DURIEUX TO RUSK: QUESTION OF THE HOUR

Document Type: 
Collection: 
Document Number (FOIA) /ESDN (CREST): 
CIA-RDP67B00446R000400090001-8
Release Decision: 
RIFPUB
Original Classification: 
K
Document Page Count: 
14
Document Creation Date: 
December 16, 2016
Document Release Date: 
June 20, 2005
Sequence Number: 
1
Case Number: 
Publication Date: 
July 29, 1966
Content Type: 
OPEN
File: 
AttachmentSize
PDF icon CIA-RDP67B00446R000400090001-8.pdf2.42 MB
Body: 
16$08 Approved For Release 2005/06/29.: CIA-RDP67B00446R000400090001-8' ` CONGRESSIONAL RECORD - HOUSE July 29, 1966 Mr. CELLED. Mr. Chairman, I move policy. Like most Americans, however, that the Committee do now rise. he recognizes that communism has The motion was agreed to. forced this struggle upon us and as he Accordingly, the Committee rose; and puts it: the Speaker having resumed the chair, I myself would rather see no flag at all Mr. BOLLING, Chairman of the Commit- over our country than the Star Spangled tee of the Whole House on the State of Banner flying in shame and disgrace. the Union, reported that that Commit- I urge all of the Members of this body tee having had under consideration the to read this very thoughtful letter: bill (H.R. 14765) "to assure nondis- '[From the Ashland Times-Gazette, crimination in Federal and State jury July 26, 1966] selection and service, to facilitate the de- To the EDITOR: segregation of public education and sure, we could get out of southeast Asia other public facilities, to provide judicial and perhaps save thousands of lives. You relief against discriminatory housing wouldn't have to open your morning papers practices, to prescribe penalties for cer- to read headlines about a bloody war which tain acts of violence or intimidation, and you think is foolish and very costly. To for other purposes," had come to no res- begin sowith, you ns being dd ft habetoreor about olution thereon. drive a car and life in h t ld tional-because it is the title that affects them most directly. Mr. Chairman, although I feel that this section of the bill is without ques- tion unconstitutional, I do not believe it to be any more unconstitutional than the rest of this bill. In 1963 Supreme Court Justice Harlan stated in the case of Peterson against Greenville : Freedom of the individual to choose his associates or his neighbors, to use and dis- rose of his property as he sees fit, to be irrational, arbitrary, capricious even unjust in his personal relations are things all en- titled to a large measure of protection from government interference. This language states as clearly as pos- sible that the Federal Government has no business telling a person to whom he may or may not sell his home. CORRECTION OF ROLLCALL TITLE V Mr. PRICE. Mr. Speaker, on rollcall Title V of the omnibus civil rights bill No. 186, on July 28, a quorum call, I am is supposedly based on the equal protec- recorded as absent. I was present and tion clause of the 14th amendment. But answered to my name. I ask unani this title would apply to the action of mous consent that the permanent REC- both States and private individuals, ORD and Journal be corrected accord- which in my judgement violates the ingly. Constitution. I quote from the Supreme The SPEAKER. Is there objection to Court in the 1948 case of Shelly against the request of the gentleman from Kraemer: Illinois? The principle has become firmly embedded There was no objection. in our Constitutional law that the action Mr. DON H. CLAUSEN. Mr. Speaker, as s may the 14th fairly on rollcall No. 189, a quorum call, I am such action section amendment nby is the only first a be said to be that of the State. That amend- recorded as absent. I was present and I ask unani- ment erects no shield against merely private answered to my name. conduct, however discriminatory or wrong- mous consent that the permanent REC- ful. ORD and Journal be corrected accord- enoug o hardly o general, might seem a lot more peaceful all around. But while you're thinking of how good things would be, you might also stop and remember the some 4,500 boys who have al- ready paid the supreme price, their lives. You might also think of the thousands who have been wounded, many crippled for life, because while people in this country protest, hold marches and demonstrations, burn draft cards and write their congressman about how bad and awful this war is (these men, who several months ago, in a great many cases, hadn't even seen an M-14 or a 45, who knew no more about the ways and means of war than about the man in the moon, much less places such as Chu-1i, DaNang or even Viet Nam itself) were and still are fighting and dying in a war of which few even know how it started. But yet, you could ask any one of them why they were there and behind every reason would be an answer similar b tt d a ere ear.. . its colors from the Asian under the law, this section would-afford The SPEAKER. Is there objection to Pointing towards a special protection to certain groups. the request of the gentleman from sun, showing not eo lythe effects ofoweather TITLE VI California? but also bearing the evidence of war. Here Title VI authorized the Attorney Gen- There was no objection. a man might say, I have a son at home and because of him and his mother and all peo- eral to institute court proceedings to ple's children, I am here. and other public afac lit es. This section ASHLAND, 'OHIO, SAILOR SPEAKS States of America. I believe in her past, lher would grant him the power to institute OUT present but most of all her future and to such proceedings as he may desire even (Mr. ASHBROOK asked and was giv- her future. I will pledge my own life. I though there may be no complaints of en permission to address the House for also believe in that banner up there. Mil- any discrimination in the case involved. 1 minute, to revise and extend his re- lions have given their lives in its defense. I am no different. God gave us the privilege This section to me reveals that those marks, and to include extraneous mat- to live in a country of which there is no proposing this legislation have no con- ter.) equal and I intend to give this opportunity fidence in our present judicial procedure. Mr. ASHBROOK. Mr. Speaker, every to not only my children but everyone who There is no doubt in my mind that this now and then you run across a state- believes in freedom and justice for all. bill would further restrict the indi- ment that cuts through all of the double- Therefore, we must stay in Viet Nam until vidual liberties so granted by our talk, all of the veil of duplicity of pur- Communism is driven, not only from Viet Nam, but the entire world. It is not only a Constitution. pose and protest which seems to cover threat to our way of life, but to our very In summary, this bill is unnecessary our current Vietnam involvement. In existence as a free nation on this planet. and unconstitutional. It does not en- reading the July 26, 1966, issue of the If we admit to defeat in Viet Nam, we'are courage equality for all-it seeks to pro- Ashland Times-Gazette, I saw the fol- not only letting our boys down, we are/ letting vide special treatment for minority lowing statement by a young serviceman every American who ever died for America's groups. This bill must be defeated in who is heading for Vietnam: cause down. But most of all, we would be country down and we might as order to guarantee the rights and liber- I am here because I believe in the United letwttlintg ke our down Old Glory forever. I. myself, Cos tithe individual as provided in our States of America. would rather see no flag at all over our coun- onstitution. What a succinct statement. Sounds try, than the Star Spangled Banner flying in i shame and disgrace ,. --- -- - ` -- ---' . he N All ment offered by the gentleman from power or pocketbook but by their patri- N North Carolina [Mr. WHITENERI. otic fervor. (Boyd, who is the 19-y r d ri) Mr. WHITENER. Mr. Chairman, I Robert C. Boyd is in the U.S. Navy. and Mrs. Charles E. Boy ' l t eav o demand tellers. Like many young servicemen, he has Ave., is scheduled Tellers were ordered, and the Chair- seen the grumblings, the anti-American in November: Ed.) h d o oes w man appointed as tellers, Mr. WHITENER slogans and the campus weir and Mr. CELLER. protest our involvement in Vietnam. He The Committee divided and the tellers is probably like most Americans when he reported. that there were-ayes 51, noes feels a regret that it is necessary in this 116. supposedly enlightened age to still use THE HOUR warfare as an instrument of national - permission to extend his remarks at this Approved For, Release 2005/06/29 : CIA-RDP67B00446R000400090001-8 July 29, 1966 Approved For Release 2005/06/29 : CIA-RDP67B00446R000400090001-8 CONGRESSIONAL RECORD = HOUSE 16967, hearings, where this is dealt with-that guarantee the fundamental rights of all Republicans opposed it by a margin of is the only reference I find to the title. our citizens. greater than 5 to 1. In doing so, they We have the Attorney General before The New York Times today carried an voted for legislative responsibility on the this committee testifying that there is editorial, entitled "Legislating Bias," and part of this body. no evidence of discrimination in the it is so appropriate to our discussion here H.R. 14765 is composed of eight titles. Federal system that he believes requires and now that I am taking the liberty of I want to say at this point that I have any further legislative action. We have inserting it in the RECORD at this point. always been opposed to this type of omni- the Attorney General saying that he is I would call the attention of all my col- bus legislation. The administration has not taking it up with the Judicial Con- leagues to this editorial, which is, I be- made a practice of presenting this type ference. He has not sought, in effect, lieve, self-explanatory. of legislation intending to include in it, the opinion of the judges. The editorial follows: record that we have made here on the The House of Representatives is now en- floor 01 the House, which shows that out gaged in the unseemingly specatcle of decid- TITLE I of the 90 U.S. districts in the Federal ing who shall be allowed to discriminate Title I of this bill would eliminate al- court system, not a single judge has come against Negroes and who shall be required to leged discrimination in the selection of forward and urged or approved the en- treat them fairly. Federal Juries. However, in an unprec- actment of title I of this bill. Representative CHARLze MATIHIAS, Maryland edented manner, this section received Mr. CASEY. Mr. Chairman, will the Republican, believes the distinction should very little consideration by the Judiciary be drawn at