ANOTHER DIENBIENPHU

Document Type: 
Collection: 
Document Number (FOIA) /ESDN (CREST): 
CIA-RDP67B00446R000300170027-2
Release Decision: 
RIFPUB
Original Classification: 
K
Document Page Count: 
6
Document Creation Date: 
December 15, 2016
Document Release Date: 
October 7, 2003
Sequence Number: 
27
Case Number: 
Publication Date: 
January 1, 1965
Content Type: 
OPEN
File: 
AttachmentSize
PDF icon CIA-RDP67B00446R000300170027-2.pdf1.01 MB
Body: 
1965 Approved For Release 2003/10/15 : CIA-RDP67B00446R000300170027-2 CONGRESSIONAL RECORD,- APPENDIX A65 1964, release of the GTA Daily Radio Roundup, St. Paul, Minn. This focuses attention on the practice of the.Com- modity Credit Corporation of dumping Government grain, which has resulted in disastrous economic hardship to the American farmer. This release deals with wheat, but the practice that is under attack in this ar- ticle has also been employed in the feed grain commodities. This has driven the price of feed grains down and has done much to stimulate the glut in livestock production. As a result, many farmers have been driven to the wall in compet- ing with the biggest farm market monop- oly in the .world, the Government of the Vnited States. This article which I insert hits the nail right on the head, and I compliment GTA for its willingness to bring, to the attention of the American farmer these policies which are detrimental to his best interests. The article follows : GTA has a primary responsibility only to the farm people who own it. That comes first. This primary responsibility is not to the Government, not to the buyers of grain, not to the consumers, the politicians or any- body else-just to the farmers. And we feel now that an explanation is owed to the grain farmers for the miserably low wheat prices that were bid to them generally during har- vest this year. These wheat prices could have been about 20 cents per bushel higher, and there is a very simple explanation why they were not. Beginning in July the U.S. Government, through its Commodity Credit Corporation, began the most massive dumping operation in history. The CCC was originally formed to help farmers, not to put a ceiling on their prices. But here is what actually happened and unfortunately continues to happen. During the first month of the 1964 harvest the huge Government corporation dumped 50 million bushels of wheat with the ex- pressed and vocal intention of preventing farmers from getting higher prices for their CCC sold this wheat to buyers who other- wise would have been ready customers for your wheat from your cooperatives and other handlers. But, you didn't sell this, wheat; the Government did, Incredibly, during the harvest period of approximately 90 days more than 150 million. bushels of Government wheat was dumped on the market. Buyers got some of the most unbelievable bargains in history because the CCC wheat flooded the market and put a low ceiling on farm wheat prices. This is immensely disturbing, GTA has looked into the history of Government oper- ations all over the world, and we have found "no precedent for this behavior. No other country does it. GTA General Manager M. W. Thatcher had this to say about it: "CCC price support activities when con- ducted, to help farm producers have no stronger advocate than GTA, But," Mr. Thatcher said, "we oppose CCC's misuse of the farm program." GTA's grain experts estimate that with- out this CCC dumping during this harvest wheat would have gone on the market about 20 cents a bushel higher than it actually sold for. Twenty cents a bushel on a crop of 1,200 million bushels is $240' million. That is what was taken out of the wheat producers' pocket by the dumping action by CCC. We are sorry to have to expose this beha- vior. We do not believe that the President of the United States, or the Vice President, or the Congress had any intention that the farm law would be administered in this manner. We believe that these decisions were made by a small handful of persons, perhaps very inexperienced, in charge of CCC who were determined to use its power to punish those farmers whom they refer to as noncompliers. We also believe that the purpose of the present wheat legislation is very clear, and it is that those who comply with the program receive certificates worth on the average about 50 cents a bushel. That is their pay- ment for complying. Punitive action by the Government to hurt them, as well as the noncompliers, was never intended by Con- gress. The punishing ceiling that CCC oper- ations impose on wheat prices in the mar- kets, a deliberate thing that punishes all growers without reason, is plainly obnoxious. Moreover, the dumping operation that we described did not actually rid the Govern- ment of one single bushel of surplus. And why not? Because by dumping 150 million bushels CCC drove market prices so low that farmers were sealed within a narrow-price range and had no choice but to put their new grain under loan. The Government just took the grain right back into its ware- houses. It took different kernels, true, but ultimately as much or more grain than was dumped came back into CCC's bins. It need not have been thus if enough price leeway had been allowed so producers could sell in- stead of going in to the loan program. That wheat might have been sold through your farmer cooperatives and regular market channels instead of to the Government which ultimately will probably dump it again and keep the vicious circle going. If this is the policy of the Federal Gov- ernment, then there never will be any "mus- cle in the marketplace" for farmers. Instead, in time there will not be any cooperative marketing system, at all. It is that serious and that dangeros to producers. That is why we at GTA believe that we would be derelict in our duty to farmers if we did not call this maladministration to the attention of the voters. And that, we should ' add, is in concur- rence with resolutions adopted by GTA dele- gates at their recent annual meeting and expressed in resolutions by other regional cooperatives, just like GTA, of which there are more than two dozen in the Nation. If the Government continues this process of nationalization, it should openly advo- cate it. Then the voters would have a chance to make a decision. J. Edgar Hoover Commended by City of Lakewood Resolution EXTENSION OF REMARKS OF HON. CRAIG HOSMER OF CALIFORNIA IN THE HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES Thursday, January 7, 1965 Mr. HOSMER. Mr. Speaker, the city of Lakewood which, incidentally, recently was awarded first honors in the 1965 Pasadena Rose Tournament, by action of its city council on December 22, last, has commended the fine work of FBI Director J. Edgar Hoover. The coun- cil's Resolution 1575 reads as follows: RESOLUTION 1575 Resolution of the City Council of the City of Lakewood commending J. Edgard Hoover and the Federal Bureau of Investigation Whereas, J. Edgar Hoover and the Federal Bureau of Investigation have recently been under attack for alleged dereliction of duty; and Whereas, the Federal Bureau of Investiga- tion, under the direction of J. Edgar Hoover, has an exemplary record in