CURRENT INTELLIGENCE WEEKL;Y SUMMARY

Document Type: 
Collection: 
Document Number (FOIA) /ESDN (CREST): 
CIA-RDP79-00927A001800090001-4
Release Decision: 
RIPPUB
Original Classification: 
S
Document Page Count: 
41
Document Creation Date: 
December 20, 2016
Document Release Date: 
December 12, 2005
Sequence Number: 
1
Case Number: 
Publication Date: 
October 27, 1999
Content Type: 
SUMMARY
File: 
AttachmentSize
PDF icon CIA-RDP79-00927A001800090001-4.pdf3.13 MB
Body: 
Approved For Release 2007/10/23: CIA-RDP79-00927AO01800090001-4 CONFIDENTIAL CURRENT INTELLIGENCE WEEKLY SUMMARY COPY NO. 50 OCI NO. 1800/58 AUTH: HR 70- NEXT REVIEW DATE: d DECLASSIFIED CLASS. CHANGED TO. w 31 July 1958 DOCUMENT NO. NO CHANGE IN CLASS. 0 CENTRAL INTELLIGENCE AGENCY OFFICE OF CURRENT INTELLIGENCE CONF~L State Department review completed 1~ibiw 6 :/flFd~iwi. & 1 .cn.h ,C;,tb; Approved For Release 2007/10/23: CIA-RDP79-00927AO01800090001-4 Approved For Release 2007/10/23: CIA-RDP79-00927AO01800090001-4 THIS MATERIAL CONTAINS INFORMATION AFFECT- ING THE NATIONAL DEFENSE OF THE UNITED STATES WITHIN THE MEANING OF THE ESPIONAGE LAWS, TITLE 18, USC, SECTIONS 793 AND 794, THE TRANSMIS- SION OR REVELATION OF WHICH IN ANY MANNER TO AN UNAUTHORIZED PERSON IS PROHIBITED BY LAW. The Current Intelligence Weekly Summary has been prepared primarily for the internal use of the Central Intelligence Agency. It does not represent a complete coverage of all current situations. Comments and conclusions represent the immediate appraisal of the Office of Current Intelligence. Approved For Release 2007/10/23: CIA-RDP79-00927AO01800090001-4 Approved For Release 2007/10/23: CIA-RDP79-00927AO01800090001-4 Next 6 Page(s) In Document Denied Approved For Release 2007/10/23: CIA-RDP79-00927AO01800090001-4 Approved For Release 2007/10/23: CIA-RDP79-00927AO01800090001-4 CONFIDLN I IRL CURRENT INTELLIGENCE WEEKLY SUMMARY 31 July 1958 PART I OF IMMEDIATE INTEREST MIDDLE EAST DEVELOPMENTS General Shihab's election on 31 July as the new president of Lebanon will almost certain- ly be followed by opposition de- mands that President Chamoun retire immediately and that the American and UN forces be with- drawn. The opposition clearly anticipates that Shihab will be merely a caretaker president until a new parliament can be elected and another president chosen--possibly in six months' time--who would be even more to the opposition's liking than Shihab. If Chamoun remains in office until the legal expira- tion of his term on 23 Septem- ber, and if "loyalist" elements seek to frustrate the opposi- tion's efforts::to gain control of the government quickly, there may well be a new.crists. An- other critical issue is likely to be the choice of an army commander to succeed Shihab. While weariness with ter- rorism and the exhaustion of the politicians may temporarily produce a calm internal situa- tion in Lebanon, the "manifesto" put out by part of the opposi- tion this week is indicative of longer range Moslem demands for a radical revision or abolition of the traditional structure of Lebanese politics. The mani- festo, attacking the fiction that the Christian population of the country constitutes a majority, demanded that hence- forth half the offices be given Moslems and that parliamentary constituencies be on a geograph- ical rather than coAfessional basis. The authors of the mani- festo originally said they would insist that Shihab sub- scribe to the document, but subsequently backed down and indicated the statement was merely to "appease the mob." Such statements nevertheless tend under present conditions to become positions from which radical Arab nationalist lead- ers dare not retreat. Iraq The Baghdad regime, which has succeeded in obtaining gen- eral diplomatic recognition, has continued to express itself publicly in moderate terms and to profess friendship for the West while pressing for Ameri- can recognition. The basic be- lief in Western antagonism to- ward the new regime found ex- pression on 30 July, when a fire which broke out in the tank farm of a British-owned oil company in Baghdad was popularly attrib- uted to "imperialist" sabotage. The regime, obviously fearing an outbreak of anti-Western vio- lence, quickly imposed a curfew and asked the populace not to believe rumors regarding :the origin of the fire. King Husayn's effort to make Jordan some kind of pro- Western "fortress" has been further undermined by the fa- tigue of Prime Minister Rifai. Rifai's disability, added to the burden': of other problems and to evidence of increasing disaf- fection, may lead Husayn to capitulate to UAR pressure. At the present time, the King's only secure safeguard is the presence of British troops; if CONFIDENTIAL 00 C OF 'IMMEDIATE INTEREST Page 1 of 6 -- Approved For Release 2007/10/23: CIA-RDP79-00927AO01800090001-4 Approved For Release 2007/10/23: CIA-RDP79-00927AO01800090001-4 Approved For Release 2007/10/23: CIA-RDP79-00927AO01800090001-4 Approved For Release 2007/10/23: CIA-RDP79-00927AO01800090001-4 SECRET CURRENT INTELLIGENCE WEEKLY SUMMARY 31 July 1058 these leave the country, the King would seem to have little choice but to go with them or bow to Nasir. For the present, the Jordan radio has been in- structed to take a "softer" line toward Nasir, and there are some indications that Nasir, besides preparing for Husayn's over- throw, may be making an effort to persuade him to surrender. he believes the Arab peop a are behind Nasir, right or wrong, and that, even if Nasir intends eventually to overthrow the Persian Gulf sheikdoms, one cannot resist "Kismet." At present, however, the security situation in Kuwait appears fairly good following a strong stand by the police against demonstrations. Prime Minister Khalil has retained office through the end of the parliamentary session, but his pro-Western policy has been attacked heavily in both houses, which passed unanimous resolutions condemning the Amer- ican and British use of troops in Lebanon and Jordan. The pro- Egyptian elements which seek Khalil's ouster now have turned to arousing the sentiment of the "street" against him. Kuwait The Ruler of Kuwait re- t4rned-from Damascus this week in a "defeatist" mood following talks with Nasir. The Israeli military re- main alert for possible trouble, especially a deterioration in the Jordanian situation. Most Israeli activity at present is in the diplomatic field, how- ever, and is concentrated on trying to ensure that Israel's interests do not suffer from any high-level international discussions on the Middle East. While French-Israeli col- laboration appears to remain close, the Israelis may have been rebuffed in an attempt to obtain more formal commitments from France. Foreign Minister Meir plans a trip to Paris next week. The Israelis are also seek- ing ways and means of avoiding being further identified in SECRET PART I OF IMMEDIATE INTEREST Page 3 of 6 Approved For Release 2007/10/23: CIA-RDP79-00927AO01800090001-4 Approved For Release 2007/10/23: CIA-RDP79-00927AO01800090001-4 SECRET CURRENT INTELLIGENCE WEEKLY SUMMARY 31 July 1958 Afro-Asian circles as handmaid- ens of imperialism. The, immedi- ate problem is their acquies- cence in the overflight of Brit- ish and American aircraft sup- porting the British forces in Jordan. However, they also face a longer range danger of being completely isolated in an area dominated by Nasir, who in turn would be backed by the USSR. A shift by Israel to a more neutralist position in an effort to diminish Soviet hostility is one of the long-range tac- tics reported being discussed. Moscow on 30 July named G. T. Zaytsev, head of the Near East department of the Soviet Foreign Ministry, as ambassador to Iraq and continues to move rapidly to establish close work- ing relations with the new Iraqi Government. Soviet leaders apparently believe that the possibility of early Western military action against Iraq, either alone or in cooperation with Middle East allies, has diminished. Peiping continues to con- centrate on Asian states in ef- forts to gain popular support for the bloc's case against the Western intervention. Peiping, like New Delhi, refers in its statements to the "tense situa-, tion in Western Asia" rather than the Middle East. Chinese Communist ambassadors in Karachi and Djakarta have called on Prime Minister Noon and Presi- dent Sukarno respectively, and the envoy in New Delhi has con- tacted Nehru. Peiping has begun accusing the Chinese Nationalists of us- ing the Middle East crisis to "step up war preparations" and carry out new "harassment." Large numbers of military per- sonnel and civilians in the coastal provinces have partic- ipated in mass demonstrations protesting against Chinese Na- tionalist activity and pledging readiness to "liberate" Taiwan "at any time." Baghdad Pact Meeting The Baghdad Pact Ministe- rial Council meeting in London on 28-29 July focused primarily on the altered situation in the Middle East as a re{ult of the Iraqi coup and resolved to carry out the purposes of the pact despite the probable loss of Iraq as a member. Turkey, Iran, Pakistan, and Britain decided the new Baghdad regime should be recognized this week. The question of Iraq's mem- bership was left to Baghdad's initiative and it was decided to avoid any action that might drive Iraq from the organiza- tion. This policy will permit the members to maintain flexi- bility until Iraq's intentions are clear. It had been feared that the new Iraqi regime might send delegates, especially to the Military Committee sessions, in an attempt to learn pact in- tentions. In view of the in- tense Arab nationalist opposi- tion to the Baghdad Pact, Iraq's continued membership is consid- ered unlikely. Meanwhile the headquarters of the pact is being transferred to Ankara, and plans are being made to counter Egypt's exploitation of alleged pact documents. The delegations all ex- pressed concern over Iraq's new orientation, and Iranian Prime Minister Egbal especially noted the added threat to Iran, ex- pressing fear that his country SECRET PART I OF IMMEDIATE INTEREST Page 4 of 6 Approved For Release 2007/10/23: CIA-RDP79-00927AO01800090001-4 Approved For Release 2007/10/23: CIA-RDP79-00927A001800090001-4 SECRET CURRENT INTELLIGENCE'WEEKLY SUMMARY 31 July 1958 might now become a primary ob- jective of Soviet pressure. Turkey believes Egypt and the USSR now will try to achieve a direct land connection via Iraq between the two countries, pos- sibly through the promotion of a Kurdish republic. The London conference con- firmed the intentions of.all remaining members to strength- SOVIET TACTICS ON Khrushchev's latest notes on 28 July calling for an im- mediate conference of the Big Four heads of government,plus Indian Prime Minister Nehru and UN Secretary General Ham- marskjold, reflect Moscow's hope that it can exploit Premier de Gaulle's dislike for a sum- mit conference in New York to force the United States and Britain to accept a meeting sub- stantially on Soviet terms. Comments of De Gaulle's foreign policy advisers suggest that he actually is not eager for summit talks at this time, particularly in the UN frame- work, which he feels would of- fer the Russians too many prop- aganda advantages. They also believe Khrushchev's proposed inclusion of India would make difficult an agreement on the agenda and a list of other par- ticipafts. Preoccupied with constitutional reform and Al- gerian problems, De Gaulle pre- fers a later, carefully prepared and discreetly conducted con- ference. Although on 23 July Khru- shchev had ostensibly accepted en the Baghdad Pact, and the prospect: of closer' American affiliation appeared to bolster the morale of the delegates. The further consolidation of Arab nationalism and the in- creased fear of Soviet actions will encourage heavier demands on the United States for mili- tary equipment and guarantees. SUMMIT MEETING American and British suggestions that the meeting be held within the context of the UN Security Council, the latest Soviet notes back away from this position. Alleging the United States and Britain abandoned their earlier proposals for a special session of the Security Council at the heads-of-government level in favor of an "ordinary session" of the Security Council, the Soviet leader, calling this a step backward on the West's part,?endorsed Premier de Gaulle's suggestion for a "private" meet- ing of the major powers in a European city. Moscow has been careful not to close the door to a com- promise formula for a summit meeting within they UN frame- work. Khrushchev, in his 28 July letters, adopted a pose of un- concern