the city line. Those who rent gentleman yield? apartments in buildings with five units or Committee. This is one of the faults of Mr. WHITENER. I yield to the gen- more will have to be good Americans and not omnibus legislation-invariably, some tleman from Texas. ' discriminate against otherwise qualified ten- sections of the bill are either purposely Mr. CASEY. In further reference to ants just because they are Negroes. Since or accidentally overlooked. this, at the bottom of page 1185 of the these buildings are mostly in the center of TITLE n hearings, the gentleman from Ohio [Mr. cities, bigotry would be banned there. But at the city line where the suburbs begin and Title II would supposedly prohibit so- MCCULLOCHI asked if the Department of the neighborhoods are made up of one-family called discrimination in the selection of Justice in the last 25 years had recom- houses, discrimination against Negroes would State jurors. All a defendant would mended to the Judicial Co feren t ce or o recommendations that there be uni- The defenders of the suburban interests be- the burden of proof would shift to the formity, to which the Attorney General lieved that they had achieved their goal of State to prove the charge untrue. Under said "No." writing this dual standard into the civil rights bill when this provision all criminal prosecutions Mr. WHITENER. That is correct. they amended Title IV in committee. But since the Attorney General could be delayed indefinitely. In the I hope Members will vote in support of has expressed the opinion that brokers acting light of several recent Supreme Court the amendment. on behalf of bigoted property owners would decisions increasing the rights of crim- The CHAIRMAN. The Chair reCog- not necessarily be immune, these proponents inals, and the recent riots in Chicago, nizes the gentleman from Ohio [Mr. Mc- of the double standard have another, more South Bend, Omaha, Cleveland, and CuLlocHi to close debate on the amend- explicit, amendment to make their intent Brooklyn, this is clearly not the time to meet. clear. It leaves no doubt that both brokers further restrict our law enforcement Mr. McCULhOCIi. Mr. Chairman, and owners can discriminate with no worry notwithstanding the about punishment, It is a dismal per- machinery. questions I pro- formance. TITLE III pounded to the Attorney General and his what is most astonishing is that Repre- Title III of this omnibus civil rights answers thereto, I came to a studied sentative EMANUEL CELLES and the other Ad- bill would authorize the Attorney Gen- judgment that title I should have my ministration managers of the bill seem in- eral to institute proceedings to prevent support. clined to accept this latest amendment as a person from having his civil rights vio- The method of selecting Federal jurors the neecssary price of Republican support lated. Undoubtedly, if this title is en- and grand jurors is not uniform in all for the bill. Admittedly Mr. CELLER and his Democratic colleagues in the House have re- parts acted, the courts would be flooded with of-the United States, and judges ceived something less than stout-hearted cases, since the term "civil rights" can who are most conscientious find that the support from the white House and the Jus- be construed to cover any form of human guidelines are not all clear. By reason tice Department on this issue. But that is activity. The Federal Government of the fact that the guidelines are not no reason for timorous counsels to prevail. would also have to pay the costs of any clear, from time to time convictions are There is no certainty that the majority of suits under this title. The defendant had by juries which have not been se- House Republicans are going to desert this would be entitled to no such services. Netted in accordance with constitutional bi or even this section of it f realyeseate brokers are denied the immunity they seek. This is merely another attempt to give basic rights and principles. The original Mathias amendment, aa; preferred treatment to certain minority Mr. Chairman, I know that this is adopted in committee, was a mistake and groups instead of equal treatment for all. going to entail the assembly of millions an act of injustice. This further clarifying TrTLE - rv of names in some districts or divisions amendment only makes it worse. Title IV of the Civil Rights Act of thereof and that it will require additional Mr. WALKER. of Mississippi. Mr. 1966, better known as the so-called fair clerks for that work. But when the work Chairman, H.R. 14765, the so-called housing section could in my estimation is done I am sure there will be a uniform Civil Rights Act of 1966, is just another be termed the "great equalizer." On constitutional method of selecting jurors one of the many Great Society bills which four previous occasions in recent years, in this country which will meet the tests this body has been ordered to pass with- the Congress has passed four separate laid down by the highest court of this out giving adequate consideration. This civil rights bills. But, none of the four land. When those who are indicted are bill was brought to the floor under the previous bills have had anything included tried and convicted there will be far few- 21-day rule. However, the Rules Coal- that would have such a nationwide er reversals and remanding of convictions mittee was allotted only one-.third of effect as would the fair housing section than there have been in the past. this time to give the bill ample examina- of this bill. For the first time, many of For that reason, and notwithstanding tion. The final report on this bill was my colleagues from north of the Mason the fact that it will cost substantial mon- submitted an July 14, giving the Rules Dixon Line have expressed concern that ey to implement this title, I expect to vote Committee barely over a week to exam- against the amendment and in support of ine it. If this bill is as important as the they feel this bill goes too far. I well title I. I hope others will, too. Great Society administration says it is, understand what they mean, it goes too Mr. ROSENTh AL. Mr. Chairman, then certainly all committees concerned far north. For the first time, we have yesterday I spoke on the Civil Rights Act with it should have ample time to debate a civil rights proposal that reaches now before us, and expressed my views all the issues at hand. The rule for the home-every home in the Nation. And in favor of the strongest possible bill, if consideration of H.R. 14765 passed by a now, many of my colleagues are saying we are to fulfill our obligations to vote of 200 to 180 and I am proud that that title IV of this bill is unconstitu- No. 123--3 Approved For Release 2005/06/29 : CIA-RDP67B00446R000400090001-8 July -W, 1966 Approved fqN&*BM?$AIOMWOUD-RDH W446R000400090001-8 16809 of us who serve In the Congress, as it is of our older Americans. There can be to all Americans. However, it is most no matter of more extreme importance especially a matter of concern to the mil- In this field. point in the RECORD, and to include ex- traneous matter.) Mr. ASHBROOK. Mr. Speaker, a con- stituent and good friend, Lee Durieux, of Mount Vernon, Ohio, was in town last week, He left his mark. He was attend- ing a meeting of the International Plat- form Association and was present when Dean Rusk opened up a session to ques- tions and answers. Lee offered the ques- tion : - Why don't we bomb the port of Haiphong- and to hell with Russian shipping? What Mr. Durieux did not expect, how- ever, was the evasive and questionable answer which the Secretary _ of State gave. My constituent came up with about the best summation of the handling of the Vietnamese war that I have seen as yet. He noted: It is like a mackerel hanging in the moon- light-it shines and stinks. To clarify the matter, Mr. Durieux wrote to Drew Pearson. A copy of his letter follows. It is a good summation of what many Americans from our part of the country are thinking. Congratula- tions, Lee, and please come to Washing- ton more often: WASHINGTON, D.C., July 23, 1966. MR. DREW PEARSON: Yesterday after Dean Rusk's speech, I handed you a card with the question, "Why don't we bomb the port of Haiphong-and to hell with Russian ship- ping?" I note that this made headlines in the newspapers. I was, however, disappointed with Rusk's answer even though I feel he was the top speaker so far in the IPA. I too was a flier during WW II and can re- call that we had more than a dozen places like Vietnam to conquer, but in those days we went in to win! Therefore, you can under- stand my bluntness and inability to compre- hend this "half-vast" war in Vietnam! I have two sons in college; one of which is going into the army in 2 weeks-the other carries a draft card. I would prefer that these sons go into the service to end this war, not a part of appeasement and delayed action.. I would like for Mr. Rusk to name one instance since 1945 that the Communists haven't backed down when we showed sin- cerity and force! I would even go so far as to state that I would like to see us dare China to come into this war just for an opportunity to knock out their atomic in- stallations before the day comes that we all know will come when they will be able to "deliver" these weapons. I have always admired your comments and editorials; I also feel you have been a god- send to the IPA. Sincerely, lions of our fellow citizens who live on fixed incomes. Today, I have introduced two bills which are directed particularly at the needs of this group of people- the aging. This past year I have had the privi- lege of serving on the Republican Na- tional Task Force on the Problems of the Aging. If there is any one fact which stood out in the course of our investiga- tions, it is the fact that inflation and the consequent rise in living costs have often brought harsh and dire consequences to our senior citizens. Inflation steals from everyone, but those who live on pensions and fixed in- comes are especially hurt. When infla- tion takes place, the purchasing power of the dollar goes down. Money that has been allocated to the later years of one's life often becomes inadequate in meeting unforeseen increases in the cost of vital goods and services. Congress has not remained entirely oblivious to this problem in the past. The social security and the railroad re- tirement programs have had their bene- fits raised periodically. However, these increases have been sporatic and uneven. Between these increases, there has usu- ally existed a period during which the purchasing power of the pensioners' dol- lar has drastically declined. For exam- ple, our task force found that between 1956 and 1964 inflation cost social secu- rity pensioners approximately $1.4 billion in loss of purchasing power. Statistics such as this are alarming, but not nearly as alarming as the dep- rivation suffered by those of the aging who cannot keep pace with the rising cost of living. Mr. Speaker, I believe that my two bills will directly aid those caught in this squeeze. Our task force recommended that the Social Security Act and the Railroad Re- tirement Act be amended to provide an automatic increase in their insurance benefits which is tied to increase in the Consumer Price Index, the principal indicator of inflation. My bills are de- signed to accomplish this objective by raising those benefits when there is a 3- percent cost-of-living increase., I am pleased to note that the Repub- lican leadership in the House of Repre- sentatives have joined our efforts to achieve these goals. Enactment of my twin proposals is essential if we are to meet the needs of the aging. Mr. Speaker, under my proposal the increased benefits will not necessitate an MOUNT VERNON, OHIO. P.S.