efficient and just police work; and Whereas, by reason of the successful opera- tion of the Federal Bureau of Investigation, law enforcement in each city, county and State is benefited and strengthened; and Whereas, said J. Edgar Hoover and the men in his Bureau should be commended for their contribution to maintenance of law and order in the United States, rather than being con- demned: Now, therefore, the City Council of the City of Lakewood does hereby commend J. Edgar Hoover and the men of the Federal Bureau of Investigation for their successful and unshirking performance of duty in the maintenance of law and order in the United States. The city clerk is directed to forward certi- fied copies of this resolution to the President of the United States, to our Congressman and Senators as well as to said J. Edgar Hoover. Adopted and approved this 22d day of De- cember 1964. ROBERT W. BAKER, Mayor. JO BENNITT, y City Clerk. Autumn in Full Glory EXTENSION OF REMARKS OF HON. LINDLEY BECKWORTH OF TEXAS IN THE HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES Thursday, January 7, 1965 Mr. BECKWORTH. Mr. Speaker, I desire to include in the CONGRESSIONAL RECORD the enclosed article entitled "Autumn in Full Glory" by Woodroe Wylie, Carthage, Tex., Route 1. The article follows: AUTUMN IN FULL GLORY. (By Woodroe Wylie) Ever since I was a boy, I have wanted to write a discourse, on autumn. The changes and scenes that take place are most spec- tacular. Everywhere one looks or listens there are distinct admissions or omissions of multivarious events. On November 5, 1929, at Carthage Tex., a flock of wild geese became lost at night in low clouds and blinding lights. The be- wildered geese honked all night long. Some people were*amused at their musical sounds while others were annoyed because the geese kept them awake. The flight of the geese is timed with the falling of the leaves. The most glorious show that nature has to display is the changing colors of the leaves in October and November. Perhaps the most beautiful colors are pink, yellow, burgundy, orange, and red. For those who have a poet's soul, their eyes can feast upon the beauteous glory until their starved souls are content. In the valley of the many colored leaves, a mazy, meandering stream flows toward the rivulet. Its progress comes almost to a standstill when it brushes against some clogged leaves and brush. But then it bursts forth with its freedom, and it seems to make musical laughter in its progress. Here, be- fore in the lustrum of spring when beauty reigned supreme, the songbirds would gather in this hallowed grove to take a bath in the stream, consequently displaying their win- some plumage. The ones that sang the loud- est laid claim to that strip of domain. Approved For Release 2003/10/15 : CIA-RDP67B00446R000300170027-2 Approved For Rele.Sse A66 CON is a variety of tress- lackgum, Nearb y sweetgum, maple, hickory, and others-thillhat t f the th AL RECORD - APPENDIX January 7 are dotted upward to e op EXTENSION OF REMARKS slope. It is perhaps here that God's crea- tion of beauty is at its best, for each specie or of tree and every leaf seems to be vying HON. WILLIAM L. SPRINGER for splendor's prizes. Amid the glory of the beautiful trees is a unique one. It is the pine tree, and it knows no changing season, f 11. is een the year round The e gr o f it g s or winds pierce the giant pine trees' needles, Thursday, January 7, 1965 and most beautiful musical sounds issue forth. A million produce music, but none is too audible nor any out of key. The soft, mournful sounds summarize the events of a lifetime. Over the flood of years, methinks that I can see a little bright, blue-eyed boy, in a shy, concealed way, grab his long-visored cap, gather up some sacks, and set forth for au- tumn's rich fruits. He encounters a strange, frightening bird called the screech owl. This unique bird has a mysterious talented voice; in the black hours of night he haunts people who . have departed from the straight and narrow way. Some guilty, superstitious ones will get up and turn over an old shoe. Now barefooted and on tiptoe, the boy reaches the desired woodlands, scales the persimmon tree, and feasts upon the rich, luscious fruit. Then he fills his sacks with chinquapins, war- nuts, and hickory nuts. He looks about him and sees the squirrels gathering nuts and taking them up large trees to deposit them in hidden holes for winter food. Their thoughts are so much like his own. Then falls the cruel, telling frost. Each leaf seems to cling to its accustomed place tenaciously, but volleys of wind smite it again and again, and like a human gasping for his last earthly breath, at last it gives way to eternity. The fallen leaves scurry over one another like little children play- ing leapfrog. Then at last the leaves come to :rest, and I lament that in all their beau- teous glory they must, like common earth, rot. The gayer hours of life were ours; the worst is mine. With the passing of the leaves go many songbirds, which were heavenly sweet and earthly present. Then the ones left are deleted of their gay songs. Their pleasures seem to have terminated during the flight of their earthly companions of the air and the falling of the leaves. Even the persistent musical voice of the pretty bluejay is no longer heard, "Cing, chang, ching." The multitude of )c kingbirds has departed and taken their multivarious songs. with them. The most abundant birds left are the crows and blackbirds which, at their best, only produce a cacophony of sounds. The wise old owl perches himself on the top spray of the loftiest tree in the forest. He has seen many seasons come and go, and from his vantage point he appears to be taking inventory. Beyond the Woods, out in the open meadows, a wilderenss of wild flowers in their gay sisterhood was mutilated by Jack Frost's wintry breath. Upon sur- veying the scene in the woodlands, the owl still has left with him hawks, doves, quail, But the war in South Vietnam is fought province by province. In province after province, the balance of the fighting is al- ready close. And in too many provinces, a local catastrophe can too easily result from the injection of no more than one or two additional main force enemy battalions. In Quang Nal, for example, the anti-Com- munist forces have already been pushed back so far that the enemy controls just about the entire province, except for the main town and two or three other strong points. In main force battalions, moreover, the balance in Quang is probably already about 7 to 5 in favor of the Communists. Obviously, therefore, there is grave risk in Quang Nai of some such local catastrophe as the capture of the provincial capital and destruction or capture of all the defense forces by a Communist surprise attack. This is not the only province, either, where risks are being run, In-Darlac, to. name another, the odds are now better than even on a sec- ond Communist-inspired rising of the Rhade tribespeople. Logically, of course, a mere local catas- trophe in Quang Nai or some other province ought not to achieve decisive results for the Communists. This kind of logic is very