for procedural details in the face of the overriding importance of an immediate meet- ing to ease Middle East tension. Moscoi continues to insist on the parti+6ipatioh of India, but, unlike the 23 July notes, the latent `Soviet messages-do not mention the "natural" par- ticipation of the Arab states. SECRET PART I OF IMMEDIATE INTEREST Page 5 of 6 Approved For Release 2007/10/23: CIA-RDP79-00927A001800090001-4 Approved For Release 2007/10/23: CIA-RDP79-00927AO01800090001-4 SECRET CURRENT INTELLIGENCE WEEKLY SUMMARY 31 July 1958 Moscow's charges of Western , duplicity. and procrastination in the face of the "extraordi- narily serious situation" in the Middle East are designed to place the West on the defen- sive regarding time, place, and composition of the pro- jected conference and, if no conference is held, to place the blame for the failure on the West. Khrushchev's letters con- tinue Soviet efforts to create a sense of extreme emergency with charges that "preparations for armed interference in Iraq are proceeding at full speed." On 30 July, Moscow protested against the alleged violation of Soviet air space by an Amer- ican bomber from Iran, stating the USSR attaches "especially serious importance" to this in- cident because of the tense situation in the Middle East created by American and Brit- ish armed intervention. SECRET PART I OF IMMEDIATE INTEREST On 30 July, Moscow also is- sued a sharply worded TASS statement accusing the London meeting of the Baghdad Pact mem- bers of "evolving new aggres- sive measures directed toward further aggravation of the mil- itary conflict." On 26 July, Moscow in a note to the Bonn government protested the use of air bases in West Germany for the redeployment of American forces and called on Bonn to take effective measures to halt such operations in accord with the "vital national interests" of West Germany. A Soviet aide-memoire to Turkey on 24 July reviewed press reports of Turkish troop concentrations on the Syrian and Iraqi borders and warned Ankara of "grave responsibilr- ity fbr,possible ' consequences" of an attack on Iraq. Page 6 of 6 25X1 25X1 Approved For Release 2007/10/23: CIA-RDP79-00927AO01800090001-4 Approved For Release 2007/10/23: CIA-RDP79-00927AO01800090001-4 tivimUCIV 1 IY1L 31 July 1958 The TASS summary of the Soviet economic plan fulfill- ment report for mid-1958 shows a 10.5-percent increase in in- dustrial production over the first half of 1957, indicating that the economy has not been disrupted by the industrial re- organization. Prospects for a good harvest in 1958 and the large reported increase in in- vestment, in light and food in- dustries promise continuing steady improvement in the stand- ard of living for the Soviet consumer. The report points out that all but one sovnarkhoz over- fulfilled their plans, and stresses that production suc- cesses were a result of the reorganization. PERCENTAGE ANNUAL RATE REPORTED PRODUCTION DURING FIRST HALF 19SS PLANNED PRODUCTION FOR FULL YEAR 1958 PLANNED PERCENTAGE INCREASE 1958 OVER 1957 OF INCREASE NEEDED 1959-1960 TO REACH ORIGINAL 6TH PLAN GOALS STEEL 27.0 ?O 53.6 5 0% 10.0% MILLION TONS . M MI IRON 19.3 39.1 5.7% 12.6% MILLION TONS ROLLED METAL 21.3 41.7 3.7% 9.4% MILLION TONS COAL 245.0 488.9 5.6% 8.7% MILLION TONS PETROLEUM 54.0 112.6 14.5% 11.0% MILLION TONS CEMENT 15.9 33.9 17.3% 24.0% MILLION TONS ELECTRIC POWER 114.0 231.0 10 3% 15.0% BILLION KWH . REPORTED PERCENTAGE INCREASE FIRST HALF 1958 OVER FIRST HALF 1957 GROSS INDUSTRIAL 10.5% 7.6% 10.7% OUTPUT LABOR PRODUCTIVITY 6.0% 5.4% 9.6% IN INDUSTRY NOTES AND COMMENTS Industry The reported increase in industrial production of 10.5 percent over that for the first half of 1957 maintains approxi- mately the same rate of growth as that achieved in the past two years. The physical output data included in the report indicated that 1958 production goals for the basic branches of industry will be fulfilled without dif- ficulty. The 1958 goals, how- ever, like those for 1957, rep- resent lower rates of growth than were attained during the early postwar years and than were originally planned for the Sixth Five-Year Plan. CONFIDENTIAL Pace 1 of 16 Approved For Release 2007/10/23: CIA-RDP79-00927AO01800090001-4 Approved For Release 2007/10/23: CIA-RDP79-00927AO01800090001-4 SECRET 31 July 1958 The reported increase in industrial labor productivity of 6 percent is the same as last year, suggesting that the steady decline in the rate of increase of labor productivity from the 8 percent achieved in 1955 may have been halted. The volume of capital in- vestment increased 11 percent. An increase of 28 percent in capital investment in ferrous metallurgy suggests that plans were implemented for expanding production capacity in those critical industrial materials industries which affect the growth of dependent economic sectors. The reported 23-per- cent increase in investment in the light and food industries is striking compared with the modest increases accorded these industries in past years. Agriculture The report states that the plan for sowing spring crops was overfulfilled and that the total area under crops for the 1958 harvest is 3,700,000 acres, or about 1 percent greater than in 1957. This would place the area under crops slightly above that during the record harvest year of 1956. Good growing con- ditions have prevailed, partic- ularly in the main grain areas, thus enhancing the prospect for a bumper harvest in 1958. Livestock flocks and herds, at least in the socialized sec- tor, were considerably larger in mid-1958 than in mid-1957, and the state procurement and purchase plan for the first half of 1958 was reported over- fulfilled for meat, wool, and eggs. Milk procurements re- portedly increased 9 percent as compared to the first half of 1957, but no mention was made of plan fulfillment. Milk produc- tion may have increased only slightly, if any, over last year, when milk output was fa- vored by good pasturage from an early spring and relatively abundant feed supplies from the 1956 harvest. According to the report, '65 percent of the collective farms by 1 July had purchased machinery, and in June the collective farms conducted 73 percent of the total volume of tractor work performed on all collective farms with their own tractors. Retail trade, which grew more rapidly than planned during 1957, is increasing at a slower pace in 1958, slightly above the 7-percent rate planned for the year in contrast to the 10 percent planned and 14 percent achieved in 1957. Housing goals achieved indicate that the state plan calling for a 19-percent in- crease for the full year is being 'fulfilled. ORR) KPrepared by SOVIET WITHDRAWALS FROM EASTERN EUROPE Three Soviet line divisions have been withdrawn from Hungary and Rumania in accordance with plans announced at the Warsaw Pact meeting on 27 May. The units involved are believed to SECRET Page 2 of 16 Approved For Release 2007/10/23: CIA-RDP79-00927AO01800090001-4 Approved For Release 2007/10/23: CIA-RDP79-00927AO01800090001-4 SECRET CURRENT INTELLIGENCE WEEKLY SUM ARY have been relocated in military districts in the western USSR where they would be readily available for redeployment to the satellites. There are 25 combat divi- sions totaling about 400,000 men still stationed in East Germany, Poland, and Hungary. With the possi- ble exception of some headquarters person- nel and an advisory group, all Soviet personnel in Rumania have been withdrawn. 31 July 1958 EAST J GERMANY -4 4n Diviniens 22 Air Regime WEST 2 Divisions 14 Air Regiments 3 Divisions 9 Air Regiments ADNIA TIC SEA SOVIET STRENGTH DISPOSITION Figures are for line divisions only. 31 JULY 1958 an advisory group w ch existed before the withdrawal will continue to ex- ert influence over the Rumanian armed forces. Two line divi- sions, an antiaircraft artil- lery division, and five fight- er regiments were involved in this withdrawal. In Hungary,a division with headquarters at Esztergom was withdrawn from the area north of Budapest. Concurrent with the departure of this unit, there was some relocation and realignment of subordinate units. At least three combat divisions totaling 45,000 men supported by tactical air elements remain in Hungary, almost twice the Group Only (western USSR only) 55 Divisions 160 Air Reg;rnents AEGEAN "a SEA SLACK SEA strength of Soviet units there before the rebellion. The USSR has taken pains to demonstrate the fulfillment of its announced withdrawal plans by holding departure cer- emonies in each of the major garrison areas. Western mili- tary observers, however, were not invited to witness these ceremonies as they had been in East Germany. In addition to these withdrawals, the Warsaw Pact announcement stated that satellite armed forces Would be reduced by 119,000 men. There has been no positive evidence that this reduction in force has been carried out. SECRET PART II NOTES AND COMMENTS Page 3 of 16 Approved For Release 2007/10/23: CIA-RDP79-00927AO01800090001-4 Approved For Release 2007/10/23: CIA-RDP79-00927AO01800090001-4 SECRET CURRENT INTELLIGENCE WEEKLY SUMMARY 31 July 1958 INDONESIA operation yet undertaken. The rebels reportedly reached the center of the,city before government forces were suffi- ciently organized to force their withdrawal. The govern- ment has regained the initia- tive, but Djakarta did not release news of the attack until 27 July. According to the Djakarta announcement, the dissident attacking force totaled 2,000. In Sumatra, rebel activity continues at an increasing pace. The dissident attack on Bukittinggi, Central Sumatra, which began on 23 July is the largest dissident offensive yyd ~" I b- jR%181 ongga. Tobolr~'" SECRET NOTES AND COMMENTS Page 4 of 16 Approved For Release 2007/10/23: CIA-RDP79-00927AO01800090001-4 Approved For Release 2007/10/23: CIA-RDP79-00927AO01800090001-4 SECRET CURRENT INTELLIGENCE WEEKLY SUMMARY 31 July 1958 LAOTIAN CABINET CRISIS Prospects for a revitalized Laotian Government dominated by young, anti-Communist civil and military leaders appear to have diminished. Premier-designate Souvanna Phouma has offered the "Young Turks" 5 seats in a 14- man cabinet that is otherwise in character with previous in- effectual governments. The Communist-dominated Neo Lao Hak Zat is report- ed willing to back this or any, other cabinet headed by Souvanna. It apparently regards Souvanna as tractable and fears that op- position would ultimately lead to the closure of the National Assembly and the imposition of a strong government by Crown Prince Savang or the army. The young reformists--or- ganized as the Committee for the Defense of the National In- terests (CDNI)--have refused Souvanna's offer and are threat- ening a coup unless giving a ma- jority representation in the new cabinet. The committee, recent- ly formed and without organized popular support, has had to rely, on threats of extra constitu-' tional action to give weight to its demands. fluidity of the situation. Recent police maneuvers and the placing of the army on an alert status demonstrate the 25X1 Cambodian Premier Sihanouk may accept some form of military assistance from Communist China when he visits Peiping about 10 August unless Cambodia's border disputes with South Vietnam have been settled. Most Cambodian officials oppose such a drastic step, but Sihanouk feels sure of broad mass support in view of inflamed public opinion over the border incursion by Viet- namese forces in Stung Treng Province in June. Sihanouk re- cently has spoken of "dwin- dling" American military assist- ance to Cambodia, in contrast to "ample" amounts given the "enemy" Vietnamese, and he has even warned his people that this aid may soon be terminated altogether. Sihanouk's act of according full diplomatic recognition to Peiping has already aroused some internal opposition. Gen- eral Dap Chhuon, influential anti-Communist governor of Siem Reap Province, has sent word to Ambassador Strom in Phnom Penh of his "deep distress." The in- definite postponement of the National Congress, scheduled to have opened on 27 July and to have reviewed this policy, indi- cates that opinion is also di- vided in Phnom Penh. In Saigon, Vietnamese Pres- ident Diem has described Phnom Penh's recognition of Peiping as "a body blow," and he fore- sees the complete isolation of Vietnam. He regards Laos-as SECRET PART II NOTES AND COMMENTS Page 5 of 16 Approved For Release 2007/10/23: CIA-RDP79-00927AO01800090001-4 Approved For Release 2007/10/23: CIA-RDP79-00927AO01800090001-4 SECRET CURRENT INTELLIGENCE WEEKLY SUMMARY 31 July 1958 seriously in danger of being lost to Communism and feels