-I am a signer and entertainer-not a writer. To sum up this war in Vietnam, it has its bright prospects and bad ones. It is like a mackerel hanging in the moonlight- it shines and stinks! HORTON SUBMITS BILLS TO HELP AGING KEEP PACE WITH IN- CREASES IN COST OF LIVING (Mr. HORTON asked and was given permission to address the House for 1 minute and to revise and extend his re- marks.) Mr. HORTON. Mr. Speaker, increases in the cost of living are a concern to all increase in taxes. Inflation brings with it increased wages. In turn, increased wages will naturally bring increased pay- ments into social security and, addition- ally, the benefits paid represent a smaller proportion of an individual's wages as his wages approach the maximum limit- $6,600. Therefore, because of these fac- tors, there will be no increase in payroll deductions to finance my proposal. I believe that my bills, if passed, will have an immediate and immensely bene- ficial impact on our senior citizens. Mr. Speaker, I urge all my colleagues to sup- port these bills. We need to act immedi- ately if we are to meet the present needs JIM FARLEY AT 78 (Mr. JOELSON asked and was given permission to extend his remarks at this point in the body of the RECORD and to include extraneous matter.) Mr. JOELSON. Mr. Speaker, because of the admiration which we all feel for James A. Farley, I am sure my colleagues will enjoy reading the following article about him by Ernest Cuneo. It appeared in many papers, and was published by the Morning Call in the congressional district which I represent on May 31, 1966. It is good to know that "Jim" Farley is still going strong, and I am sure that we all wish him many more years of success and accomplishment. The article follows: NEW YORK.-Big Jim Farley was 78 years old yesterday. He celebrated with his usual 78-hour work week. Since his last birthday he has attended 125 dinners and 70 luncheons at many of which he was principal speaker. He also traveled 60,000 miles by land, sea, and air, visiting 20 countries, including all European capitals, all Central American capi- tals, and the principal cities of Mexico. He reads the box scores of every major league ball game-without glasses-as part of his habit of reading at least four newspapers every day. He is 6 feet 3 inches tall, literally in the well-known pink, and his 205 pounds haven't varied in the last 20 years. He has a most peculiar walk, one of very quick and very short steps. His towering figure seems to scoot through the New York winds, in spite of the fact that it is inter- rupted every 10 paces by some one who wants to shake his hand. Perhaps no man since Daniel Webster's Boston has so much received the adulation of a city. New Yorkers give him the respect accorded Al Smith and the affec- tion bestowed on Jimmy Walker. There is an astonishing simplicity about this most sophisticated of men. He still has the clean wholesomeness of the lanky coun- try boy who played first base for the town team 60 years ago. He brought this same zest to politics. The Democratic Party was his team, and he gave it all he had. From 8 every morning till 6 at night, he's in there pitching for his current team, Coca- Cola Export. He's head of it, but he puts on no airs. He calls himself a salesman, and sell he does. Jim was the second of five boys. His father was a Hudson River schooner captain, sailing bricks down to New York City. He prospered. He bought two small brickyards. But just before Jim was 10, his father went out to harness the horse to go to a neighbor's fu- neral. The halter was long, the horse frisky. Suddenly wheeling, he kicked Captain Farley in the chest. He died that night. Ellen Goldrick Farley, Jim's mother, would run neither a schooner nor brickyards. Cap- tain Farley left no debts, small assets, sturdy bodies, an honorable name, and a great mother for his boys. Jim promised his mother he would never touch an alcoholic drink, and he never has. He doesn't smoke either. These are tremendous advantages for a man to bring to the hard-dealing games in the smoke-filled rooms of politics. Jim wanted to be Town Clerk. An Irish- American Catholic Democrat stood as much chance in the rock-ribbed Republican town of Grassy Point then as Mao Tse-tung stands of being elected Governor of Utah now. But Jim took to the mails. Apparently Republi- cans like to receive letters because they Approved For Release 2005/06/29 : CIA-RDP67B00446R000400090001-8 16810 h r Approved For Rele se 2005/06/29 : CIA-RDP67B00446R000400090001-8 CONGRESSIONAL RECORID - HOUSE July 296, 1966 elected him, This started the most unbe- lievable romance in history between Jim Parley and the United States mails. He be- came Postmaster-General of the United States, then practically a concomitant of be- ing chairman of the Democratic National Committee. He deserved it as its chief cus- tomer alone. Being at the head of the Post Office Department did not soothe his letter- writing propensities; it inflamed them. Fol- lowing the 1932 campaign, he signed 22,000 first-name letters of thanks; In 1936, 27,000. And not when he got around to it; immedi- ately. Within a week after election, there were 27,000 families in thousands of cities and villages proudly exhibiting the letters of thanks with the famous green-ink signature. HOW TO SUCCEED Parley, a boy who never graduated from high school, has 22 honorary degrees. He, with President Herbert Hoover, were the two distinguished members of both parties select- ed to reorganize the United States executive department. He has served on New York State's sacrosanct Banking Commission, and its Boxing Commission, and is currently on its Racing Commission. He can discuss as an expert whether foreign trade will expand (he thinks it will multiply) or whether Mickey Mantle is swinging too hard (he thinks he is). About 10,000 letters will pour Into his office this week. The whole world waved to Jim Farley on his birthday. And Big Jim beams back. To him this is a great big wonderful world. THE IRS AUDITORS' IMAGE (Mr. FASCELL asked and was given permission to extend his remarks at this point in the body of the RECORD and to include extraneous matter.) Mr. FASCELL. Mr. Speaker, the au- ditors of the Internal Revenue Service often have been depicted as unreason- able, almost inhuman automatons, in- terested solely in squeezing every pos- sible cent from taxpayers,. regardless of how far they have to stretch the tax laws to do so. I believe it is fair to say that that impression has so grown that the average taxpayer who has not gone through the experience dreads the pos- sibility that sometime he will be put through the auditing process. The In- ternal Revenue Service has done much to attempt to dispel the unfavorable image of its audits and auditors, by in- sisting that its auditors deal in all fair- ness with taxpayers. Nevertheless, in- stances continue to arise in which IRS auditors are accused of overzealousness, to the point of ]harassment. The May 5, 1966, issue of the Reporter magazine contained an article entitled "The Tax Appeal Ordeal," in which the author, Mr. William R. Frye, detailed his experiences with IRS audit proce- dures. Perhaps the author fully sum- marized his feelings of what he had been through when he said it was "a miser- able experience." The article follows: THE TAX-APPEAL ORDEAL (By William R. Frye) Pity the poor taxpayer. He assembles his records, studies the instructions, wrestles with the forms, pays his tax-and then sits back to await doomsday. Doomsday, for him., is the day Form 3R73 arrives with this mes- sage: "Your above-described tax return or document for the year indicated has been assigned to the above-named Agent for ex- amination. Please communicate with the Agent.. . . The possibility of being audited is the third dimension of the Income-tax nightmare. Substantiating that office at home, finding that Washington hotel bill, proving that lunch was a business entertainment-these could be more difficult than making out the return itself. They could even be impossible. Some sixty-six million personal income-tax returns were filed in fiscal 1965; 3,092,000-- one in twenty, or just over five per cent- were "examined," as the Internal Revenue Service puts it. Deficiencies, or taxes due, were found in fifty-one per cent of the cases, producing $1,063,000,000 in additional rev- enue; refunds were paid by the government fourteen per cent of the time, for a total of $47,052,000. No change was made in thirty- five per cent of the returns. The average deficiency was just below $700; the average refund just above $100. Aside from gamblers and other special cases, only 1,216 of those who were examined (or 0.04 per cent) were prosecuted for fraud. How many of the more than 1.5 million taxpayers who were made to pay additional tax really had short-changed the govern- ment, accidentally or intentionally? How many ran afoul of an IRS overeager to maxi- mize collections? The IRS feels sure it was practically always right (an understandable view), but many taxpayers are by no means sure. I know how they feel. I have just been through the mill. Mine was one of the relatively rare cases-one in seven-where the taxpayer is found to have overpaid his tax. The return had been prepared for me while I was abroad and contained several major errors in the governments favor. I was due for a refund. It was, nevertheless, a miserable experience. Day after day after exhausting day was taken up in minutely detailed, repetitive nit- pick-ing. Accountants whom I told about the case said that they had never known an audit to be so detailed and prolonged. At the end of each session, I was assigned to prepare fur- ther data for the next visit-a task requiring