SPECIAL REPORT SANCTIONS AND THE SOUTH AFRICAN ECONOMY

Document Type: 
Collection: 
Document Number (FOIA) /ESDN (CREST): 
CIA-RDP79-00927A005000040002-3
Release Decision: 
RIPPUB
Original Classification: 
S
Document Page Count: 
14
Document Creation Date: 
December 16, 2016
Document Release Date: 
December 20, 2004
Sequence Number: 
2
Case Number: 
Publication Date: 
September 3, 1965
Content Type: 
REPORT
File: 
AttachmentSize
PDF icon CIA-RDP79-00927A005000040002-3.pdf675.77 KB
Body: 
e 2005/01/05: CIA-RDP79-00927A0 00%4Qpep2ember 1965 Copy No. SPECIAL REPORT SANCTIONS AND THE SOUTH AFRICAN ECONOMY 25X1 CENTRAL INTELLIGENCE AGENCY O F F I C E O F R E S E A R C H A N D R E P O R T S SECRET Approved For Release 2005/01/05: CIA-RDP79-00927A0050000400O i' I Excluded from automatic 25X1 Approved For Release 2005/01/05 : CIA-RDP79-00927AO05000040002-3 Approved For Release 2005/01/05 : CIA-RDP79-00927AO05000040002-3 Approved For Rel de 2005/01/05 : CIA-RDP79-00927A005Q 0040002-3 SECRET SANCTIONS AND THE SOUTH AFRICAN ECONOMY Within the next several months, the Interna- tional Court of Justice is expected to rule against the Republic of South Africa on the issue of its continued administration of South-West Africa. When it does, Afro-Asian and Communist demands for wholesale economic sanctions against South Africa, particularly by the main trading partners, the US and UK,are certain to reach a new high. The booming South African economy, however, re- mains the most modern and best balanced in all Af- rica, and the threat of economic sanctions has spurred it to attain increasingly greater self- sufficiency. The Afro-Asian and Communist trade boycott instituted some three years ago to force changes in South Africa's racial policies has been no more than a nuisance to the republic, and in mid-1965 its economy was measurably less suscepti- ble to outside economic pressures than when the boycott began. General Economic Condition The last four years of eco- nomic boom have wrought dramatic changes in the makeup of the South African economy, which con- tinues to break nearly all pro- duction records. New industries have been started, and existing ones have been expanded markedly. South Africa now has the begin- nings of a substantial armaments industry and soon will be pro- ducing its own military aircraft. Automobiles and trucks, which heretofore were only assembled in the Republic from components. imported from abroad, will even- tually be produced almost wholly within South Africa. kaans-speaking South Africans, once content to leave the Re- public's factories in the hands of their English-speaking com- patriots, now control a grow- ing number of the country's manufacturing plants. South Africa's prodigious mineral wealth is being exploited at record levels. Indeed, rap- idly expanding gold production has been a major factor in sparking the boom. There have also been rising earnings on merchandise exports, sharp in- creases in government expendi- tures, especially on defense, and a rapid introduction of new technology. Foreign investment, chiefly from the UK and US, is responsi- ble for many of the new plants and much of the new equipment, but an increasing amount of in- dustry is locally owned. Afri- As a result of all this ac- tivity, the slack in the econ- omy has been just about elimi- nated,. Resources are now fully employed, prices are going up, gold production continues to SECRET Approved For Refegse12005/I?~:`~-009718506(~040002-3 Approvedftr Release 200 IA-RDP79- ^ 0 7AO05000040002-3 SErifflip TABLE I SOUTH AFRICA'S GROSS NATIONAL PRODUCT (In Millions of US Dollars at 1958 Prices) 1960 1961 1962 1963 1964 Private consumption 4,929 4,866 5,191 5,664 6,303 Public consumption 757 809 934 1,011 1,116 Gross capital formation 1,525 1,494 1,485 1,791 2,038 Exports of goods and nonfactor services 2,206 2,374 2,512 2,678 2,762 Imports of goods and nonfactor services -1,877 -1,730 -1,792 -2,139 -2,674 Net factor income from abroad -281 -316 -280 -284 -297 Terms of trade adjustment -28 11 13 -52 78 Gross national product 7,231 7,508 8,063 8,669 9,326 Percent increased - 3.8% 7.4% 7.5% 7.6% TABLE II CONTRIBUTIONS OF SOUTH AFRICA TO FREE WORLD SUPPLY OF SELECTED MINERALS I N 1963 Percent of Commodity Free World Production Gold 70.4 Chromium ore 33.5 Platinum-group metals 41.8 Antimony 37.4 Manganese ore 20.3 Vanadium Uranium, U308 Diamonds Asbestos Approved For