Thailand is politically unstable. Diem still professes an inter- est in reaching some agreement with Phnom Penh but basically feels the situation in Cambodia cannot be retrieved as long as Sihanouk remains in power. He claims that "thinking" Cambo- dians are becoming increasingly aware that Sihanouk's do- mestic and foreign policies are "ruin- ing the country," and seems convinced they will oust him from leadership with- in a year. Diem has taken no action as yet to order the removal of the massively con- structed and heavily defended concrete border marker erected by Vietnamese troops in June more than a mile inside the old Cambodian frontier. A company of Vietnamese marines has also been sent to the dis- puted Pirate Islands in the Gulf of Siam. Some of these small islands are already occupied by Cambodian garrisons and, even if an incident does not occur, Phnom Penh will consider this move further evidence of Vietnamese aggression. NORTH VIETNAM ACKNOWLEDGES CHINESE MODEL FOR DOMESTIC PROGRAMS The slogan "We Must Learn From Chinese Experience" is be- coming commonplace in North Vietnam as Hanoi begins its much-heralded "transition to socialism." To popularize the programs which form the "new phase" of the revolution, the regime is telling the peasants how much better off they would be in cooperatives like their Chinese colleagues, and the bourgeoisie is being lectured on the merits of Peiping's joint state-private ownership system. The army has promised to "catch up" with the Chinese People's Liberation Army as it carries out its modernization program. Although North Vietnam's new programs are being advertised as Chinese in origin, the deci- sion to adopt them was probably made on Hanoi's initiative rath- er than Peiping's. President Ho Chi Minh urged last month's Congress of Labor Heroes "to study the experience of fraternal countries, par- ticularly China." Practically no strata of society has been immune to this admonition. In July the increased pub- licity being given to Peiping's tactics became particularly noticeable when Nhan Dan, the official party paper,TEegan a daily column devoted to Chinese SECRET NOTES AND COMMENTS Page 6 of 16 __ Approved For Release 2007/10/23: CIA-RDP79-00927AO01800090001-4 Approved For Release 2007/10/23: CIA-RDP79-00927A001800090001-4 SECRET CURRENT INTELLIGENCE WEEKLY SUMMARY 31 July 1958 experiences."Rectification" has received special attention and praise, perhaps because Hanoi has declared its intention to thoroughly house clean the party apparatus this year. "Coopera- tivization of agriculture" has been given wide play, and Chi- nese movies illustrating the joys of the peasant's new life were shown to members of the National Assembly at its last session. The regime hopes the prom- ise of achievements matching China's will offset the tradi- tional distaste bordering on antipathy which Vietnamese feel for their northern neighbors. Although the Lao Dong party statutes enjoin the North Viet- namese Communists to "follow the thinking of Mao Tse-tung," the regime in the past has adopted programs such as land rent reduction, the agricultur- al tax, and ag-rarian reform without acknowledging their Chinese inspiration. The word- ing of the Vietnamese directives were virtual translations of the Chinese prototypes. Whether Vietnamese cadres showed less imagination and adaptability or whether condi- tions in Vietnam are less like those in China than it would appear, these programs were not nearly so successful in the smaller country. Agrarian re- form in particular was bungled so badly that the regime had to backtrack on its goals. If Hanoi should prove inept or in- competent in carrying out its present programs, which for the first time are frankly acknowl- edged to be Chinese in origin, it might weaken the appeal of Peiping's argument that Chinese Communist methods are applica- ble to other underdeveloped countries. LEFTISTS EMERGING AS DOMINANT POLITICAL FORCE IN SINGAPORE The Communist-influenced People's Action party (PAP) ap- pears likely to become the dom- inant political party in Singa- pore when internal self-rule is achieved next year. The PAP victory in the recent city-coun- cil by-election in the Kallang district, widely regarded as an important test of strength, is further evidence of the con- tinuing left-wing trend in Sin-- gapore. The party is now in a strong position for the elec- tions to rural district coun- cils in September and those to the Legislative Assembly next spring which will precede the institution of self-rule. The PAP success was achieved despite a major effort by the moderate parties. The Labor Front and the Liberal' So- cialists combined to support a single candidate, and Chief Minister Lim Yew Hock campaigned strongly for him. The PAP over- came the further handicap of running a Malay in a predomi- nantly Chinese district. This victory, after the PAP had won 13 of the 14 seats it contested in last December's city-council elections, seems likely to have a bandwagon effect which no mod- erate coalition can arrest. Chief Minister Lim's embryonic United Socialist Front (USF) seems to have little chance to stem the leftist tide, especial- ly since the USF's primary strength must be drawn from the Labor Front and the Liberal So- cialists, which have already failed in their first coopera- tive efforts. The poor showing of former Chief Minister David Marshall's SECRET PART II NOTES AND COMMENTS Page 7 of 16 Approved For Release 2007/10/23: CIA-RDP79-00927A001800090001-4 Approved For Release 2007/10/23: CIA-RDP79-00927AO01800090001-4 SECRET CURRENT INTELLIGENCE WEEKLY SUMMARY 31 July 1958 Worker's party appears to have nullified its chances of becom- ing a political force in Singa- pore. This performance by the party which won the Kallang district seat only last Decem- ber tends to confirm reports that the Communists have with- drawn their support from the Worker's party and are now sup- NEW CHINESE PROGRAM MAY SOLVE BLOC COPPER SHORTAGE As part of the present pol- icy of bending all efforts to achieve "more, better, faster, and more economical results," Peiping has launched a program to increase China's copper- smelting capacity by 150,000 tons within a year. It intends to get this tenfold increase by setting up some 3,000 small copper-smelting furnaces, each with a capacity of 50 to 100 tons. Built by local capital, the furnaces will be scattered throughout the country, in some instances to take advantage of minor deposits which might oth- erwise not be workable. Copper is in short supply throughout the Communist world, which over the past five years has imported an average of 120,- 000 tons a year from the free world. If the new program is successful, China will be pro- ducing about 165,000 tons of copper a year, some four times its annual domestic requirements, and may have around 120,000 tons a year for sale to its bloc partners. Peiping will doubtless run into administrative problems in getting this program under way. The supply of the neces- sary raw materials does not ap- pear to present any special dif- ficulties, and China has had centuries of experience in op- erating small smelters, which require a minimum of technologi- cal know-how for construction and operation. Capital outlay is minimal; Peiping has cited one such smelter built out of local materials at a total cost of only $60. On the other hand, wide employment of smelters of this type is wasteful and inefficient. The quality of ore used must in general be a good deal higher than is the case with more mod- ern smelters. Metal losses will run high. The crude cop- per produced will contain a'high percentage of impurities and re- quire further refining prior to use. Peiping's motive in build- ing such plants doubtless is to get the largest possible in- crease in output in the least time and at the least cost. It probably looks on the program as a useful stopgap until the larger, more modern facilities now under construction at places such as Paiyinchang in Kansu Province and Tungchuan in Yun- nan Province go into production in a few years, and replace the less efficient small plants. Prepared by ORR) 25X1 SECRET PART II NOTES AND COMMENTS Page 8 of 16 Approved For Release 2007/10/23: CIA-RDP79-00927AO01800090001-4 Approved For Release 2007/10/23: CIA-RDP79-00927AO01800090001-4 SECRET CURRENT INTELLIGENCE WEEKLY SUMMARY 31 July 1958 Widespread violence be- tween the Greek and Turkish com- munities on Cyprus continues despite a major security offen- sive, during which about 1,600 Greek- and 50 Turkish-Cypriots were placed in detention camps and the Turkish Resistance Or- ganization (TMT) 'proscribed. Over 100 people have been killed and nearly 200 injured in the intercommunal fighting since early June--over half in the past three weeks. Although Greek- and Turk- ish-Cypriot leaders, including Archbishop Makarios, have joined Governor Foot in public appeals for an end to the violence, ex- tremists refuse to heed the call. Following the mass ar- rests, EOKA leader Grivas pro- claimed in a new leaflet that he preferred "total destruc- tion" in Cyprus to continued British rule. Foot, while aware that EOKA would probably react to the security drive by all- out attacks on the British po- lice forces, had hoped that the roundup might cause EOKA to cease its assaults on the Turks and thus prevent a continued drift toward civil war. In Greece, the arrests have been denounced as a further in- dication that Britain favors the Turkish Cypriots. Athens has protested the recent securi- ty measures to London and Wash- ington, as well as to the secre- taries general of the UN and NATO. Within the next two weeks Greece will probably again ask the UN General Assembly to place the Cyprus issue on the agenda of its forthcoming session. In Turkey, the press and radio, inspired by pleas for help from Turkish-Cypriot lead- er Fazil Kuchuk, are reiterating the demand that Turkish troops be sent to Cyprus to protect the Turkish Cypriots, a move which London has been firmly reject- ing. Ankara has recently in- structed Kuchuk to cooperate with the British, but Turkish Foreign Minister Zorlu has stated that future Turkish ac- tion regarding Cyprus will be determined by the success or failure of the British drive against EOKA. Meanwhile, Prime Minister Macmillan discussed Cyprus with Turkish Premier Menderes follow- ing the Baghdad Pact Council meetings in London, and is ex- pected to confer with Greek Pre- mier Karamanlis at some early future date. In Paris, NATO Sec- retary General Spaak is continu- ing his efforts to secure some form of compromise agreement re- garding the new British plan; among the NATO representatives of Greece-Britain and Turkey. TUNISIA FACES DIFFICULTIES WITH ALGERIAN REBELS The presence in Tunisia of several thousand well-armed Al- gerian rebels poses a growing threat to Tunisia's internal stability which the small, ill- equipped security forces are un- prepared to meet. President Bourguiba has granted facilities to the Algerian National Liber- ation Front (FLN) to carry on SECRET PART II NOTES AND COMMENTS Page 9 of 16 Approved For Release 2007/10/23: CIA-RDP79-00927AO01800090001-4 Approved For Release 2007/10/23: CIA-RDP79-00927AO01800090001-4 SECRET CURRENT INTELLIGENCE WEEKLY SUMMARY 31 July 1958 its rebellion in Algeria, hop- ing to influence rebel leaders toward a more moderate and pro- Western policy as well as to limit the extent of Cairo's in- fluence over them. The FLN has been cautious regarding attempts to control its policies and now assails Bourguiba for having granted a pipeline concession to a French firm. Its leaders complain that this concession violates the principle of Maghreb (North Africap) unity, which Bourguiba has so assiduously sought, con- stitutes recognition of French claims to the Sahara and com- promises the fight of the Al- gerian people for independence. Tunisian officials now fear the FLN is "ready to cooperate with the Egyptians and Soviets to throw Bourguiba out." Danger from the FLN is made more formidable by the growth of anti-Bourguiba sentiment among officials and students as well as by the presumed contin- ued activity of Bourguiba's principal rival, Salah ben Yous- sef, who has been granted asy- lum in Cairo. Last March sever- al score of Ben Youssef's fol- NEW FRENCH POLITICAL GROUPINGS As many as ten new politi- cal groupings reportedly have formed in France to participate in the forthcoming constitution- al referendum and to take ad- vantage of the changed politi- cal framework the revised con- stitution is expected to pro- vide. Most of these profess support for the stronger execu- tive which Premier de Gaulle's draft constitution calls for, lowers were rounded up when a purported plot to assassinate Bourguiba was uncovered. Last week Bourguiba reiterated de- mands that the United Arab Re- public expel Ben Youssef. Bourguiba, claiming that the FLN knows his weakness be- cause they loaned him arms in May when French forces in south- ern Tunisia seemed About to at- tack the Tunisian Army, has again requested arms from the United States and Britain. French of- ficials in Tunisia claim they have offered him arms from stocks issued to the French forces now leaving the country, but Bourguiba fears acceptance would incite charges by the FLN that he had made some kind of military peace with France against the Algerians. Bourguiba, still wary of any French attempts to maintain a monopoly over Tunisia's arms sources, prefers alternate West- ern sources,so that France would be unable to maintain an inven- tory of Tunisia's materiel. The Tunisians probably are also aware that France seeks to dis- rupt North African unity. 