NIE-64 (PART I): SOVIET BLOC CAPABILITIES THROUGH MID-1953.

Document Type: 
Collection: 
Document Number (FOIA) /ESDN (CREST): 
CIA-RDP79R01012A002100020003-2
Release Decision: 
RIPPUB
Original Classification: 
T
Document Page Count: 
35
Document Creation Date: 
December 9, 2016
Document Release Date: 
October 2, 2000
Sequence Number: 
3
Case Number: 
Publication Date: 
April 30, 1952
Content Type: 
MF
File: 
AttachmentSize
PDF icon CIA-RDP79R01012A002100020003-2.pdf2.63 MB
Body: 
0, 75,65-0 - 62- Approved For %lease 12 p gto,s e CIAIROP79R01012A0.03100020003-2e--V-# / DEPATToF? ARMY OFFICE OF THE ArISTANT CHIEF OF ST#F, G-2, INTELLIGENCE WASHINGTON 25, D. C. TSC-- b 3 -4 TOP SECRET CONTROL SECTION A. C. of S., G-2, DA G2 ?PR 80 APR 1952 MEMORANDUM FOR: EXECUTIVE SECRETARY, BOARD OF NATIONAL ESTIMATES, CENTRAL INTELLIGENCE AGENCY SUBJECT: NIE-64 (Part I): Soviet Bloc Capabilities Through Mid-1953. 1. Reference is made to CIA memorandum, subject as above, dated 4 April 1952. 2. In accordance with request contained in reference memorandum, attached hereto as Tab "A" is the Department of the Army contribution to NIE-64 (Part I), prepared by the Office of the Assistant Chief of Staff, G-2, Intelligence, Department of the Army. FOR IkIE ASS/3.1111C CHIEF OF STAFF, G-' 1 Incl Tab "A" (8 cys) w adt-kat HARVEY If. Crgenel, es t!let, Production Division, 04 *ARMY Declass/Release Instructions On File* Review of this document by CIA has determined that CIA has no objection to declass It contains information of CIA Interest that must remain classified at TS S Authority: HR 704 Rats H c ntains nothing of CIA Interest Reviewer TOP.CREi Approved For Release 2001 8All tt Ri SiEt dsL 01012A002100020003-2 Approved For Rerlivse EN HI. ONTEMITer TAB "A" 9t f9R01012A002100020p3j2_, TSC-- TOP. SECRET CONTROL SECTION A. C. 0 . G-2. DA G-2 COBTRIBRION TO 2113t-6k _part I) Internal Political Factore Affoeting Boviet Bloc Capabilities for 3.=??.....bm???? Political and Militmilaefare A. What is, the relationnhip now exioting in the U,S.Sat, between the Communist Party, the Secret Police and the military forces? Are there any strains within any of these groups? The Soviet Communist Party holds complete and effective control over the country. However, there in considerable evidence of frictions and strains within and between the various groups making up Soviet society. A few of the more important include jealcupies among officials on lower levels of the Communist Party, peasant resentiment of the controlling authorities,. and dissatisfaction with conditions within the Ai*. These are all exploitable psYehol teeny and, ptrticularly in wartime, would require certain attention from the Soviet Government. It is believed, howeter that these problems do not constitute any particular obstacle to Soviet political warfare or that they would hamper a Soviet military effort to any significant degree. D. What is the extent of the Kremlin's control over the European Satellites and haw is it exercised? To what extent does Soviet "control denend upon Soviet noitem anA v1414.Enr7 reeee. ueon Satellite nolice and military force? How successful hes the Kremlin been in winning active aupport for ite peliciee? In eliminating effective opposition to those policies? Soviet control over the European Satellites is complete in the sense that there is no present likely threat to the continuance of the Communist regimes. In all the Satellites except East Germany, the local security forces, backed by the Satellite Armies, probably are sufficient to maintain Communist power. In every country, however, the proximity, if not the actual presence, of the Soviet Amy is the basic element of control. Approved For Release 1r9R01012A002100020003-2 firimmula Approved For Releas Ai P79R0101ta02100020003-2 &MEW EnflAtirf The Kremlin has had little success ineinning active support for its policies, except among youth groups, opportunists, and Cc:amen/et elements. Popular discontent is general in the Eurocean Satellites. It affects all population categorieo, and is caused primarily by econoadc hardships resulting from Soviet demands and by Communist interference with personal liberties. Sege hostility to Communist rule, particularly intense among the older generation, is to be found even within the structure of the Satellite regimes all Of which still conain some Ratiocalist elements. The Kremlin's police methods have been almost cempletely successful in controlling all popular discontent and prevent it from seriously threatening Soviet goals. In no Satellite is there a resistance group or combination of groups which appeare to have the slightest chance of over- throwing the regime or even of raterially slowing down its program. The Kremlin has been highly successful in eliminating upen resistance, although in all the Satellites guerrilla bands rtill carry cut limited and sporadic activity. These underground organizations are presently