popular, nowadays, with the U.S. staff officers in Saigon. They seem to forget that it was also quite illogical for France to be deci-, sively defeated at Dienbienphu, which was a very small scale fight by normal standards. The Vietnamese people have been at war for too many years, with no end in sight. On their resistance, as, on the French, a mere local catastrophe can all too easily produce decisive effects. The raw materials for an- other Dienbienphu are plainly present. To be sure, there is one vast, potentially saving difference between 1964 and 1953. This is not just Vietnam's war. It is also our war; and the United States has gigantic uncommitted reserves. But unless we soon begin to bring American power to bear in deadly earnest, we must gek ready for the greatest American defeat in the history of the United States. - That is what now looms ahead, as a clear possibility if not a probability. And using Laotian pilots, in training planes converted into bombers, to attack the Ho Chi Minh trail cannot be described as bringing American power to bear in deadly earnest. Chains Open Fire on Family Farms EXTENSION OF REMARKS HON. ANCHER NELSEN or MINNESOTA IN THE HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES Thursday, January 7, 1965 Mr. NELSEN. Mr. Speaker, the ques- tions farmers are increasingly asking, no matter what farm organization they be- long to, are brought out in an article, "Chains Open Fire'on Family Farms," by Gene Cervi of the Rocky Mountain Journal. This alarming article was brought to my attention by Mrs. Kenneth Tellers, of Cologne, Minn., and I hope that my col- leagues will give it their careful consid- eration as the National Commission on Food Marketing gets down to business in Washington this week. The article follows: killdees, and the four-footed animals: wolf, in guerrilla fighting. Hence it is as certain coon, skunk, mink, squirrel, opossum, and as anything can be that the draftees were hare. The owl mops the brow of his sad sent to the southern front with'their bat- ccuntenance and seems to say, "The birds talions. have taken a leave of absence and will re- The appearance of organized units of the turn with the arrival of spring. The flow- North Vietnamese army in the southern ers and the leaves will appear in the regur- fighting is a new and startling fact, which rection next May." might well divert the State Department's When death comes to a bird, it usually wrath from Gen. Nguyen Khanh to Gen. Vo is preceded by a brief illness. Birds do not Nguyen Glap. To be sure, this movement feel any responsibility for whatever happens southward is not large by normal standards. to them after death. Their plight is not so It cannot as yet amount to more than a complex as the departure of us humans. couple of battalions a month. Mr. SPRINGER. Mr. Speaker, I at- tach herewith another article by Joseph Alsop entitled, "Another Dienbienphu?" Mr. Alsop has been on the scene in Sai- gon and, apparently, understands bet- ter than any other correspondent the sit- uation there. He has been giving forth- right reports in simple language about South Vietnam. The article follows: (By Joseph Alsop) Everyone in Washington is hard at work worrying about the political situation in Vietnam. They should also begin worrying about the military situation which is the prime cause of the recurrent political dif- ficulty. Just 11 years ago, this reporter left Saigon to fly halfway around the world for an earlier family Christmas. Doing exactly the same thing this time, with exactly the same cold dread of disaster-soon-to-come lying clammy on one's stomach, was not an agree- able experience. Yet facts must be faced, however disagree- able they may be. And the central fact that now needs facing is the grim similarity of the present military situation in South Viet- nam to the Vietnamese military situation at the end of 1953, on the very eve of Dienbien- phu. By December, 1953, the Communists had managed to stretch the defense to the ut- most, leaving the French high command with almost no reserves in hand. This.year, once again, the defenders' resources are bad- ly overstretched. The central reserve amounts to hardly a division and a half; and a good part of this slender reserve is actually pinned down in the Saigon area, because of the strength of the Communist underground in the city. In December 1953, the Communists also had large reserves outside the war zone, in the form of the newly trained division in China whose commitment in Vietnam then caused the French disaster at Dienbien- phu. This year, once again, the Communist reserves outside the war zone are extremely important, theoretically comprising the en- tire North Vietnamese Army. And units of this reserve have almost certainly begun to be infiltrated southward, over the Ho Chi Minh trail., This startling fact must be deduced from recent captures of very young North Viet- namese draftees in South Vietnam. No gen- Approved For Release 2003/10/15 : CIA-R. DP67B00446R000300170027-2 Z4 Approved For MN(T1 SLIMY M619-6f BAT OJ00170027-Z correct determination to terminate these political payoffs. We look forward to the "slugfest" for the simple reason that commonsense, common decency, and fiscal integrity dictate an end to the misuse of Federal funds, both of the tax dollars you are paying today and the heavier Federal debt with which the future of our country is being mortgaged. We maintain that these programs are local responsibilities and can be solved locally, as Indianapolis has demonstrated. We main- tain that under any circumstance they are not being administered fairly, but are being used to bribe the electorate, to subsidize po- litical employees, to penalize the cities and counties that exercise their own fiscal respon_ sibility, to benefit the relatively well off, and to make the poor poorer. They cannot be justified morally, nor can they be justified economically or defended ethically. It's One View of Recent Events in Vietn EXTENSION OF REMARKS OF HON. CLEMENT J. ZABLOCKI OF WISCONSIN IN THE HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES Tuesday, January 7, 1964 Mr, ZABLOCKI. Mr. Speaker, the sit- uation in South Vietnam is one of con- tinuing concern to Members of Congress. The United States has made heavy com- mitments in money and manpower in the effort to defeat the Communist Viet- cong rebels. Ina current issue of America maga- zine, Miss Marguerite Higgins, well- known journalist and Pulitzer Prize win- ner, reported her views on the situation following a recent visit to South Viet- nam. , Her article makes a number of per- tinent points on current events in that troubled country and I commend it to the attention of my colleagues: SAIGON SUMMARY: OUR COUNTRY PLAYED AN INGLORIOUS ROLE IN THE FINAL DAYS OF THE DIEM REGIME _ (By Marguerite Higgins) What is the meaning of the five tragic self- immolations that took place in Vietnam in the 6 weeks following the November coup d'etat against Diem? How did it come to pass that under the military junta, which seized power in the name of an end to "per- secution," there have been more suicides by fire over a short period than had ever been the case under