25X1 but at least one is ranged with the Communists in opposition. Although Premier de Gaulle disappointed many of his fol- lowers, particularly in Algeria, by failing to scrap "the old system" of political parties, he sharply curtailed their scope of action by sending Parlia- ment "on vacation." Occasional party conferences have been held, SECRET NOTES AND COMMENTS Page 10 of 16 Approved For Release 2007/10/23: CIA-RDP79-00927AO01800090001-4 Approved For Release 2007/10/23: CIA-RDP79-00927A001800090001-4 SECRET INTELLIGENCE WEEKLY SUMMARY 31 July 1958 but they have been lethargic and have left the field open to new groupings. Daniel Mayer's "Union of Democratic Forces," most left- ist of the new groupings, in- cludes several left-wing Social- ist party (SFIO) leaders in ad- dition to ex-Premier Mendes- France, the Orthodox Radical leader, and Francois Mitterrand, left-wing Democratic Resistance Union (UDSR) leader. A number of long-established splinter Bidault as too rightist-oriented, and such stalwarts as ex-Premier Robert Schumann are organizing a National Committee of Liaison for Christian Democracy. A potential rightist throat to De Gaulle's program is the recent appearance of Informa- tion Minister Jacques Soustelle's Union for the Renovation of France, stemming from his Union for the Salvation and Renova- tion of Algeria (USRAF), which played a key role in preparing movements in the non-Communist for the 13 May coup there. left also adhere to this group. Soustelle claims it will be non- Despite the movement's refusal political and not compete with thus far to cooperate with the his own GRS. Communists, its opposition to the revised constitution will play into Communist hands. It could permanently breach the already badly divided SFIO and may attract left wingers of other parties as uneasiness over rightist influence on De Gaulle mounts. It faces minor competi- tion on the non-Communist left in a new grouping of "leftist Gaullists," mainly a group of Radicals who followed Mendes- France during De Gaulle's long political eclipse and who now hope to "save" De Gaulle from extremists on both sides. In the center, former Pre- mier George Bidault proposes to build his new Christian Demo- cratic Movement into a broad center and right-center organi- zation, combining elements of his own Popular Republican par- ty (MRP), the Social Republicans (GRS), various Radical groups, and the Independents. Most MRP members, however, now regard It seems probable, however, that he felt it unwise to form a new political party while still a member of the govern- ment, particularly in view of De Gaulle's dislike for a multi- plicity of parties, and that he also sees possibilities in tapping the USRAF apparatus of Committees of Public Safety, veterans' organizations, and other "nonpolitical" rightist groups as vehicles both for exercising more influence on De Gaulle's policy and for en- hancing his own personal power position later. Only a few of the new groupings are likely to have much impact on the politi- cal scene, but their crea- tion weakens the existing par- ties, probably facilitates the growth of extremism, and, in any case, will complicate the period of transition to new political institutions. 25X1 AUSTRIAN CHANCELLOR RAAB'S NEGOTIATIONS IN MOSCOW As a result of Chancellor Raab's negotiations in Moscow from 21 to 28 July, Austria's relations with the Soviet Union may become somewhat closer, par- titularly in the economic and cultural fields. Raab said and did things, moreover, 'not pleasing to the West, but he nevertheless ;seems to have SECRET PART II NOTES AND COMMENTS Page 11 of 16 Approved For Release 2007/10/23: CIA-RDP79-00927A001800090001-4 Approved For Release 2007/10/23: CIA-RDP79-00927AO01800090001-4 SECRET CURRENT INTELLIGENCE WEEKLY SUMMARY 31 July 1958 avoided any dangerous politi- cal commitments, and Vienna's pro-Western neutrality is still intact. Of the various minor con- cessions won by Raab, the most important--expected ultimately to be worth about $70,000,000 --is the USSR's agreement to supply free of charge quanti- ties of oil equivalent to 50 percent of Austria's annual oil reparations deliveries. This arrangement, rather than a straight reduction, was ap- parently worked out to pre- serve established trade routes for Austrian oil, much of which--under Soviet account-- is taken by the European satel- lites. As a graceful gesture to the Soviet Union, the Austrians on their own initiative declared an intent to adhere to the Eastern Danube Convention. This Soviet-dictated instrument, which regulates Danube traffic east of the Austrian border, has never been recognized by the West, and Vienna has here- tofore limited its recognition to the sending of observers to technical meetings. In response to an Austrian suggestion, more- over, Bonn is already consider- ing following Vienna's lead. Khrushchev claimed on Raab's departure that a "unanimity of views on a wide range of inter- national subjects" had been reached, but from the content of the final communique and from comments by both Soviet and Austrian officials, it is clear he did not press the Austrians for pro-Soviet policy statements on principal East-West issues. While it can be expected that on appropriate occasions Moscow will claim Austrian "agreement" with Soviet international policy, Khrushchev's primary efforts were directed rather toward the more realistic objectives of en- couraging Austria's neutrality and demonstrating to the smaller neutral nations continuing Soviet interest in their welfare. Nearly all Austrians have welcomed alleviation of a burden they considered unjust, but it is doubtful that their basic suspicion of the USSR will be greatly affected. Raab's role in the agreement has made him a national hero in some quarters, but his very friendly attitude toward the USSR has also provoked alarm and consternation even among those sympathetic toward (Concurred in by ORR) ITALY'S ECONOMIC OUTLOOK The prospect of a further slow decline in the rate of Italy's economic expansion will probably enable both left and right to assail Premier Fan- fani's weak Christian Democratic - Democratic Socialist govern- ment. Foreign exchange re- serves are close to a postwar high, but, of ter several years of relative prosperity, almost 9 percent of the labor force is still unemployed. Present government measures to stimu- late the economy may be insuf- ficient to prevent a worsening of this chronic problem. The rapid economic expan- sion which took place up to November 1957 has now fallen off markedly, and there are no signs that the slowdown will be reversed. Projections for SECRET PART II NOTES AND COMMENTS Page 12 of 16 25X1 25X1 25X1 Approved For Release 2007/10/23: CIA-RDP79-00927AO01800090001-4 Approved For Release 2007/10/23: CIA-RDP79-00927AO01800090001-4 SECRET CURRENT INTELLIGENCE WEEKLY SttY 31 July 1958 1958 fix the rate of: growth of the GNP at 2-3 percent in con- trast to a rise in 1957 of 5.6 percent. The only marked improve- ment has been in foreign-ex- change reserves, which reached a postwar high of $1.215 billion by March 1958, largely as a re- sult of a 15-percent drop in imports and a 3-percent rise in exports, along with continuing US mili- tary expenditures and loans. Slackening world trade, however, has since retarded the expansion of Italian exports, while imports for industri- alization have con- tinued at a high level, leading to a foreign payments def- icit. The sharp reduc- tion envisaged in the 1958-59 budgetary deficit and the pos- sibility that foreign demand will continue to decline could re- duce economic activi- ty. With this in mind, the government has lowered the discount rate from 4 to 3.5 percent and boosted state ex- penditures, even though this will make more difficult the reduction in the budget deficit. Even so, a decline in economic activity during the second half of 1958 is now predicted by many prominent Italian in- dustrial, commercial, and bank- ing leaders. If deteriorating economic conditions in other European countries force large numbers of Italian immigrants to go home, the unemployment problem in Italy could be seriously aggravated. An increase in the 1,700,000 unemployed would increase the Communists' popu- lar appeal and add to the government's instability. The Democratic Socialists are al- ready divided on continued participation in the Fanfani coalition. At the same time, the right would reiterate recent charges that the government's public spending 25X1 program will involve economic and financial ruin. Iceland's unilateral ex- tension of its fish conserva- tion limits to 12 nautical miles becomes effective on 1 Septem- ber, and it is unlikely that any compromise will be reached before that date with other nations having fishing in- terests in Icelandic waters. SECRET PART II NOTES AND COMMENTS Page 13 of 16 Approved For Release 2007/10/23: CIA-RDP79-00927AO01800090001-4 Approved For Release 2007/10/23: CIA-RDP79-00927AO01800090001-4 SECRET CURRENT INTELLIGENCE WEEKLY S:URY 31 July 1958 In late June the Icelandic representative to the North Atlantic Council indicated that his government was will- ing to negotiate special rights for a limited number of years in the outer zone of the new belt. Late in July, however, he still had not made any spe- cific or practical suggestion.,, and the British Foreign Office is extremely pessimistic about the prospects of negotiations on any basis. In mid-July, the West German Government ex- pressed the hope that Iceland would enter into negotiations to achieve agreement before 1 September. Representatives of the fishing industries of the United States, Britain, France, Spain, Belgium, Holland, and West Germany met in the The Hague on 20 July and passed a resolution condemning Iceland's action and stating would be disregarded. Press r~,,ports hint that the group may recom- mend joint economic action a- gainst Iceland if the situation does not improve. Iceland's leftist coalition government is under strong local Communist pressure to remain adamant. The Commu- nists have intimated that they will with- draw from the govern- ment if the Social Democratic foreign minister attempts negotiations permit- ting foreign trawlers within the 12-mile limit. The Progres- sives and the Social Democrats will go to any length to avoid an election, which they feel would only benefit the Communists and the Conservatives. The Progressive press opposes any compro- mise and hints that Iceland will ask the United States for as- sistance if Britain gives its trawlers naval pro- tection. The USSR has reportedly suggested a Soviet naval visit to Iceland around 1 September and is also urging Iceland to request any assistance required to implement the 12-mile limit. If no compromise is reached, the Communists will have created dissension between Iceland and its NATO allies; if the NATO countries recognize the new limit, the Communists will claim the victory. 