long days and longer nights, sometimes run- ning into weeks. (Everything involved had happened three years before.) My profes- sional life was intermittently disrupted for more than seven months. The lost time was worth conservatively $4,000 to $5,000-and since I was self-employed, I had no way to cushion the loss. Moreover, legal and other fees ate up much of the refund. The only comic relief was that each time I was ordered to dive deeper into the records, I came up with a new accounting error in the government's favor, and hence a larger potential refund. This was not what the agent had in mind. "How am I going to justify my time?" he asked. Finally, as a consequence of another of his probes, I dis- covered a $1,500 reimbursement that had been reported, both as income and as a credit against expense. Whether by coincidence or not, the roof promptly fell in. My agent (or his supervisor) re-opened the whole audit and disallowed deductions that previously had been fully substantiated. The law had not changed; the facts had not changed; nothing had, except that someone seemed to have decided that letting a tax- payer get back that much money would not look good at all on the report of such a pro- longed audit. I could appeal the ruling, first to a "con- feree"-a higher official of the IRS--and then, if necessary, to a still higher one, I could even go to tax court. But in the process, the additional time lost and the new legal fees Incurred could more than wipe out any tax recovered. It seemed I would have to take the licking; either way, I would lose. After considerable additional dispute, the agent reconsidered and an appeal became unnecessary. But in my bitterer moments, I felt my government had subjected me to a form of legalized extortion. THE HIGH COST OF APPEALS A spot check of accounting firms in the New York area suggests that thousands of taxpayers every year may have similar un- pleasant experiences. Similar, that is, not in the denial of refunds that are due but in the levying of additional taxes which they consider unjustified but which they cannot recover economically through the normal ap- peal process. By comparison with the total number of returns filed, the number of these taxpayers may be small, but to the people concerned it is a serious matter. Mr. S., a partner in a New York accounting firm that specializes in tax work (because of his continuing dealings with the IRS, he insisted on remaining anonymous), said he used to fight, on behalf of his clients, as many as fifty appeals at a time. But in virtually every case, once the appeal was over the client was so angry at the size of the accounting bill that, whatever the results of the appeal, Mr. S. would lose the account. So he made it a firm rule never to handle appeals. He now negotiates with the las agent as stoutly as posible the first time around, and then proposes to the client that he accept the outcome, favorable or other- wise. If the taxpayer wants to appeal, some other firm must take the case. His rela- tionship to the client is then finished either way. The effect of this policy is that In cases where Mr. S.'s advice is accepted, the gov- ernment has been allowed virtually to dic- tate its terms to the taxpayer on the issues in dispute. If Mr. S. is right, many if not most appeals are too expensive to be practi- cal. Other accountants are not quite so sweeping; but they say that unless at least $1,500 to $2,000 In tax is involved, the tax- payer can scarcely expect to break even from an appeal to "conference," even if he wins. Unless he feels qualified to handle it on his own, he must pay an accountant $50 to $200 a day, not merely during the conference it- self but throughout a period of preparation. And the taxpayer's own time is also a, factor. Still higher appeals, beyond the conference stage, are not considered economical, unless something in the neighborhood of $10,000 in taxes is involved. The ras does not release figures on how many cases went to confer- ence; but In 1965, 21,737 disputes (less than one per cent of the total) were handled at the appellate level, the next stage, and only 5,448 (roughly one quarter of one per cent) were disposed of by the tax courts. The money In question however, was in the hun- dreds of millions. The man who decides to do without costly help is, in effect, throwing himself on the mercy of the IRS. Mr. C., a partner in a Connecticut consulting firm, was on the road five days a week, year round, returning home only for weekends. He naturally had a large travel and entertaintment deduction. When the return was selected for audit, he could not take time off to attend personally; his "billing rate" (the rate at which clients were charged for his services) was $250 a day, and he was fully booked. So he sent his wife to the tax auditor, armed with can- celed checks and credit-card bills. The audi- tor contended there was not proof the travel was not personal, and disallowed the whole amount. The wife did not know how to pro- test persuasively. So the whole year's travel was lost. This couple could have hired professional help, but did not. Many others cannot af- ford to. Few men making less than $15,000 a year care to pay $15 to $50 an hour for an accountant, let alone $25 to $100 an hour for a lawyer. A return showing a $4,000 Income is not as likely to be examined as one show- ing $400,000, but it can happen. The test, the IRS says, Is not the size of the income but whether there is anything unusual about the return, anything that causes raised eye- brows. If the ax falls, the little men have no choice but to fend for themselves. Approved For Release 2005/06/29 : CIA-RDP67B00446R000400090001-8 16904 Approved tiously optimistic," but said he saw no indi- BOMBINGS CLEAR AIR-No OTHER CHOICE cations that the Communists were ready to There is a new feeling of pride and a sense go to the negotiating table. He indicated of purpose among the people of the United additional appropriations, above the present States of America that can almost be felt figure of $1 billion a month, might be neces- tangibly. sary, and other administration spokesmen It dates from the day when the United have indicated the U.S. might have to beef States Air Force and Navy carried the most up its troop commitment in Vietnam. telling blow of the war to the enemy in Viet Secretary of State Rusk was equally realis- Nang by bombing military targets at Hanoi tic when he said, "One can be encouraged and Haiphong. without believing the war is over." And then The President is entirely correct in his he added, "We are not over the hump yet. assessment that American people "would We haven't begun to see the end of this rather reason than fight. We are using our thing. There has not been the necessary power in Viet Nam because the Communists decision on the other side." have given us no other choice." The President, speaking to the American He also is entirely correct in the state- Alumni Council meeting at White Sulphur ment that American people "when they un- Springs, W. Va., Tuesday said that peace derstand what is at stake have never run "may be long in coming, but it is clearly on from their duty ... The American people the way. And come it must." have never left an ally in a fight." If the average American gets impatient Unfortunately, at times in the past the with alternate messages of optimism and American public has been justifiably con- pessimism, he must realize that no one can fused o,,er the war in Viet Nam, not about predict day-to-day developments on a battle- goals but in tactics. field. What Americans should realize is that For too long the initiative has been given the Vietnam war is going better for us than the enemy. Our responses were only to meet for the enemy, in a military sense, and that some new condition of battle he imposed. a new element of political stability seems to Important strategic targets such as the oil have asserted itself in Saigon. Only a few storage facilities that now have been severe- months ago, the Buddhists were burning ly damaged were untouched by our superior themselves all over the place and the peace- air might. niks were saying the U.S. could not possibly Equally confusing is the fact that some of win. The pendulum may have swung too far our other allies who protest loudly at each the other way last week, but it has been countermove the United States made to an Fo~MsJ4&02ikte.P67,R00040009000J*gy 29, 1966 Why have American balance of pay- ments and monetary policy had these bad results-so opposite to those for which any reasonable man would hope? The answer, I believe, is that there has been the same kind of open-ended com- mitment, the same kind of increasingly frozen position, and consequently, the same kind of escalation of effort, without characterized our policy in Vietnam, reconsideration of purpose, that have Our commitment to total elimination of our payments deficit, our frozen position on the emergency balance-of-payments program, and our escalation of interest rates-all three require immediate re- consideration. In Vietnam our purpose must be peace-I hope it is, and I pray that this administration seeks peace- and our policies must be brought into line with that purpose. Just so, in the economic world, our pta-pose must be prosperity-and our policies must be re- thought, refashioned, and reformulated to bring them into line, too. As our un- precedented military po er must be used for world pe e soyour unprece- dented econom'l wJr oday must be STAKES IN VIETNAM Mr. SMATHERS. Mr. President, the Arizona Republic takes us to the heart of the Vietnamese situation in an edi- torial commenting on waves of public optimism and pessimism over the fight- ing in southeast Asia. President Johnson and Secretaries Rusk and McNamara have put matters into perspective, the newspaper says, after an unduly optimistic impression sprang from the President's guarded news conference remarks early in July. Whatever else, the Republic comments, Americans should realize that the fight- ing is going better for us than for the enemy, that a new element of stability has asserted itself in Saigon and that a campaign of economic and social recon- struction is progressing in South Viet- nam. The stakes are high, says the newspa- per-high enough for patience and forti- tude at home as well as courage and strength on the other side of the Pa- ciflc. I wish to insert this editorial in the RECORD. There being no-objection, the editorial was ordered to be printed in the RECORD, as follows: [From the Arizona Republic, July 14, 1966] VIETNAM PENDULUM President ,fohnson made an optimistic as- sessment of the Vietnam war in his July 4 interview on the ranch. He said "diplo- matic reports" indicate