President Diem and his broth- er Ngo Dinh Nhu? Even though virtually ignored by the Western press, will this latest spate of suicides by fire-without clearly stated reason-destroy at last the false no- tion that the repeated acts of self-immola- tion in Vietnam were indisputable proof of massive persecution of the Buddhist religion by President Diem, a Roman Catholic? Will historians be more equitable with President Diem than his contemporaries were? On two trips in Vietnam in 1963, one be- fore and one after the coup d'etat, this writer was never able to And an instance of repres- sion on religious grounds. Under Diem, there was repression of Buddhists, Catholics, Con- fucianists, etc., when-in defiance of clearly stated laws-they took to the streets to dem- onstrate against the Government. But Diem's repression was not directed against a religion. It was aimed at overt political oppo- sition. There were deplorable police excesses in Vietnam, but there is no sign that they were desired or condoned by Diem any more than police excesses in Alabama are con- doned or desired by Washington. There was, for a longtime, a clear double standard in Vietnam, in which accusations against Diem gained, in most cases, giant headlines, but attempted refutations received only perfunctory notice. For instance, last summer Thich Duc Nghiep, the Xa Loi pagoda spokesman, told reporters dramat- ically that 366 persons in a Saigon suburb had been arrested "because they were Buddhists." That figure was headlined throughout the world. But when I went to the suburb in question, I found that a routine check was being made of a neighborhood through which the Vietcong often infiltrated. I stayed for 2 hours to talk with those rounded up as they emerged from the police compound after questioning. I talked to 20 persons- picked up. So the charge of "365 persons arrested because of being Buddhists" was invention. There is no doubt that the overwhelming majority of the American press corps in Saigon thought-out of the most idealistic and patriotic motives-that they were serv- ing a good cause in arousing world opin- ion against Diem. Whether his strengths and faults were greater or less than those of his junta successors remains to be seen. It is certain that under the military junta, Vietnamese have been jailed for far less than was necessary to send a person to prison un- der Diem. Said a European observer; "Under Diem, a Vietnamese had to do something specific against the regime to get into trou- ble. Under the military junta, a Vietnamese can be jailed without charge, simply under the suspicion that he was loyal to the Diem regime when it was the legally constituted authority." Sanche de Gramont, of the New York Herald Tribune, has estimated the number of arbitrary arrests right after the coup as around 500. So far, Mr. de Gramont and this reporter, are the only ones who have written with any detail about the junta's reversion to some of the police state tactics the Saigon press corps so bitterly cirticized in Diem. Nowadays, some of the most ardent anti- Diem writers, such as David Halberstam, Saigon correspondent of the New York Times, acknowledge that the Buddhist agitation of last summer and fall was politically moti- vated. In an admiring magazine article writ- ten by his close friend George J. W. Goodman, Mr. Halberstam is quoted as saying: "I always said it. The Buddhist campaign was polit- ical. * * * I thought I always emphasized that this was a political dispute under a religious banner-the only place an opposi- tion had found to gather in an authoritarian regime. * * *" Whatever Mr. Halberstam's intentions, his and other press dispatches last summer and fall did create the impression in the outside world that some kind of religious crisis was going on -inside Vietnam. And it was the image of religious persecution-false as it was-that paved the way for Diem's down- fall. Without the embarrassment of being the patron of a country suspected of battling Buddhists, it is- doubtful that the United States would ever have reached the decision to try to get rid of Diem. The authorities in Washington knew, of course, that the conflict in Vietnam was political, not reli- gious. But they were reluctant to speak out lest, in the process, they attract to Wash- ington some of the onus being poured- with hardly any contradiction-on Diem. - By staying silent, Washington acted as if it thought Diem guilty. And this helped to complete the vicious circle. Or as Roger Hillsman, Assistant Secretary A23 of State for Far Eastern Affairs, put it: "After the closing of the pagodas on August 21, the facts became irrelevant." So, evi- dently, did a sense of perspective. What, for example, about the fact that President Diem was far more lenient to his political opposition than President Sukarno of In- donesia or Premier Sarit Thanarat of Thai- land, both recipients of American aid? Whereas some 300 political prisoners, at most. were found in Diem's jails, the prisons of Thailand, Indonesia and Burma were filled- and are still filled-with tens of thousands of political victims. - "But," explained a procoup State Depart- ment officer, "the world spotlight is not on those countries, and it is on Vietnam." At the State Department, there have been some attempts to rationalize the coup d'etat by describing it as necessary to save the Vietnamese war effort from going to pieces. One difficulty with this argument is that it makes liars out of Secretary of Defense Mc- Namara, Chief of Staff Maxwell D. Taylor and Gen. Paul Harkins, who testified under oath to Congress in October that the war was making reasonable progress. If the State Department ever took seriously the argument that the disturbances in the cities would affect morale in the countryside, it betrays a regrettable lack of understanding of the structure of -Vietnam and of the gap between the countryside, where the war will be won or lost, and the cities, where less than 10 percent of the Vietnamese live. For the Buddhists, intellectuals and stu- dents who marched the streets in anti-Diem demonstrations could not have cared less about the war-before the coup, or after the coup. Vietnamese students in particular tell you quite frankly that one reason they prize admission to a university is that it enables them to avoid the draft. Vietnam's intel- lectuals have narrow horizons, are exces- sively inward turning, and make constant and factional criticism their specialty. Ex- cept for a handful of terribly militant leaders, Buddhist monks are rather passive. If the success or failure of the war were to depend on these groups, Vietnam would have been lost from the start. As to the effects in the countryside of the critical clamoring by Viet- nam's spoiled young intellectuals in the cities, it was virtually nil. The American attitude seemed to be that if a Vietnamese student demonstrates, virtue is on his side and the government is wrong. But in the countryside there were many peasants and plain soldiers who disapproved of the de- fiance of the regime-in those rare places where anyone knew anything whatsoever of what went on beyond the next village. If there was any slowdown