25X1 SECRET NOTES AND COMMENTS Page 14 of 16 - Approved For Release 2007/10/23: CIA-RDP79-00927AO01800090001-4 Approved For Release 2007/10/23: CIA-RDP79-00927AO01800090001-4 SECRET CURRENT INTELLIGENCE WEEKLY:SUMMARY 31 July 1958 ARGENTINE PETROLEUM POLICY ANNOUNCED President Frondizi's out- line of his petroleum policy on 24 July emphasizes private par- ticipation in Argentine oil de- velopment under contract with the State Oil Fields (YPF). He said that foreign private firms had agreed in general terms to invest approximately one billion dollars on this basis and men- tioned a last-minute Soviet of- fer to supply $100,000,000 worth of oil equipment payable in Ar- gentine products over a long period. Frondizi declared the main obstacle to Argentina's economic progress was its dependence on fuel and steel imports at a cost which forced Argentina to remain a producer of primary materials. He plans to triple oil produc- tion by 1962. Argentina pro- duced only 34,000,000 barrels in 1957--about 37 percent of domestic needs. Frondizi specifically men- tioned eight final or prelim- inary contracts with private firms, six of which are Ameri- can, one Argentine, and one Bel- gian. He made no detailed com- ment on the offer delivered by the Soviet ambassador shortly before his broadcast. He did refer, however, to the favorable terms of Argentina's purchase last June of 7,266,000 metric tons of Soviet crude. The principal agreement, "signed in general terms," is with a "US group" which includes one German firm. This calls for an estimated investment of $700,000,000 to: 1) drill about 4,000 wells; 2) establish a factory to produce oil-field equipment; 3) furnish at least 18,000,000 barrels of crude oil and derivatives on two to three years' credit; 4) construct a new gas line; 5) loan $30,000,- 000 to the 'Central Bank for five years; and 6) supply $50,000,- 000 worth of machinery and equipment on credit. Frondizi plans to submit to Congress a proposed petroleum law affirming national control over oil resources and assuring the provinces of participation in the profits. No new conces- sions will be granted, but the situation existing prior to 1 May 1958 will be respected. Frondizi's party controls Con- gress, but the bill will prob- ably be attacked by the minority party as well as by some of his own followers. At the same time, his new policy may serve to offset criticism that he has concentrated on pacifying the Peronistas and has neglected Argentina's pressing economic problems. (Concurred in by ORR VENEZUELAN MILITARY'S ANTILEFTIST MOVE DEFEATED Venezuela's military lead- ers appear to have been decisive- ly defeated recently when their ultimatum calling for action a- gainst members of the Communist and Democratic Action parties proved ineffective in the face of united civilian resistance to the threatened coup. The military move seems likely to result in continuing tensions, increased Communist prestige, and possibly more anti-American feeling. The junta government headed by Admiral Larrazabal is said to. have imprisoned about 200 SECRET PART II NOTES AND COMMENTS Page 15 of 16 Approved For Release 2007/10/23: CIA-RDP79-00927AO01800090001-4 Approved For Release 2007/10/23: CIA-RDP79-00927AO01800090001-4 SECRET CURRENT INTELLIGENCE WEEKLY SUMMARY 31 July 1958 supporters of Defense Minister General Castro Leon, who spear- headed the movement, and is ex- iling others. Castro resigned and left the country on a for-' eign assignment on 24 July. Lt. Colonel Martin Parada, chief of staff of the air force, was also sent into exile. Meanwhile, conservative 33-year-old civil- ian junta member Arturo Sosa publicly admitted that armed forces officers had offered him the presidency of a new junta some two weeks before the ulti- matum. Although Sosa claims he refused the offer, his in- volvement with the military leaders will probably necessi- tate his resignation and the politically delicate choice of a new junta member. Venezuela's civilian-mili- tary tensions may lead to in- creased feeling against the United States. Communist leader Mach- 25X1 ado has called for the depar- ture of foreign military mis- sions, charging that they have been intervening in Venezuelan Venezuela. The military's association of the Democratic Action party-- which is probably supported by about half of the electorate-- with the Communists as a tar- get for repression seems likely to reinforce the "united we stand" feeling which has been prevalent in Venezuelan politi- cal groups since the Perez dic- tatorship was overthrown last January. This feeling has been one of the key factors in the recent growth of Communism in SECRET PART II NOTES AND COMMENTS Page 16 of 16 Approved For Release 2007/10/23: CIA-RDP79-00927AO01800090001-4 Approved For Release 2007/10/23: CIA-RDP79-00927AO01800090001-4 LQNHUU 111 L CURRENT INTELLIGENCE WEEKLY SUMMARY 31 July 19 58 PATTERNS AND PERSPECTIVES MOSCOW'S POLITICAL PROBLEMS WITH EASTERN EUROPE Campaign Against Revisionism Moscow's present campaign to achieve bloc unity, of which the execution of Nagy and the ideological break with Yugo- slavia are but parts, began in mid-1956. At that time the Soviet Union was attempting to restore its prestige and au- thority over the Communist move- ment, after both were shaken as a result of the de-Stalin- ization campaign and Moscow's encouragement in 1955 and 1956 of the "separate roads" theme and more local initiative by satellite leaders. Moscow realized the dangers of this course when the riots occurred at Poznan in June 1956, but its indecisive attempts prior to the Hungarian revolu- tion to close its Pandora's box were ineffectual. Even after Gomulka returned to power in October, Moscow was reluctant entirely to abandon its "liberal" course, and its admission of past mistakes in handling the satellites in its declaration of 30 October was made even more emphatic by the Chinese state- ments at the time criticizing "great-power chauvinism." The uprising in Hungary was the last straw for the Com- munist leaders, however, and, from November on, the preoc- cupation was not with the evils caused by past arbitrary prac- tices toward the satellites but with the dangers posed by separatist trends and the prac- tice of ignoring the experience of the Soviet Union in building "socialism." At the same time, bloc leaders began to speak more and more of the "basic principles" of socialist Revisionism can be defined as the attempt to revise fundamental Marxist-Leninist principles as accepted by Moscow. The main fundamental principles were listed in the 12-nation Moscow declara- tion of November 1957 and included: a) establishment of a dictatorship of the proletariat by means of a proletarian revolution in one form or an- other and leadership by a Marxist-Leninist party; c) abolition of capitalist ownership and establishment of public ownership of the basic means of production; d) the gradual socialist reconstruction of agriculture; e) planned development of the national economy aimed at building socialism and communism; f) proletarian internationalism (i.e., Soviet leadership); g) the defense of achievements of socialism against at- tacks by, external and internal enemies. One of these principles, (d), was vaguely worded in the November declaration in deference to Go- mulka, to whom gradualism in agriculture is a cardinal element of his "Polish road to Socialism:' Many of the other bloc leaders would have preferred to omit the term "gradual:' Similarly, although Gomulka subscribed to "proletarian internationalism" in the declaration, his subsequent interpretation of this principle differed considerably from that of, say, the Chinese leaders. In any case revisionism could easily be expanded by Moscow, if it suited the needs of the moment, to cover opposition in various forms--e.g., the "right-nationalist deviation" of Gomulka. CONFIDENTIAL PART III PATTERNS AND PERSPECTIVES Page 1 of 16 Approved For Release 2007/10/23: CIA-RDP79-00927AO01800090001-4 Approved For Release 2007/10/23: CIA-RDP79-00927A001800090001-4 SECRET CURRENT INTELLIGENCE WEEKLY SUMMARY 31 July 1958 construction derived from So- viet experience--an approach which had been de-emphasized after Stalin's death. Clearly, both Moscow and Peiping were apprehensive after Hungary over the trend toward "national Communism." Only two countries at the time posed any immediate danger--Poland and Yugoslavia--the latter be- ing outside the bloc and thus less accessible to pressure to conform. Therefore, the first goal had to be to ensure that the "national Communism" of Poland would be kept within bounds--that it would be pre- vented from heading toward another Hungary. Both Chinese and Soviet leaders made state- ments in November and December 1956 about the "basic princi ples," and in January 1957 Chou En-lai went to Warsaw and, acting on behalf of Moscow, ap- parently made some progress selling these principles to Go- mulka. Shortly afterward, Gomulka made a gesture toward accepting the Soviet lead in intrabloc af- fairs--by altering his position on the Hungarian rebellion and subscribing at the central com- mittee plenum in May to the "basic principles." Gomulka still hedged on the question of recognizing unqualified So- viet leadership of the bloc parties and insisted that the principles which might affect the most important aspects, e.g., agriculture, of his "Polish road to socialism" be vaguely worded. Nevertheless, his agreement pro- vided some assurance to Moscow and Peiping that his "road" would not go in the same direction as Nagy's and thus the immediate danger posed by Poland was re,- moved. Yugoslav Revisionist Threat Yugoslavia remained a men- ace, however, since it continued to exert great influence in all the Communist countries, the more so since it was outside the bloc. The polemics between Moscow and Belgrade between No- vember 1956 and April 1957 clear- ly reflected Moscow's considered view that Yugoslav influence, which the satellites had been SECRET PART III PATTERNS AND PERSPECTIVES Page 2 of 16 Approved For Release 2007/10/23: CIA-RDP79-00927A001800090001-4 Approved For Release 2007/10/23: CIA-RDP79-00927A001800090001-4 SECRET CURRENT INTELLIGENCE WEEKLY SUMMARY 31 July 19 58 warned about in September 1956, had' played, a major role in the events leading up to the Hun- garian revolution. Relations improved, however, following the purge of Molotov and com- pany in June, and, after some uncertain preliminaries, Khru- shchev met Tito in Bucharest at the beginning of August 1957, where some of the former rapport was restored. They agreed that although they had opposing viewpoints, there was no point in stressing them in public. Turning Point--November 1957 The November meeting of bloc leaders in Moscow had great significance for the sub- sequent dispute with Belgrade. From Khrushchev's speeches to Moscow had reason to feel in the fall of 1957 that Tito might re- join the bloc by signing this declaration, it would certainly explain why so much importance was attached to the declaration, as well as to Tito's failure to sign it. Tito's attitude toward Khrushchev apparently altered suddenly in late October, how- ever, following Marshal Zhukov's visit and subsequent removal, and Belgrade announced on 29 Octo- ber that Tito would not attend the Moscow meeting in November. These developments probably led to the decision in Moscow that since Tito could not be en- ticed into the bloc, other tac- tics were necessary to counter- act the serious influence of The Communist party of the Soviet Union will continue to dress down the attacks of opportunists and revision- ists quite decisively. We shall do this not by interfering in the internal affairs of this or that party, but through comradely criticism and influence on the part of the revolutionary world movement and Marxist-Leninist parties on mistaken positions which may appear in one party or another. We do not want the interference of parties in the internal affairs of other parties, or even the interference of states in the home affairs of other states, but comradely criticism, which also brings comradely aid, of those who make mistakes, but are capable of appreciating them, of understanding how they arose and of correcting them. As for the leadership of this or that party and the leadership of this or that country, they are a matter for the party and the government of the people in question to decide for themselves. --from speech at East German party congress, 11 July 1958 the Bulgarian and East German party congresses ion 3 .June ;and 11 July 1958., it appears that Moscow had hoped to secure Tito's signature to the bloc declara- tion. Khrushchev argued in Ber- lin that it was not Moscow but the "other fraternal parties" which made alterations in the draft declaration--which Tito had been shown before November --to include mention of "Soviet leadership of the socialist camp and of the socialist par- ties." Tito was apparently will- ing at the time of the Bucharest meeting in August to associate himself formally with the "so- cialist camp" provided the com- mitment would not involve sub- servience to Moscow. If indeed Yugoslav ideas within the Com- munist movement. As Khrushchev