preoccupied with efforts to avoid annihilation and to conserve their strength until it can be used effectively. They do, however, eenstitute a nucleus which could be reactivated if given outside aid and hope of liberation. Passive resistance, apparently increasing as opportunities for overt resistenee have diminished, at times constitutes a vexing harassment for the Satellite regimes, but not a seridus threat. However, in a car which offered hope of liberation, passive resistance might be expected to increase and to play an important role in reducing Soviet capabilities. E. What is the extent of :',.remain influence or control over Communist China and hiw is it exercised? The relationship betweee Communist China and the Soviet Union is unique among Communist-Bloc countries. The ereciee nature of the Sino Soviet relationship results from external and internal conditions affecting both Soviet Russia and Commueist Chine. China cannot be termed e "satellite in the same sense that 2 VEV Approved For Releetsieri 4/118/3C4 ezz vpz tro 012A002100020003-2 Approved ForRelease2001/08/31:=-RDP79R0101242p2100020003-2 Now' INF SECRET MOM 0 other Communist-dominated countries are "satellites"; Soviet influence and control over C mist China ie not exercieed.in the same degree and manner as that over Communiet-Bloc countries of Eastern Europe and ASIA. Communist China may well be on the road to beceming a complete satellite; or it may achieve a full, though Junior, partnership with the Soviet Union. The special position of Communist China may not be one desired by the Kremlin, but. it is an existing one which the Soviets evidently feel they must accept f r the present at least. The extent of Soviet influence and control is seen in Chinese Communist foreign policy. Hero the,:ainese Communists have openly touted Kremlin leadership in Communist world strategy, and Chinese Cemmunist foreign relations appear at least to follow Soviet guidance, if not obey Soviet dictation. By a co ination of circumstances the Soviets are precluded from "taking over" full control of Communist China. They can, however, effectively direct Chinese Communist relations with other countries and, to a lesser degree, internal development. This oapability derives fr IE A the community of interest existing between the Soviet and the Chinese C mist leaders. It is greatly reinforced by tha Soviets ? capability of seising Manchuria, Inner Mongolia, and Sinkiang and by Chinese Communist dependence upon the Soviet Union for military and industrial modernization. F. Whtb political or social problems within the Satellites may develop in such a way as either to weaken or to strengthen Bloc capabilities for political or military warfare? l. European Setellitee Soviet Blm capabilities for political warfare would not be affected by the development of Satellite political or social problems. Tie only exception would be the possibly, thoaeh highly improbable successful 3 TOP stow SWAM OEFOR TO Approved For Release 2001/08/31 : CIA-RDP79R01012A002100020003-2 Approved For Release 2001/08/31 : CIA-RDP79R010124p2100020003-2 Ter SKR SICRIEITIT xrinEkTilr emergence of farther "Titoism" within the SLtellite orbit resulting in the defection of another Satellite state from the Soviet Bloc. , Soviet Bloc capabilities for military warfare, however, are limited by passive resistance to Communist political repression and socialization. Such resistance, which has increased as social and economic hardshipa have multiplied, takea many forms. It varies from annoyance of the Communist regimes by ridicule and apathy to more serious harassment and interference with Cemmunist goals through peasant and worker resistance. Although not serious threats to the Satellite regimes, popular apathy, indifference, and noncooperation have to date placed an upper limit on what the regimes can extract fr the people. In war, the Kremlin's failure to fully Sovietize the Satellite peoplea would become more significant. If the war promised liberation, indications are that passive resistance would grow and become widespread, would hamper the Satellite economics, and would eventually tie down a significant number of troops as security forces. The only political-social development which will operate to increaae Soviet military capabiXities is Communist success in the indoc- trination of youth, which can te expected ultimately to produce a Cemmunist-indoctrinated generation which will compensate for the present lack of whole hearted support by the older groups. 