in the war in September and October of 1963, it was be- cause the Vietnamese generals-under American prodding-were concentrating on thoughts of a coup d'etat, while Diem and Nhu, out of fear of America, were concen- trating on how to prevent a coup. It was not until after the coup d'etat that the Vietnamese war took a decidedly down- ward turn. The military junta with its un- certain leadership, after purges of key (and scarce) officials, finally plunged much of the countryside into the confusion from which it purportedly was trying to save Vietnam. No wonder the Vietcong took advantage of the situation to seize the military initiative for the first time in many months. No won- der that, in the 2 months after the coup d'etat, the military junta lost more real estate, lives, and weapons to the Vietcong than at any previous time in the war. It was precisely out of fear of such predic- table consequences of trying to , change regimes in midwar that Secretary of Defense McNamara and Central Intelligence Director John McCone opposed a coup d'etat. But they were overruled by the procoup d'etat faction led by Ambassador Henry Cabot Lodge, Under Secretary of State Averell Har- Approved For Release 2003/10/15 : CIA-RDP67B00446R000300170027-2 A24 Approved For Release 2003/10/15 : CIA-RDP67B00446R000300170027-2 CONGRESSIONAL RECORD - APPENDIX January 7 riinan, and Assistant Secretary of State for Far Eastern Affairs Roger Hillsman. The Diem-must-go decision came shortly after the temporary closing of about a dozen (out of 4,000) pagodas on August 21, which outraged Washington. Diem said that his only aim was to get the Buddhist leaders out of politics and back to religion. The Viet- namese leader insisted that unless he shut down the propaganda machinery of the pago- das and put a halt to the glorification of suicide by burning, public disorder in the cities would mount and world misunder- standing would deepen. Washington dis- agreed. Further, it felt that Diem had not only humiliated it and flouted its advice, but had broken a promise to be conciliatory. Washington's anger was heightened by hor- rendous stories of alleged killings and bru-, talities during the pagoda raids. (There were no such killings, as the monks themselves later said.) In any case, on August 24, the State De- partment sent out word-without the knowl- edge of Secretary McNamara or of CIA Direc- tor John McCone-instructing Ambassador Lodge to "unleash" the Vietnamese generals with a view, to toppling the Diem govern- ment if they could. Plotting among edu- cated Vietnamese, including the generals, is a kind of national pastime, as chess is to the Russians. Until lately it had been a pretty harmless pastime, because everybody knew that real action was dependent on an Ameri- can green light-and until August such a green light had been withheld. But on Sunday, August 25, Washington publicly gave the generals a green light in a Voice of America broadcast that virtually called on the Vietnamese military to take over. At the same time, Ambassador Lodge asked the CIA to poll the Vietnamese gen- erals and see when and if they were ready to translate revolt talk into action. Diem's shock at the Voice of America broadcast and the CIA poll of the Vietnamese generals can only be imagined by turning the tables around. Suppose the United States were engaged in a war against the Communists in which we depended almost totally on aid from Vietnam; suppose, In the middle of that war, Vietnam issued a broad- oast calling for the American Joint Chiefs of Staff to overthrow the American Govern- ment. The miracle is that the Diem regime sur- vived as long as it did the virtual declaration of political war served on it that August by Washington. What, after many months of hesitation, finally decided the generals (in mid-October) to stage the coup? In separate interviews with this correspondent, members of the military junta spoke of these factors: 1. The late President Kennedy called, at a press conference, for "changes of policy and maybe personnel" In Vietnam. 2. Washington announced the withdrawal of 1,000 American soldiers by the end of 1963, and possible total withdrawal by 1965. (Said one general: "That convinced us that unless we got rid of Diem, you would aban- don us.") 8. The economic aid was cut. Many gen- erals agreed that this cut was psychologically the most decisive goad to a coup d'etat. "It convinced us," a key plotter explained, "that the United States was serious this time about getting rid of Diem. In any case, this was a war we wanted to win. The United States furnished us with the jeeps, the bullets, the very guns that made the war possible. In cutting economic aid, the United States was forcing us to choose be- tween your country's help in the war and Diem. So we chose the United States." Ironically, President Diem did make some important concessions to the United States in September and October. For example, in mid-September President Diem agreed to every point put forward by the United States in a program to reform and consoli- date the strategic hamlet program in the Mekong delta. Many Americans had long felt that this program had been overex- tended. At last President Diem agreed with the diagnosis and decided to do something about it. Why was this move toward the American position never publicized? One Western diplomat put it this way: "Am- bassador Lodge and his deputy, William Truehart, were so determined to get rid of Diem that they were -opposed to putting him in a conciliatory light. They were afraid this would strengthen the hands of those in Washington against a coup d'etat." Even at the 11th hour, Ambassador Lodge could, of course, have turned off the revolt if he had chosen to give the slightest sign that the New Frontier and President Diem were even beginning to move to heal their rent. As one member of the military junta put it: "We would never have dared to act if we had not been sure that the United States was giving us its moral support." In the last hours before his death, Presi- dent Diem was stripped of any doubt what- soever of Washington's hostility. Telephon- ing the American Embassy from the palace at 4:30 p.m. on November 1, after the bom- bardment had started, President Diem asked Ambassador Lodge: "What is Washington's attitude toward this?" Lodge replied: "I don't know Washington's attitude. After all, it is 4:30 in the morning there." "But you must have some idea," Diem said. Whereupon Lodge turned the conversation to the matter of Diem's safety, offering him an airplane to take him out of the country. Could anything have indicated more clearly that in American eyes the success of the coup d'etat was a fait accompli? The only certain thing about the murder of President Diem and Counselor Nhu is that they were shot in the back (Diem in the neck, Nhu in the right side) with their hands tied behind them. Nhu also had a dagger or bay- onet wound in the chest, which was appar- ently indecisive. These facts were established beyond all doubt by this reporter through photographs and through talks with military eyewitnesses, attendants at St. Paul's Hospital (where the bodies were first taken) and from informa- tion given by two relatives, a niece and neph- ew who handled the preparations for the burial. In the light of the way Diem and Nhu died, there is a strong possibility that the shoot- ings were ordered by some or all members of the military junta. Would a junior officer take such a responsibility on himself? Now for the Buddhist leaders who started it all: have they got what they wanted? I use the word "leaders" advisedly, for of the Bud- dhists in Vietnam, who form about 30 per- cent of the population of 14 million people, the overwhelming majority are largely non- political. Buddhist monks tend to be some- what passive. They would never have dreamed of resorting to violent demonstra- tions had they not been subjected to the skillful and inflammatory propaganda that poured from the humming mimeograph ma- chines of the Xa Lot Pagoda. By the end of last summer, the original grievances of the Buddhist leaders in Hue-matters of prop- erty rights, flag flying, etc.