the Communists "no longer expect a military victory." He felt the air raids on the oil depots near Hanoi and Haiphong had destroyed well over half of the enemy's reserves and equipment. "Success will be ours in Vietnam." he said. if these guarded statements were parlayed into the general impression that Ho Chi Minh_ was hanging on the ropes and that his backers were likely to throw in the towel at any minute, that is unfortunate. For such is not the case. This week, Secretary of Defense McNa- mara put matters into better perspective when he told a news conference he was "cau- righted this week. enemy tactic are themselves contributing In the meantime, if anyone has any doubt, substantially to prolongation of the war. the Vietnam war gives every appearance of Without the supplies they ship to North being one of the decisive battlefields on Viet Nam through the port of Haiphong, the which communism must be stopped. Just war may have taken a far different turn some as communism was stopped in Greece and time ago. In other words, some of our allies in Korea, it must be stopped in Vietnam or have made our drastic action necessary. the future, not only of Southeast Asia, but From recent history Americans are aware of the whole free world, will be endangered. that the only way to meet what the President Nor should Americans forget the other war, calls "raw Communist pressure" is by looking the campaign of reconstruction, that is be- it in the eye and making it unmistakably ing waged in Vietnam. Just as South Korea clear that we will not retreat. and Formosa have built up their economies It was this type of confrontation that made to the "take-off point," at which economic the Communist guerrillas retreat in Greece, aid is no longer needed, so can South Viet- it broke the blockade of Berlin, prevented nam establish a viable economy. And when Russian nuclear tipped long range missiles that is done, the siren call of communism from being installed in Cuba and it worked will fall on deaf ears in South Vietnam and in the Dominican Republic where a free elec- the international conspiracy will have suf- tion has been conducted. fered another great setback in its effort to It was understandable that the U.S. public subvert and conquer free countries every- might be confused why we were not apply- where. ing the same pressures in air and naval The stakes are high-high enough to call superiority, as military leaders suggest. for patience and fortitude on tie part of Since the enemy has not shown any desire strength for thon the othe/ side the' tle be- Pacific. This w n't e 1 t bat le tween freedom nd r y, put its impor- BOMBINGS CLEAR AIR Mr. SMATHERS. Mr. President, the Copley newspapers detect a new feeling of pride and sense of purpose among the American people. They suggest it dates from the day our planes bombed the oil storage facilities near Hanoi and Haiphong. The newspaper organization agrees with President Johnson that we would rather reason than fight, but we never run from duty nor desert an ally. The air strikes served notice to the enemy that the price they may have to pay for aggression might not be to their liking. And they represent tactical action aimed at a quicker honorable peace in Vietnam. I offer for the RECORD the Copley edi- torial as it appeared in the Elgin, Ill., Daily Courier-News. There being no objection, the editorial was ordered to be printed in the RECORD, as follows: any conditions, the price of the war to him must be made untenable. The air strikes against oil storage and other strategic targets were a plain notice to the enemy that the price they might have to pay for the war might not be to their liking. On a purely military level, the latest air strikes undoubtedly hampered the flow of supplies to the south and as a result saved many American lives by reducing the Viet Cong ability to wage war. For these reasons, the long delayed air strikes are really tactical action for a quicker honorable peace in the embattled nation. ORDER FOR ADJOURNMENT TO MONDAY Mr. SMATHERS. Mr. President, I ask unanimous consent that when the Sen- ate completes its business today, it stand in adjournment until 12 o'clock noon on Monday, August 1, 1966. The ACTING PRESIDENT pro tem- pore. Without objection, it is so or- dered. REDWOOD PARK A NATIONAL MUST Mr. KUCHEL. Mr. President, I have introduced S. 2962, to establish a Red- Approved For. Release 2005/06/29 : CIA-RDP67B00446R000400090001-8 July 29, 1966 _pprpved For RR lIease 2006/06/29 : CIA-RDP67B00446R000400090001-8 ease RECORD-SENATE 16903 rowers, Even subsidiaries of American superseded by a-once more-growing mestic expansion, has now become a corporations have been flriven to finance deficit; dollars spent to buy imports and crazy international competition at ever their operations and investments in the to pay the dollar price of escalation in higher levels. Just as currency devalua- narrow, divided financial markets of con- Vietnam have risen faster than the emer- tion by one nation breeds competitive de- tinental Europe. Every dollar that is not gency program can cutdown on produc- valuations by others, so interest rate invested abroad today means a dollar tive dollar investments. A $1.3 billion escalation in one financial center leads to that will not return as income on that deficit in 1965 has become a 1966 pay- competitive escalation in others. Dur- investment tomorrow. Further, begin- ments deficit which is headed toward ing the last 3 months alone, as U.S. rates ning in June 1965, there has been a $2.5 billion; no firm figure is possible as have moved to historically high levels, breakout in international borrowing In only the Defense Department planners four major foreign central banks-- Europe, with the lions' share being taken can even estimate the further dollar- cost Germany, Belgium, Holland, and Brit- by the subsidiaries of American com- of Vietnam escalation. ain-have increased new their discount rates parries. Such international financings Third. The international negotiations to meet et this neww competition. have more than doubled in the last 12 on monetary reform have demonstrated The United States is not alone respon- months, This rise-desirable in Itself as clearly that there is no consensus either sible for this destructive competition. it contributes to a growing ability of in- for the need or for the method of reform; But the international aspect and impact dustrial Europe to finance its own ex- they have demonstrated equally clearly of higher U.S. interest rates is incom- pansion-has taken place haphazardly that we cannot depend upon these nego- parably greater than that of any other and recklessly. From February to May tiations to bail our bankrupt policy out nation's monetary policy. There is yet of this year, in fact, the European capital before It bankrupts the world. another irony here in American economic market broke down; no issues could be For, :let us make no mistake about it, policy. Without floated whatsoever. This forced-draft question the United expansion, too, has involved a driving l world. The unmistakable signs have tor in determining the course of the free of interest rates to levels rarely seen be- been seen in Britain. After months of world's economy and finances. But in- fore. Moreover, much of the cash which creeping, Government-sponsored defla- ternational considerations are-in nor- has gone into the new European capital tion, after two full-scale, international mal times, at least-far from the most market has simply been taken out of New rescue operations inspired, organized, important factors in determining U.S. York for that purpose-thus, once again, and led by the United States-the only economic policy. There is an old saw offsetting the supposedly positive impact alternative to devaluation of the pound that when America sneezes, the rest of of the emergency program. The fact is has been seen to be savage economic re- the world catches pneumonia. It is that U.S. balance-of-payments policy, by strictions and the deliberate promotion neither excuse nor consolation to say placing a near-embargo on New York, of unemployment in Britain. In simple that we did not even know we were has placed a in-supportable burden upon terms, the British Government has de- sneezing. the free world's financial system. Here, termined that its only hope for avoiding It is also no excuse or consolation to the balance-of-payments policy of the devaluation is to create unemployment. note that European central bankers United States is clearly self-defeating. i point out parenthetically that this is seem happy with the financial situation, Finally, American balance-of-pay- the same policy that was followed In 1931. Their irresponsibility is no excuse for ments policy has struck at the under- This continuing, cruel British experi- ours. When Germany, for example, de- lying stability of the entire international ence points up the bitter irony of Amer- Oates at a time of sound U.S. expansion monetary system. The compromise sys- ican policy. On the one hand, the and contribution to prosperity, Ger- tem formulated at Bretton Woods more United States has-as I have said--in- many's restrictiveness is isolated before than 20 years ago was based upon inter- spired, organized, and led emergency it hurts the prosperity of others. But national cooperation. At its center was rescue operations to save the pound by today, German restrictiveness--which a twofold determination: the United pumping dollars into British reserves. has, incidentally, sent short-term Ger- States determined to supply the rest of But, on the other hand, U.S. restraint man interest rates up to 10 percent-is the world with dollars for trade, Invest- on dollar outflows has created a condi- being aided, abetted, and international- ment, and reserve purposes; and the rest tion of international tight money which Ized by American policy. of the world determined to hold and use has forced ever greater restrictiveness There is no excuse again for American those, dollars for these productive ends. on Britain. It is clear, after all, that policy, in the fact that the run on the Unilateral action by France and a range the fundamental problems in the British London money market has "at least" of other nations to cash in their dollars economy-an outmoded industrial plant, brought new funds to New York to off- for gold has for some time threatened archaic union, and management prat- set the dollar outflow. For these funds the second determination. And the U.S. tices-require massive new investment to are the notorious "hot money" which reaction to the excessive dollar outflow solve. Jumps from of the 1958-63 period-a reaction em- Deflation, effective as It may or may