said on 11 July in East Berlin, he drew the "necessary conclu- sions." "Antiitbvisionist't Campaign Accordingly, the November meeting was followed by a full- scale ideological campaign against "revisionism" directed against such well-known Western European "revisionists" as Kolakowski (Polish), Lukacs (Hungarian), Djilas (Yugoslav), and Harich (East German). The similarity between their ideas and those of the Yugoslav party leaders was obvious, but Yugo- slavia was not explicitly linked during this period to the re- visionist heresy. SECRET PART III,.. PATTERNS AND PERSPECTIVES Page 3 of 16 Approved For Release 2007/10/23: CIA-RDP79-00927A001800090001-4 Approved For Release 2007/10/23: CIA-RDP79-00927AO01800090001-4 SECRET CURRENT INTELLIGENCE WEEKLY SUMMARY 31 July 1958 Tito had meanwhile drawn his own conclusions, as seen in the draft Yugoslav party pro- gram published on 13 March, which codified his heresies. His defiance, at a time when Moscow and Peiping both attached great importance to re-estab- lishing discipline under Soviet authority, had to be answered and vigorously condemned. With the mid-April Kommunist article on the Yugoslav program, an- swered by defiant replies at the Yugoslav party congress, the polemical exchange. between the bloc and Belgrade was re- newed. Moscow's and Peiping's efforts, however, could never be successful if something were not done to negate the influence of the major revisionists, and thus Moscow could not ignore the man who of all others trans- lated revisionism into ac" tion--who actually restored a multiparty system and called for the severance of his country from the Communist camp--Imre Nagy, Necessity for Nagy's Execution Nagy had long ago been de- clared a traitor and a detailed case built up against him. A severe sentence at some time was to be expected, but there was no pressing internal need to execute him. Externally, the move had many serious dis- advantages. Moscow doubtless appreciated that Nagy would be- come a martyr in the West and that his execution would shock world opinion. Many relatively minor counterrevolutionaries had already been executed in Hungary, but Nagy's secret trial and execution were viewed by many Communists in Eastern Europe to signify a return to methods which had been dis- credited and disavowed only a year or two before. Thus it would appear that the Nagy execution was decided on by Moscow as a symbolic step in the antirevisionist campaign, the necessity for which far out- weighed the damage it would do abroad. The necessity arose from the fact that the paramount task of neu- tralizing Yugoslav ideological influence had not been accom- plished by the polem- ics waged against Bel- grade up to that point. The Problem of Gomulka SECRET Gomulka presents a problem to Moscow, not so much because of his internal pro- gram, but because of his refusal to accept unconditional Soviet leadership. and to as- sociate himself un- reservedly with the line set by Moscow. This has obstructed bloc unity and exerts a dangerous influence on the other satel- lites. PART III PATTERNS AND PERSPECTIVES Page 4 of 16 Approved For Release 2007/10/23: CIA-RDP79-00927AO01800090001-4 Approved For Release 2007/10/23: CIA-RDP79-00927A001800090001-4 SECRET CURRENT INTELLIGENCE WEEKLY SUMMARY 31 July 19 58 Unlike Tito, however, Go- mulka has not been accused of harboring revisionist views himself. Since October 1956, moreover, the Polish leader has demonstrated that by conviction he is strongly opposed to re- visionism and has dealt firmly with Polish revisionists. He has committed Poland to the basic principles of socialist development based on Soviet ex- perience, which provides a safe- guard for Moscow against re- visionist influence in his in- ternal program. Gomulka still refuses, however, to submit to Soviet control over his inter- nal program, and, by doing this, runs the risk of one day being tagged a revisionist who re- fused to subscribe fully to Moscow's interpretation of the letter and spirit of "proletar- ian internationalism;" i.e., Soviet leadership. In mid-June, however, Mos- cow's main concern was with Go- mulka's obstruction of the bloc line toward Yugoslavia, and the Nagy execution was doubtless a warning to him, and possibly to Kadar as well, not to cause dif- ficulty for Moscow in this most important sphere. Moscow is caught up in the same dilemma it faced when it first attempted to change its methods of dealing with the satellites--loosening the reins has the effect of undermining basic discipline with disastrous possibilities, while, on the other hand, direct exploitative methods, as practiced under Stalin, only antagonize the satellite peoples and build up anti-Soviet feeling. The Soviet leaders, by altering their relationships with these countries after the death of Stalin, themselves contributed in large measure to the very undermining of bloc unity and discipline, not to mention the authority and pres- tige of the USSR, which they now desire so strongly to re- store. If they use the neces- sary measures to restore dis- cipline, then they will be re- turning to the practices which they discredited in 1955 and 1956, and, moreover, will run the risk of building up the same resentments and animosities which contributed so much to the upheavals of 1956. One of the most curious aspects of recent developments has been the frequent changes in the Soviet position, first of all during the anti-Tito cam- paign and later concerning the execution of Nagy. Thus, the original relatively mild lan- guage of the Kommunist article was soon followed y increas- ingly insulting attacks on the Yugoslavs. Later, the emphasis changed to maintaining correct "state" relations, as if the previous articles had gone too far. There were also variations between the tone of the attacks on Yugoslavia by some of the bloc countries and the less un- relenting line of Moscow. In the case of Nagy, there was the shift in position between the indictment itself, which stressed the connection between "revision- ist ideas" and Nagy's fate, and later reassurances from Moscow (as well as from Kadar) that the execution resulted solely from his treason. The threatening attitude of Peiping toward the Yugoslav leaders also contrasted with Moscow's more moderate ap- proach. These contrasts and incon- sistencies suggest indecision, perhaps reflecting disagreement in Moscow on these issues, or at the very least indicate that bloc Communist leaders have not received clear directives on the proper line to follow. Moscow's Present Policy Recent speeches by Khru- shchev provide some indication SECRET PART III PATTERNS AND PERSPECTIVES Page 5 of 16 Approved For Release 2007/10/23: CIA-RDP79-00927A001800090001-4 Approved For Release 2007/10/23: CIA-RDP79-00927AO01800090001-4 SECRET CURRENT INTELLIGENCE WEEKLY SUMMARY 31 July 1958 of Moscow's present approach to this problem. In his speech in mid-July at the Czech re- ception in Moscow, Khrushchev referred to a "brotherly com- monwealth of states with equal rights," the establishment of which, he said, was the major task at the moment. This same commonwealth was mentioned ear- lier in the 12-nation Moscow declaration of November 1957, although at the time it was not clear how the various par- ticipants would deal with one another. in his 11 July speech in Berlin, as in an earlier speech in Bulgaria, Khrushchev ap- parently attempted to reassure Gomulka that his "equality" and "national sovereignty" need not be affected if he were to as- sociate himself fully and un- reservedly with such a common- wealth under Moscow's leader- ship. At the same time, how- ever, Khrushchev made it clear that all satellite leaders, in- cluding Gomulka, are expected to consider not just their own country but the interests of the socialist camp as a whole. To do otherwise would "harm the lives and interests of their own people, and the interests of socialism." The Cominform, it might be recalled, was organized in 1947 ostensibly as a "voluntary" association of countries partic- ipating on an equal basis. The present approach is not dis- similar, although the conditions have drastically changed. Khru- shchev referred in his 11 July Berlin speech to the socialist camp as a "voluntary alliance of equal sovereign states in which no one aspires to special rights or seeks privileges and advantages." Moscow is apparently at- tempting to attain its goal of restoring control and discip- line through the medium of this ostensibly free and voluntary "commonwealth." In this way the satellite leaders receive assurances that their positions and internal programs will not be interfered with by Moscow as long as they subscribe in essentials to Moscow's leader- ship. This cautious approach is influenced by the necessity of not antagonizing Gomulka, the chief problem child, into tak- ing a hostile stand in the be- lief that his internal independ- ence is threatened. Moscow probably hopes that by persuasion and indirect pres- sures Gomulka can be slowly pushed to a point where his in- dependence and control over in- ternal policy will be different only in degree from that of the other satellites. Moscow, more- over, has apparently already achieved considerable success in talking Gomulka into going along with this scheme. As early as last November, on his return from the 40th anniversary cele- brations in Moscow,Gomulka ap- peared pleased with the pros- pects for this new commonwealth. In discussing the proposed "practical ties" between the Communist parties--bilateral and multilateral meetings--he still cautioned that: ...the question of the internal policy of each party cannot be determined by inter- party conferences. We must hold to the principle that each party should decide the best line of policy for it- self and its country. Since that time, however, the Poles have committed them- selves to participate in the new international Communist journal, a sign that Gomulka's initial objections to this publication have been overcome. Indeed, Gomulka would seem to present no obstacle at the moment to Moscow's plan for in- trabloc relations. Khrushchev, in his Moscow speech on 12 July, even gave Gomulka an "out" on the question of Western aid, al- though he warned that its accept- ance was permissible only if the country concerned "marches in step with all socialist coun- tries." SECRET PART III PATTERNS AND PERSPECTIVES Page 6 of 16 Approved For Release 2007/10/23: CIA-RDP79-00927AO01800090001-4 Approved For Release 2007/10/23: CIA-RDP79-00927AO01800090001-4 SECRET CURRENT INTELLIGENCE WEEKLY SUU&RY 31 July 1958 POLITICAL CONDITIONS IN IRAN The Shah,:who has always been unusually suspicious of subordinates, seems to be con- cerned that ambitious men in his entourage will nor associate with dissatisfied groups to force either his removal or a serious limitation of his pow- ers. The recent placing of tanks, antitank weapons, artil- lery, and additional troops around Saadabad Palace in Teh- ran is regarded by Iranian mili- tary men as a sign of f ear and weakness on the part of the Shah. Indications that he is primarily concerned about his own safety will probably have an adverse effect on the morale of the army, on which he relies heavily to preserve his regime. The Shah has consolidated his power until he is a virtual dictator, but has created op- position which, under certain conditions, could overthrow him. Having observed ex-Premier Mos- sadeq arouse nationalism and having witnessed the fates of other Middle Eastern monarchs, he realizes he must push through political and economic reforms or eventually face revolution from urban leftists. At the same time, his ref orms must not antagonize large landowners and other wealthy groups into organizing a rightist coup. In addition, he is trying to hold the loyalty of the peasants, who constitute 80 percent of the population, and who could become a decisive political force. He is doing this through the distribution of crown lands. Although Iran's moderniza- 'tion program and preservation of the delicate political bal- ance demand the most effective use of all available talent, the Shah refuses to delegate au- thority for fear that persons of ability may usurp power. He wants to surpass the achieve- ments of his father, Reza Shah, but lacks the will and desire to use similar ruthless methods. The Shah, moreover, while sin- cere in his intention to elimi- nate corruption in general, has not taken measures to prevent members of ,the .. royal fam- ily from using -. their posi- tions :._m tou , inctBaSe their fortunes. Typical of the Shah's un- willingness to delegate author- ity is his treatment of Prime Minister Eqbal. Eqbal, a force- ful and popular personality when he took office in April 1957, has now become completely sub- servient to the Shah and thus SECRET PART III PATTERNS AND PERSPECTIVES Page 7 of 16 Approved For Release 2007/10/23: CIA-RDP79-00927AO01800090001-4 Approved For Release 2007/10/23: CIA-RDP79-00927AO01800090001-4 SECRET 31 July 1958 has lost his political prestige. 