Release 200,Vf+ iM. T-RDP79-00927A005000040002-3 25X1 Approved For Rele 2005/01/05 : CIA-RDP79-00927A000040002-3 SECRET increase, although at a declin- ing rate, and more and more locally produced goods are be- ing consumed within South Af- rica. In fact, unless the gov- ernment markedly alters its policy of keeping nonwhites out of many jobs, additions to the labor force will be well below the level required. Although the economy will continue to grow at a respectable rate, some slowdown from four years of boom is inevitable. This slowdown does not, however, in- dicate any basic weakness in the economy. Despite the apparent fu- tility of their campaign, Afro- Asian and Communist countries with little or no stake in trade with South Africa will continue to demand that the Republic's major trading partners institute a boycott. They will not be de- terred by the evidence that such actions could have extremely serious consequences--especially for the UK--or by the growing consensus in responsible quart- ers that South Africa would be able to outlast any such boy- cott. The composition of South Africa's economy, its geographi- cal setting, and the determina- tion of the government to go its own way all combine to make the country one of the least vulnerable to economic sanctions. The Changing Economy Accelerated industrializa- tion in South Africa has been accompanied by a relative de- cline in agriculture, whose share of the net domestic prod- uct fell to only nine percent in 1964. Part of this decline re- flects a prolonged drought, but most of the change results from the shift of resources into manu- facturing, construction, and min- ing. Mining production jumped from $550 million in 1955 to more than $1 billion in 1964. In the same period, the private manufacturing and construction sector grew from $1.1 billion to $2.4 billion, an increase of about 113 percent. By comparison, agriculture grew only 21 percent during the same decade. An unusually large share of South Africa's income is the re- sult of foreign investment. In fiscal year 1964 about 7.2 per- cent of the net domestic product went to overseas investors, in- cluding $95 million in salaries and wages earned by foreigners in South Africa. Net domestic product esti- mates for calendar year 1964 are not available, but according to South African statistics re- leased at mid-year 1965, gross national product in 1964 increased by 7.6 percent, maintaining the level of the previous two years. (see Table 1). Mining South Africa is a major sup- plier of minerals to the free world--almost $1.5 billion worth last year--and consuming coun- tries would have difficulty find- ing alternative sources (see Table II). SECRET Page 3 Approved For Release 200$ggTE/CU-i ICI O79-0A2s$A9056D040002-3 401 Approved r Release 2005/01/05 : CIA-RDP79-00927A005000040002-3 SECRET Gold production dominates the country's mineral industry. In 1964, output reached 29.1 million fine ounces, equivalent to 70.4 percent of free world production. Gold sales totaled about $1.023 billion in 1964, a 27-percent increase over 1961. New mines have been opened, and higher rates of production have been achieved in some existing mines. Many older mines, how- ever, especially in Witwaters- rand,, operate at very little profit. Annual production-in- creases seem likely to continue, but rates of increase will cer- tainly decline barring new dis- coveries. Gold production rose 10.7 percent in 1962, but only 6.4 percent in 1964. Diamond production jumped more than 20 percent in 1964, and sales brought a record $61.9 million. Production increases in the Republic's mandated ter- ritory of South-West Africa were even more striking than in the Republic itself. Sales of South-West Africa's gem and in- dustrial diamonds which are marketed through the Republic amounted to about $84 million in 1964--some 47 percent over 1963. Although the spectacular growth in 1964 may not be repeated, diamond production in both the Republic and in South-West Af- rica is likely to continue to increase markedly. Rich fields have been discovered in northern Cape Province. Further, the in- novation of offshore dredging has been very successful in South- West Africa. Last year 286,000 carats'worth--close to $8 mil- lion, or almost 10 percent of the value of the territory's total diamond production--were recovered in this fashion. Oil has not yet been found, despite a relatively