-had largely been met by the Diem regime. In the midst of the anti-Diem ferment I wrote an article asking: "What do the Bud- dhists want? They want Diem's head, not on a silver platter, but wrapped in an American flag? You have to hand it to the Buddhist lead- ers that they got what they wanted. But will this satisfy the more militant Buddhist lead- ers? It is heady stuff, even for Buddhists, to have the attention of the entire world fo- cused on you, and to exercise the kind of political power than can topple governments. Will, for instance, the venerable Thich Tri Quang, the mastermind of the Buddhist cam- paign and by far the most intelligent and militant of all, be satisfied to take a political back seat? Thich Tri Quang is a Buddhist leader from Hue who was granted asylum at the American Embassy even though his past is in some controversy. According to records of the French- Colonial Office, he had twice been arrested during the postwar French oc- cupation of Indochina for dealings with Ho Chi Minh. By his own admission, he was a member of the Vietminh Communist Liberation Front. He claims to have fallen out with the Communists later. Again ac- cording to the French, who still have repre- sentatives at Hanoi, Thich Tri Quang's brother is currently working for Ho Chi Minh in the Communist Vietnam's Ministry of the Interior, The duties of Thich Tri Quang's brother are the direction of sub- version in South Vietnam. None of this, of course, proves anything about Thich Trf Quang's current attitude to- ward the Communist Vietcong. What does seem clear is that he learned a lot from the Communists about organization and propa- ganda. He ran his emergency headquarters at the Xa Loi pagoda like a company com- mend post. Orders were barked out, direct- ing a demonstration here, a protest meeting there. Messengers scurried in and out, car- rying banners with their newly painted slo- gans. Respectful monks brought In the latest anti-Diem propaganda blast for Thich Tri Quang to review word by word. In my discussion with Thich Tri Quang, I was somewhat taken aback at his indiffer- ence about the war against the Communists. When I asked whether the occasional out- burst of turmoil might not offer the Viet- cong the opportunity to infiltrate among the demonstrators, Thich Tri Quang shrugged his shoulders and said: "It is pos- sible that the current disorders could lead to Communist gains. But if this happens it will be Diem's fault, not ours." In the same Interview in the Xa Loi pagoda, Thich Tri Quang told me that his preferred solution for Vietnam was neutral- ism, adding: "We cannot get an arrange-, ment with the north until we get rid of Diem and Nhu." The Vietcong are suspected of having led several of the attacks against property on November, 1, the day of the coup d'etat. For instance, a small but violent gang of young people attacked and demolished the newly opened headquarters in Saigon of the Asian Anti-Communist League. This league had no connection, financial or otherwise, with Diem. Yet the coup-day rioters systematical- ly removed its anti-Communist literature onto the streets, burned it, then wrecked the headquarters. Whether the new military junta's govern- ment by committee can do any better than Diem and Nhu remains in doubt. The junta Is ripe for further coups and countercoups. In any case, it was not because he enjoyed being condemned by world public opinion that President Diem engaged In repressive measures (mild as they were by Asian stand- ards). The new government will be faced by similar problems, because the funda- mental situation has not changed. For ex- ample, the change of government has not al- tered the tendency of Vietnam citified Intel- lectuals to take to the streets. Within 2 weeks after the coup d'etat, 10,000 students at Hue demonstrated noisily against the military junta because it had not dismissed several professors who had been loyal to Diem, This is but one example of pressure by mob. Can the military junta long tolerate decisions enforced by street mobs, or justice by demand of the newly freed and utterly irresponsible Vietnamese press? Three Saigon newspapers have closed-and rightly-already. The smut and sheer mendacity of the postcoup "free press" Approved For Release 2003/10/15 : CIA-RDP67B00446R000300170027-2 1W4- Approved For Release 2003/10/15 : CIA-RDP67B00446R000300170027-2 CONGRESSIONAL RECORD - APPENDIX A25 of Vietnam is one of the blackest marks of recent months in the annals of Vietnam's so- called intellectuals. In view of the in- discipline, factionalism and irresponsibility of citified Vietnamese, can the military junta long escape resorting to the same tight rein held by President Diem? The only sure thing in Vietnam today is that the United States has set an extremely this Nation in the direction of freedom and respect for person, and they killed Mr. Lincoln. In this centennial year of the Emancipa- tion Proclamation and the Gettysburg Ad- dress-98 years after the assassination of Abraham Lincoln-the ablest and most dedi- cated spokesman for those ideals in the 20th century was suddenly shot from the same controversial precedent by encouraging, for kind of darkened crevices of hate. the first time in our history, the overthrow They killed President Kennedy. The in time of war of a duly elected government same hands; the same forces. The same har- i hting loyally against the common Corn- / bingers of hate, greed, tyranny, avarice and m nist enemy. arrogance demonstrated again and beyond a doubt that they will still stop at nothing In Memoriam: John Fitzgerald Kennedy, President of the United States EXTENSION OF REMARKS OF HON. JOHN D. DINGELL OF MICHIGAN IN THE HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES Tuesday, January 7, 1964 Mr. DINGELL. Mr. Speaker, under unanimous consent, I insert into the Ap- pendix of the RECORD a memorial tribute to our late President read to the Wayne County (Mich.) Board of Supervisors on November 26, 1963, by one of its mem- bers, Dr. Broadus N. Butler. Dr. Butler, a distinguished citizen of Detroit, is as- sistant to the dean of the Wayne State University College of Liberal Arts: IN MEMORIAM: JOHN