1 merous opposition members. Al- As the public has become aware that the Shah has taken full re- sponsibility for directing af- fairs, public criticism of gov- ernment failures has been in- creasingly directed at the mon- arch. Veiled threats by the Shah to ensure prompt passage of desired legislation have in- creased parliamentary dissatis- faction with his methods. The Shah's apprehension that his power will be usurped precludes the development of political parties in the West- ern sense. To ensure that no political groups acquire real strength, the Iranian intelli- gence agency is charged with overseeing the membership of the two existing "parties." In an effort to give the impression that Iran is a de- veloping democracy, the Shah has artificially created the Nationalist party and the Mar- dom (people's) party. The Na- tionalist party is designed to be "progovernment" and was re- luctantly formed by Prime Min- ister Eqbal at the Shah's in- sistence in February. Eqbal has shown little enthusiasm to organize its membership and, as a result, the party has re- cently lost some important com- mittee chairmanships in the Majlis to the "opposition" Mar- dom party headed by Assadollah Alam. Alam formed his party in May 19 57 and has moved ener- getically to enlarge its mem- bership. The Shah may be groom- ing Alam for the prime minister- ship; however, if Alam is too successful in enlarging his party, the Shah will probably undermine his position. Non-Communist Opposition If political groups were permitted to develop naturally in Iran, nationalists who for- merly were followers of Mossadeq would probably be the most nu- though the government uses various repressive tactics on them, they continue to meet and plan. They are plagued by dis- putes as to the tactics they should adopt to oppose the re- gime. The arrest of over 70 nationalists last year may have inclined them toward planning extremist measures. The Shah's recent success in gaining favor- able oil agreements with Ameri- can companies temporarily raised his prestige, removing some of the nationalists' appeal. The Shah apparently has no program to obtain the support of the growing urban middle class, which admired Mossadeq and is either actually or potentially the enemy of the regime. The Shah's hatred of all-who were associated with the Mossadeq movement keeps him from utiliz- ing the talents of even the conservative leaders of these groups. The discontent of the middle class is a grave politi- cal danger in Iran, and should this group ever seize the gov- ernment, moderates might soon be replaced by Nasir-type dema- gogues. The Shah still has something to fear from the Communist Tudeh party. Declared illegal in 1949, the party continues to operate, particularly in Tehran and the oil center of Abadan, despite the best efforts of the Iranian security forces to eliminate it. Although Khosrow Ruzbah, the Tudeh leader, was executed in May, his death seems to have had little effect on the organization. The present size of the Tudeh is unknown, but in 1953 it had about 35,000 members before the Iranian Government sought to annihilate it. The party continues to de- velop by recruiting Iranian youths and students abroad and receiving assistance from for- eign Communist parties. In an SECRET PART III PATTERNS AND PERSPECTIVES Page 8 of 16 Approved For Release 2007/10/23: CIA-RDP79-00927AO01800090001-4 Approved For Release 2007/10/23: CIA-RDP79-00927AO01800090001-4 SECRET CURRENT INTELLIGENCE WJEKLY SUMMARY 31 July 19 58 effort to ease some of the bit- terness left over from the Mos- sadeq period, the Shah in March ordered the release from prison of certain Tudeh members for- merly in the army and reduced the sentences of others. Tribal Loyalties Many tribal leaders are dissatisfied with the regime's policies, but the tribes are unlikely again to play a large political role in Iran without foreign assistance. Develop- ment of the Iranian military forces, rapid communication, higher educational levels, and increasing prosperity among the tribes have reduced tribal in- clinations to struggle against the central government. The powerful Bakhtiari .; tribe in west-central Iran has been closely allied with the regime, and a number of its mem- bers hold important positions in the government. Since Sor- aya, a Bakhtiari, was divorced by the Shah in March, however, there have been rumors that the tribe has been losing in- f luence. The 500,000-strong Kurdish tribe in northwestern Iran of- fers a potential threat to.Irani- an security, since members could, along with some of the 800,000 Kurds in Iraq, 250,000 in Syria, and 1,500,000 in Turkey, agitate for an independent Kurdish state. Kurdish-language broadcasts from the UAR, aimed at arousing Kurd- ish nationalism, began in June. These, together with the influ- ence of a pro-Nasir government in Iraq, could cause widespread unrest in northwestern Iran. Iran is counterattacking by us- ing propaganda and agents to convince Kurds in Iran and Iraq that they are an Aryan people having nothing in common with Arabs, who are using them to advance Arab imperialism. Iran is especially sensi- tive to Kurdish nationalism be- cause Mullah Mustafa Barzani, former leader of the Barzani Kurdish tribe of Iraq, helped organize a Soviet-sponsored Kurdish republic in Iran in 1945-46. When the incipient re- public was overthrown by Irani- an troops, Barzani and some of his followers fled to the USSR. The Army The Shah relies heavily on his 143,000-man army to pre- serve his power, and he devotes considerable time to ensure the personal loyalty of its command- ers. To prevent conspiracies, he plays one leader against the other. In spite of the Shah's precautions, General Valiollah Gharani, former G-2, was able to form a group, uncovered by the Shah early this year, which had been plotting for almost a year to reduce the Shah to a figurehead. While the army is the most dependable of the Shah's supports, it contains weaknesses which, in a period of severe po- litical pressure on the monarch, might cause elements to support opposing political forces. A major weakness is the growing rivalry between the old officers and the young. The older commanders are disturbed by. the threat to their positions which arises from young officers who are returning from the United States after being exposed to the latest military doctrine and advanced equipment. These young officers in turn,i who now see their senior officers in a new light, are dissatisfied with the army's inefficiency and with promotions based on family con- nections rather than on merit. The Shah has assured Ameri- can officials he intends to pro- mote trained officers into high positions. If he does so rapid- ly, however, the older officers may attempt to limit his powers or remove him. On the other hand, if opportunities for ad- vancement occur too slowly, the SECRET PART III PATTERNS AND PERSPECTIVES Page 9 of 16 __ .__ Approved For Release 2007/10/23: CIA-RDP79-00927AO01800090001-4 Approved For Release 2007/10/23: CIA-RDP79-00927A001800090001-4 SECRET CURRENT INTELLIGENCE WEEKLY SUMKARY 31 July 1958 impatient younger officers may organize to force their will on the Shah. These present and potential factors of unrest could bring about a rapid deterioration of stability in Iran if the right spark were applied. Dissident elements have probably been en- couraged by events in Iraq. USSR PUBLISHES NEW DRAFT CRIMINAL STATUTES After years of delay, draft "basic principles" of both So- viet criminal law and criminal procedure were published in June 1958 to set the guidelines with- in which the 15 union republics will draw up their own detailed criminal codes. The drafts are still open to discussion and change before they are ratified by the USSR Supreme Soviet,prob- ably toward the end of the year. While major overhauls are un- likely, there have been signs of continuing disagreement among legal experts which might re- sult in minor revisions. The draft statutes, which to a considerable degree merely update the old codes first f or- mulated in the 1920's and em- body recent legislative enact- ments, contain no surprises and envisage no drastic revision of present legislation. They contain some innovations for protecting the rights of the accused, suggested during a period of public discussion, over the past several years, but fail to incorporate several of the more liberal proposals. This failure and evidence of compromises can be traced not so much to opposition of the leadership to adopting moderate legal reforms, but rather to conflicts of interests among the various branches of the legal profession--jurists, the procuracy, collegia of lawyers --and also the police and se- curity organs. Most of the changes intro- duced by the draft statutes are apparently designed to give the Soviet citizen a fuller expecta- tion of a fair trial and, in this, they supplement earlier measures--the abolition in 1953 of the MVD's summary trial boards and the abrogation in 1956 of legislation which pre- scribed special trial procedures for political crimes. While the draft codes still assign the Soviet legal system the prime political function of pre- serving the present political and social structure, they also acknowledge for the first time the "personal, political, prop- erty, and other rights of citi- zens." Thus, without seriously weakening its coercive power, the party leadership has sought to adjust the code to the rela- tively more stable conditions of Soviet society, and, at the same time, garner whatever pop- ularity is to be gained from a relaxation of criminal penal- ties. Many questions about crimi- nal legislation are left unan- swered by the draft statutes, and a final appraisal of the criminal law and procedure must await the appearance of the re- public codes. This is particular- ly true in the case of criminal law, as opposed to the code of criminal procedure, because the draft statute provides only a SECRET PART 7- T nn mmt+"ve Awn OVOCDTi!OTT VTi'..S' Page 10 of 16 Approved For Release 2007/10/23: CIA-RDP79-00927A001800090001-4 Approved For Release 2007/10/23: CIA-RDP79-00927AO01800090001-4 SECRET CURRENT INTELLIGENCE WEEKLY SUMMARY 31 July 1958 frequently advocated in the public debate. Its literal adoption was opposed by the procuracy and investigative or- gans on the grounds that it would inhibit the prosecution of a case--the prosecutor must be convinced that the data from the pretrial investigation supports the charge against the defendant or else he must re- fuse to prosecute. As a compromise, Article 13 states that "the obligation to prove the guilt of the ac- cused lies with the prosecutor. A verdict of guilty may not be based on assumptions and may only be passed if guilt of the accused for the commission of the crime is proved." Trial: During the public discussions, it was recommended that the number of "people's assessors" participating in a criminal trial be increased over the present two, and there were even suggestions that the assessors be organized into a kind of jury which would de- liberate without participation of the judge. These proposals were categorically rejected as repudiating time-proven Soviet court procedure and as marking a return to Tsarist court prac- tices. Soviet legal authorities would be wary of relying on a group of citizens to make a decision without benefit of a trained jurist. Trials are to be held in open court except where state secrets or information about the intimate life of the par- ticipants are involved or where a minor is concerned. The court is obliged to base its decision on a review of all of the infor- mation presented, not just one type of evidence, to preclude, Baranov states, the "overevalua- tion" of a confession. How- ever, suggestions that a con- fession be given a secondary status were rejected. The procuracy is charged. with the general responsibility of ensuring that persons sus- pected of a crime are appre- hended, detained, and charged only in accord with legal pro- cedures. According to Article 17, an arrest may be made only by decision of the court or by sanction of the procurator, and detention of suspects must be duly reported