center at the drop-Dr ciao center of financial inter- bodied in the emergency program- not be in the short run to "save the est rate. In fact, it is this "hot money" now threatens the first determination. pound," only at best puts off the day of which has again and again provoked the The indispensable basis for the mere op- reckoning with the critical need for mod- sterling crisis of the past 35 years. There eration of the present monetary system is ernization of plant, equipment, and at- is no consolation for American policy in disappearing more quickly than negotia- titudes. It has been American balance- making the United States, as well, today, tions can proceed to reform that system. of-payments policy which bears a share a prisoner,of hot money. The fact Is that a growing number of of the responsibility for this forced re- There is neither excuse nor consolation nations no longer desire to hold dollars- straint. It is American economic policy for American monetary policy In any despite the clear need of their bankers in another field which has put a halt, aspect of the growing international fl- and businessmen for dollars with which for the time being at least, to Britain's nancial and monetary anarchy. Inter- to do business-and the United States modernization hopes. U.S. monetary nationally, as well as domestically, Amer- is just as desirous to prevent their get- policy, which has produced unprece- ican monetary policy has proved disrup- ting more dollars. dentedly high interest rates at home, tive where it has not actually been The emergency program, and its sub- here in the United States, has contrib- destructive, as the homebuilders demon- sequent extension to cover direct foreign uted to the international interest rate strated in their march on Washing- Investments by American corporations, war and has helped provoke the current ton yesterday. Domestically, American was explicitly intended as a temporary crisis in Britain. expedient to eliminate the dollar drain monetary policy has baen destructive to and, thus, to gain bargaining Interest; rates have been rising higher the housing industry and disruptive to power for and higher in every financial center in the savings industry. International the effort to reform the monetary system. the world. In good part, this reflects the American monetary policy has been de- What has been its real effect? deliberate tightening of credit by foreign structive to Great Britain and disruptive First. A temporary expedient has be- central banks. But the movement to the whole complex system of interna- come ever more institutionalized. toward tighter money in the majority of tional financial relations. This is con- Second. The immediate achievement of Industrial countries, which began as sep- sistency of a kind-and it is a kind that surplus in the summer of 1965 has been crate, individual efforts to restrain do- spells disaster. No. 123-15 Approved For Release 2005/06/29 CIA-RDP67B00446R000400090001-8 16900 Approved For F19?0??fft. ?kN(l~;W7B~,FQ0400090001-8July 29, 1966 5. Depletion allowance of 25 per cent on summit meeting between the two Presi- income receiyed by nonoperators from gross dents, if feasible. royalties or rentals based on production. President de Gaulle's stop in Guade- 6. Shareholders can deduct 20 per cent of their dividend income from companies that loupe seems to me to offer an ideal op- get at least 75 per cent of their earnings portunity for these two statesmen to from mineral production. meet, if not at Guadeloupe then perhaps 7. Full deduction from producers' federal in Puerto Rico. Surely, our differences income tax of any provincial taxes against should not stand in the way of such a production, meeting. On the contrary, a discussion 8. Special 40 per cent, or $4 per ounce- of these differences should contribute to whichever is greater-depletion allowance for gold mines. improving understanding between the 9. Ten-cents-per-ton subsidy for coal-pro- two countries. duction. I hope that the President will give T?r r_T?TTT. TTTTTr1 TTr DnuniAe?~ ??a serious consideration tdi myet;ing with now let me aaa that the passage by the Senate today of H.R. 4665 introduced by our able House colleague, Representative AL ULLMAN, of Oregon, a companion bill to S. 338 which I introduced is an im- portant and gratifying first step in the direction of encouraging mining as Can- ada has done. My bill was favored by a number of dishinguished cosponsors who were my colleagues Senators BOB BARTLETT of Alaska, ALLOTT of Colorado, BENNETT Of Utah, BIBLE of Nevada, CANNON of Ne- vada, CHURCH Of Idaho, DOMINICK of Colorado, HART of Michigan, JACKSON of Washington, JORDAN of Idaho, LONG of Missouri, McGOVERN of South Dakota, METCALF Of Montana, MONTOYA of New Mexico, Moss of Utah, MUNDT Of South Dakota, RANDOLPH of West Virginia and SIMPSON of Wyoming. The strong sup- port of these able colleagues has been invalua le in achieving the result today of enactment of this important legisla- tion to aid the American mining indus- try. The amendment of Senator SMATHERS which increased the flexibility of the measure is a very useful contribution and a provision I am happy to have seen adopted. . In the work which has been done to obtain passage of H.R. 4665 our able and distinguished colleague from Montana, Senator METCALF, has been invaluable. His energetic and constructive assistance represents a major contribution to the welfare of the mining industry and one for which I am very gateful. SUMMIT MEETING WITH DE GAULLE Mr. CHURCH. Mr. President, this week's issue of Newsweek suggests that some diplomats, in both Washington and Paris, see a good chance for a meeting in September between President de Gaulle and President Johnson. Presi- dent De Gaulle has planned a trip around the world, stopping in southeast Asia to visit Cambodia, and according to Newsweek, has scheduled a 48-hour stop on the French, Caribbean island of Gua eloupe on his way back from the Pacific. As Senators know, I visited Europe in early May. In a report to the Committee on Foreign Relations, entitled "Europe Today," I made a number of recommen- dations. One of them was that effective communications must be restored be- tween the French and American Govern- ments.. I suggested, in this connection, a THE DANGER OF EMPIRE MT ASIA Mr. CHURCH. Mr. President, the course of the war in Vietnam has begun to generate an uneasiness that we may be slipping unawares into the role of a colonial power in Asia. A recent edi- torial in the July 12 edition of the Lewis- ton, Idaho, Morning Tribune raises a clear alarm over this possibility. Quot- ing two widely respected foreign corre- spondents, the editorial concludes with the following warning: Two American presidents have said this must never be permitted to become an Amer- ican war. It not only has become an Ameri- can war, but South Vietnam has become an American enclave and Southeast Asia has become a bog from which we will have a most difficult time escaping. The possibility of empire by accident is by no means remote. Mr. President, I ask unanimous con- sent to have printed in the RECORD the editorial from which I have quoted, en- titled "The Danger of Empire in Asia," published in the Lewiston, Idaho, Morn- ing Tribune of July 12, 1966. There being no objection, the editorial was ordered to be printed in the RECORD, as follows: THE DANGER OF EMPIRE IN ASIA Is the United States in danger of stumbling into empire in Asia? C. L. Sulzberger, the foreign affairs columnist of The New York Times, thinks so, and a reporter's conversa- tion with some military officers bears him out. Sulzberger pointed out in a recent column that the United States has plowed millions of dollars into Southeast Asia in the form of harbor developments, roads and military bases. He believes the temptation may be great, once the shooting war ends, to seek to protect these enormous investments by main- taining a strong American presence there. This would create the danger "that the United States might unoonsciousv create an empire in Southeast Asia. At whatever cost we must avoid any absent-minded imperial- ism that would not only contradict Amer- ica's national philosophy but could lead to nothing but trouble." One can scarcely argue with Sulzberger's point of view. Yet there are ominous signs that some military men on the scene are not daunted by the prospects of empire. Richard A. Dudman, a roving correspondent of The St. Louis Post-Dispatch, is writing a aeries of reports from Saigon. American officers in South Viet Nam, he writes, are now speaking in terms of 400,000 U.S. troops in Southeast Asia by the end of this year and possibly 600,000 by the end of 1967. "Some speak seriously of needing a total American buildup of 1-million men." Dudman adds: "Carried to its logical conclusion, the Americanization of the war could conceivably lead to a complete American takeover of South Viet Nam. A widely respected Amer- Scan commander advocates this course privately in so many words. "'We should occupy and rule this coun- try,' he says, 'instead of pretending to respect the sovereignty of a government that really is only temporary and illegal and could change tomorrow. It would be more efficient, and probably the end result would be better if we abandoned the idea of assistance and pacification and settled for subjugation, re- garding South Viet Nam as an enemy country ...' " Two American presidents have said this must never be permitted to become an Amer- ican war. It not only has become an Amer- loan war, but South Viet Nam has become an American enclave and Southeast Asia has become a bog from which we will have a most difficult time escaping. The possibility of empire by accident is by no means remote.