2. China The pn.titical and social developments within, Communist , China moat likely to affect Mazo capabilities for political and militery warfare are those which will probably flow from Chinese Communist success or failure to solve fUndamental economic problems. The moat pressing of these problems is that of increasing goverment revenue, Which, in turn, is related to the mere fundak ntal economic problem of increasing production. SElletr In Tl \ICH 311\ Approved For Release 2001/08/31 : CIA-RDP79R01012A002100020003-2 Approved For Release 2001/08/31 : CIA-RDP79R01012A002100020003-2 Nor Ter SE sactumnrr I lit Mr 111 Two basic facts restrict Chinese Communist capabilities in any immediate attempts to cope with their economic difficulties. The first is that the Chinese economy is able to produce only a small surplus over minium requirements for subsistence. The second is that by far the greater part of total national income and of government revenue is derived from agriculture. Because the Chineee economy is operating so near the subsistence level, increases in taxes can rapidly become intolerable, resulting in a falling of industrial production and in widespread peasant discontent. The Chinese Communist regime--in spite of the size and effectiveness of its organieati --still does not have enough trustworthy and c petent personnel to operate all of China's industry or to regulate all its agriculture. The Chinese Communieto Lack men and means to create a bureaucracy able to manage effectively the whole economy. Widespread resistance not only liquid be difficult to suppress but would certainly cause such a fundamental cleavage within the Chinese Communist party as could seriously weaken the stability of the regime, That the Chinese Commentate have handled with some degree of imam their basic. economic problems appears to be indicated by the apparent relative stability of the Chinese economy over the past two years. Chinese Communist military operations in Korea have so far been carried by Manchuria, leaving China proper more or lees insulated against the effects of the war. Manchuria is one of the few regions of China which produces a substantial surplus and is, therefore, an area in which the tax burden can be increased without seriously affecting production. Therefore, Chinese Cocain/et capabilities for political and military warfare are largely dependent upon the aucCess of economic policies in Manchuria. Failure in Manchuria will increase the burden in China proper where econamic resources are much less flexible. Approved For Release 5 p12A002100020003-2 Approved ForRelease2001/08/31:UA-RDP79R01012A002100020003-2 Noe *id 'ir22( 3 inf Wm nor 3. Indochina Two political pessures are currently evident within the Viet Minh party machinery. The first is the etrengthening of the Indo- chinese C niet Party'e control of the Viet Minh united front. Since 1950, the Viet Minh have neglected their original policy f emphasising the nationalistic bane of its struggle against the French; and have openly identified their regime with the Asiatic Commnnist movement. In this process, the identity of interest with the Chinese C*ie nist "Feople?8 Revolution" to frequently emphasised. The seconCpolitical pressure results front the increasingly active role in the Viet Minh of Chineee Coemunists in the political and, partieularly, the militere fields. This Viet Minh dependence upon Chinese Communist aneletance has heightened the traditional antipathy of the Vietnameee people for the Chinmee, and available information indicates that some Viet Minh leaders fear the dChinese Communists? more sing influence and control. However, it seems probable that during the period of this estimate, the traditional Vietnamese dislike for the Chinese will be subordinated to the Viet Minh ' niet policy of cooperation with the Chinese COmmuniets. There shorld thus be a continued strengthening eat= military and political capabilities in Indochina. be G. What Will/the probable effects upon the political situation Within the Moe of the Continuntion of the cold war and of the present conflicts in Korea and Indochina, of extension of the war in the Far Fasts of limited attacks in the Mtddle Fast, of general war without the Use of mass destruction weapons, of general war with the use of mass destruction weapons? Approved For Release 21t /3 Nam llves RD1012A002100020003-2 Approved For .jease 2001/08/31: CIA-RDP79R010124902100020003-2 TN SEERY ENFORNEW The continuation of the cold war and of the present conflicts in Korea and Ind hina are not likely to have serious adverse internal political effecte within the Bloc, but will probably result in a further tightening . of control over local populations. In particular, advantages to be gained by the Chinese -Communists by the present type of United war appear to outweigh the probable economic and political disadvantages. This conclusion is subject to the qualification that the greater part of the economic burden of the war continues to be carried by the Manehurian economy, and that the Soviet Union continues to provide substantial aid. The Wobable political repercussions of an extension of war in the Ear East viii depend largely upon the form which this extension of war takes, the areas of Communiet China which it affects, and the military objectives of this warfare. Assu ,ng