FITZGERALD KENNEDY, PRESIDENT OF THE UNITED STATES (By Supervisor Broadus N. Butler) At the height of the first ray of hope for a new national climate of brotherhood, democ- racy, and opportunity in this tragedy ridden 20th century comes the assassination of the one President of the United States who has symbolized not only for America, but for the world, the ideal of executive leadership to- ward the full recognition of human dignity. This has been a century in which the re- spect of person and human dignity has been trampled unto death and degradation in some dramatic way in each generation. This century has seen three major international wars take millions of lives, untold numbers of smaller wars add up to more millions. It has seen genocide in the extermination of 3 million Jews in Germany, the rise of com- munism and massacres in Asia, the assassi- nation of Mohandas Gandhi in India, apar- theid and the killing of thousands of black Africans, particularly in Angola and South Africa. It has suffered killings, riots, and more than 50 bombings of churches and schools-killings of men, women, and chil- dren-in the United States. The past decade of this century has seen this violence go un-. mitigated and unpunished in our own Na- tion. It has watched the overthrow, by vio- lence of government after government throughout the world. John Fitzgerald Kennedy tried in less than 3 years to write a chapter of human dignity and equality of opportunity for all into our national life. He tried to see and move optimistically toward a new climate of brotherhood and hope at least in our own land, if not throughout the world. We must now face finally and ultimately the stark fact that is no joke that fanatical forces of the right and the left have tried and are, still trying to write an obituary for this great, overgrown and, they think, dying Nation. One hundred years ago, Abraham Lincoln told this to the 19th century Amer- icans in the Emancipation Proclamation and in the Gettysburg Address. He tried to set to prove that the American creed of democ- racy and brotherhood is not viable-that America will die before she will be free. And, like Mr. Kennedy, she will die unless we ac- knowledge this shocking reality. We must finally know that the extreme right would rather see the Nation dead than see one Negro free; the extreme left would rather kill the Nation than see one American free. That was the essence ' of the meaning of the assassination of Mr. Lincoln. That was the essence of the failure to implement the original Declaration of Independence. That is now the essence of the meaning of the death of President Kennedy. The President is not dead; the presidency lives. But the only President since Abraham Lincoln who devoted so much of his executive resources and moral suasion to give real meaning to civil rights, equal opportunity, and human freedom is dead. No, we say in disbelief. It cannot be. But, it is. In our time, there is one and only one significant difference between America and Germany, Italy, Japan, and the other coun- tries that died of their own involvement in violence, America and America's creed of freedom revived and saved them. America retrieved them with men, the ideology of freedom, and with all the moral power and economic resources that it takes to recover a dead society from itself and infuse it with a new vision of life and hope-a new freedom from its own ashes. Now, it is America. Can America save America? Will God? Will Americans? This time it is we, ourselves. What will we do now? . Goodby, dear Mr. President. May your soul and your memory-your ultimate sacri- fice-save a people and a nation so great as ours that cannot otherwise save itself from its own domestic violence. Will those who could not learn from the deaths of Christ, of Lincoln, of Gandhi now see that the shot of hate that pierced John F. Kennedy, was aimed to kill Thee. Americans, be of good judgment and firm dedication to complete his unfinished task. In the transition from John Fitzgerald Ken- nedy to Lyndon Baines Johnson there is one great comfort for our saddened Nation. The Presidency moves from strength, courage and moral integrity to continued strength, cour- age and moral integrity in the quest for democracy, for domestic brotherhood, and for international peace. Our hearts go out to the President's family and especially to Mrs. Jacqueline Kennedy who has suffered the double personal tragedy of the loss of a son and a husband in so short compass. May the wisdom of our departed President rest upon and give strength to our new Pres- ident, Lyndon B. Johnson. May his soul and purpose pervade the whole American citi- zenry across the land to remove the hate and bigotry which besets us. May the people of America now see the light and learn the truth that his martyrdom beams forth so clearly to us. Cannot we hark the painful miracles of this year? Cannot we heed the words of our great and departed exemplar who implored us to "Ask not what your country can do for you. Ask what you can do for your country." Jesus Christ said, in effect, "If you will love God, you must love one another." Every re- cent martyr has echoed, "If you will love one another, you must love me." Let every American learn to love-to respect the person and dignity of-one another. (Read to the Wayne County Board of Supervisors, Tuesday, November 26, 1963.) George Fisher EXTENSION OF REMARKS OF HON. JOHN A. BLATNIK OF MINNESOTA IN THE HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES. Tuesday, January 7, 1964 Mr. BLATNIK. Mr. Speaker, I wish to take this opportunity to pay well- deserved public tribute to a man of unusual gifts and inexhaustible energy, a man whose memorable contributions to all of northeastern Minnesota stand as a monument to his life's work, my dear friend and dean of journalists on the Mesabi Iron Range, Mr. George Fisher. Celebrating his golden anniversary of journalism, 47 years of which were spent with the Hibbing Daily Tribune, George Fisher announced his retirement on January 1, 1964. Throughout these many years of devoted service to the public interest George Fisher has truly been the voice, conscience, and spirit of all the good people in the Iron Range area. His retirement-surely well-earned and deserving-brings to his many friends and admirers feelings of sadness mixed with pride over his achievements and gratitude for his con- tributions. In true journalistic tradition George Fisher started at the bottom of the lad- der as a young reporter, working himself up to be city editor, managing editor, and finally executive editor. Not con- tent to achieve excellence as.a journalist, he has taken the lead in many local matters of public interest, spearheaded numerous civic projects, and been active in many organizations. His untiring efforts have on three occasions won him the honor of being named Hibbing's out- standing citizen. Mr. Speaker, the eloquent and warmly sincere editorial in the December 26, 1963, edition of my hometown news- paper, the Free Press of Chisholm, Minn., sums up the thoughts and emotions of all of us in northeastern Minnesota on the occasion of the retirement of "Mr. Hibbing," our