(EST PUB DATE) ESTIMATED EXPENDITURES ON THE PRC NUCLEAR PROGRAM

Document Type: 
Collection: 
Document Number (FOIA) /ESDN (CREST): 
0000365042
Release Decision: 
RIPPUB
Original Classification: 
U
Document Page Count: 
27
Document Creation Date: 
June 24, 2015
Document Release Date: 
September 27, 2011
Sequence Number: 
Case Number: 
F-2008-00222
Publication Date: 
July 1, 1975
File: 
AttachmentSize
PDF icon DOC_0000365042.pdf2.23 MB
Body: 
Copy No. l ESTIMATED EXPENDITURES ON THE PPC NUCLEAR PROGRAM 1 ! i , ' I , . ! if dltu nuclear weapons research, development; fabrication, and testing have accounted pro uction,, uranium enrichment, and plutonium production)- Rack niiripir Pa .._t. pro uction of nuclear a , 1materials (uranium mining and concentrating, ..feed materials and heavy water a e if Y an a of expenditure has gone to the construction and operation of facilities for th d I. , Expenditures on the nuclear program'of the People's Republic of China up Irregularly in about $150 million in the early 1960s to 1-Inn million a? Pa,.-+ totaled an estimated US, $3.7 billion,through 1974. Annual spending has moved 2. Capital investment and operating expenditures have accou t d f n e or about 148 and 52% of total spending, respectively F'ightl mor th h ; ?V-rAVaVJJiing ~_nma s second generation of production facilities,, occurred in 1970-71. p es merit peaked during the e arly; to mid-1960s ; as initial production facilities were being completed. A new ---- I -,- vu,?v?I. a uc largest amounts ;were spent 'on installations for plutoniuproduction, uranium enrichment, 1 and nuclear, 'weapons R&D and, fabrication Ca ital trip IF i~ I! ,. j3.. Capital investment through 1974 in facilities identified as part of the it, 16 ., g m o service. By 1973.74,: 'annual: operating costs had risen to $220 million. Operating costs n crease continuously f since the early years of the program; as new installations have one ' t , s Ong, %, ' and basic, nuclear research, 20%. Annual operating costs have i d estimated at approximately $1.9 billion. 'Of: this total, production of nuclear materials accounted for 47%, nuclear; weapons R&D fabrication and to t' 33 4. Operating expenditures on'the PRC nuclear program through 1974 are ey:,may! ;be uL'ected to: of the:;Office of Economic Research, 3?C3 V11 LnC:autnor..e;omments and queries regarding the publication are welcomed. I' 7~h i ? a e summariesof j( the estimates of capital investment and nnprnfin.. e......_a:...___ d coordinated arc an with the Office of Scientific Intelligence More det '1 d Note:! This; publication was prepared by the office of Economic Rese h July 1975 :The Chinese nuclear program began in earnest following the signing in October 1957 of an agreement with the Soviet Union concerning new technology --- - -- -- -..?.v .....,, ~.uu.Vav %--- wum i n imu to uranium f eYr'!,ration land . mining and basi nuci:ar : research. Although terms of the I Sino-Soviet agreement have never been made public, the USSR is known to have - .------''-- - ..?. ... VYJ.V, JV1VI,,,IIG 1Usv11wi, raw materials procurement, fi sionable materials production, and weapon production facility IF Aesign. In 1957-58, ,the Soviet :Union supplied China with major items of nuclear !f research equinment.j as part of an earlier (April 1955) agreement on cooperation `m the peaceful uses of nuclear. energy. Included in the equipment was a 7-10 megawatt (MW) (thermal): research reactor that was installed at the newly created Institute of Atomic, Energy (IAE) outside' Peking. 