-Khrushchev cabal, to share power with Brezhnev, who had a strong base in the Party apparatus; instead the sec- ond place went to Kosygin, an engineer with a large following among industrial management.) Besides, Suslov is too old, too ill, and too closely associated with the present regime to make a likely heir apparent. Several Kremlinologists are speculat- ing about the chances of two other Pre- sidium members, Nikolai Podgorny and Peter Shelest. Both are Ukrainians and former proteges of Khrushchev; Pod- gorny, indeed, may have been the last to desert his old boss in the crucial Oc- tober 14 meeting of the conspirators. Consequently if Party sentiment begins to turn again toward a more flexible and experimental policy, of the kind Khrush- chev attempted so ineptly, one of them might profit from it. Probably an even better bet is Alex- ander Shelepin, the bumptious young man of the Kremlin, at least in compari- son with the rest of the Soviet geron- tocracy. Only fifty years old, he is con- Since 1938, thousands of American y sponsors have found this to be an inti- mate person-to-person way of sharing their blessings with youngsters around the world. Little Mie-Wen and children like her need your love-won't you help? Today? Sponsors urgently needed this month for children.in Korea, Taiwan, India, Brazil. (Or let us select a child for you from our emergency list.) Write today: Verbon E. Kemp CHRISTIAN CHILDREN'S FUND, INC. Box 511, Richmond, Va. 23204 (Country) ^ Choose a child who needs me most. $12 -fl, . I enclose my first payment of $-- I will pay a ,,? . Zip State Send me child's name, story, address and picture. I cannot sponsor a child but want to sidered a spokesman for the New Class. And since he has been a trade-union leader, chief of the secret police, and organizer of the Young Communist League, he has excellent connections with several main elements in the power structure. Other rising young men, such as Dmitri S. Polansky, sometimes are men- tioned as possibilities. But at bottom, all this is sheer speculation. After all, even Khrushchev did not know, until the last moment, which of his friends had turned against him. How then could anybody outside the Kremlin hope to guess what shape the next conspiracy will take? Only three things can be said with some assurance: (1) Such a conspiracy is bound to take form sooner or later, because Russia has no other way of changing administrations. (2) The rec- ord of the present regime hardly seems good enough to promise it a long life. (3) Whoever does succeed to the top command will face much the same array of problems and policy dilemmas which Khrushchev and Brezhnev-Kosygin have found so intractable. ( I 95R001100030010-9 Address - City - Registered (VFA-080) with the U. S. Government's Advisory Committee on give $ . . ductible. Canadians: Write 140! Yonge, ^ Please sen me more information. Tor 7 HP39 /17: CIA-RDP80B01495Rb01100030010-9 the heart of the matter..a Master musicians freely cornment that MASON & HAMLIN is today's finest piano. They speak of tone that's richer and better bal- anced. A treble that's brilliant at the top, warmer throughout. An action of heartening response, yet a shade quieter and easier to adjust. Such commentaries mean we are succeeding. They testify to the fact that MASON & HAMLIN occupies a unique position even among the world's great pianos. MASON & HAMLIN builds more meaningfully dif- ferent features into each piano than anyone else. This makes for more restricted and costlier pro- duction. But these differences are at the heart of the matter. One is the Tension Resonator that maintains for- ever the critical crown of the soundboard. Another is the special Duplex Scale. Hand- 33 WEST 57TH STREET, NEW YORK, N.Y. 10019 SURS,O,ARY OF AEOLIAN CORPORA LION AMERICA S LARO#Sr PRODUCER OF IANOS placed, individually adjustable bridges called aliquots add treble depth by perfectly tuning the elusive non-singing string lengths. More. The long side of a MASON & HAMLIN angles to the left, not straight back. The width that is gained allows a larger soundboard and longer string length. Bigger, better sound. Other makers have none of these and other dif- ferences. Do they sound expensive? They are. But h wort it. After all, what goes into a piano makes the difference in what comes out. For free color catalog, write Dept. SR Approved For Release 2006/01/17 : CIA-RDP80BD1495RO011'00030010-9 Approved For Release 2006/01/17 : CIA-RDP80B01495RO01100030010-9 TRANSMITTAL SLIP DATE 3, 7/69 TO: M roctor ROOM NO. BUILDING F1. RM 36-8 FORM NO I .2 A WHICH MAYBE USED. 1 FEB 5 55 `I' Approved For Release 2006/01/17 : CIA-RDP80BOl 495RO01 100030010-9