beloved George Fisher. I commend to all the moving story of this remarkable man: GEORGE FISHER'S TREASURES Perhaps no other profession in the world is so studded with joys, pin-pricked with sorrows and jeweled with rewards of personal satisfaction as is that of journalism. Those who follow in the footsteps of the fourth estate watch each day's events blaze on the horizon, die in the ashes of forget- fulness and torn newspapers, and then watch them kindled into new flames as dawns an- other day and the rising sun shoots new directives. THEY FEEL THE HEARTBEAT The efforts of the vast working corps often remain unsung. These men and women ask, nor demand recognition. Their fruits of Approved For Release 2003/10/15 : CIA-RDP67B00446R000300170027-2 A26 Approved For Release 2003/10/15 : CIA-RDP67B00446R000300170027-2 CONGRESSIONAL RECORD - APPENDIX January 7, -? M. their endeavors are spelled out in the accu- racy of their stories, details and authenticity of their research to educate a strong and healthy nation. In times of joy, they fade into the darkness and observe with an inner satisfaction the happiness of a surging, for- ward democracy of humanity. They feel the anguish of war, the tragedy of assassinations, the pain and death of accidents; the desola- tion of destruction and violence, the heart- beat of the new-born babe; the pride and accomplishment of a college diploma; the hope of the downtrodden; the hunger and cold of the poor; the pulse of mankind's yearning for peace. An integral part of all of this fascination for more than half a century has been the dean of journalism on the Iron Range, the indomitable, persevering, dedicated George Fisher. Journalism is a field that knows neither night nor day. Compensations and remunerations are not measured in terms of money. The reporter's "Beat", known to the man on the street as an assignment, be- comes like a drug. The events and hap- penings of little towns, big cities, thriving, teeming states, a young democracy, and powerful nations race through the blood- stream. Once the smell of ink, the hum of the typewriter and linotype, the roll of the presses, and the pressure of deadlines get into your blood, there is no turning back. One just keeps on driving, working, racing, writing. This, Mr. Fisher has done with a dignity and respectability that marks the great men in journalism. EDITIONS ARE MEMORIALS This man's greatest memorial tribute are the editions of the Ribbing Daily Tribune, ageless, yellowed and preserved for the past 46 years. His chronicles, anecdotes and edi- torials magnify the heartbeat of the Iron Range. And as he gathered the material for his many stories and columns, he sowed the seeds of friendship which have blossomed into a magnificent symbol of the kind of wealth that money cannot buy. Because he was fair, firm, determined, kind and just, Mr. Fisher earned for himself a following that encircles his beloved Iron Range, his grief- stricken United States, and his embracing world. A BIGGER MAN Though the formal records will show that Mr. Fisher is retiring from his position of executive editor as of January 1, 1964, his colleagues and friends know way down deep that the ring of the telephone, the clang of the siren, the hum of the typewriter will quicken his pulse, and an unexplainable "something" known as a reporter's ninth sense will start racing through his veins. The years have been kind and good, spiced with humor, rare joys, and some very bitter sorrows. All have made Mr. Fisher a bigger, more tolerant, and understanding reporter and American citizen. His journalistic con- tributions, his civic accomplishments, his reservoir of friendships are treasures he can always cherish. We, your colleagues, are proud of you, W. Fisher, and in sincere tribute, thank you for a "job well done." PRINTING OF CONGRESSIONAL RECORD EXTRACTS It shall be lawful for the Public Printer to print and deliver upon the order of any Senator, Representative, or Delegate, extracts from the CONGRESSIONAL RECORD, the person ordering the same paying the cost thereof (U.S. Code, title 44, sec. 185, p. 1942). LAWS RELATIVE TO THE PRINTING OF DOCUMENTS Either House may order the printing of a document not already provided for by law, but only when the same shall be accompa- nied by an estimate from the Public Printer as to the probable cost thereof. Any execu- tive department, bureau, board or independ- ent office of the Government submitting re- ports or documents in response to inquiries from Congress shall submit therewith an estimate of the probable cost of printing the usual number. Nothing In this.section re- lating to estimates shall apply to reports or documents not exceeding 50 pages (U.S. Code, title 44, sec. 140, p. 1938). Resolutions for printing extra copies, when presented to either House, shall be referred immediately to the Committee on House Administration of the House of Representa- tives or the Committee on Rules and Admin- istration of the Senate, who, in making their report, shall give the probable cost of the proposed printing upon the estimate of the Public Printer, and no extra copies shall be printed before such committee has reported (U.S. Code, title 44, sec. 133, p. 1937). GOVERNMENT PUBLICATIONS FOR SALE Additional copies of Government publica- tions axe offered for sale to the public by the Superintendent of Documents, Government Printing Office, Washington 25, D.C., at cost thereof as determined by the Public Printer plus 50 percent: Provided, That a discount of not to exceed 25 percent may be allowed to authorized bookdealers and quantity pur- chasers, but such printing shall not inter- fere wits? the prompt execution of work for the Government. The Superintendent of Documents shall prescribe the terms and conditions under which he may authorize the resale of Government publications by bookdealers, and he may designate any Gov- ernment officer his agent for the sale of Gov- ernment publications under such regulations as shall be agreed upon by the Superintend- ent of Documents and the head of the re- spective department or establishment of the Government (U.S. Code, title 44, sec. 72a, Supp. 2). RECORD OFFICE AT THE CAPITOL An office for the CONGRESSIONAL RECORD, with Mr. Raymond F. Noyes in charge, is lo- cated in room 1-1-112, House wing, where or- ders will be received for subscriptions to the RECORD at $1.50 per month or for single copies at 1 cent for eight pages (minimum charge of 3 cents). Also, orders from Mem- bers of Congress to purchase reprints from the RECORD should be processed through this office. CHANGE OF RESIDENCE Senators, Representatives, and Delegates who have changed their residences will please give information thereof to the Government Printing Office, that their addresses may be correctly given in the RECORD. CONGRESSIONAL DIRECTORY The Public Printer, under the direction of the Joint Committee on Printing, may print for sale, at a price sufficient to reimburse the expenses of such printing, the current Con- gressional Directory. No sale shall be made on credit (U.S. Code, title 44, sec. 150, p. 1939). Approved For Release 2003/10/15 : CIA-RDP67B00446R000300170027-2