intensive search. Coal is used for about 85 percent of the Republic's energy requirements, is essen- tial to the transport system, and is the feedstock for a grow- ing synthetic gasoline industry. The country's coal reserves are enormous: 25 billion tons of proved reserves, and 50 billion tons of known but not yet proved reserves. Production in 1964 reached 49 million tons, worth in excess of $100 million. Agriculture Farming is decreasing in importance relative to other economic sectors, but still pro- vides the bulk of the Republic's exports other than gold. South African crops, like those of the United States, range from temperate to tropical products. Corn has been a most im- portant export crop, and the six- million-metric-ton harvest in mid-1963 produced a considerable export surplus. However, drought reduced the 1964 har- vest to less than 4.3 million metric tons, and the crop har- vested this past July was even smaller. For the first nine months of 1964, corn exports earned about $133 million in foreign exchange, but sales this year will fall off sharply and exports in 1966 are expected to be negligible. As a result of the corn shortfall, over-all South African agricultural pro- duction in 1963-64 increased SECRET Approv 6ot4Relegpt@@?V0A,,@fioqoA-RPPff&p%09a A005000040002-3 Approved For Rel a 2005/01/05 : CIA-RDP79-00927A00 00040002-3 SECRET INDEXES OF MANUFACTURING OUTPUT (Base: 1956/57 = 100) 1961 1962 1963 1964 Food 122.9 127.3 135.0 140.8 Beverages 130.4 137.7 155.9 178.8 Tobacco 93.5 91.4 98.6 102.6 Textiles 163.6 177.7 190.0 221.2 Clothing and footwear 117.6 119.3 129.3 143.0 Timber 108.6 124.4 139.1 144.1 Furniture 103.5 105.4 118.9 131.7 Paper and paper products 137.8 155.0 182.9 199.2 Printing 135.4 144.9 169.5 191.4 Leather and leather products 96.7 100.3 107.7 117.7 Rubber products 103.8 106.2 118.3 135.5 Chemicals and chemical products 129.7 142.5 156.5 176.6 Petroleum and coal products 138.6 149.6 182.4 291.0 Nonmetallic mineral products 112.8 113.3 127.7 156.7 Basic metals 134.8 139.5 165.9 186.7 Metal products 105.8 115.3 137.8 164.1 Machinery 122.0 131.4 140.6 158.5 Electrical machinery 120.8 129.6 155.4 184.9 Transport equipment 104.2 130.6 179.4 226.6 Miscellaneous 142.0 160.0 171.5 201.4 Composite weighted index 122.0 130.3 148.3 170.1 25X1 less than one-half of one per- cent over the previous year. Manufacturing and Construction From a 1956-57 base, manu- facturing output increased more than 70 percent by the end of 1964. The greatest growth oc- curred in the more sophisticated manufactures and in certain basic industrial activities. Pe- troleum and coal products, for example, increased 191 percent, transport equipment 127 percent, electrical machinery 85 percent, and chemicals and chemical prod- ucts 77 percent. Large addi- tions to capacity in 1964 are likely to result in even more substantial increases in output (see Table III) Thus far, at least, foreign and local investors have shown no appreciable reluctance to in- vest in South Africa, and govern- ment efforts to increase invest- ment in industry have been very successful. For example, work has begun on a $32-million Cal- tex refinery, construction is under way on a $17-million Japa- nese automobile factory, a SECRET Approved For Re $@ 2F005/0AR ?61A-k$ T0092tA% fO0 0002-3 Approver Release 2005/01/05 : CIA-RDP79-00927A005000040002-3 SECRET $34-million aircraft factory is programed, and the Anglo-Ameri- can Corporation is planning a $140-million steel-vanadium proj- ect at Witbank. Much of this new investment will reduce the Republic's dependence on imports and hence, to some degree, the effects of any boycott. Rates of return, reported to range between 20 and 30 percent annually, pro- vide a major incentive to in- vestors. South Africa's widespread shortage of skilled labor may be- come acute despite heavy additions to both the white and nonwhite labor force. Pressures are grow- ing to end or modify the govern- ment's practice of reserving cer- tain jobs and trades for whites only. Immigration has increased, but government efforts to ease the shortage of skilled workers by recruiting abroad have failed, partially because of the "unset- tled political situation" in South Africa. Many skilled work- ers were unwilling to move to a country which might be the target of "unfavorable" international ac- tions in the near future. As a practical matter, the job-reservation policy is