- L. H. EDITORIALS COMMEND 'SENATORS BYRD OF WEST VIRGINIA, ERVIN, AND DIRKSEN , Mr. SIMPSON. Mr. President, I ask unanimous consent to have printed in the RECORD two editorials entitled "BYRD Sparks U.S. Promise of Aid To End Race Riots" and "Would Lift Confession Bar," published in the Huntington, W. Va., Advertiser of July 26, 1966, and an edi- torial entitled "Congratulations to Sen- ator DIRKSEN," published in the Chicago Tribune of July 18, 1966. In connection with the latter editorial, the concluding sentence, I believe, is very pertinent: For his successful leadership Senator DIRKSEN deserves the thanks and congratu- lations of the American people. I certainly subscribe to that sentiment. There being no objection, the edi- torials were ordered to be printed in the RECORD, as follows: [From the Huntington (W. Va.) Advertiser, July 26, 1966] BYRD SPARKS U.S. PROMISE OF-AID To END RACE RIOTS Law-abiding Negroes and responsible civil rights workers as well as other conscientious citizens will welcome the federal govern- ment's promise of assistance to cities har- assed by race riots. The announcement of federal aid was made by Attorney General Nicholas Katzenbach in response to a letter by Sen. ROBERT C. BYRD (D-W.Va.) to President Johnson urging him to use the power and prestige of his office to stop the outbreaks of "lawless and provocative demonstrations." Sen. BYRD'S letter declared "There is no rational justification for tolerating these in- credible attacks on firemen, policemen and innocent victims." In calling the President's attention to the responsibility of the federal government to discourage outbreaks of lawlessness, Sen. BYRD was serving the cause of law-abiding Negroes as well as the public generally. His statement that continued violence would set back the cause of civil rights was substantiated in part by the announcement from New York that extremism was sharply cutting contributions to the more militant organizations. There are also Indications in Congress that riots are causing reluctance to enact the ad- ministration's civil rights measure now pend- ing. Much of the money for civil rights efforts has come from northern liberals. In spite of this some of the militant individuals and Approved For Release 2005/06/29: CIA-RDP67B00446R000400090001-8 July 29, 1966 Approved F ft1 %i5AJ6/i~C DPNgR9i46R000400090001-8 16899 Minerals: Canada's diversified mineral in- dustry is pacing the world in growth rate. Output has tripled in value since 1950 and is expected to approach the 4-billion-dollar mark this year as Canada- Leads the world in nickel, zinc and asbes- tos production. Ranks second after the U.S. in total out- put of uranium and of molybdenum, a vital additive in steel manufacturing. Beeps Its place as the world's third biggest producer of aluminum. Stands fourth in output of lead, fifth in copper and iron ore, and sixth in production of potash. Canada ranks ninth in output of oil and gas. The future, to Canadian geologists and mining men, is even more exciting than the feverish present. The potential of Canada's mineral wealth Is awesome. The rush to measure it and bring It out of the ground is turning the country into the world's biggest mining camp. Ores: Two big iron-ore bodies, far to the north, are getting attention. One is on Baffin Island, almost 300 miles beyond the Arctic Circle. There, Baffinland Iron Mines has mapped more than 127 mil- lion tons of high-grade ore that can be shipped directly to mills without upgrading. In the Yukon, Crest Exploration, Ltd., a subsidiary of Standard Oil of California, has located an estimated 11 billion tons of medium-grade ore. The deposits are near the Snake River, close to the boundary be- tween the Yukon and the Northwest Ter- ritories. A rail line nearly 600 miles long would be needed to haul the ore to tide- water at Skagway, Alaska, but an existing narrow gauge road, the White Pass & Yukon, might serve as the final leg, from White- horse, Yukon Territory, to Skagway. The search for nickel, too, is moving north- ward. A belt of mineralized rock cutting across the Ungava Peninsula In northern Quebec is believed to hold rich nickel de- posits. Canada now produces 80 per cent of the world's nickel, mostly from mines in Ontario and Manitoba. Metals locked together: Canada's booming base-metals industry feeds chiefly from ore bodies that produce more than one metal. The big nickel deposits in Ontario and Manitoba also are major producers of copper concentrates. Zinc, lead and copper-often with silver included-are found linked in various combinations in the mineralized rock that is found throughout Canada. Spurred by a worldwide shortage and high prices, the search for copper deposits now is centering in the mountains of British Columbia and the Yukon. Several copper mines in Western Canada already In production are being expanded, and a number of new bodies of ore are being developed to meet Japanese requirements. Production from a deposit found on an island in remote Babine Lake in northern British Columbia is to start this year at a 5,000-ton-a-day rate. Potash success story: Within the last four years, Canada has emerged as a major pro- ducer of potash-an ingredient in much of the world's fertilizer. Thick beds of potash were found far un- derground in Saskatchewan by oil drillers. During 1965, three companies were In pro- duction, two others were sinking shafts or wells, and three more had announced major potash projects. Production in 1965 totaled 1.3 million tons of refined potash, either by mining or by a process using wells to pump dissolved potash to the surface. By 1970, is estimated, 750 million dollars will have been invested in developing. Sas- katchewan's potash beds, and Canada will be producing 7 million tons of potash, enough to make it the world's largest supplier. Re- coverable potash in vast Saskatchewan beds has been estimated at 60 billion short tons, about half the world's known supply. Asbestos is another giant Canadian indus- try. Asbestos Corporation, Ltd., a major pro- ducer with large mines in Quebec, is spend- ing 50 million to develop a large deposit at Asbestos Hill, 1,100 miles north of Montreal. The mine is expected to be turning out 100,000 tons of asbestos fiber a year in 1970. It will be shipped to plants in Canada, Britain and the U.S. from Deception Bay, on Hudson Strait, during the phort ice-free sea- son there. Uranium marks time: Canada has the big- gest known reserves of uranium--an esti- mated 200,000 tons producible at $5 to $10 a pound. Even under current conditions of relative depression in the uranium market, Canadian production is second only to that in the U.S. Most mines in the major producing areas-- Beaverlodge, Sask.; Elliot Lake and Bancroft, Ont.-are shut down or operating only part time. Rising world demand, however, is expected to revive the uranium-mining industry In the 1970s, Stockpiling by the Canadian Government is helping to keep the mines functioning. Forests: Canada leads the world in news- print production, ranks second In the pro- duction of wood pulp for other paper prod- ucts and fourth in output of lumber and plywood. Exports of Canadian forest products total nearly 2 billion dollars. New mills are being built all across Canada to meet the growing demand for newsprint and other paper goods. Currently, Canadian timber workers cut an estimated 8 billion feet of wood annually. Experts say the forests of the country could sustain an annual yield of 12 billion cubic feet under intensive management. Oil and gas: Vast quantities of oil and natural gas in Canada's sedimentary rock provide one of the best guarantees of future prosperity. "As far down the road as we can see.," says a geologist-executive of the oil industry, "Canada will have oil for world markets." Present known reserves are set at 7.7 bil- lion barrels of oil, enough for 23 years of pro- duction at the present rate, and 44.4 trillion cubic feet of gas, a 35-year supply. These are the proven reserves of fields that have been in production. for some time. There are new discoveries in northern Al- berta and northeastern British Columbia that soon will send the official estimates of reserves soaring. It is believed that more than a million cubic miles of sedimentary rock, of the type that bears oil and gas, lies under Canada's northern regions. On the basis of the North American average of production per cubic mile, the oil potential of the Yukon Territory is set at 3 billion barrels of the Northwest Territories at 13 billion barrels and of the .Canadian Arctic islands at 33 billion barrels. Oil from sand: Oil-impregnated sands :fie close to the surface under several hundred square miles of wilderness along the Atha- baska River in northern Alberta. This "tar sand" can be mined by strip-mining processes. Production is to begin next year on a limited basis, Great Canadian Oil Sands Ltd., a subsidiary of Sun Oil Company, is rushing a 230-million-dollar plant and pipe- line system into completion. Early next year, the firm will start pump- ing 9:5,000 barrels of oil a day through Its 266-mile pipeline. Water: Canada now produces 22 million kilowatts of hydroelectric power. All of it, plus 7 million kilowatts produced by ther- mal-electric plants, is used by Canada's own booming industrial machine. Giant new projects are under way in Que- bee, British Columbia and Manitoba. All told, U.S. power authorities believe, 7 million kilowatts of new hydroelectric power will be available for export to the U.S. within the next decade. Electric power in Canada is now a billion- dollar business. But much of the value of the country's hydroelectric resources shows up in the form of exports. Canada's position as the third-biggest producer of aluminum, for instance, is due to its plentiful supply of hydroelectric power. Canadians are beginning to view their al- most limitless flows of fresh water as a val- uable source of export dollars. Arthur Laing, Minister of Northern Affairs, sees water "as one of the prime resources of the Yukon-one which I predict in the fu- ture will be of equal, if not greater, impor- tance than the mining industry Two plans are being pushed in the U.S. to make use of the waters of the Yukon River- the Rampart Dam proposal in north-central Alaska and the North American Water Alli- ance proposal. The latter is a plan advanced by private engineering interest with support from some western members of Congress. It would di- vert Alaskan and Yukon water southward through a network of waterways reaching into Mexico and across the plains to the Great Lakes. The U.S. stake: In the race now going on to develop the resources of Canada, the big- gest spenders are American firms or their Canadian subsidiaries. Foreign corporations, mostly from the U.S., already own or control more than half of Canada's industry. American-owned firms dominate the oil and gas fields and their pipelines. Nearly 60..per cent of Canada's mineral production belongs to outsiders. One Canadian leader who welcomes even more American investment is Premier W. Ross Thatcher of Saskatchewan, who has this to say: "In the last several years, American capital has been responsible for a dramatic trans- formation of Saskatcehwan from an impov- erished 'have not' province to its present position as one of the most .... 