that such an extension of warfare would consist principally of. effective air attadre on industrial and communications targets of strategic importance in Manchuria and North China, the Chinese Communist ability to maintain forces in Korea could be crippled, and China proper could be cut off both from substantial material aid from Soviet Russia and fr the economic re3ources of Manchuria. Since the economic burden of supporting the war would-then, in a larger measure, be trans- ferred to the sconamk of China proper, the probability Oft adverse political repercussions would be greatly increased. On the ether hand, if extension of warfare in the Far East is limited to air attacks on strategic targets in Central and South China, the probable political repercussions viii not seriously damage either Chinese C tat military or political potential. Not only would it be difficult to cripple the econo,v of this part of the country by attacks on strategic targets, but it is doubtful that adverse soonomic developments in South China woUld greatly affect the Chinese Communist military capabilities in Korea? Approved For Releda 01012A002100020003-2 Approved For Release 2001/08/31 : CIA-RDP79R01014V02100020003-2 Ter SECRET SECORMI. DRODIEFOOT The internal political effects which will probably result from a general war will depend, to a large degree, upon the effect such a var would, have on the continuation of Soc-det material assistanae 40,-upon the.. military pressure maintained against the Chinese Communists. Deprived of Soviet Military assistance and under heavy military pressure, the Chines, economy, would be subject to such strain that ?trona political opposition to the Chinese Cemmunist regime could readily develop. On the other hand, even if ComManist China were deprived of Soviet aid but not subjected- to military pressure Sufficient to put a serious drain on her resource?, the political repercussions are not likely to be serious. The probable internal political effects of the use of mass destructi weapons are largely unpredictable, for they depend, to a great degree, both on the reaction of the people and upon the skill with which this reaction is exploited. H . In each of these instances, how viii the resultant political developments within the Bloc affect Bloc capabilities for political and military warfare? A continuation of the cold war and of the present conflict in Korea and Indochina would, in seneral, favor the Communiat capabilities for political and military warfare. The Chinese Communist econoss. has not yet shown signs of serious strain; its army is being modernised and trained in 'modern warfare, and no politteal opposition to the Chinese Communist regime has shown signs of boo BOTiOUS. As long as the present conditions :continue, the Chinese Communists can increase their military potential while exploiting the OportunAties for:political warfare during the period of great uncertainty. While it to true that continuation of the cold war is depriving -Communist China of the benefit of normal trade relations with non-Communist countries, Conmunist China is increasing, Its degree of economic self-- sufficiency and is.constructinc alternate lines of communication with Approved For Release ?tzwirmonny R01012A002100020003-2 Approved For Release 2001/08/31 : CIA-RDP79R01012V2100020003-2 Nor, Tar MORT sem= ormolus" the Soviet Unica?thus improving her war potential. III. SORTZET BEOC CAPABILITIES FOR POLITICAL WARFARE B. To what degree does Soviet Bloc nilitary power contribute to the effectiveness of the Bloc's political warfcret 1. Military power--or the threat inherent in the possession of military power?is One of the key weapons in Soviet political warfare. This weapon constitutes the owl serious Obstacle to Western programa designed to reduce the threat of Communist power to the point where it is no longer a threat to international security. The Soviets use military power in three major uays in a "cold war" senses a. The threat value of a force in being, b. The use of Satellite forces against non-Communist areas and, c. The use of military-economic aid to insurgent groups. 2. The mere threat of Soviet military action, in Europe or Asia, has several political effect'''. Wherever Soviet military forces are present, the West is faced with the necessity of deploying opposing military fortes to prevent other areas from being absorbed. Obviously, Western failure to defend peripheral areas could result in their loss. Of equal importance, however, are the inherent political disadvantage(' of Western maldeployment arising from Soviet ability to mass in any given area greater force than the West possessee. Similarly, the massiveness of Soviet power in any given location tends to induce despair, the feeling that little effective oppositien could be offered to a Soviet invasion. Efforts to overcome this feeling of futility and neutralism require an impressive amount of Western political effort. (b) Of perhaps greater value is the type of operation exemplified in Korea wherein Cosmanist forces are employed to achieve territorial advantage and cause attrition in Western forces without directly eameitti Soviet Forces. Such operations have the dual effect of permitting further C list expansion at far less rinks of global war than would be ? 