becom- ing more honored in the breach, and in increasing instances white and nonwhite employees work side. by side, although at markedly dif- ferent pay scales. This erosion of apartheid in the labor field is causing considerable concern among white unionists. Some unions reportedly will insist that the infiltration of nonwhite workers into traditionally white jobs be controlled, and that non- white workers be permitted to join white unions or that non- white unions be given legal status. Many white unionists are disturbed by increasing em- ployer preference for lower paid nonwhites. Labor leaders also fear that an increase in nonwhite workers will enable employers effectively to resist demands for wage increases from the white labor force. As a result, these union- ists are now arguing that a non- white who does a white man's work must receive the same salary as the white worker. They also claim some white unions represent Africans, despite legal prohibi- tions. In addition, they note that white unions accept colored and Indian workers in the Cape Province, and that these non- whites are moving into white jobs as more and more employers simply ignore job reservation. Foreign Trade Much of the equipment and material needed to sustain South Africa's economic growth is im- ported from the industral coun- tries of Western Europe, from the United States, and more re- cently from Japan. In return, South Africa ships most of its exports to these markets. Only a negligible amount of trade is with independent African coun- tries, which at least partially explains the failure of the Af- ro-Asian boycott to cause South Africa more than minor incon- veniences. SE CRE T Approved For Release 2005/01/05 : CIA-RDP79-00927A005000040002-3 Page 6 SPECIAL REPORT 3 Sept 63 Approved For ReI 'e 2005/01/05: CIA-RDP79-00927A005,0040002-3 SECRET TABLE IV DIRECTION OF SOUTH AFRICAN IMPORTS Monthly Averages in Thousand US Dollars January - September 1963 1964 United Kingdom 40,946 48,992 United States 22,714 33,189 West Germany 14,997 15,234 Japan 6,556 9,442 Canada 4,968 5,627 Italy 4,069 5,194 France 4,083 4,540 Netherlands 3,399 4,338 Switzerland 2,263 3,301 Sweden 2,333 2,885 Total all countries 1 3 6, 730 173,477 In 1963 the bulk of the Re- public's imports came from the UK (about 30 percent), the US (almost 17 percent), and West Ger- many (nearly 11 percent). In- complete trade data for 1964 in- dicate that the US and Japan in- creased exports to South Africa substantially. For the first nine months of 1964, the monthly aver- age of US exports was about $33 million, 46 percent more than the same period in 1963. Japanese exports rose 44 percent during the same time span. Exports from the United Kingdom increased 20 percent (see Table IV). The UK bought a third of South Africa's exports in 1963 and was again the largest purchaser in 1964. The US, however, slipped from second place in 1963 to third place after Japan in 1964. This change was the result of a sharp increase in Japanese purchases rather than a sharp decline in South African ex- ports to the US. Japanese im- ports from the Republic in- creased about 32 percent during the first nine months of 1964, compared with the same period in 1963. West Germany, South Africa's fourth most important customer, also increased imports --by almost 14 percent (see Table,V) , South African exports are largely agricultural and mineral products. Imports are mostly DIRECTION OF SOUTH AFRICAN EXPORTS (Monthly Average in Thousand US Dollars) January - September 1963 1964 United Kingdom 32,279 34,360 Japan 7,647 10,068 United States* 8,417 8,883 West Germany 5,466 6,239 Belgium 4,544 5,938 S. Rhodesia ... 5,930 Italy 5,227 4,900 France 3,245 3,457 N. Rhodesia ... 3,305 Netherlands 3,072 2,502 Total all countries 104,372 110,032 * Excluding uranium. 