6. Ins June 1959 the Soviet Union abrogated the 1957 a t e gr emen , and in mid-1960, with th%; ;widening of the 'Sino-Soviet rift Moscow summaril wtl d i i row ` y ? its technicians of all. sorts from China. Peking's determination to continue a nuclear weapons development program remained unchanged, and work continued on the E facilities required for research , and the manufacture of nuclear materials. The ,'',People's Republic detonated its first nuclear 'device on 16 October 1964. fl 7 t The. Chinese program ,has continued to move forward in spite of internal political upheavals, notably the Great Leap, Forward (1958-60) and the Cultural (:, Revolution; (1966-69). The program' has had ,the highest priority, and the rapid I;progress! in; the, field 'reflects the nuclear program's near isolation from nmiri,.,i I. -? ? ???; c.~a,uy,c, LIM n w... progressea irom its first fission test in 1964 to the'' successful .detonation ' of a ft, l ermonuc ear device on 28 December 1966. Although the USSR took four, years and; France more than eight to make this ' progression , China made', it, in less than three years, working with a much less d ,i , a vance , ndustrial 1 and scientific base. Today, the People's Republic has a The .nuclear program has absorbed a large portion of China's choicest Y,u,VYw I ,l currency represents less than one-quarter of ;1 of China's GNP, the program constitutes a substantial cost in forgone opportunities, fore industrial and technical advances on other fronts. -TOP SE-GRET 8. Total expenditures on the Chinese,'nuclear program are estimated to have has constituted operating expenditures.'; The scheduling of expenditures on the $1.75f billion, or, 48%, has constituted; capital investment, and $1.9 billion, or 52%, been approximately $3.7 billion through 19,74 (see Table 1). Of this total, about Although an estimate of cumulative expenditures at installations built or in operation prior to 1960 has been included, any allocation of the , estimate year, by year would be arbitrary. Table 1{ ~1', 'II'I -'?~~ i~,i I ~i II .iii ~ 'i, ii i,~ ~ I. ~ ~ f~ ~ it ~ ! I I Capital :.;' Operating 1 Investment ; !; Expenditures !, i;' '; 1,750 110 135 ,i. 115 Jti'.110: ,,1 .150 ! 12S 135 95 95 65 ;,`11 130 ~. `I. 430 105 80 30 1,910 20 10 20, 40 50 90 1105 130 140 145 .165 ' 165 ,190 :200 220 '220 Million US $ 3,660 130 145 160 155 160 240 230 265 235 240 230 295 320 305 300 250 Annual spending on the ; nuclear program since 1960 has increased to more than $300 million in 1971-73 The largest'jumps in annual spending occurred new, Chinese :nuclear material production facilities and in a nuclear weapons completed and placed into operation, the share of operating costs in total spending development and production complex peaked 'in 1970. As new facilities were has increases ;steadily (see Figure 2). CHINA: Estimated Annual Expenditures on the Nuclear Program Figure 2 function has not yet' been determined, has been excluded. (To avoid ambiguity in' the coverage of j the present' estimates, a list, of facilities included is given in Appendix,. A.) i dollars used' are; a "mixed breed" based on ruble/dollar ratios, direct analogies, installations in the West under Chinese technical and administrative conditions. The i .11'.. 'i,? ! These estimates of expenditure, .on the PRC nuclear program purport to represent the dollar spending ;required to :build and' operate the various nuclear and various, foreign 'exchange rates. of the total cost of the program. expenditures through 1974 are estimated to have ; been nearly $2 billion, or 54% production' of nuclear materials (uranium mining and concentrating, feed materials production, uranium enrichment, and plutonium production). In China's case, these Functional : Allocation' of Expenditures llj~ ' 111 ', The ; acquisition of a 'comprehensive, nuclear weapons production capability requires 'the construction and operation of a large number of diverse , facilities. The ~ largest expenditure , is usually associated with facilities for the 13. !,: Facilities; for the necessary basic nuclear research and weapons research, development,, and testing also require sizable! 