9 Approved For Releas 9R01012A002100020003-2 MEM ONFOIMETW Approved For Release 2001/08/31: CIA-RDP79R01012AQ02100020003-2 M ; r the case where Soviet forces themselves employed and of increasing the instability of large areaa of the world for exploitation by other means. (0) Finally, the naterial ettength of Soviet military- ?commie force in being enables the Soviets to provide extensive aid to insurgent movements attempting to achieve control in emerging natiemal states. Such aid has contributed materially to the success of the Communist or Communist supported groups iv such areas. C. To what extent has the emergence of Communist China affected Bloc political warfare? The principal effect of the emergence of Communist China is the capability this development has given to the Bloc of posing major military threats in the Far East as well as in Westin% Europe and the Middle East. It has also given the Bloc greater flexibility and greater roan for maneuver in the execution of political varfare. A threatening military posture in one part of the world can be aecompanted by proposals of "peaceful settlement" in another. Coesunist China can be engaged in a limited war with the United States while Soviet proems-nada preaches the feasibility of "coexistence" of capitalism and socialism. The emergence also appears to have uade it more profitable to the Bloc to place greater emphasis on political warfare in Europe by pursuing a "peace offensive." Because the Bloc's military capabilities in Europe are quite thoroughly appreciated, the Bloc does not need to resort to bellicose demonstrations to remind Western Europeans of the military threat it poses. Chinese Communist forces have the capability of invading Indochina and Burma. But probably more tmportant is the stimulus given to Communist penetration of all Southeast Asia by the material and technical assistance which the Chinese C nista are now able to give Southeast Asian Communists. IreilD MIEN Rife@ 10 Approved For Release 2001/08/31 : CIA-RDP79R01012A002100020003-2 Approved For Release 2001/08/31: CIA-RDP79R01012502100020003-2 Nose TN ECIEHTT II The emergenee of Communist China has also greatly strengthened Mee political capabilities with reference to Japan and India. While keeping the military threat in the background, the Bloc can, among other things, place propaganda emphaeis on the economic advantages of reestablishim economic ties with continental China. At the same time the laze can exploit the propaganda value of the continued presence on Japanese soil of United States forcee and the fear that United States policies will draw the world into another war. 146. What is the ttitude of the e ?ward rearmament? Toward the nttSqgglet The attitudes of the peoples toward rearmament in the various geo- graPhic areas. greatly. In Latin America a traditionally isolationist attitude Their Interest in increased. rearmament is principally ooncerned. with the problem of quelling internal disturbances. Within Western Europe, the people of most nations are resigned to the neceosity for refusing to meet the present Communist threat but have not anthusiastioallY accepted this condition. Moat of the Trench people are torn between their anti-Communist, pro-Western syapathies and their fear of a resurgent Germany, Pr this reason theylreuld. mamma soma solution Which might reduce the Soviet threat end prevent German rearasnent. The people of Italy generally support remment. On the Oerman side, their endorsement of the remanent program is tempered by the fear that such action may jeopardize unification0 is for the Near and Middle Bast, only Greece and. Turkey are fully cooperative with the Wst. The peoples of the Arabia countries are not par- ticularly iaterested in anymmemmemxt progranihich has as its &lathe active support of Western policies. The people of X'an and Afghanistan, because of their proximity to the U.S.S.R. and. their inherently weak military Mir SECRET rt ULM lliTW , Approved For Release 2001/08/31 : CIA-RDP79R01012A002100020003-2 Approved For Release 2001/08/31 : CIA-RDP79R01012A002100020003-2 'rime NINO IMP SECRET SEEEDEmi onnEwroor potential even with consideroble lbsterr aid, are interested In develop- ing strong armed forces principallr for internal security purpodes. In south Central and. Southeast Asia, inforred public opinion is generally against rearmament. This Element fears that such a course of action will hasten rather than delay general wzr and in turn will deny to them a prolonged. period of peace, whicb they feel is needed. for strengthening the