25X1 SE CRE T Approved For Rele sj 20P5/0ynr_ - CI L- RREPORT 9-0092 3A 05p0006050002-3 Approvebr Release 2005/01/05 : CIA-RDP79-007A005000040002-3 SECRET manufactured goods, machinery and transport equipment, chemi- cals, and petroleum. In 1963 imports of goods in these cate- gories totaled $1.3 billion, about 77 percent of all imports. Petroleum products alone were $107 million. The largest cate- gory of US exports to the Re- public last year was nonelectric machinery ($125 million), fol- lowed by chemicals ($52 million), textiles ($38 million), and motor vehicles ($27 million). In 1964, total imports rose about 23 percent, but exports increased only 6.5 percent. As a result, the trade deficit in- creased sharply from $390 mil- lion in 1963 to $710 million last year. South Africa's gold output, in excess of $1 billion, helped to finance this deficit, but for the first time in recent years the current account went from a favorable balance of $207 million in 1963 to a deficit of $109 million in 1964. By 9 July 1965, gold and foreign exchange reserves had reached a low of $475 million. Despite the warning signs evi- dent in the balance of payments and the continuing decline in reserves, South African offi- cials do not seem unduly con- cerned. Clearly, however, bar- ring an unlikely upsurge in ex- ports, imports will have to be reduced before many more months. The Boycott The Afro-Asian and Commu- nist trade boycott of South Af- rica--designed to win a reversal or major amelioration of the Verwoerd government's apartheid policies--has in fact been coun- terproductive. Instead of weak- ening the economy, it has given impetus to the government's pro- gram of economic nationalism and helped to stimulate the Republic's rapid growth. The boycott's failure to influence appreciably South Africa's domestic policies points up the relative unimpor- tance of the Afro-Asian and Com- munist countries in the Repub- lic's trading pattern and the necessity for the Republic's ma- jor trade partners to participate if sanctions are to be effective at all. Furthermore, many African countries continue quietly to trade with South Africa, which has suppressed its foreign trade data since January 1964 so as to avoid Afro-Asian harassment of those countries. South Africa's nrom official trade statistics and replaced it with a "miscellaneous" category. SECRET Approved For Release 2005/01/05 : CIA-RDP79-00927A005000040002-3 Page 8 SPECIAL REPORT 3 Sept 65 25X1 25X1 25k1 Approved For Rele'e 2005/01/05: CIA-RDP79-00927A00SG?0040002-3 SECRET 25X1 Even before the boycott, South Africa's trade with the Com- munists was not very important. In 1963, its exports to the Com- munist world were about $15 mil- lion, of which China took $6 mil- lion, and imports were less than $12 million. Although this trade has since declined sharply, it is continuing, either directly or, especially in the case of China through third parties. Neither Japan nor Iran, the Republic's major Asian trading partners, has shown any inclina- tion to restrict trade. Iran, which supplies the bulk of South Africa's petroleum requirements, has already pleaded before the UN an inability to halt shipments of oil, pointing out that Iranian oil exports are handled by a con- sortium of foreign companies rather than by the government. Tehran also argued that experience had shown that when supplies from one country were stopped, the gap was immediately filled by other countries. Although an oil embargo is a favorite subject for those pushing for economic sanctions, South Africa's vulnerability to this form of pressure is more ap- parent than real, especially in view of the world oil surplus. Moreover, commercial interests of producing countries tend to outweigh political causes that do not immediately affect them. Iran, for example, still sup- 25X1 plies most of Israel's oil needs, despite years of protests by Arab governments. Furthermore, South Africa has taken steps to reduce its petroleum vulnerability; it is building more storage facili- ties, adding new refining capacity, and is investigating setting up its own oil-tanker fleet which would operate under a flag of convenience. South Africa's indifference to African pressure tactics also extends to possible secondary boycotts against countries and companies doing business with the Republic. South African Airways has already been banned from most African countries, but the com- pany has maintained the increas- ingly profitable routes to Europe through Lisbon via Portuguese West African Territories and the Canary Islands. If foreign air- lines were prevented from serv- ing South Africa, the country would be further isolated, but this would not be serious. A marked reduction in ocean shipping serving South Africa could deal the Republic a crip- pling blow, but an effective secondary shipping boycott is almost inconceivable. The ships of the three US lines serving SE CRE T Approved For Release 2005/01/05 : CIA-RDP79-00927A005000040002-3 Page 9 SPECIAL REPORT 3 Sept 65 