'expenditures. Table 2, provides a functional ;allocation of estimated,, spending on the; Chinese nuclear program. A brief' discussion of each of the major portions. of the program follows in the text. Both the.discussion and the estimates of spending presented are limited to activities required] 'up to and including -the fabrication and, assembly of nuclear devices. No it have { been made of ,expenditures for, nuclear weapons delivery systems operating expenses make up '57% and 43%, respectively. Operating costs in 1974 are j estimated' at about $30 n.illion !11111 !Uranium i Exploration. Mining; and Concentrating in China, through ;1974 are estimated : to. have been, about $435 million, 12% of the total 'program costs (see Table 2). Of, this amount, capital investment and TOP SECRET 1 i~ 1 f I' ~~ Ji 14 lt$~.I4 1 .~l1 iI 1~I1L.~:,) on the Nuclear Program Through 1974 Total I1 ` ' !(' Uranium;exploration mining, !il' I': Feed materials and heavy Basic nuclear research i ranlum!enrichment Plutonium production '! J, Nuclear weapons research, de- ,'' 'velopment, and fabrication Nuclear' weapons testing I 1,750 100 1,910 100 3,660 - 100 '250 14 135 !,I 8, 340 18 475 13 180 10 385 20 565 15 !;330 19 215 11 545 15 -360 21 r 155. 8 515 14 3S0' , 120; 530 28 880 24 145 8 '100 5 245 7 Production of feed materials and heavy water through 1974. About one-third of 16. The PRC 1 is estimated to have spent approximately $475 million for the ' thew expenditures was for capital investment Cumulative operating expen itures are,* estimated at about., $340 million (see Table 2), and annual operating ;costs in ;l 974 at about :$30 million. Spending for basic nuclear research has been through 4974. ;Capital 'expenditures have accounted for about 32% of this am unt 0 0 , or approximately ; $180 million, and operating costs for the remainder, about $385 million (see. Table 2). relatively : constant at annual operating expenditures have remained about $25 million since the mid-1960s. ' Uranium Enrichment ' 1, program. million per year in- the period 1964.71 to. more than $30 million in 1974. at 52l.5 million /see Tahlk 21 nnAratina meta have inerpaenrI frn.,. ahn.,? e I i Basic ; Nuclear .Research I9. i Cumulative. ope'rating;expe'nditure's for uranium enrichment are estimated iTI -11 Plutonium Production 21.. , Chinese expenditures for the production of plutonium are estimated at approximately $515 million. Capital investment has accounted for 70% of this total, or, $360 million, and operating expenditures about 30%, or $155 million (see Table: 2). TOP SECRET- I I I ~ I ~ I r~~ i (I~: ;u l J~~ ~I~ .~ I I f It!l 7 tN . ~llIII!.I! I I" ~I Iie~ ..l avr S E vi~nz Nuclear ; Weapons Research, Development, and Fabrication Capital 'investment of about $350 million and operating costs of $530 million make 123.-; Total expenditures by the Chinese on nuclear weapons R&D and fabrication through 1974 are estimated to have, been approximately $880 million. increased 'since the early 1960s to more than, $70 million in 1974. up I this total.i This spending category is the largest in the Chinese program, making up 1124% of total program costs (see Table'' 2). Annual operating costs have steadily }H PRC ' spending for' the; testing of, nuclear weapons through 1974 is estimated at $245, million, 7% of the cost of the nuclear program. (China is not a signatory of the PAGE # BLANK PAGE # BLANK 1 %JAa%.IJL'%J6~ J6 -FOP ' ~i:..if.ta!EJfl~~174..)1~~RMVM~.Y.~l~~ll I i '~1' it ! I i.I~'.I I r~ ~fi '. {I Y, ~_. ~it, i ~ ~I ~ ~ti: '~ .~.~ I ,.i ~91~~) f ~ r?',4 ~i ;~,,~ Iii ;i ~ ~ ! ~i ~.') . f~~;~ 'i ti ndi~.i~ l~.~~~~~-1a1, I ._.i, !I 11! I I 'I i I I , ~ i, ~i41 i 777 1~ J i {