11 . U.S. companies are spending heavily in the search for oil and gas, in developing Saskatchewan's rich potash beds, and in cre- ating a pulp and paper industry in the Province. "Had our doors been even partially closed to America's capital," Mr. Thatcher says, "we would still be one of Canada's backward Provinces. The Government of Saskatche- wan, in the months ahead, intends to take every practical or feasible step to attract additional American investment." National policy toward foreign investment in Canadian resources, and ownership of those resources, may change in the future. But meanwhile in Canada, with the help of U.S. dollars, the biggest deveolpment boom of modern times is under way. [From U.S. News & World Report, July 25, 1966] A HELPING HAND-TAX INCENTIVES Here are the ways Canada encourages min- eral development: 1. A full write-off of exploration, drilling and excavation costs in connection with the search for minerals. 2. Any company with income from min- eral production can write off its off-property exploration costs against its mineral income. New syndicates for mineral exploration can write off cost against future mineral income, with unlimited carry-forward privileges. 3. Income from production of new mines is exempt from income tax for three years. 4. Depletion allowance of 331/3 per cent for most types of oil, gas, prime-metal and in- dustrial-minerals operations on net income. Approved For Release 2005/06/29 : CIA-RDP67B00446R000400090001-8 A4000 Rep. FALLON is chairman; James E., 20, a student at Cornell in the field of Metallurgi- cal engineering and Joseph Robert, 18, a re- Approved J-I?6"g91@"M6 MADRD f~Ib~R0004000900" 29, 1966 cation and are motivated by the highest principles in our religious heritage, what can we expect of our future leaders? Freedom of religious expression is a basic human right. Many of the original Colonies were founded upon religious liberty. Jeffer- son's "wall" between church and state should remain intact, but the religious principles upon which this country was founded must not be discarded nor replaced by godless doctrines in our public schools. J. E. Kennedy Retires From Customs Post EXTENSION OF REMARKS HON. CLARENCE D. LONG OF MARYLAND IN THE HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES Friday, July 29, 1966 Mr.-LONG of Maryland. Mr. Speaker, after more than 42 years of outstanding customs work in Baltimore, Mr. J. Eu- gene Kennedy retired from his post as District Director of Customs. Baltimore is one of the busiest and most important port cities in the United States, and effi- cient and reliable customs workers like Mr. Kennedy have contributed to,Balti- more's current status as a port city. The Havre de Grace Record of July 14, 1966, summarized Mr. Kennedy's accomplish- ments in his long career, and I should like to bring this article to the attention of my colleagues: J. E. KENNEDY RETIRES FROM CUSTOMS POST Mr. J. Eugene Kennedy, district' director of customs, retired on his birthday last Thursday after more than 42, years of cus- toms work in Baltimore. A native of Havre de Grace he has been dubbed "Mr. Customs" cent graduate of Boys Latin Sch Mr. Kennedy is an accomplis and studied for a number of ye body Conservatory of Music. Lon dents remember with pleasure certs he gave in Havre dy Chrac ago. Treatment of AmeWans Captured by the North Vietnamese EXTENSION OF REMARKS HON. STROM THURMOND OF SOUTH CAROLINA IN THE SENATE OF THE UNITED STATES Friday, July 29, 1966 Mr. THURMOND. Mr. President, on Wednesday, July 27, 1966, the Augusta Chronicle, Augusta, Ga., published an editorial entitled "The Mark of the Beast." The editorial concerns itself with the treatment of American fliers captured by the North Vietnamese and reports of executions by beheading. It also takes note of the barbaric actions of the Communists who have been shoot- ing our wounded on the field of battle. This entire area is a most serious prob- lem and demands immediate and affirm- ative attention. I ask unanimous con- sent that the editorial be printed in the Appendix of the RECORD. There being no objection, the editorial was ordered to be printed in the RECORD, as follows: THE MARK OF THE BEAST mane" Communists summarily beheaded the American they had caught. These men, wounded on the battlefield or fleeing a prison camp, were beyond com- bat status. They were defenseless, and by all the rules of civilized conduct were pris- oners. By the vicious and barbarous way in which they were done to death, they join many thousands of others in South Viet Nam who have suffered hideous deaths at the hands of Communists. They share the fate of village chiefs and their families tor- tured to death to intimidate the villages. They share the fate of civilians in Saigon who have been callously bombed into oblivion by the Viet Gong who-we are told in some quarters-simply are seeking their rights. Regardless of who is spared from a trumped-up "war crimes" trial in the prison camps of North Viet Nam, these men were given not even the benefit of mock trials. They were simply slaughtered by Commu- nists acting like Communists. Such incidents mark the character of the forces under Ho who will be enabled to perpe- trate more of the same kind of atrocities if we can just be persuaded to cease oil depot bombing, and let more of the killers move south. They mark the foreseeable action of future waves of invaders if we will just "de- escala?te," or withdraw our forces and let Ho's horror sweep over the South Vietnamese countryside. Such incidents place the mark of the beast also on the Soviet Union, which is supposedly a peace-loving member of the United Na- tions, and on Red China, for which many persons in a soft-on-communism bloc are trying to win UN membership. Russia's active participation' in aggresion by sending weapons and munitions to Hanoi, and Pe- king's vociferous moral support and threats of intervention brand them as being un- worthy of associating in the society of civil- ized nations. A group of American fliers captured by the North Vietnamese after being shot down will not be tried as "war criminals"-yet, at least. That's the word relayed to our government through diplomatic channels. President Ho Chi Minh is quoted by a Czech news agency as stating, in Hanoi, that North Viet Nam in this decision has behaved Colorado River Project-Address by Hon. Barry Goldwater EXTENSION OF REMARKS and "the fount of all knowledge" regarding collection problems along the entire East Coast. In an interview with the Record on Monday, Mr. Kennedy was enthusiastic about the full life he anticipates in the future as he maintains an interest in a warehouse business he helped to found, plays the piano for his "own amazement" and flies the me- mentos of the past fruitful years. Mr. Kennedy was honored at a gathering of some 300 persons last Thursday night in- cluding many co-workers, the city's Congres- sional delegation-Representatives FALLON, "GARMATZ, and FRIEDEL, and Thomas J. D'Ale- sandro, 3rd, president of the Baltimore City Council and acting mayor. In paying tribute to Mr. Kennedy, the speakers praised him for helping to build Baltimore to its present status as a port city. One recalled when he entered the customs service in 1924 as a clerk-stenographer-"a freckle faced boy with bushy red hair". Pres- ent indications are that the hair has given way to forehead. The Bureau of Customs' highest award was presented Mr. Kennedy, the Honor Award, making him the tenth man ever to receive it. He has also received the Treasury De- partment's Gallatin. Award for distinguished service. Mr. D'Alesondro presented him the The Kennedy family, not to be confused of any wounded Americans who moved, kill- in a slightly different role from the one in with the Cape Cod Kennedys, the retiree ing at least six and then looting the bodies which I have appeared here on so many occa- -hastened to point out, consists of his wife, of any valuables, sions in the past. For once, I am not going Aberdeen and At the same time, an American Navy air- to exhort you about politics or my views on four former children: Agnes John EE. Jr. of four the IB, 25, a Company; Ann man who had escaped from a North Vietna- the state of international affairs or the prob- Cornell now with the IBM Company; Ann mess prisoner of .war camp was telling of lems we are encountering on the domestic Carey, c a graduate of Notre unior Colpay- the fate of a fellow-escapee who was cap- front. I have no doubt that some of you now mpool and Villa Juie Junior College, tured by pursuing North Vietnamese. As will get at these matters when the question Public c as an Works Investigative Commimmttee of aide whicych the survivors hid and looked on, the "hu- period is held. But, in the meantime, you the now em House employed Approved For Release 2005/06/29 : CIA-RDP67B00446R0004000900Q1-8 in a humane manner. No doubt, around the HUN. JOHN J. RHODES world, advocates of a free hand for the Com- munists in South Viet Nam will parrot this claim, and use it as ammunition for new at- tacks against resistance to. aggression. If a humane element is involved, it is sheer coincidence. Humaneness is not commu- nism's way. Ask refugees from the Baltic states, from Hungary, from Tibet. The de- ciding factor in the decision with regard to the fliers is propaganda value. By this means the friends of communism around the mane" He with the "ruthless" Johnson, who dressed himself to the false impressions is ordering barbarous attacks on a Viet Cong which wants only a peaceful, democratic dia- given by preservationist groups as to the logue with the obstinate South Vietnamese effect Marble and Hualapai Dams would who erroneously think freedom is good for have on the Grand Canyon. Since the them. Senators knows the canyon like he knows Even as the message on rejection of a his own Arizona patio, his remarks are "trial" was being evaluated in Washington, particularly well-informed and persua- North Vietnamese regular army units ille- gally rive, and I include them herewith: in South Viet Nam were overrunning an American unit. The Americans had been EXCERPTS OF REMARKS BY HON. BARRY GOLD- forced by heavy attack to withdraw with- WATER TO THE NATIONAL PRESS CLUB, WASH- ',out even an opportunity to evacuate their INGTON, D.C., WEDNESDAY, JULY 27, 1966 __ _ - .. f +he P ess T trust o OF ARIZONA IN THE HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES Monday, July 18, 1966 Mr. RHODES of Arizona. Mr. Speaker, on Wednesday, July 27, former Senator Barry Goldwater addressed the National Press Club on one of his favor- Approved For Release 2005/06/29 CIA-RDP67B00446R000400090001-8 Appendix Grand Canyon Threat EXTENSION OF REMARKS or HON. JEFFERY COHELAN OF CALIFORNIA IN THE HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES Friday, July 29, 1966, Mr. COHELAN. Mr. Speaker, a timely defense of the Grand Canyon was pre- sented by our distinguished colleague, the Honorable HENRY S. REUSS, in his letter to the Washington Post of July 25, 1966. As Congressman REUSS points out: If Congress acts wisely, Arizona can have Water and America can continue to have the Grand C