strained economy of the area and for stabilizing internal political situations. India, in particular, is generally apathetic towards war- fare due to their religious beliefs and Gandhian principles of non- violence. Support for rearrament in Southeast Asia is L.trongest in Indochina, but even there is found conaiderable anxiety that the strengthening of defending forces might lead to an invasion by Communist China. In Burma and Indonesia there appears to be wide-spread public support for governmental policies of neutrality, Among the Japanese, there is no widespread enthusiasm in support of rearmament, but avast majority of the people have accepted this course as an inevitable neces- sity. Chief opposition Is centered in the Socialist and Communist Parties, but some apprehension is found among conservatives over the Japanese ability to support economically such rearming. Attitude on the East-Weet struggle is similar to that on rearming. The people of Latin America show little interest and are in no position economically to become involved in heavy rearmament. The people") sympathies in these countries are with the West however, and In the event of general hostilities their active support could be expected. In spite of fairly large Communist Parties in France and Italy, all of the Western European nations are aligned with the Vast, raw EEC NET MUM fall:WM P Approved For Release 2001/08/31 : CIA-RDP79R01012A002100020003-2 Approved ForRelease2001/08/31:UA-RDP79R01012A002100020003-2 Nov Nage TOP MERE 2rtZLE,Ld'1i LIMIRMITINV and the majority of the people can be expected to continue thie eUpport. In the Diddle and Veer at, Grow,' and Turkey are pre-Western, but generally the fear of the Soviets and interest in the Nast-Weet Struggle is progreseivai-weaker as the distance from the Soviet border increases. The people are concerned principally with local problem Popular opinion in South Central and Southeast Asia has been generally to shy away from alignment with either aide; however, there appears to be a growing sympathy for the West as opposed to the Communiat Nations. Sharp criticism often received by the West from, people of Asian countries is attributed more to antipathy against colonialism than to orientation toward Cammuniam. In Japans the present Government, dominated by the Liberal Party, and the major conservative opposition parties favor alignment with the West. The Socialists largely favor neutrality while the Cammuniet Party is, of course pro-Bast. 13 Tor ,51ECIRET OECCO211117 FROTRITOr Approved For Release 2001/08/31 : CIA-RDP79R01012A002100020003-2 17611115-1 E? Approved For Releaskittp1/ P79R01012A002100020003-2 '***03m( 1121FORNATiler A. What is the over-all ontloek for Bloc political warfare capabilities during the period of this estimate? In Communist eyes, political warfare techniques are not distinct from warfare in general. All premoures -- political, psychological, economic, and In the final analysis military -- are considered part of a general offensive designed to achieve the Communiet goal of world domination by the Kreklin. Accordingly, it is necessary tc consider present cold-war activities as a part of and contributing to the over-all program of Communist expansion. In this context Soviet political warfare efforts are designed to gain as much, as possible short of ear; they are also designed to improve the absolute military position of the Communist Bloc in the event that war occurs. Thule political preseures applied against India are designed inter alia to increase the macifistic tendencies of that country, both to prevent its active partici- pation in the struggle against Communism on the side of the West and t improve the Soviet ability to achieve domination over that country -- either by military or non-yilitary means -- whichever may at some future time appear most suitable. Similarly, Communist proaganda designed to foster neutralism in Europe are designed to have the same dual effect. So long as the Communist ma= holds the offensive in political warfare efforts and the initiative in propaganda designed to show its devotion to peace, so long may neutralism and opposition to Western defense efforts be expected to continue. At the same time, Communist Bloc political pressures designed to cause or increase disagreement betweee the Western Powers and other countries of the non-Communist world weaken the individual ability of the several nations to resist Coranuniemse attacks either military or psychological. It also reduces the rate of Western efforts to develae a potter position capable of achieving balance with that of the Communist Bloc by causing maldeployment of Western political, economic, or military pressures. Thus, by association df Communist elements with anti-colonial and emergent nationalist groups in Southeast Asia 111? 5E0E11 Approved For Releasegillliaa awaign 11)'s 12A002100020003-2 it WI aVaLtnaei SINUM end in iiiiirietath?P