Approved Fbr Release 2005/01/05 : CIA-RDP79-00 27A005000040002-3 SECRET South Africa generally make no stops on the continent other than at South African and Portuguese African ports. For lines serving other ports, South African ton- nages are far more important than the sum of cargoes collected along either the East or West African coasts--probably worth five or six times the combined totals of Kenya, Uganda, and Tanzania. Thus, shipping interests might well choose to cut out other countries rather than abandon their more profitable South African calls. The Effect of Sanctions With the complete failure of their own halfhearted efforts to boycott South Africa, the Afro- Asian countries have turned their attention increasingly toward en- listing the participation of the Republic's major trading partners. On 1 December 1964 the Organiza- tion of African Unity sought such support, arguing that "the regime can be forced to come to its senses or to relinquish its hold over the governmental machinery in South Africa ... (through) the use ofitcon- certed economic sanctions.... Four days later the OAU apparently concluded the job was simpler and that "a total embargo on the sales of rubber to South Africa can sufficiently achieve the above purpose." Earlier it held a simi- lar position with respect to an oil embargo. However, independent studies on South Africa's ability to with- stand boycotts of selected items such as petroleum or rubber gen- erally agree that the country's economy could stand such denials indefinitely. The Republic's Many Afro-Asian countries refuse to recognize the military, political, and economic realities involved in a boycott of South Africa, or the fact that boy- cotts simply do not work. Even the present arms embargo, agreed to by most countries, has not halted the flow of weapons to South Africa. France, for ex- ample, is quite willing to sup- ply South Africa a variety of military wares and, as a matter of principle, refuses to con- sider an economic boycott and has even declined to participate in UN discussions of the problem. British Prime Minister Wilson has called oil sanctions "some- thing very relevant to near-war or war situation." The UK con- siders British implementation of economic sanctions completely out of the question, partly be- cause of the virtual impossibil- ity of enforcing an embargo, but chiefly because the cost to the British economy would be prohib- itive. Neither West Germany nor Japan has shown the slightest in- clination to take any initiative in economic sanctions. South African Countermeasures In clamoring for a boycott, South Africa's more vocal Afri- can critics seem unaware or un- concerned about the Republic's Approved For Release Page 10 SPECIAL REPORT 3 Sept 65 Approved For Rele'e 2005/01/05 : CIA-RDP79-00927A00f90040002-3 SECRET ability to institute counter- measures. Likely targets would be the British High Commission Territories adjacent to or sur- rounded by South Africa. The UK has reported to the UN that, if South Africa cut off trade with the territories, the ef- fect would be "disastrous" in Basutoland and a "severe eco- nomic crisis would develop for Bechuanaland which the United Kingdom would be powerless to avert." The prospect for Swazi- land was described as likely to be "serious." Should South Africa also repatriate migrant labor, the problem would be even worse. South Africa's role as the world's largest gold supplier gives it a potent economic weapon of reprisal. A denial of South African gold exports to world money markets either by South African initiative or as the re- sult of a boycott would be most serious. There is already a greater demand for monetary gold than can easily be satisfied from present stocks. Furthermore, the increasingly propensity of some countries, France for example, to hold gold rather than dollars is putting an additional strain on dwindling US gold stocks. Mone- tary authorities are increasingly concerned with the problem of international liquidity and, given the present makeup of the world monetary system, the denial of South Africa's annual addition of over a billion dollars to the world gold supply would likely have an extremely deleterious eff ect. F_ 25X1 SECRET Approved For Rogge 326051 NI.A&AP-14 8-00A7AeD$06040002-3 Approver Release 2005/01/05 : CIA-RDP79-0097A005000040002-3 SECRET SECRET Approved For Release 2005/01/05 : CIA-RDP79-00927AO05000040002-3