to the procuracy. Until the new republic codes are drafted, it will not be clear what, if any, exceptions to the procuracy's supervisory functions exist. All of these prerogatives were granted in the 1955 Statute on the Proc- uracy, and, yet, in the 1956 edition of the RSFSR Criminal Code, it was stated in a foot- note that the method of sanc- tioning arrests by the MVD is provided for "in special rules." Certain features of the draft statute on criminal law apparently have been operative for some time but have not ap- peared in the official code un- til now. According to Article 4, only "the courts, in accord- ance with the law," may sentence persons for criminal offenses. D. S. Karev, dean of the Law Faculty at Moscow University, indicated in a recent article that this clause was included in the draft statute to ac- knowledge that the Special Board of the MVD, which was authorized to sentence administratively, had been abolished. The lan- guage of the statute confirms that corrective labor camps have been reorganized into cor- rective labor colonies. Special colonies have been established for juvenile offenders. According to Article 3, criminal proceedings are not to be brought against anyone ex- cept for "crimes provided for in the criminal code." This elimi- nates the "analogy article" which permitted a court to prosecute an action "constituting a so- cial danger," even if not direct- ly specified by the codes, by means of applying sections of SECRET PART III PATTERNS AND PERSPECTIVES Page 12 of 16 Approved For Release 2007/10/23: CIA-RDP79-00927AO01800090001-4 Approved For Release 2007/10/23: CIA-RDP79-00927AO01800090001-4 SECRET CURRENT INTELLIGENCE WEEKLY S'UM &RY 31. July 19 58 the code "that deal with crimes of the most nearly similar na- ture." The republic codes could circumvent Article 3 through loose and vague defini- tions of crimes, particularly Section 58 on counterrevolu- tionary crimes and sections on economic and administrative crimes. The severity of the terms of confinement have been temp- ered.. According to the RSFSR Criminal Code now in force, persons may be sentenced for imprisonment up to 25 years for very serious crimes. The upper ! limit has been reduced in the new draft to 15 years. In addi- tion, the maximum term of exile has been reduced from 10 to 5 years; the terms of parole have been liberalized so that a con- vict may be released after com- pleting one half of his term instead of two thirds, and the conditions under which an indi- vidual can have his criminal record expunged have been eased. The death penalty has been retained for treason, espionage, sabotage, terrorist acts, pre- meditated murder under aggra- vated circumstances, and, in time of war, especially serious military crimes. Recent Negative Developments by groups of citizens, and the decision is reviewed not by the judiciary but by the local soviets. Several distinguished ju tiSts, including a deputy chairman of the RSFSR Supreme Soviet, have objected to the "parasite laws" on the grounds that they are unconstitutional and usurp the judicial function. It is apparent that the regime, in order to correct what it con- siders a serious domestic prob- lem, has chosen a rather arbi- trary procedure open to manipu- lation by police and party of- ficials and outside existing criminal codes and the new basic principles. In addition, the regime has recently taken a Step back- ward from the recent trend to- ward rescinding criminal sanc- tions in the economic field. A decree of 24 April provided that economic administrators repeat- edly violating contractual ob- ligations for interregional deliveries are to be held "crimi- nally" responsible. In cases involving repeated violations, personal criminal responsibility is to be established rather than mere enterprise responsibility as heretofore. Thus the regime, faced with what it apparently con- siders serious problems of "lo- While the revisions in calism" in connection with the the criminal codes have moved industrial reorganization, has in the general direction of not hesitated to use criminal protecting the rights of the individual and removing the more blatantly arbitrary fea- tures, the regime does not con- sider the criminal law sacro- sanct or beyond politics, The, "parasite laws," approved or under discussion in all of the union republics since 1957, provide for exile and.compul- sory labor for "antisocial and parasitic elements" in a manner falling outside the normal le- gal framework. Offenders are sentenced not by the courts but legislation for assistance, and it may draft new laws of a simi- lar nature to cope with other problems of its reorganized in- dustrial management--such as mishandling of investment funds. meat of its programs. All this is to say that criminal codes in the USSR do not have an independent juridi- cal basis but are viewed by 25X1 the regime as a political instrument for the achieve- SECRET 25X1 PART III PATTERNS AND PERSPECTIVES Page 13 of 16 Approved For Release 2007/10/23: CIA-RDP79-00927AO01800090001-4 Approved For Release 2007/10/23: CIA-RDP79-00927AO01800090001-4 SECRET CURRENT INTELLIGENCE WEEKLY SUMIARY 31 July 19 58 Colombia--Latin America's fourth most populous country and the world's second largest coffee producer--is faced with serious economic problems, de- spite substantial real gains in output, new record highs for commerce and industry, in- creased employment, and other indications that the domestic economy is operating at a high level. The drop in coffee prices and the poor prospect for any reversal of this trend, inflation, and the burden of a large commercial debt are threats to the stability of the democratic government of Lleras Camargo which takes of- fice on 7 August. Background The financial mismanage- ment of the Rojas dictatorship from 1953 to May 1957 left Colombia with a rapidly grow- ing inflation, a critical defi- cit in the balance of payments, and an annual budget deficit of 10 percent. The gross na- tional product grew at an aver- age annual rate of 6 percent during this period, but money in circulation rose at a rate of 18 percent. Dollar earn- ings increased rapidly, but imports expanded at an even faster rate, leaving a foreign commercial debt recently esti- mated at $470,000,000. Since the downfall of the Rojas re- gime, the military junta and civilian cabinet have taken steps to free the exchange rate and settle the backlog of com- mercial debt. They have also restricted credit and imports. and conducted a limited eco- nomic austerity program. A deepening of the eco- nomic crisis could threaten Colombia's attempt to achieve social and political stability after some ten years of auto- cratic government, bitter po- litical warfare, and rural violence which have resulted in an estimated 100,000 deaths. While the scheduled inaugura- tion on 7 August of Lleras Camargo as the joint Liberal- Conservative president will give Colombia for the first time in many years a leader elected by a majority of the people, the long-standing political and so- cial conditions which have re- sulted in instability and vio- lence still remain. Neither of the parties comprising the government has pressed for a program of basic social or economic reforms to better the position of the low- er classes. Both parties repre- sent the landed upper classes and will probably do little to make the needed changes in the agricultural sector of the economy, except to rehabilitate the peasants driven off their farms by partisan guerrilla warfare. In spite of credit and import restrictions, the econ- DOLLARS 900 EXCHANGE UTILIZATION EXCNANOE INCOME omy on the whole continues prosperous under the momentum generated by the inflationary growth of previous years. The reduction in imports of capital goods, however, is likely to have an adverse effect on the long-range productive capacity of Colombian industry. The present inflation is a source of great bitterness SECRET PART III PATTERNS AND PERSPECTIVES Page 14 of 16 Approved For Release 2007/10/23: CIA-RDP79-00927AO01800090001-4 Approved For Release 2007/10/23: CIA-RDP79-00927AO01800090001-4 SECRET CURRENT INTELLIGENCE WEEKLY SUMMARY 31 July 19 58 among the lower classes, whose real wages continue to decline. The rising cost of living could lead to social unrest and strikes which would threaten the delicate balance of the bipartisan political accords. Government attempts to control prices have had limited suc- cess. COLUMBIA : COST OF LIVING INDEX ( JULY 1954 ? JUNE 1955 = 100 ) 40 30 10 00 J F M A M J J A S O N D J F M A 1 1957 I L- 1958 J The burden of the huge commercial debt left by the Rojas regime, coupled with the drop in exchange revenues from coffee, is a further obstacle to the government's attempts to restore the country's eco- nomic position. The backlog has been settled by drawing on reserves and current income from coffee sales, by funding arrangements with US banks, and by borrowing from the Export- Import Bank and private banks. As a result, Colombia must de- vote 15 percent of its future dollar income to servicing its foreign governmental and com- mercial debt, a burden further compounded by falling foreign exchange revenue from coffee sales. The prospect that such revenue would be inadequate to cover minimum essential imports led Colombia to obtain a $103,- 000,000 credit line from the Export-Import Bank and pri- vate US banks in June. The world overproduction of coffee has forced prices down from 72 to 52 cents per pound in New York during the past year, and has drastically reduced Colom- bia's dollar exchange earnings, 85 percent of which are obtained from coffee exports. Since last October, when it signed the Mexi- co City Agreement, in which the members agreed to withhold a percentage of their crops from export, Colombia has accumulated a surplus of over 3,000,000 bags of coffee, and exports have de- clined steadily during recent months. Unless exports increase substantially in the second half of the year, the annual level will be the lowest since 1942. The government has been forced to print money to pay producers for coffee held off the market. With the amount COLUMBIA : FOREIGN EXCHANGE RATE ( IN DOLLARS ) 4 - 000 000 A M J J A S 0 N D J F M A M J 1 1957 1 1958 1 of money in circulation at an all-time high, the further is- suance of money will accelerate the inflationary spiral if, as it now appears, the retention of surplus coffee stocks has to be continued over an extended period. A return to free marketing is opposed by the Colombian semi- official National Coffee Federa- tion, which fears that the price SECRET 0, 000 0000 000 0 000 0000 000 PART III PATTERNS AND PERSPECTIVES Page 15 of 16 Approved For Release 2007/10/23: CIA-RDP79-00927AO01800090001-4 Approved For Release 2007/10/23: CIA-RDP79-00927AO01800090001-4 SECRET CURRENT INTELLIGENCE WEEKLY SUMMARY 31 July 1958 of coffee would drop sharply if the Latin American coffee surplus were put on the market. This drop would not be offset by an increase in sales, since the demand for coffee is fair- ly constant regardless of price variations. Opponents of Colombia's coffee policy feel the market for Colombian cof- fee would not drop as much as that for other stronger varie- ties, such as Brazilian and African. Nevertheless, the policy of the National Coffee Federa- tion is supported by many in- fluential government officials and is not likely to change in the near future. Meanwhile, the United States may expect continued pressure for an in- ternational pact to stabilize coffee prices. Economic Prospects The government can be expected to maintain its tight SECRET money policies under the lead- ership of Lleras Camargo, who has promised to direct major efforts to the solu- tion of the country's eco- nomic problems, and this will also have some arrest- ing influence on the pres- ent high level of activity. Inflationary pressures show no signs of abating, and, unless a new coffee arrangement is reached, the government may be forced to print more money to pay for the coffee retention program. The $103,000,000 loan from the United States will ease the austerity of import restrictions, but will not provide sufficient im- ports to eliminate the ex- cess demand for imported goods and services. These inflationary pressures and the foreign trade deficit will continue to threaten political stability. 25X1 PART III DATTFRWR A) T DPDgDTirTTVVq Dace 16 of 16 Approved For Release 2007/10/23: CIA-RDP79-00927AO01800090001-4 25X1 Approved For Release 2007/10/23: CIA-RDP79-00927AO01800090001-4 Approved For Release 2007/10/23: CIA-RDP79-00927AO01800090001-4